M/S Sandley Industries v. Union Of India & ANR
!"#$#%&'&() * +',!($-#.($/'"0&#' #"&"&(#0
(&(($&!!($"2#0' 1 #'3($#("'
) 45 ,6 5 45 ,
! "###
$ %& %% '
( &
& &
&$%
)*+ * ! "## # $$( ,## ! "### (& - )
!
#+.)#-. ! ,+)# !/) *
" 7!.6/8!0 &""!-9 1#
#" 2*! "## #3
$ %& %%
(
&
& &
&$%
$$( (& #*# #
"#### #! 4. !2#5!
2 # 26"## 7*#)*2* % ,* & 85!#,* /#
9 ,* :02#26 ". " #2#6 ! #!6#*;* #!#2* " +* #! . !* #! #* "## *#" !6 .#"## %
. ! !## ! 6 # #
62#! 1 "### #* !* 3#! 3#!
#* " #$( ( ;#)! *
85!#1#
! (& 1.# * 26"###3#!
3#!!" 3#!2 .#1.# .
## *2+! < * 15/8< 101"## # # #8< 1 ## 8< 1 #,* /# 9 ,* :01 * ### # 6 .+ " *6#"# 8< 11"### #"# =#"*! # *6"62 ## " 2#!!* *6 ")!#% 85!# ! (
/# 9 !:0 *6 5!#!
8< 1# #2 " *! * !* #= # ",* ,*
6"." *!* !*65!#2
"6 *6 #2 *! #" # #,* & ,* * 6 . #2## ! ",* & ,* *6 !6.*
% *#
2"# 26 6
.# # *6# "# !#!
6 26 6
.# #6!
",* % ,* * !*" *! #
" *!## ! # *6 5!# #2 * !"
*# 5!#"!# # #,* ",* %/ 0 ,* 8< 1 #62*# #3 "6 6 *66 # " *! 12+! 8< 1 ## # !! #
! *# #2 #
1 > 5 2 # ! # *6"# #"** * !* ## ",* &/% 0 ,* # * #"6 *626 % 6 *
"65!# *6 !!##
.#**# #3#8< 1 ##
"6* #* #!
* ##"!# # 26 > 1"### # #8< 1 #3#! 3#!!" 3#!2 .#1 ## " *!#3#! ?*#"! ! # 3#!!"@ #3#!
.#.#!#!
3#!1"###!
#3#!.
3#! "6 *61 * ### 6 .
*6## 6"#
8< 1 #!!* 6
*#"# #! ?*# A!2 "##!
# # *6*#(
@B1"##"# * & &
% @B *8< 1!!* $ @B*" !!* #!1!!* "##.# ! !* # *6 #2# #6 "#!C #* 6 $@B . !* #* .
$@B=* #"6 *6*#(
@B
1"##. #8< 1 #
@B" ! # *# #3 "6 *6.7*# 6# "6 *6?*#C!! #2# #6. #!
2** (
@B."# 1# !!C.
"##.
#!# " "# *2* 1"### # 6 "# # * .## 1"## # > ,$ % % "# * ( @B . *6 (@B. #="# "# *6 .## " 6#*",* &/% 0 ,* "##"## 6 "6 *6 #.2 "6# *6 8< 1!!*).!*#! % 5* .#* "## ! 6 5!# *6 # " 626# ( $ &&&@B "# ?!2 )## .!*#! % 5* . #* "## * "## . 6*# #3 8< 1 #*# &$ @B *#*6 %A!2 % !! # "## *2B* % ,* & ,* #!6. ! 8< 1! #4!#.#"##
!* "#
#"### # ,* &/% 0 ,* D !* "## # *" !## >*+4#*#
/% 08D1&%% /% 0 8D1 ( 4# * #
!
"!
! B1=ADB B4B ?B*,* &/% 0 ,* . 2 5 # !# . E.#* *# #3# 8< 1 #E ##*2 1*2# #.! *! !* ##C "### 6 "# *6*.#!.26 (
@B .#!* ( $ &&&@B &$ @B#"**!,* &/% 0 ,* 2*2# C #
.2 # +* 8< 1! # 6#**# # ##!!*26#*#.!* #! 5* =.* ,* &/% 0 ,* #2#6 # 6*2 # #2 2*!C . D !* **2# # * #3##*# .# . # " ## ,* &/% 0 ,* . $ ;* #! . "
! +* # # $
%& ! &/(08D1( /'40 '$
(
"
) * %$=1, % />*+0
"
+ , #
! - ( -. "$=1, (/? 0 #/ / 0)%& $ '
-0 / 08D1% %/'40
A !6 !* * 2# *""##"* " ##*2# #"!2 * " ##2* #1"*" " ## .!*2 # 5!# *6)*"". . +* # '! ! !+
=, &)
+(, !+ .
$ !/((0(%1, /)0 '
!& 1#2 !/ $0 )
+''
"
#' /% 08D1
/ 0 + 3 ) !
$ ' !1 2 /% 08D1%/)0 3/
! 1#2 ! /(&0%%=1,%(/)0
,'!& !
- +- !+ /
! =,(&() +!/! "
&' !
=,(() (
5!/*"0 $ # 6*2!#*2## !* * & FB ,* &/% 0 ,* *B
!"#$ %
&''
(
) *
!"#$
+
)
)
,
)
-.
/-#* : ;8#($#$<#= > 9= # "6 *6 !
"62 26 ##*.##"# * # #2 "6" 6 "!*!* *6"# ! " ! !* *
$ "# *#.#!*! # *!#*:
(
"* ,* &/% 0 ,* #! . * #"6 *626 #6 6 * "65!# *6 !!##
.#**# #3#8< 1 ##
"6* #* #!
* ## = # * #.* 2 *! 2!
.#*"6 *6 !7*! " #" # #* .*
. 1# * 2 . $ !! # .#! 7*# * !
"6E.#**# #3#8< #E2 .6.#= *!.* # # " 6 "! !" ! !*
* 1# =
5 ! .# ### #! #* >*+4#* ##"6*"# *.#**# #3#8< 1 #
.#!# *6 #*#"* 6"# 26# #*2 * ""##*2!# =. * B &/- $
0
1
) )
0
/
-$ ,
-
- 2
(
(
) !"#$ -$
&
-$
0 0
3 - 4
!(
)
) )
)
)
)
- 53
)
) )
)
)
)
-
)
-53
&
!(
%
)
)
6)
(
)
( )
) - (
"- 78&''9
)
3 ))
:
; )
) )
+ )
)
(
) )
3 + 3 !"#$
(
+ 3 !"#$ )
)
+
(
) )
) +
(
)
)
-;
$ &
6)
) - '-
(
)
) - !(
)
3
) )
-
(
) !"#$
-
3
(
- !"#$ )
-
!"#$
) <
(
-
)
- $ )
)
) !"#$ - $
- - $ (
) -
)
) !"#$
6) -
)
- =
)
)
)
3
) -
4
!
> 5
-
4
?72
!(
%
/
*
>)
> //?
-4 )
,
-$
4
(
)
*
(
-2
*
)
)
9-- //?-$
)
-$
4 3
)
(
*
(
<
, - $
(
)
3
(
-@
A B 3 5
(
(
, 3
-
3 (
(
- &-
4
;
;
<
(
)
,
- 5
(
) )
,
3
/
9
/
, - -
CB
4 *
<
) )
-
) :
;?-" - /& 9
-
)
(
) ,
,
,
-
) )
0 0<
-$ - -D
1
( ,
) (
(
) !"#$
-
)
)
-$ ,
) )
- ) )
-
/
-C
- ?-$
3
-@
)
1
%
-4
)
-
)
!"#$
-
-=
)
!"#$
)
)
- @
)
E - 9-
1 *
!"#$
-$
;
*
!"#$ ; 1
!(
%
&''&
) -.
)## #..# # !##26>*+ 4#*# 5! /*"0
&- 2
>
=
< 6< =
: ?-
A
)
!"#$ -
% 1)
)
)
- 4 & % 1
(
(
)
) (
-F % 1
- % 1)
% !"#$ %
&''
(
) *
!"#$
-$
!"#$
4
4 A B 3 5 - - $
(
) ) - $
!"#$
)
)
-$
<
*
!"#$ 00
)
!"#$
-
)
-@
)
6< =
%
1 )
-.
% # !+* .#! 6 #! 2"
! 26 !* " ."! 5# # # # *
6=+
5!/*"0 "5*.
!# ##* #)!# $ )" ! &(( 7*##"6 "# G #!#" *6! ##"!
!
! = . # . !#!
* .#."
* " !*" 6 #3# " *6 !* 2# 2*!#*#
# )*"*# +(, 5 !/*"0
# ." ##7*## *5*6527* *# 2#" # # #!!##!= '
!& 5 !/*"0 #."# 26 "5*5# .*" #!
#*# = # * 2 2 !
# #!#.#!* 25*.#2+!* 2!# =$ ' !1 2 5!/*"0 #. 2 26 "5*5!2#" 26# !26 6266#"2## # * 26!# # ..*2! *!#"" ###* *""
66* #!#!6= 3/ 5 /*"0 )*"* #! 2 ." 7*# * #!
! #!.# # 2 # # #!
#*#= '!& !
- +-5 !/*"0 "5*. #.##"## !* #. #
2!# !"# #!# #6 !#"=+!/! 5!/*"0
"5*.!# ##* #"#.## * # #26B . =. ## !* 7*##* ## ! ### #26 .*2+! 5=+'' 5!/*"0 4#
* #"*5! #2##* !!#* 1# *< * 15 !
#2 # # "!#2 26 !1#7* .#""##*!# 26!*#2 # !##1"#!#" # .# .
!#3 1#*##"!# #
5"*!!*!.#+* >*+ 4#*#
' 5 ! /*"0 4# * #
!
5!/*"0= #. 2 . ,* &/% 0 ,* 5#!#. E.#* *# #3#8< 1 #E# 22#6 *2 #*!C .=. * ,* &/% 0 ,* .262 # 8< 1 #
"# #
!*
"6. #
. # # * # 2#6 *2 =6 *2#! " #3 *2 " ## ,* & /% 0 ,* .# .. E.#**# #3# 2 # 8< 1 #E . $ 26 #!"#." 6
2#" G * * !" ! !* *
*
$ %&
&
& &
&$%
. 1 !" *#6
" C"# # #. * 2 2 # # "**! . !* #! #* "## #
.#
(
$$( (&
$
.#"* *6 2#* ## #!
2 +* #! 26 !" *#6 5!
* # . 9.#* *# #3# 2 # 8< 1 #: ,* &/% 0 ,* = %%
#"* !.26" ! 2 ""6# "
!#6#267* ## " !" *#6 "! *# # 2 #! #2 7* #"* # !# # " *#6" # !* "## !! !.# . 7!.6/8!0 &""!- /$?# /?/'" 9
!8#($0!!&( @?'@ /$?#