High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10534/2014allowed

Dhian Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others

2016-09-20Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan4 pages

!"# $#%&'&()*+ ,&!(-&(., #"&"&(#/ 0#/'1'

-"!"# 1(2!3!($",#/'

#'4($#("'

) 56 - 7 6- /#'#(")8 /##/!2-,!/9!:$;%!"#: /",#4#"&"&(#/ /!2!"!('!<:''&'"!(" 1(2!3 ,#",#/",##4/"#/' <%!<(#='4!4#/9!>3#!<<=#$" '##",#21$.9#("?

3#/# #//#$"",##4/"#//(" ,#",#/",#21$.9#("',1<$3#/#4/"#$&(",#$&.#'"? 88 88 6-

6 ,#4#"&"&(#//#($#/#$"='4#<<' '#/;&%#1($#//#'4($#("

:(#!'=/@%,!/.# /9*A"A*B,#/#!

"#/:!

"#/!

3/#!@ &;#>#!/':",#4#"&"&(#/=!'!.!&(#94<>#$!'!#%,!(&%&( 7,!/!/ ('"/1%"&(&;&'&(:,!<&:(*BA &''#/;&%#'=#/# /#.1<!/&C#$(+!($,#/#"&/#$ /9'#/;&%#(:=,&<# =/@&(. !" #%,!(&%!< /!&(!.#&;&'&(:!241/! ,# %<!&9 ",# 4#"&"&(#/&'",!",&'4/#;&1'=/@%,!/.#'#/;&%#/#($#/#$ /9*A" A*B ',1<$ 3# %1("#$ !' D1!<& >&(. '#/;&%# / ",# 41/4'#

4#('&(!/>3#(# &"' ,#-"!"#&(",#/#4<>,!'"!@#(",#'"!($",!"",#'!&$4/#;&1' =/@%,!/.# '#/;&%# /#($#/#$ /9 *A " A*B %!((" 3# %1("#$ /4#('&(!/> 3#(# &"'!'",#/#=!'!3/#!@ &;#>#!/'&( '#/;&%#,#/$#/$!"#$* ((#E1/#88+ ,!'3##(4!''#$&(",&'

/#.!/$

88 ,!;#,#!/$",#<#!/(#$%1('#<' /",#4!/"&#'!($,!;#!<' %!/# 1<<>.(#",/1.,",# &<# 1<#A 3 ",#1(2!3 &;&<-#/;&%#'1<#':0<19#8:

!/"8,!'3##(/#<&#$14(3>",#-"!"#:=,&%,&'/#4/$1%#$!'1($#/)8 FA ,#( ! ;#/(9#(" #94<>##: =, ,!' 3##( $&'9&''#$: /#9;#$: %941<'/&<> /#"&/#$ &' /#&('"!"#$ !' ! /#'1<" !44#!<: /#;&'&( / /#;&#= / =1<$ ,!;# 3##( /#&('"!"#$31" /,&'/#"&/#9#("('14#/!((1!"&(=,&<#1($#/ '1'4#('&( / (": ",# !1",/&"> %94#"#(" " /$#/ ",# /#&('"!"#9#("',!<<%('&$#/!($9!@#!'4#%& &%/$#/)8

/#.!/$&(.",#4!>!($!<<=!(%#'"3#4!&$"",#

;#/(9#("#94<>## /",#4#/&$ ,&'!3'#(%# /9 $1">:&(%<1$&(.",#4#/&$ '1'4#('&(:4/#%#$&(.,&'

$&'9&''!<:/#9;!</%941<'/>/#"&/#9#("!'",#%!'# 9!>3#:!($

=,#",#//("",#'!&$4#/&$',!<<3#"/#!"#$!'! 4#/&$'4#("($1">G ,#'!&$/1<#&'("!""/!%"#$!"!<<&(",#4/#'#("%!'#!'&"=!' ("!%!'# $&'9&''!<:/#9;!</%941<'/>/#"&/#9#(":31"&"=!'!%!'# /#"/#(%,9#("!

"#/%94<#"&( =/@%,!/.#'#/;&%# ,#4/#;&1'=/@%,!/.#'#/;&%#4#/&$ ",#4#"&"&(#/ /9 *A"A*B!($",#/#!

"#/ /9*BA"&<<,&'/#"&/#9#("( &'("$&'41"#$$9&""#$<>:",#/#=!'!.!4 &;#>#!/'=:

",#D1#'"&(=1<$!/&'# /%('&$#/!"&(&'",!"!'"=,#",#/",#4/#;&1' =/@%,!/.#'#/;&%#/#($#/#$ /9*A"A*B&'"3#%1("#$!' !D1!<& >&(.'#/;&%# /",#41/4'# ./!(" 4#('&(!

"#/#E%<1$&(.",#

88 3/#!@4#/&$(",&'/#.!/$:",#'#/;&%#&'"3#%1("#$&("#/9' 1<# A8 :=,&%,&''132#%""1<# ",#1(2!3 &;&<-#/;&%#'1<#':

0<19#8,#'!&$/1<#!9#($#$=&",#

#%" /9+**B:3# /#",# 4#"&"&(#/2&(#$",#'#%($'4#<< '#/;&%#:&'/#4/$1%#$!'1($#/)8 F (",#!3'#(%# '4#%& &%&($&%!"&("",#%("/!/> &(",#'#/;&%#/#%/$:!(&("#//14"&(3#"=##("='4#<<'

'#/;&%#/#($#/#$1($#/",#-"!"# ;#/(9#("',!<<3#"/#!"#$!'

!1"9!"&%!<<>%($(#$:!($",#4/#8&("#//14"&('#/;&%#',!<< 3#"/#!"#$!'D1!<& >&(.'#/;&%# /4#('&(41/4'#':#E%#4"

=,#/# ",# &("#//14"&( ,!' 3##( %!1'#$ 3> /#'&.(!"&(: $&'9&''!<//#9;!< /9'#/;&%#/$1#"4!/"&%&4!"&(&(!

'"/&@#: 31" ",# 4#/&$ &("#//14"&( &"'#< ',!<<: 1($#/ ( %&/%19'"!(%#':3#/#%@(#$!'D1!<& >&(.'#/;&%# /4#('&( 41/4'#'G ,#/1<#9!@#'&"%<#!/",!"",#4/#8&("#//14"&('#/;&%#&'"3# "/#!"#$ !' D1!<& >&(. '#/;&%# / 4#('&( 41/4'#': #E%#4" =,#/# ",# &("#//14"&(,!'3##(%!1'#$3>/#'&.(!"&(:$&'9&''!<//#9;!< /9 '#/;&%#/$1#"4!/"&%&4!"&(&(!'"/&@#:31"",#&("#//14"&(4#/&$&'(" "3#/#%@(#$!'D1!<& >&(.'#/;&%# /4#('&(41/4'#'(",&'%!'#:",# 4#"&"&(#/=!'!$9&""#$<>/#"/#(%,#$!

"#/%94<#"&(. &/'"'4#<< '#/;&%# (A*B,#/# /#:",#%!'#&'%;#/#$3>1<# ",#1(2!3

&;&<-#/;&%#'1<#':0<19#8 /#4/$1%#$!3;# !($",#'#/;&%# ",# 4#"&"&(#/ /9*A"A*B&'"3#%1("#$!'D1!<& >&(.'#/;&%#

/4#('&(41/4'#'=#;#/:",#3/#!@4#/&$&'(""3#%1("#$!' D1!<& >&(.'#/;&%# /",#4#('&(41/4'#'&("#/9' ",#'!&$/1<#,# /#'4($#("'!/#$&/#%"#$"/#8 &E",#4#('&(!

"#/%1("&(.",#'!&$4#/&$ !($/#<#!'#",#4#('&(!%%/$&(.<>=&",&(",/##9(",' /9",#$!"#

88 /#%#&4" %4> ",&'21$.9#("%%/$&(.<>:",#=/&"4#"&"&(&'!<<=#$ &(",#!3;#("#$"#/9'

*+ '2@' ,#",#/'4#!@&(. /#!'(#$ ) #' ,#",#/#4/"!3<# ) #'