High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/8540/2018dismissed

Ashok Logani v. M/S Pc Jain Textiles Pvt Ltd And ANR

2020-01-28Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan21 pages

!# $!#% & ' (!)"

*! +" ""!# !,!"

!# $!#% & ' (!)"

*! +" ""!# !,!"

!# $!#% & ' (!)"

*! +" ""!# !,!"

!# $!#% & ' (!)"

*! +" ""!# !,!"

!# $!#% & ' (!)"

*! +" ""!# !,!"

!# $!#% & ' (!)"

*! +" ""!# !,!"

# $%# & & # #!!".

#/0*1*2+3"!4 " ##% %"#2+3"!

5#"!,!"

!# **,!"

#61 2+3"!

5#"!#!,!" **"!,!"

& #' 18" #!#29** ,!5 ),!"

5 *! :8 ,!"

1# !5*8""!253"5"!3!#!"""!30,* "

& ' (!)"

*! +" "2;%#% #0"#% "%"# ! ,!#6!<+:#% ""#!!30,* "%!#6!3"

5"!=!

:*!9"#%0!"3"2 !#!

5"!##!5!##!" "!3" !0,* "=-5 -20,* "=5 -0,* "=-5 - "&9"8*!>),#" +" "2 ;%#% #0 "#% " #,# !"#&%"# ! 6

"#8 # 2*0""! *#**!

24 3 3%!

:# !5#!""30,* "30,8 ! ! 0%53"%#

!),#"5# ::2*3!2",!25# !2!0:# !#825:# 323# !"3 "! 33%! ,,#3! "! 30,* " 30,8 5# ,%#3!5 24 34!#!33# *8 ,"3!""!33%! 33!#30,8"!30,* "30,8:!!# " #!,!3"

+! + 3! "!0%"5#"! %,,* !""!

33%!%!"0 " #% 33%"5"!33%! ,!#"!""!0!"533%"2%05 22 4%""

" ,!#"!+!#0!"0! 0,* "=-5 -2" 3# !"! * :

* "82"!33%! %!5**4

3!?%! 5+%#5"!30,* ".

!?%! = #4 **: 1 "2 @"! -5#22 A%# %,!!*8

: !?%!= @#4 **: 1 "2 @"! -5#22& A%#*%,!!*8

3 !?%!= -**:1 "2@"! -5# 2 2&

! A 5"8(4(%A +!%,!!*8 ""!"

0!5 %3!53!?%!2"!33%!

+! %#3!""!30,* """,#!!""

2"!3!?%! 4%*:!!3!33# *82"!30,* ",#!!"!"!

3!?%!5#!30!":%""!4!#!#!"%#!%3!:8:!#

5"!33%!4 "#!0#B>)3!!## !0!"C - (!30,* " 00! "!*8:#% "%3 "%"

""!"

3!5 "!33%!"!33%!#!?%!"!"!30,* "",#!!""!

3!?%! (!30,* " :%""!0! "%"

4 "!#!3!?%!4!#! %#!:8"!:!#5"!33%! #!"%#! " "! 30,* " + ! #!"%# 0!0 "!

- !?%! = 4 " #!0# B>)3!!## !0!"C(!30,* "!#+!*!

3!"! - ,"3! - "#% #!

"!#!&,!! ,"&3%# !#""!*"

+!#!3** %,"!33%!",8 "!3!?%!0%"4 " 85#!3!

,"5"

3!:%"33%! 5 *!"2

+ # !"3%!53"

""!30,* "" :# 30,* "%!#"!3" ""!33%! 9"!#05!#"

0! 0,* "=5 -2" 3# !"! * :

* "82"!33%! %!5**4

3!?%! 5+%#5"!30,* ".

!?%!= @#4 **: 1 "2 @"! -5#22 A%# ( #"8(#!!(%A +!

D%#!A#"86!+!%,!!*8

: !?%!= @#4 **: 1 "2 @"! - 5# 2 &

! A 5"8 ! (% !

- D%#!(4!"8A +!*8

3 !?%!= @#4**:1 "2@"! -5#22& A%# %,!!*8 ""!"

0!5 %3!53!?%!2"!33%!

+! %#3!""!30,* """,#!!""

2"!3!?%! 4%*:!!3!33# *82"!30,* ",#!!"!"!

3!?%!5#!30!":%""!4!#!#!"%#!%3!:8:!# 5"!33%!4 "#!0#B>)3!!## !0!"C - (!30,* " 00! "!*8:#% "%3 "%"

""!"

3!5 "!33%!33%!#!?%!"!"!30,* "",#!!""!

3!?%! (!30,* " :%""!0! "%"

4 "!#!3!?%!4!#! %#!:8"!:!#5"!33%! #!"%#! " "! 30,* " + ! #!"%# 0!0 "!

- !?%! = 4 " #!0# B>)3!!## !0!"C(!30,* "!#+!*!

3!"! - ,"3! - "#% #!

"!#!&,!! ,"&3%# !#""!*"

+!#!3** %,"!33%!",8 "!3!?%!0%"4 " 85#!3!

,"5"

3!:%"33%! 5 *!"2

+ # !"3%!53"

""!30,* "" :# 30,* "%!#"!3" ""!33%! ,!# +!# 5 "! 30,* " 3" !

0,* " =- 5 -2 " 3# ! "! * :

* "82 "!

33%! %!5**4 3!?%! 5+%#5"!30,* ".

!?%!= @#4 **: 1 "2 @"! - -5#--2 )"86 )(%%,!!*8

: !?%!= @#4 **: 1 "2 @"!

-5#22 & ""!"

0!5 %3!53!?%!2"!33%!

+! %#3!""!30,* """,#!!""

2"!3!?%! 4%*:!!3!33# *82"!30,* ",#!!"!"!

3!?%!5#!30!":%""!4!#!#!"%#!%3!:8:5 "!33%!4 "#!0#B>)3!!## !0!"C -(!

30,* "!#+!*!

3!"! - ,"3!

-"#% #!

"!#!&,!!,"&3%# !#2""!*"

+! #!3** %,"!33%!",8"!3!?%!0%"4 "

85#!3!

,"5"

3!:%"33%!5 *!"2

+ # !" 3%!53"

""!30,* "":# 30,* "%!#"!3"

""!33%! 5"!##!3# 5"!,#!* #8!+ !3! **"!

30,* "2 "! 33%! 4 %00! ,%" ,,!#3! **"!"#!!30,* "40 ""!": *D!

0+! ,,* 3"

** "! "#!! 30,* " 5#

3# !&#,, "!,#3!! " 03"! "".

"!,,* 3" !

"!#,#,# !"##,#"!#533%!= E 30,8

"""!#! **!

" 0"5"!* :

* "8%!# 6!3"

5"!3"

"""!,,* 3"":!!%00!:8"!%#" "!#! 33%!= "!0""!#2*8!33%! "!#! "

3! 4!"" 33%! ! &9"8*!

>),#" +" "2"!#!5#!,!"

!# " 33%!

+"",,* 3" 4"%"# !:81#5 @ #!3"#"#!,#!!""!3!2"!#!5#!2!3",,!# :!*55"!30,8

+""6!3"

5"!=!

:*!9"#%0!"3""

,%*"! """!*!#0%"

+!"

3!"""! "#%0!":!! %#!2 " ** "! ,#"

! "! *!# !! " 0!

!+!#**8* :*!"!#! "!,#!!"3!"!30,* "

+! "

3! 5 %# *8 " 33%! = !

30,8"!55!3!:!!300 ""!:8"!30,8

+ ""*!

3!4!"""!,,* 3"

""3# ** :

* "83:!5"!%,"!,,* 3"

3!6!3"

5"!3",#+ !""5#0 ,!# * :*!5#"!55!3!2"!,!#0%":! 3# !5"!

30,8 "!,#!!"3!2"!#! +!#0!" "!

30,* """"!,,* 3" 3# !5"!30,8 6!+!#*F% 0!":8"!,!)%#"4!#!#!5!##!" ""#!

# (! ,,* 3"

4 ,,! :8 "! 30,* "

3**!

"0 " :

* "83"! "" !*" 4 " "! 30,* " "#%3! 0!*5 "!

@ #!3"#5"!33%!33!#

"%#!#!"!#!"!

3!?%! ?%!"

""*!

3!4 %!"&9"8*!

>),#" +"

" "#%

" %"# !

"#8& #,# !"#&@ #!3"#

"%#! 5

"!*54%*

+!# !" * :

* "8 5"!# !# # %0!" +3! :8 "! 3%!*2 *!#! "# *

"#"! 0 ! "! ,,* 3"

+ ! !,#"!

#!#"!

(!,!#"

+!,#"5"!#!#5##!8 #!5!#!3! :!

#!,#%3!%!#.

! "

# !

$ % ! #

&'( ) * * + ,

, * ,

- ## # $

## ! #

# $

# #

# ! #

. #

# # $ (/( 012 # ( 343

$ $

#$ &' ( ) ( ) % !,

( #

# $ #

# # ## .

$ #

$# + # &' ( )

( ) % !,

( #

# $

# 367 # 8

! $ #

- #

# $

(

&'( ) ,+ ,

( 343# 5

& ) (

$ ## $#( 343032 012#8

)

(!!#!#*!5""!,!"

# !+! !,,#3!" %#":84855 *

3"! "" *!#! "# *

"#"! #

"*8 **4! "! ,,* 3"

5 & 9"8*! >),#" +" " %!# 6!3"

# 5#,, "0!"5#!,#!!""

+!5,!"

!# 30,82 4!+!# 4# *8 0 ! "! ,,* 3"

5# #,, "!,#3!! ""!,!"

!# (! ,!"

!# * 5 *!

!! ?% 5**"!"#!!30,* ""!

%00 #!# ,! "!#!

4!** ** "! 3 **#8 ,#3!!

3! 5 "! ,!"

+! " "!

#!,!"&30,* "24,%" ,,!#3!"#% 3%!* 9"08:!0!"

!!#!""33%!30,85 *! ,,* 3"

%!# 6!3"

# 5# ,, "0!" 5 #!,#!!""

+! !3 30,* "2 4 3 4!#! 3"!"! :8 "!

30,* "(! ,,* 3"

4!#! ,!5:8"!"# *

"#"!+ !#!#

(!,!#"

+!,#"5"!#!# 5##!8#!5!#!3! :!

#!,#%3!%!#.

( 69:)

)

; ) &

( !

;

)# <

; #

# +$ #

$ ;

) # ( 69:)

)

$ ( !

9+!!#*!#!3%!*5#"!,#"

!:! !

"#% "!#!3#95 """!#! :*%"!*80!# " "!

,!"

0 ""!*82"!,!"

@ #!3"#5"!

33%!E30,8!

!**"!3!?%!24 3 ,#!!""

:!! %#! 5"!# "! 30,* " 4

5#0!:8"!:!#4 "#!

#" %# 53!?%!2"!

30,* "!#+!"

3!""!33%!33!#"#% " %"# G!

"#8&,#,# !"#& #!3"# 9 "!

30,* " %!# 6!3"

5 "! 3"2 33%! 33!# 4

0,*!!"#% ",#,# !"#&%"# !

"#8

5"!#:!

!#+!2 ,,!#! "!3!(%

3*!+!#0+!2! ",,* 3"

%!#6!3"

# 5 *! 5# ,, "0!" 5 #!,#!!""

+! 5 33%! 4! "!

,,* 3"

4!#!**4!:8"!"# *

"#"!+ !#!#"!

2 ,,* 3"

5# 3# !4#

"*8 0 !:8 "!"# *

"#"!(!,!"

!#3"4 55"!

0""!# %30!#D!:!

@ #!3"#5"!

33%! 33!#

"#8 "! 3!?%! ?%!"

3 3!#" *8"30!%,4 ""#

"53!""!""! " "4 ""!0""!#!%*":!,#!3%"! 33%"5 %# 5"!3!?%!24 3:!! %!%!#

"%#!5#"!33%!33!#D8,!#"!3 3*,,#3 %3 "8,! 5 0""!# 3 3!#" *8 :! " ,"! (! "# *

"#"!45%**8F%"

! %00 533%!33!# "#% 0 ,,* 3"

5# 3# !

#"!F% 0!"#!5!##!":8*!#!3%!* 5#"!,!"

!# !

#$$# %"&

'"( !)# !" *) + # , '-# . #

+ 0 . ' "

11"

*#)

## "& 3 22,% " $

*4 5 / "&. 01

#$$# " 6 %"&7 5

- !"&8# 2 "!"5 ,,* 3"

""!,#!!"3!%!" 55!#!"53" 3 #3%0"3!"!3"!)" 4 3%3:!#+"

:!!0!

H!#!"!F% 0!"#!* !%,:8*!#!3%!*5# "!#!,!"30,* " !9$"4$ #./ + :+ -#40 ?% "!!*,5%* ,#,!#*8 F% 3"

"!3"#+!#8(!,!"

!#:!

@ #!3"# 5"!33%!30,8 ":!"!93# !#!, :*!" "!30,85#3%3"5"!:% ! "!#056!3"

5"!3"2! !!0!":! % *"85"!55!3!* :*!":!

,#3!!! ",% !33# *89%3!5!,#"!

3!" 04"!3!#8:!!!* ,#= "

-5" F% 0!"

9"!#F% 0!"#!5!##!":8*!#!3%!*5# "! #!,!"&30,* " !

;3 .##3 8#

# $"* )+

+ .

2<2,# =

5"!F% 0!",!:8@!* D

%#"#!?% "!

#!*!+" 5# #!8 #!5!#!3! "! #! :! #!,#%3! %!#. $

)

- #*# $

# #

) - $

# #

. # /# #

# #

= $

) - #

#( (

0 - $ # ## #

( ) # $

# # $ $

# ##

## . )

H!#! F% 0!" ;

"4 2%

# 2"!,!)%#"%00# ! "!, %!#6!3"

%!#.

02 #

- > -

# #

# ## #

$ ##

! #

# $

# #

# ! #

# - (

#( 10142#) 2 # 02 0#2# ( :#)

# $

# #

( 343032

0 2" "## #

( 343032?" "## #

( 343012

9 5 / "& . 0=1 7 ) #,,2"!,!) %#":!#+!""4!3!?%! %!:830,8 :!! %#!"!30,8 " #02@ #!3"# 55 3!##!:!

,#!3%"!2 3!5@ #!3"##55 3!#5 "!30,824

!"!3!?%!:!*55"!30,82"!#!

!!"0!,!3 3+!#0!"""!4 3# !5

4#!, :*!""!30,825#"!3%3"5"!:% !5 "!30,8 9"!,#!!"3!2" ,#!3 !*8:!

"!,*!"!:8 "!,!"

!#24 3 + !45"!!""*!*4* 43":!

33!,"!6 3!"!"

3!:!! %!""!33%!33!# "#% "!,!"

!# 0!*52"!#!4!3! "85 %

!,#"!"

3!" 0%!#"!3 #3%0"3!D! "!#!:!5#!"!

"# *%#"0!#!*8:!3%!"!"# *%#"**4!0!

%"# !,!#",,!#:!*55"!30,8!"0! """!,!"

!# !":*+!5 3# ** :

* "8 3,3 "8

@ #!3"#5"!33!#

"#85"!3!?%!2 4 3:!! %#! 6!3"

# !*4 " !#!",4!#5"!

%#",#+ """ " !**:!!!0!" * "#55!3""! !#!",4!#5"!D

%#""0!%3 #!#08:!!3!#8"

+!!55!3""8#!#%!#" !2#",#!+!":%!5"!,#3!58%#"#"!#4 !" !3%#!"!!5F%"

(! 0,% !#!#,!:8"!"# *%#"#!?% "!

!" *!24!**#!!2:!%,,#,!#,,# *,,#!3 "

5!+ !3!3##!3" "!#,#!""

5*4(!#! **!

* "8#

5 #0 "8 "!#!

6 *#*8 "! 3# * 30,* " 5 *! %!# 6!3"

5"!3""%55!#5#08*!

* 5 #0 "8"!

%00 #!#%33!5%**8,"!*!

*3#%"

8 =!5"!,!"

5**%!#5%#3#!#56!3"

# "3**5# "!#5!#!3!:8" %#"#!

#"!

0,% !#!#230,* "%00 #!# (!#!5#!2"!,!"

" 0 !33# *8 ( & #) 1# *++,,-./01 . *++,,/,23 .