Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd v. State Of Haryana &O Rs
! " # $% &
% ' #
& & (')* +#
)& $
,
!!"#
-
& ' $.
& %. ' !" # ' #
& & (')* +#
)& $
,
$% &'$
() ) %%%% ' /&
/ 0# /,1 0# " /1 #+ " 0
0# + /& #& &
0# ) / & /, + " 0#
2
$3' 44 /, + " 0# 2
$3' 254
%% /0 6 " &
0# ) / ' 7 0# 8
$3' 44 / ' 7 0# 8
$3' 254 %%%% 3" "" 7)
9* :7" 9* 2 3
7"
9*
%%%% :) "
$3' 44
( ; ;* ) "
$3' 254
7 -
( ;- ;* :
##
)
"
)) < 7 7 $3' 44 ) "
2
7 =
, $
:
) "
4 "
# :"
" >7?
&
6
(?&6*
(.* =
, $
(:
$
+ $
# @" 0
A %&:
7 & *,
) >5
%2% ,
0 " 2)
7 / 0 B
" ,
) > 5 ,
?&6 )
7
,
) "" (.* 7
"
" D
"
"
) E
) "
E " E " ) 7
7
F (
* :$ "
E
) E
)
"
=
0 ) =
" 7 $ +#
A) "
"' 6=E " $ ( ;'6=$;*
7 $
)
) < " ") )
""
" '6=$ ) "
E
: $ " ;
# ) ) 7
)
"
)
%4% "
E "
"
)
" :7 )
7"" "
)
E" ") : "" ) E "" '6=$) "
: " )
E
7 6 >42)
7 "# '6=$ ) 7 7 ) "
) E #
) "
) 7
2 :
,
E
)
D F ""
, 2, )
7 ""
0 ) E
) ""
)
E
$
< " "#
) "
" ) "
") "
)
) "
) < 7 "
%%
-" ) )
"
)
""
% #" A )
')$" '6=$ "#
, (.*)
7
" "
"
)
) )
" 7 ) 7
" 4 3
)
$
7 # ""# )'6=$7 # ")7 "
7 7 "
7 E 7')$" "
: $
)# 7 # "
") 7
7"
)
7
7 "
")
7 7
:$
7 # ) #
,
# ) )
A 7
7 " '6=$"
) )
) ""#
%.% $
# )
# "
") )
7 ) 7
) < 7#
7 6
"
7"
) "
) ""
,
:))
7 " E
) "
) 7 7'6=$
# ) "
"#
"
)< )
) "
E "E " )7
7
:"
)
" 7 )
E
)""
$
7"
" . :
) )
# )
E
") $
")
) 7 %
# )7
7 ,
"
7 $
) 7
"" ) " )
7:
%>% "
""
7" ) ) ) "
7 ) " :
""
7
" # '6=$"
=# ) A
#
"
7"
) E"
) 7
> :
)< ") $
)
"
7 7 7
) " ""
$
!"#
$ %: "
)
!
"
#$
%&
$!!
#
# & '
&
%&
(# ! # )#
*+#, :& " $
"
"
%8% , & >8 "")
70"": & )# "" 0"" : # , & >8A 0"" : =
) #
# ,
7 $ =
,
& >8=
0 2:# , )# 7
7
# ) 0 .$
A ) , (.*
E
7#'6=$"
) " ) A )
"
, (.*
"
7# '6=$"
7 "") 8 A <
7$
) # "7 "
)
" )
, (.*@ "
)"
,
)
"
=
0 2 ) =
' 7$ +#
: )
, 7)
%5% ""
E
"#
, (.* E
'6=$"
: ") $
7 &
. >5(* >8=
0 & ."#
, 7 & >5 )
$ $
2
) ) #
) A)
& >5(*( * )
%&
7 (*& >5
") #
"
##
"
:#
" (*& >5 ") #
$ +#
=
' " " " "
# & >8 " ")
$
5 3# & " $
( "*,
&
>8
7
# ,
#
7
7) "" 0
# ),
77 7
%% ) " 0 .$
A 7 "" "" 7)
" ,
A#"
)
"
" :"#
, (.*)
"
)
,
")
7
: 7 ) "
7$
) ") "
)
E
,
)
"
" ) < 7 3 =
$
) "
')$"
E"
"#
) < 7#
7
') $"
"" '6=$A #
"
)
"7
7 "
A )# ) #
7 ')$"
:"
7
" ) ) ") 7 , (.* "# ""
'6=$"
%% :
) , (.* 7
7 )
7 # 7 , 43 , (.*"# "
)
) "
E "E " , 4
" "
7
: )"
7 7 )
#
7
, 4 " "# )
)) )
"
) 7 7""#
"" 7,
42"# )"
" 7
$ (
* , "#
E
) ) 7 ", 4(* :
& & # & ""
7 ) )
%
7 ) " 7 ,
)
7 =
, $
22
"E
,
'6=$
# 7
%% ) "
7 "
# 7 )
7
:
)
, (.*
"'6=$ # 7"
: )
" ) ) )
0
"
" =
$
) E
:
) "
) )
)
"
,
A)
" ,
=# "
7"
)
# $
)
)
A
"7#
7
7 $
)
" ,
E
@ , (.*) "" '6=$"
"
", )
" ) < 7 :
$
E "
#
%2% ")) "
7 E
7 "
A=
$
'6=$"
#
" " 7 ) )
) )) "
7 ""#7 , (.*) 7%#
A, ) ""#
'6=$
7
"" )) ) ,
:) ) " ""# $
A)
$
7
7 7
)
) " 7 2 : " 7
#'6=$ A#7 ## $
) )
#
"#
:
)
) <
7 7 "" #
" :
""
7 ) ""
A
7 7
%4% & " $
( "*
7)
#
0 .A & " $ )
#
7
7"":
"
"
7 7 : 7 ) 7
7: 77
0 .=# 7)""
: )
E
"
) 7
"
)
A
7 7
E
0 .
# 7 %
:
: % "
7 :
A
"
7 #
"": )E
E
)
)
"
3 )
7 " "
" ;
7 4 :
" #
"
%%
#
7
" # 7
')$" &
A#, (.* )'6=$ 7
"
#7 A
:
"
=
$
< 7) "
) +) ),
#