High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10558/2014allowed

Isha Sharma v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2017-07-28Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan11 pages

!"##$%&%'( ) ) &*!+*!,-!

#"%"%'#, /#,&0& +"!"# 0'1!2!'3!'"*#, ..

#&4'3#'"&

,#&#'"(.

,5!4%65!77!,839$!"#,"*#4#"%"%'#, &'%$!**%22#,+*!,-!8+,8 0'1!2 :::

*!66#';#%'"*#%'&"!'"4#"%"%'%&""*#,3#,3!"#3 <

''#=0,# .) 84!&&#32>"*#%,#$", 026%$'&",0$"%'& + 8 0'1!2 !'3%'"#,-&?*%$*"*#$6!%-"*#4#"%"%'#,&##7%';!44%'"-#'"!& !"*%&",#&&0'3#,"*##'#,!6!"#;,>8*!&2##'3#$6%'#3 ,%#!$"&?063,#@0%,#'"%$#

#"%"%'#,8?*2#6';&""*##'#,!6!"#;,>8*!3!446%#3 , "*# 4&" !"* %&",#&& %' ,#&4'&# " !' !39#,"%&#-#'" 3!"#3

<A A8%&&0#32>"*# 0'1!2+"!"#+$*630$!"%'#4!,"-#'" ""!6<B<4&"&?#,#!39#,"%&#3!"*%&",#&&#& 4'&$,0"%'> "*#!446%$!"%',-&02-%""#32>"*#4#"%"%'#,8&*#?!&0'3#6%;%26#!'3 %&&0#3"*#,#@0%&%"#,#;%&",!"%''0-2#,&!&"4!,"%$%4!"#%'"*#4,$#&& &#6#$"%' '"*#2!&%&"*#-!,7&2"!%'#32>"*#4#"%"%'#,%'*#, #30$!"%'!6!'34,#&&%'!6@0!6%%$!"%'&!'3%'"*#6%;*""*#"#!$*%'; #=4#,%#'$#4&&#&&#38"*#4#"%"%'#,?!&!&&%;'#3B )BC-!,7&'"*# $-2%'#3 -#,%" 6%&" 3#$6!,#3 !'3 40" %' 4026%$ 3-!%'8 '!-# "*# 4#"%"%'#,%;0,#3!"+,<*#%,&"$0'&#6%';#=#,$%&#?!&

$'30$"#3%'"*#%,&"?##706>8 8?*#,#%'$!'3%3!"#&&#$0,%';-#,%"

4&%"%'04"+,AB?#,#$!66#3 6#!,6>8"*#4#"%"%'#,?!&'" #6%;%26# " 4!,"%$%4!"# %' &0$* $0'&#6%'; 4,$#&& *# ,#&4'3#'" 3#4!,"-#'"8"*#,#!"#,8%&&0#3!4026%$'"%$#$!66%';"*#$!'3%3!"#&,"*# &#$'3$0'&#6%';?*%$*?!&%=#3,) #"%"%'#,$063'"

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

% &

$ (

(

, $

./ 0

, $

, 2 ,$

(

)

./ 0

034&5.67-1 ))

,( (

(

, ,$,

(

( ( ,

' (

' ( ,

$ '

,$ ( ' (

;

0 $

'( ,

, +,

(

3 '

8) .;<9*;=9/>*>9*21 <?*/;@ "%&%'40,4,"#3$-46%!'$#"*#3%,#$"%'&%&&0#32>"*%& 0,"%'"*#103;#-#'"3!"#3< <%' BA< "*!""*# 4#"%"%'#,?!&;%9#'44,"0'%">"4!,"%$%4!"#%'!$0'&#6%';#=#,$%&# $'30$"#3' < ?#9#,8*#,$6!%-,!44%'"-#'"!&!"* %&",#&&%'"*##'#,!6!"#;,>&"!'3&,#1#$"#39%3#%-40;'#3,3#,3!"#3 < ''#=0,# .)

#,0&!6"*#%-40;'#3,3#,?063,#9#!6"*!""*#-#,%" "*#4#"%"%'#,&"!'3&,#.!&&#&&#3!'3'?&"!'3&3#"#,-%'#3!"B)BC!& 44&#3"B )BC#!,6%#,%'4%'""%-# #!&'%';*!&2##'

0,'%&*#3%'"*#%-40;'#3,3#,"*!""*#-#,%""*#6!&"$!'3%3!"#&#6#$"#3 %'"*##'#,!6!"#;,>%'"*#&021#$"!"*%&B

<C!'3!&&0$*8"*# !44%'"-#'"6#""#,$!''"2#%&&0#3""*#4#"%"%'#, '"*#1%'"?,%""#'&"!"#-#'"%6#3'2#*!6,#&4'3#'"& '!'3 0,"*#,#6!2,!"%'*!&2##'4,9%3#3"10&"%>"*#3#"#,-%'!"%' "*#%'!6-#,%""*#4#"%"%'#,"2#B)BC*#"!206!"%';%9%';"*# 2,#!7.04 -!,7& !&&%;'#3 " "*# 4#"%"%'#, *!& 2##' 0,'%&*#3 %' 4!,!;,!4* < "*# 4,#6%-%'!,> &02-%&&%'& $'"!%'#3 %' "*# ?,%""#' &"!"#-#'"!'3?*%$*%&,#4,30$#3*#,#0'3#,(.

C ;,!30!"%'

-!,7&

C3 -!,7& !,7&%'6%#0 %;*#, D0!6%%$!"%'

!,7&%'6%#0 =4#,%#'$# "!6

) B B %6 B)B *#"!206!"%',#9#!6&"*!""*#4#"%"%'#,*!&2##'!&&%;'#3E%6E -!,7&%'6%#0#=4#,%#'$# '"*#?,%""#'&"!"#-#'"%"&#6"*#,#&4'3#'"3#4!,"-#'"*!& "!7#' ! &"!'3 "*!" "*# 4#"%"%'#, *!3 4,30$#3 $#,"%%$!"#& " $6!%- ?#%;*"!;# "?!,3& #=4#,%#'$# , "*# 4#,%3 ) ) " < -'"*&83!>& %'"*#6%;*"!$#,"%%$!"#3!"#3

%'"*#+%';* +!2*!5!'>! !"*&*!6! +#'%,+#$'3!,> 82*!,!&!6&!$#,"%%$!"# 3!"#3 <,"*#4#,%3

< "<

-'"*&8)3!>& 8 ) "<< A -'"*&8)3!>& !'3 A" <

>#!,&8 -'"*&!'3<3!>& ,-&&0-4"%''9#'"+$*682*!,20" '?#%;*"!;#*!&2##';,!'"#3,&0$*#=4#,%#'$#'"?$0'"&%#"*# $#,"%%$!"#3!"#3

?!&%&&0#3!"#,"*#6!&"3!"#&02-%&&%' !446%$!"%',-&&"%406!"#3%'"*#!39#,"%&#-#'"%#A A!'3"*# #=4#,%#'$# $#,"%%$!"# ,- &&0-4"%' '9#'" +$*68 2*!, !6& *!9%';2##'%&&0#3!"#,"*#6!&"3!"#&02-%&&%'!446%$!"%',-&!'3

"*#$#,"%%$!"#*!9%';'"2##'$0'"#,&%;'#32>"*#%&",%$"30$!"%' %$#, *#9!6%3%">"*#3#$%&%'"*#,#&4'3#'"!0"*,%"%#&%' *!9%';,#1#$"#3"*#$6!%-"*#4#"%"%'#,&##7%';!44%'"-#'"""*#4&" !"*%&",#&& #'#,!6!"#;,> 9%3#%-40;'#3,3#,3!"#3 <

''#=0,# .) ?063*!9#"2##=!-%'#3!;!%'&""*#2!$73,4"*# ,#6#9!'" "#,-& !'3 $'3%"%'& $'"!%'#3 %' "*# !39#,"%&#-#'" 3!"#3

<A A ''#=0,# . %'"#,-&?*%$*"*#,#$,0%"-#'"4,$#&&*!3 2##'%'%"%!"#3 *# 3#"!%6& "*# 9!,%0& 4&"& ?#,# -#'"%'#3 %' "*# !39#,"%&#-#'"!'3!""!6<B<4&"&!&"#,&F%&",#&&#&*!32##' !39#,"%&#3+0$*4&"&%',#6!"%'""*#&021#$"!"*#-!"%$&?#,# ) *#2!&%$@0!6%%$!"%'4,#&$,%2#3?!&,+$,$-?%"*, 3+#6#$"%'4,$#30,#?!&!6&3#%'#3%'"*#!39#,"%&#-#'"!'3%'"*# 66?%';"#,-&(

,'( ,

( (,

(

( (

+ %

(, *

; 6 .;1 (,

(

'( A) .21 -%-"

+ A & .1 #

.B( ,2

B(, =

10 %"

& #B

%%% %%% %%%

.B.

0 -28- 8-08-;

-4 & 3

4 * #C -

%%% %%% %%%

! "#

#$%! $& '%'(%)#*+

,- !'. &! !/!

#!*'! ,)!

-$)#*#*+ ).! $ #'

0(%#,#')#-* -

1#%% $! +#2!* ,- ).! !/!

#!*'! %!

).* &! #

% '(

-)%

@ *#!39#,"%&#-#'"!6&$'"!%'#3$#,"!%';#'#,!6$'3%"%'& !446%$!26#""*#4,&4#$"%9#$!'3%3!"#&6!0&#& !'3"*#;#'#,!6 $'3%"%'& ?063 2#,#6#9!'" " "*# %&&0#!" *!'3 !'3 !,# ,#4,30$#3 *#,#0'3#,(.

( +

(

, D , + 8

' ( ,

2 $ E

(

; 6 . ,1

@ &4#,!39#,"%&#-#'"8-!=%-0- -!,7& ?#,# !3-%&&%26# "?!,3&?#%;*"!;#,#=4#,%#'$#2>!&&%;'%';'#-!,7,#!$*>#!, #=4#,%#'$#!"#,2"!%'%';"*#2!&%$@0!6%%$!"%'

.).

*# 6!&" 3!"# , &02-%&&%' !446%$!"%'& ,- #6%;%26# $!'3%3!"#&?!&&"%406!"#304"A A $'1%'",#!3%';$6!0&# !'3$6!0&#"*#;#'#,!6 $'3%"%'&$'"!%'#3%'"*#!39#,"%&#-#'"-!7#&%"$6#!,"*!""*#$!'3%3!"#& ?#,#"06%66!66"*#4,#&$,%2#3@0!6%%$!"%'&!'3$'3%"%'&'"*#6!&" 3!"#&02-%&&%'"*#!446%$!"%',-&

,"*#40,4&#;,!'"?#%;*"!;#"?!,3&#=4#,%#'$#"*# 6!&" 3!"# , &02-%&&%' !446%$!"%' ,-& %# A A ?063 2# ,#6#9!'"%'!&-0$*!&"*##=4#,%#'$#,?*%$*!$!'3%3!"#?!&"$6!%- ?#%;*"!;#*!3"2#4,%,"&0$*3!"#6!0&#& !'3"*#;#'#,!6 $'3%"%'&$'"!%'#3%'"*#!39#,"%&#-#'"3'"&4#660"!-!'3!"#"*!" "*#$#,"%%$!"#"?!,3&#=4#,%#'$#&*063!6&*!9#2##'%&&0#34,%,""*# 6!&"3!"#&02-%&&%'!446%$!"%',-&"%&,#6#9!'","*#$!'3%3!"#& "*!9#!$@0%,#3#6%;%2%6%">!&!6&#=4#,%#'$#"$6!%-?#%;*"!;#4,%," "*#6!&"3!"#!446%$!"%',-&%#A A #"%"%'#,%&$6!%-%';

?#%;*"!;#,#=4#,%#'$#'"*#2!&%&$#,"%%$!"#&%&&0#3'

!'3 <20",!4#,%34,%,""*#6!&"3!"#,&02-%&&%' !446%$!"%',-&*#,#@0%&%"#?#%;*"!;# -!,7&8!&&0$*8$063'"

*!9#2##'3#'%#3"*#,'6>'"*#2!&%&"*!""*#$#,"%%$!"#46!$#3,#6%!'$# 04'8 *!32##'%&&0#3!"#,"*#6!&"3!"#,&02-%&&%'!446%$!"%' ,-&'"*#!2&#'$#!&4#$%%$&"%406!"%'%'"*#!39#,"%&#-#'" !& ,#;!,3&"*##=4#,%#'$#$#,"%%$!"#"*!9#!6&2##'%&&0#34,%,""*#6!&" 3!"# &02-%&&%' !446%$!"%' ,-&8 "*# 21#$"%' ,!%&#3 2> "*# ,#&4'3#'"!0"*,%"%#&$!''"&0&"!%' *# &"!'3 "!7#' 2> "*# ,#&4'3#'" !0"*,%"%#& "*!" "*# $#,"%%$!"#3!"#3 <$6!%-%';#=4#,%#'$#,-

< '?!,3&

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

6!$#3',#$,3!"''#=0,# .A%&"*#$#,"%%$!"#%&&0#32>"*#

,%'$%4!6&&0-4"%''9#'"+$*682*!,"*!&'"2##'3%&40"#3 "*!"&0$*&$*6%&!%6%!"#3""*#0'$%6,"*#'3%!'+$*6#,"%%$!"# =!-%'!"%'& +0$*$#,"%%$!"#*!&2##'$0'"#,&%;'#32>"*#&&%&"!'" +#$,#"!,>8 0'$%6 , "*# '3%! +$*6 #,"%%$!"# =!-%'!"%'&8 #? #6*% "%&'""*#$!&#-!3#0"'2#*!6"*#+"!"#"*!""*#&$*6 %'@0#&"%'%#&&0-4"%''9#'"+$*682**!,?!&'"!,#$;'%G#3 !'3!%6%!"#3&$*6"%&'"#9#'"*#$!&#"*#+"!"#,&0$*$#,"%%$!"# *!&'"2##'$0'"#,&%;'#32>"*#$-4#"#'"!0"*,%">!&4#,,#@0%,#-#'" 0'3#,"*#$6!0&#6!>%';3?'"*#"# $#% 0'3#,"*#

.A.

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

,>&0$* $0'$%6 %;',# &0$* $#,"%%$!"#8 "*# ,#&4'3#'" !0"*,%"%#& *!3 " $'$603#"*!""*#&&%&"!'"+#$,#"!,>"*#0'$%6%&'""*#$-4#"#'" !0"*,%">!&-#'"%'#3%'"*#,#6#9!'"$6!0&#"*#!39#,"%&#-#'"3#%'%'; &#6#$"%' 4,$#30,# *!" %& '" "*# 9%#? "!7#' *# !$"%' "*# ,#&4'3#'"!0"*,%"%#&%&%66#;!68!,2%",!,>!'3$!

0,"*#,-,#8"*#4#"%"%'#,*!&!6&-!3#0"!$!&#*!9%'; 2##'3%&$,%-%'!"#3!;!%'&" '"*#?,%"4#"%"%'%"*!&2##'&4#$%%$!66> !9#,,#3 "*!" !'"*#, $!'3%3!"# '!-#6> /!'3!'! %""!6

#;%&",!"%'

A)A *!&2##';,!'"#3?#%;*"!;#"?!,3&#=4#,%#'$#$#,"%%$!"#8 #9#'"*0;*8"*##=4#,%#'$#$#,"%%$!"#*!3'"2##'$0'"#,&%;'#32>"*# %&",%$"30$!"%' %$#,>?!>,#&4'&#%'"*#?,%""#'&"!"#-#'"8%" *!&2##'$'$#3#3"*!"'#-!,7"?!,3&#=4#,%#'$#*!32##'!?!,3#3" /!'3!'!%""!6!&*#,#=4#,%#'$#$#,"%%$!"#*!32##'$0'"#,&%;'#32>"*#

#;%'!6!'!;#,8 0'1!2+$*630$!"%'!,38 !"%!6!"%&3%%$06"

"!"*-!&"'?*!"2!&%&"*#,#&4'3#'"!0"*,%"%#&!,#",#!"%';"*# &&%&"!'"+#$,#"!,>80'$%6,"*#'3%!'+$*6#,"%%$!"#=!-%'!"%'&8 #?#6*%"2#'""*#$-4#"#'"!0"*,%">"$0'"#,&%;'!'#=4#,%#'$# $#,"%%$!"#!&44&#3""*# #;%'!6!'!;#,8 0'1!2+$*630$!"%'

!,38 !"%!6! *#,#&4'3#'"!0"*,%"%#&!,#$6#!,6>!34"%';3%#,#'" >!,3&"%$7&%'"*#-!""#,;,!'"?#%;*"!;#"?!,3&#=4#,%#'$#?*%6# $-40"%';-#,%"%'!$--'&#6#$"%'4,$#&&+0$*!$"%'?063*!9#" 2#*#63"2#9%6!"%9#,"%$6#& !'3B"*#'&"%"0"%''3%! *#4#"%"%'#,%&8!$$,3%';6>8*#63#'"%"6#3""*#?#%;*"!;# -!,7& "?!,3&#=4#,%#'$#!'3*#,-#,%""2#3#"#,-%'#3!&B )BC%'&"#!3 B)B!'3!&*!32##'$!6$06!"#32>"*#,#&4'3#'"&#!,6%#,%'4%'" "%-# '$#3#36>8"*#6!&"&#6#$"#3$!'3%3!"#%'"*##'#,!6!"#;,> %'"*#&021#$"!"*#-!"%$&*!&&#$0,#3B

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

$'"%'0%">%'&#,9%$#8&#'%,%">#"$20"?063'"2#4!%3"*#!$"0!6!,,#!,& &!6!,>,"*#4#,%3%'@0#&"%'

#"%"%'%&!66?#3%'"*#!,#&!%3"#,-& & '

()*+(*,+ 60$7> *#"*#,&4#!7%';F,#!&'#3( #&F *#"*#, #4,"!26#( #&F