M/S Kataria Constructions Pvt. Ltd. v. State Of Haryana And ORS
! "# $ %&'()( ( * + , '- '. */0#&'1)(23&*&.24)2. */0#&'(1)(23&'.1'.*)#4.'4
!"#$"% &' ( "&' )#$"% &$" "*&+*%' &, - &!
#*.*&%/.&*0"1
!* 2*3
4$ /0"1
**& *3 &% /+045 / &"& *&.24)2.51 ( *$ *" *& & !* **& *$ *" *& !* **& %*1& & " 5!1/
** & /
*&% 3& &!***&* ( &% *& & !* **& * &*
*&"
"6
) $ *"$&". *&6
&" 7 &"0 8$***&0 / 96 :0 ;/ *1
8$***& $*&% 99
*&91* %*& $"*&% &" **& *$ " *& 1* % * $ "1 &"$**< *& & " . = > 9 +1 & & ?
*"
"(**& $ " &"/ $ #
8$***& 1*" "" "
&"
@&** /&*
*&$&". *&6 &" 0 ! $ *" *&13*&%$%& 1**&$&". *&= 0 & 6
&")
*1 . !***&! *"
&%*&% *&1
*& $%& 1**& *& $"*&% & & **& * =
= 2*" " "
=
/&*
*&$&". *& 0 !
*"*&1& !***& *&*&% $*&%)
7* !
%*1& &">!& * # *&$&". *& 0 0 ( &"0 8$***& !
"* "%*1$&* *&% &
3
&"
*& !@*
/**& $ *" # *& & 0&&A$ > !*& **& &1 "*& # *&
8$**& &"8$*" $ "& $$%
*&*&% &"(7 8$***& &*"" # *& &"
&"" . 41& & !*&%
,> B(* *& &" &**$ "& "*& !& . = 9 !* $"
8$*" $&" $ * &*" *& + **&$" 3&&*%1&
$& & ** %*1& *
&$&"C* D @*
/&*
*&$&". *& 0 !
$ *"& ) *& $*&%) =
1* % * &" !
" &" *& 8$*& !
&&$& " &
9
@&
*"
1* *" & 0""**& +* / E &F /5 / 3$ /*!
*&"$ *
*&
*" **& % & * & !
$&"& 6 =
$ **&"*"&&"
$&*
*&@* *&"$
) **& $% &% &" $ & 9
!* !
% *&$&" &"!
$&"
8$***& $ "@* *&"$ *% !
** "*=
&% !* ) !*" %& *& $"*&% 1* " !*
3 !*"
(
8$***& $&"
& *A" !* -* *& 1*" $& $*<" *&C
&*< *& 3*&%
* "( &" **&
8$*" &"%& * $**<" $*> 3*&% $ &!* * 1 * &*& $ $ &
&"
&" $ &*< *&@* *&"$ &" **& !
1
& * *$ &*
*& $&" . *& 6 0 &" &" **& !$"
$ $
8$***& 7 &" $& **& * 0&&A$> &&" &"!&" **&
*&% &") %& &&*" &"= "& $" "
8$***& & &"/ *3 &% "* 0&&A$> *"!*1*! *
*&*&$ **& "#*&*&%%& &"1* "*" $" $*>1 3*&%
&"* *&%!**& " *A
% $*&% F &
3. *&( / &"*8$*" $ * $ @
" *!***&!
"*" & )& * & *& &". $&
*&*&% &"!* *&8$*" & "!$"
" ( *" " !
"
6 &" !* **& "**%*& &$ 7 &" $& **& 1 & %$" &"!* "&
!**& " *%&
&&
$
8$***&*
*&& &""1 & " ( $*>1 3*&% *& $ &
3 . *& * & " " $ * $ ( /$
&&
"$ #
8$***& $" $ &*&"*&&*
*&$&" . *&6 &" 0 & &"/ *3 &% / &" +$ 0"1
4& /5 / &&"" $*>1 3*&%* "1 & " !
& " . &&" 1&* $*>1 3*&% *& $*&% F &
3 . *& 3 %$ &
&*"" & "$
8$***& $*& *"$* $ * $ " *&"*&. *&) ** 0 / /
& $ & *1 $ * $ ! & !
" +*1**&G& #$"% & *$*& =9=9 *"H % .*&% &"1. $&# " *""& 9 /!* !
&""
&*"*&% % &$ *&"*&% "& 5&; .$ $ 1 " &" $& * *&" &
**&&!***& ( %$ & &%
8$***& "*&%* &"!* "&
!**& " *%&
"
&"$" "
8$***&"& *&" & **& *" %$ & ( $ * $ * "1 &" $**< *& & " . = > 9 +1 & & ?
*"
" & " 8$*" "1" $
* 1* 8$*" 1*"" !* *&% " $*>1 3*&%* * 1* *&% " &"$* 1 $ "$ * $F1&!* #$"% & 5&; .$ $*&4$
$
&"1 (. &"/0@9==.66 I &%
1 . * &/ 0@ 9== . 6 I . 1 "+
& *J- &"/99 ). =9
&"E&*& @&"* &"1H !
& *- &"/99 ). 69 &* "*&H % .*&%;
$ /
$ * $
& $**<" &$ * $(*$*&H % .*&%;
.$ " !*&%
,> B& * $ #$"% &
2 .
/*
&& *" . 41& & 1*&%
8$*"
&$ * $/*" &1$ *"
& $ * $(*& *&"*&%
&$ * $
&& $" &$ * $(&*
!
" $& & &" *1 $*" @& ! #$"% & " 0&$
4$ /* &"
&&$& *&% !
" &" 3*&%*&$&". *& /
8$*" &" 1 !* 41& & $ ( &"!&"&% & *% 3 1*&% &"*& &" 3 *$*& *&1&* &"*&$" $ !* *!
8$*"KKK AA AA AA @& 1*!
*" #$"% &/ $% &" !
&
8$*"$&"1**& 0 / $* *&%*& *
8$***&$&"0 /$ * $ !* &"*
!
&%" &$ * $ .
41& * $ $**< *& &"(8$* &
$&* 3 & 1 *&% (
& 1 *"
&%*&%&" $ * D ( $*>1
3*&% $*&% F &
3. *& $ * $
*&%!**&. *&) ** 0 ( /
8$*"
& $ $ & $ * $ 7 &" $& **& " #$"% & 5&; .$ $ &"" *& & .*&% 4* 1. $&# &"/ .)6 &&" $
8$***&
&& &%" 0 $ *" " ! &" !
*&&""
"1 & **&% 7*&3>@@ + &" " .*"!
& 1* 3 "/7$"* ($&* " %*&
8$*" &"!
$" "*
&$*
$!* *& $ "*&&*
*&(
$ $&"!
& *" "($ & $"" $&",> B @&
*"
3"/! *&"&%*&$ **&
& *""&$
8$**&%B$$D &"/ * &" ! *8$*" *&% **&% 7*&3>@@/ !
"1 *
!* * & " *&
8$***& &*
*& *& $"
&%" *& " $(*
&& $ * $ @ &" !
$**"
$/ &&*&% *& * &" * &" " & " $** *& &"1 $ * $"& *&"* *&&
D &% *&"$
&%!* & "/ &&*&%
* /!$"
*& *&"
= %& $
!&*"&* &"*&"$*
""**&
*"
1*"
")= .*-.*&%/0""**& +* E & F + &/ 5 *& ) ) !* !* **& * $&
3& $ " **& "
.$ 1**& %& $
&
"*&+
+1 & ) 0+ ?
*"
" @ * "
&% !* & "!* $**<" . 41& "*%& $ %& $
<& @& &
/ &" * & *&%
&
$ $ $ $ 1*& $
8$***& " & $ * $*& $"*&%%& $
<&/ /$
8$***&
*&$ * $ @&1*! /!"& *&" & **&&!* **& +* *"
:+4$ *; &$ &" (* . ) ) -$&!
&"1. 5 &"
) * .*&% & 1 . 5 ) ) G$"
&"1. 5 &" 6 = ) 7*3*
&"1. 5 &"
6 G &"1. 5 &"