Yashodhra Verma v. Haryana Urban Development Authority & ORS

   
    

     
    

     
    

     
    

  











 


  



 !

"   



 !

"   



 !

"   



 !

"

#$%&%'#(')#*+%', - (')#

(.,.,/('

('$0$ #'1#/#'2#/ (3(45)(/.0.%',.1#/&.%('$

($5/&(/.$
! 6
! 6
! 6
! 6 

 ! 
 8  

 ! 
 8  

 ! 
 8  

 ! 
 8 """"
 
  
 
  
 
  
 
 









 ! 
 

  

 

 ! 
 

  

 

 ! 
 

  

 

 ! 
 

  

 '($(/.

'($(/.

'($(/.

'($(/.

!'

0/((. #4,"(/,'&39#.(*,.% !$ !/,:#%#:0'"&39#.('.%(5(.,.,/('

!$ #:#/:$%##*%/(1"&39#.( ' 6'($5/&(/.$ ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;<  

  

"  

  

"  

  

"  

  

" %(#'1#/#'2#/ (3(45)(/.0.%',.1='$%'.

7 7>#44..(&#'($,&(/.,#454. )(#$0',/?@ AB #'&$ 2(#',/?  6 "  (9.'  6C"  #',&#2#&  ,/  #30'    .%( 5(.,.,/('3,&(#44.)(/.4(..('&#.(&A   
$..%(54.

*#$,D(&#$EF""+6 ,/9(,.*#$#G5'(('(/.,#49#.(?'1 54.H".%(5(.,.,/('5#,&#/#&&,.,/#45',9(I3('#/& #23(.%(,/,.,#49$..%#.%#&2((/,D(&  $$($$,/"%*(3('"

904&/.2(&(4,3('(&..%(5(.,.,/('#$.%(54.#44..(&(44 0/&(''($.#'(# ,&('&('&#.(&C ".%( $.#.( ,9('"

 "#',&#2#&)#&(#44.)(/.#/#4.('/#.,3(54.,/#30' .%(5(.,.,/('2(#',/? @6"(9.'6
"#',&#2#&

  %(,/$.#/.*',. 5(.,.,/%#$2((/,4(& $((:,/? .%( ,$$0#/9(    #  *',.    9('.,'#',  '  B0#$%,/?  '&('  &#.(& C "//(D0'( "5#$$(&21'($5/&(/. F*%('(21.%( #4.('/#.,3(54.$.#/&$#44..(&..%(5(.,.,/(' !#/&#)0$%#$ #4$  2((/  $0?%.  '  &,'(9.,/?  .%(  '($5/&(/.$  .  #44.  #/ #4.('/#.,3(54.5'(('(/.,#49#.(?'1 %(  $4,.#'1  9/.(/.,/  '#,$(&  21  4(#'/(&  (/,' 90/$(4#55(#',/?'.%(5(.,.,/(',$.%#.$,/9(#&&,.,/#45',9( %#& 2((/ &(5$,.(& '#5'(('(/.,#454."#$$09%"(3(/.%( #44.)(/.#/#4.('/#.,3(54.%#$.2(0/&('$09%5'(('(/.,#4 9#.(?'1   /  $055'.    $09%  9/.(/.,/"  '(('(/9(  %#$  2((/ )#&(.#54,91&#.(&A  F"//(D0'( @",$$0(&21.%(
%,(&),/,$.'#.'" /.%($02J(9.(D9%#/?(+#44.)(/.

#4.('/#.,3(54.$ 
4#0$(F.%(54,914#1$&*/.%#.,/.%( (3(/.0#4,.1#/#4.('/#.,3(54.2(,/?('(&",.$%#442(/.%( $#)(.(')$#/&9/&,.,/$/*%,9%.%(',?,/#454.*#$#44..(&
4#0$($.,504#.($.%#.,/.%(9#$(#44.)(/.#/#4.('/#.( 54.".%(54.$,K(#/&9#.(?'1.%(54.*,44/.2(9%#/?(&  %('(4,#/9(54#9(&05/
4#0$(F.%( 4,91&#.(& A  F  ,/  0'  3,(*  ,$  *%441  ),$654#9(&   %(  (D5'($$,/ G.(')$#/&9/&,.,/$H'((''(&.,/.%(54,91*04&'(4#.(. .%()&(#/&)#//('5#1)(/."9/&,.,/*,.%'(?#'&..#:,/? 5$$($$,/.%(54."0/&('.#:,/?9/$.'09.,/.%('(05/*,.%,/ #$.,504#.(&.,)(6'#)((.9 #/&*04&/.93('#44.)(/.# 5'(('(/.,#49#.(?'154.

%(#44.)(/..%(#4.('/#.(54.,/ #30'.%(5(.,.,/(',/.%(4,?%.'&('&#.(&C "

//(D0'( "$5(9,,9#441'(9,.($.%#..%(.(')$#/&9/&,.,/$

*04&2(.%($#)(#$9/.#,/(&,/.%(',?,/#4#44.)(/.4(..(' &#.(&A  

3(/.%0?%
4#0$(.%(54,91&#.(&A  F"

//(D0'(  @"  #$  '(?#'&$  .%(  9#.(?'1    .%(  54.  .  2(  /. 9%#/?(& ,/.%(9#$(#44.)(/.#/#4.('/#.,3(54.*04& $055'..%(9#$(.%(5(.,.,/('"1(.*(#'(0/#24(.#99(5..%( 5'#1(')#&(,/.%(,/$.#/.5(.,.,/  !$ #:#/:$%##*%/(1"4(#'/(&90/$(4#55(#',/?'  "  %#$  2'0?%.  .  0'  /.,9(  .%#.  ,/  50'$0#/9(  .  .%( #4.('/#.(  54.  2(#',/?  @6"  (9.'  6
"  #',&#2#&  %#3,/?

2((/#44..(&/C "5%1$,9#45$$($$,/.%($#)(%#$ 2((/#99(5.(&21.%(5(.,.,/('*,.%0.#/15'.($.'&()0'/ @   3(/#9/3(1#/9(&((&,/#30'.%(5(.,.,/(' 5('.#,/,/?..%(#4.('/#.(54.$.#/&$(D(90.(&/A  09%  #9.0#4  5$,.,/  9#'',($  /  '(20..#4  #.  .%(  %#/&$    .%( .*04&#4$2(#55$,.(./.,9(.%#.#.('#44.)(/. .%(#4.('/#.(54./C ".%(5$$($$,/.%('(*#$ 2(,/?&(4#1(&#/&"#99'&,/?41".%(5(.,.,/('%#&5'((''(&
,3,4 ',.  (.,.,/        ,/ .%,$ 
0'.  #/&  ,/  *%,9%  .%( $5(9,,95'#1('*#$'.%(,$$0#/9(#)#/&#)0$'%#/&,/? 3('  5%1$,9#4  5$$($$,/    #4.('/#.(  54.   2(#',/?  @6"

(9.'6
"#',&#2#&,/4,(0.%(',?,/#454.2(#',/? 6 "

(9.'6C"#',&#2#&   5'#1('*#$'#,$(&*,.%'(?#'&. #44.)(/..%(#4.('/#.(54.#5'(('(/.,#49#.(?'1 '(6 /.,9(&  *',.  5(.,.,/  *#$  &,$5$(&    21  #  ,3,$,/ (/9%  /  ,/.%(44*,/?.(')$

 G%(5(.,.,/('%#$,/3:(&.%(*',.J0',$&,9.,/ .%,$
0'.'&,'(9.,/?.%('($5/&(/.$.%#/&3(' .%(5%1$,9#45$$($$,/ 4. @6"(9.'6
"

#',&#2#& %(5(.,.,/('*#$(#'4,('#44..(& 4. 6 "

(9.'6C"#',&#2#&"20..%($#,&54.#44$,/.%( '($.#'(# 02$(B0(/.41"#/#4.('/#.,3(54., (  4.

@6"(9.'6
"#',&#2#&"*#$#44..(&..%( %(?',(3#/9(.%(5(.,.,/(',$.%#..%( 5$$($$,/.%(#4.('/#.,3(54.%#$/.2((/%#/&(& 3('..%(5(.,.,/('

/  3,(*    .%(  #3(')(/.$  )#&(  ,/  .%(  *',. 5(.,.,/"  *(  &,'(9.  .%(  '($5/&(/.$  .  &(4,3('  .%( 5%1$,9#45$$($$,/#54.(B0,3#4(/.$,K(..%( 5(.,.,/('*,.%,/#5(',&.*)/.%$').%(&#.( '(9(,5..%,$'&('

.%(5$$($$,/.%($#,& 54.  9#//.  2(  &(4,3('(&  .  .%(  5(.,.,/('"  .%( '($5/&(/.$  $%#44  5#$$  #  $5(#:,/?  '&('  *,.%,/  .%( $#,&5(',& .,$,)5'.#/../.(.%'((.%,/?$ ,'$.4121.%(*',.

5(.,.,/"  .%(  5(.,.,/('  $5(9,,9#441  $0?%.  .%(  #44.)(/.  #/& 5$$($$,/ 4. @6"(9.'6
 (9/&41".%('&(',/ .%(*',.5(.,.,/?'#/.(&.%(5(.,.,/(''(4,(,/'($5(9..%#. 3('154.

%,'&41"50'$0#/..%('(..%('($5/&(/.$/@ 54#9(&.%(5(.,.,/(',/5$$($$,/.%,$54.#$&()#/&(&21 %('#/&#$'&('(&21.%,$
0'.

%(5(.,.,/('%#$".%('('("

2((/,/0$(#/&9905#.,/.%(54.$,/9(.%(/ .*#$/41#

1(#'  #/&  #  %#4  4#.('  .%#.  .%(  5(.,.,/('  #$  #/  #.('.%0?%. &(9,&(&  .%#.  $%(  *04&  5'(('  #/.%('  54.   %,$  9#//.  2( 5('),..(&/5',/9,54( .*04&#4$2(9/.'#'1..%('&(' .%( ,3,$,/ (/9%&#.(& @

/#$5(9,,9B0('1%#3,/?2((/50.210$"4(#'/(& (/,'  90/$(4  *04&  #&),.  .%#.  .%(  #4.('/#.(  54.  ,$    #/ (B0,3#4(/.$,K(..%(',?,/#454.

 .%#$#4$2((/9/9(&(& .%#..%('(*#$/'(5'($(/.#.,/,4(&21.%(5(.,.,/('$.#:,/?# 94#,)'#5'(('(/.,#49#.(?'154.2(.*((/C , ( .%( &#.(#4.('/#.(54.*#$#44..(&#/&.,44@ , ( .%(&#.( 5%1$,9#4  5$$($$,/    .%(  #4.('/#.(  54.  *#$  .#:(/  21  .%(  ( %4& .%( 94#,) #/&  5'#1(' '#,$(&  ,/ .%( ,/$.#/. 5(.,.,/'#44.)(/..%(5'(('(/.,#49#.(?'154..2(%,?%41 2(4#.(&#/&#/#.('.%0?%.

 9#$(',/.('('(/9(,/(D('9,$( J0',$&,9.,/0/&(''.,94(.%(
/$.,.0.,//&,#,$ )#&(0.

 (.,.,/(',$"%*(3('"%(4&(/.,.4(&.'(0/&.%( I#&&,.,/#45',9(.%#.%#&2((/&(5$,.(&'#5'(('(/.,#4 9#.(?'154.#4/?*,.%,/.('($.L@I5('#//0)  (.,.,/&,$5$(& =  8 > =  8 > =  8 > =  8 > = 

  

> = 

  

> = 

  

> = 

  

>    
 
 


 
 


 
 


 
 

 

 

 

 

 !

"

 !

"

 !

"

 !

" ! ! ! !

.(

.(

.(

.( %(.%(''((''(&.(5'.('M= ($+ > %(.%(''((''(&.(5'.('M= ($+ > %(.%(''((''(&.(5'.('M= ($+ > %(.%(''((''(&.(5'.('M= ($+ >