Bhag Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others





    
 




  !

     !  "#$%&$" ''())#&* +(,-.- *#*( .&/#0#&1*"(,-   (-'&1(&*-  23  45  
5

55 "#

 $%&$ !'

 +++ 5

55  6   ))** ,)*

--#' .$-% # 0)

-# .$-%

 -# ))** ,)*

* #*# (

( ( (3 #

(# * ( )* (* -3(4 )*(( * ! 3(((# 1'#

#$!

3 5$#1( ,)#% 
)#4%)#'% (#003#3

 /78" 4 )* (1% $ -(#)3# ( 3# -* **-**(- (%$  ! (#

' %$ 

6( %$ ## *1*1   %)

#( 1

-' (%6( $-( #1* **-** % *(

#$$# : !( $3 *
   ,        (  $  3(*  #

'#$ )#*% #1.

4 (()*

 ))#( (2$#3(* ( $))#

%#*  4  (()#)# 3 5$#1(4%)#'% #$ 6( 3# )3

 /1(; 5$

2**#6(%$ %)

3 )  (

 ; 5$ 2**#1(4%)#'% #)# $ (3# # 1$# % ( %(* (*# 6()*

!

 !3 9 (##  %**)# (5$#* 6( )*

 * -3(  (  (#  9  (  *#  #'  (

%$ )#(# (#"

(5$#* 3 < (#$-((2**#  #)

(3#! (()*

*

*    #   $ #  (  ;   5$    #     

 #-# -  (  )#)#    5$   2%)

 3

1(6#1$ *4 $#(# (3#) 3 *1

* -3(((#9 (** - -(3#!3(( 3 1( 2$# (%#(  * #(  (: =1*$)#%2$#  )4 1( , (()*

3  #*- ( 1 -()#  $ (#  :## 

#$

(  '   )# #  3((  (  (  *#  #'  (  %$   

 $#(## #'(##-(  * %

)#  #$ $) %)# ()#)#3 1(#$ 

* ( $3 )# # >**3

$ 3# #%1(*# #*2$# 1 ()*  ?((#()*

*# #*# 

(

(()*

3 #

%#< @27>A:-#$

*# ($ %#< 4&B;  *#%  )* C""  ?((#()*

*# #)#% .$  # -( #% #1*!3# -* **-** # # %

# 

-( )*

#%( ($ * * 

%

#!#

## - # - )# (#- '#3# -* **-**C""

 ?((#()*

*$  *()#

$C" /  ?((# $

%  1* )#  #% *1*1

C"

 ?((#()*

%(2$#3(*

( $))#

(%#*  #%(2$# C"

 ?((#()*

# ))1(#3  $

#% -()#  $C"  ?((#( $ 1 # 9. # % 9. #



#)# C" 0
*   7' 3 *11(()#  #*2$#

( *1()*

, ))**   3(*  1 #' -  (  (  )*

 (  *#  '*

3# $ 5$ >$#(#%#!

 )* ## (

 ) #('*3#)

*1(%1 #( 2$## (: =1*$)#%2$# 4 4 $#(#1 #'(1 ( )*

* <%- D%)

#(

#$

( #$$# *%1

#$1(%6(#* $-(

$! 1 #'!$* ))* *1())** 3

/ 

 -#'.$-%  --#'(# #%!)# ))*( *

 '(% *#-$ (( ))**  (  $ 

()#)# )$4 

$1%(# ( 3# )* (% 5$ (#00 (#

 

#) (%)

)(

(* !()*

,))**  **# $-( (

(()*

,))**  (3 #

* 4 !($ !)#( ( ))*1**3!%)$- .$-% # 0 )

-#

.$-%

 *  -#!1   *1())** 1 #(#$-($ 4('(#*#

('- (#$-(( *3((#1*

  )$  (* 3 5$# ( 3# )3

1(4%)#'% !
)#31< )#*!;#

 $ 1* )$(

3 93 # )# (5$#* 6()*

, ))** !  %*!  #'  (  %)

 )   1  ( )(5$ !* -3( (  (#  9   "*

 ,  ))**   *   *    #       (  %)

 3#  1  (  ;   5$

2**#!3((3 1(6#1$ *6( ))** ,)*

* -3(9 $-( $#(# (%)

))#(( 2$#6(%#(  * #(

(: =1*$)#%2$#;#

( #-$ (())** (*  $-(( 1# # #% 

-()*

#%(* 4 %# ## (  $% *$ -(3#)

#(##

)

(# ('1 )* ##:3'#!*#

())**  *  (( 3#) (** - -( 3# 3

!($-( ( $ 1* $# ()

%' ;# #*2$#( #-(*1 #'(()*

$ 1** ) '  #-#"? (

#

8% %((( - #

 #-(  $)    (  : =1*  $)#%  2$#  1$  (  (  (** -(%$ #*# ((3#

 * ( 1  1 $# %) .$#  @((*# $# 1*3('#-(*1 #'(( #* #  *#    (  

  (  (  ))**     (  3 #  

()#)# 

!<) '3 ()

(3# /!5$# -(*  $#(# )# # (%)

1 - *  ( -! !(3'#!#*'  ( % 3#   / 1(;  5$ 2**#( ( 4%)#'% !
)#( #5$ (78$'7 - #"?!

)#  #

%   # ! 3(( 3#)#   5$#*  (  $))*% #3# 1%D)

!

# -*4 ((*# #*2$#( *#1 #'

( ) ()*

 <%- D%)

#-# -(

#$$#! **3 )#'18 -(% (5$

1$(*# $-(

 %

#) ! 5$ *3%$(*

$1 *5$ *3 '*' ))*

 $ 1*) $

**-*!

#%#)#'#  %)$- .$-% # 0)

-# .$-%

 -#!3((** # # 1(

2$#  ))* 6(# * / 


  B) '3( ((%#(  %# !( 5$ * ))*( #% ))* !# -*! (##-$% ( #

 # -*!( ))*

3( ##   5%-#%))!

 ! 








.1$( #

?((# )< -D#

F D ?((##)#1*

F D