High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16248/2012allowed

Mdn Education Society v. Union Of India And Others

2015-06-30Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar,Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia8 pages

!

" #

! "# $$%& ' $ "# $$$# $%&

'%()& ( !#

& !**()& ( ! # ++++ $$()*+(,(-.( ,!%% *

! # '

#

! -)

/(#

0!,!

,11

1 2.(3 4 # ('! 0!##% !#

!

1 4( .1# -,/ ! 12.) (5- ! (!6) 6/! 7 2! ##% %

*# ' % 7 & -)

8/ 2!#% !#

!

% *

'

!

!"*

9

(3

* %

( %% !# # 1#

* # #

*#

:-)

/( ## &%' 04 % -& /,% -,/ !) ( !

1

84:54( 07

) ##% ' (! ( %% *'

!9 1 ! %& 1 ( *

*! *

% *'

!

11 1 ( % *&

*0 # ! 0% !

!.1# 2! ! # !0 11 0!,11

12.( "!; # *! ( !' '

.#%

!'!# 4 ' % * 0% .1#

#%(!##% !0 % % (.#%

*! <

" # 7 ! ##% & -)

/0#%

* % # !7*1 ! )#.,

2! ( ##% !0 %

= ! ) ! ! 0 1 !

1 .# ('!

!'

0% !0 '

*% 7 = ,

% ! # ! #% % #

%

8> 8 -)

:/( 01 !

; ! ## &% ! 1!0

%% :

01 ! ## &%1 8 '%0&% %

'

! '

! ' <

1

'%! 1( #

"

% 1 "%,)('!

! 1

01 ! !## &%!0 ( %0'

! '

% * # "% ! #% # ! &

? 7*1 !)%%!03 *!,

!

" $ # # ##

%&

'(

%)

*'!

% '! ; !! ' <

1 ##% ! 8 !

*

% ## &%'%

1

2!!

' (!'& (* & % 0 !#

'! !%!!

1' ##%

'

!! 1 ) !

*

% !# (' !#

! !1

< % & *

!"& 2!

*! !.1# !% 0 !# % (& :( #

%%! 542! ##% ' 1 5(

#

! 1( !' '

!##%

0 % 1 ' !

% 8 8 -)

:/(!# ' <

% ##%

.

( ! !%

! $/)01(23(*124*/3(5.)(- $3.154- # /"%& 0 &

!"#

$ % #

" "

& '

(#'

" "# (

# " &

& &

"

#

) &

'

* + "#

,

(#

+-' - -

' ( '

.

( #

,

(

& / %

& "#

((

) (,'"#

%' (

'

, "

.#' (&

%

& (&

#

0

,

( #

+-' - -

&

%

(

0

"# (&

% ) &

%

"#

!'

& "#

((

) ( , % " & (

(

,

( "#

23

4 &

) 5( # 6 & 6

0 &# 7 )

'8

6 $ /%* 9: ' ; ) &

' (&

"#

((

) (,

.

)

"#

' "

' #

&

,

< @ ! 0! !!7*1 &

? ! !

,

#+ , $ # $ %

-#

# -.

'

%) /! #!%0 !)#.,

0 1 " $ # % '

%) 22('!

! # %% !

'!!

( &

* 0%##

(! % ## &% %0'

! '

! & 0*

*!

!## &% %0 07 1

* "%& 0 &

*8

0&( 60"4 #'

! ("#4 &

0&( 7 34 &

)1

&,(

"# 60"4 #4 &

(

# "#7 34 &

'

.#'

=1

( 60" 4 # 4 &

1 0&( 0&(

&

(

8

" (

0&( "

' (#' 3 '

'(

4 2 & &' # ( ,

#

) '

& (

&

( # (

(

( #

(# #

(

5 '

& (

"

3 #) # & '

" &

# "0

" & '

,( (

"

(3 &

" #

#

3 &

) (, ,,,, ,,,, ,,,, ,,,,

4 &#

-

"

( ,

"

#

(

( (

)

# .

,

. ( .

(

8 (

"

(

& :

.

( 3 '

( ' #( (

( 3

; (3

3"

(

&

3 :

(' (

"(' " "#6

"0

"& 5

,(' ( & 3 ' - ) & ,( # &

+

( # +-

( %;' #

( &

' 6 &

"0 ( (

#

/ & "

( (

& 8 (

& "0

& '6(#

&

& ) ( " >:

( & ) 8 (3 & '6 ,( )

3

'9 & ( ?

( ) :$

)

'"

# 3"# - &

"#

&

(

'

& &

' &,( '& & ( '

& ,( ' ( & (

) ?

( ) ( #'6 (#&

( ( )

(6( &

# - (# (

& "

("#

' " ,( '

' " - &

" ( 4 ' &

'

"

& 6

& "

(

(

,

6

& "# &

(

3'(#'6 "0

(# " &

( "-

< 8 ) ! # 1'!

!'

!! 1#* '

7

! # ! #% % # ! 0 &

!)#.,

! )(2*(6- # /('!

!0 *!0

*

!0!# !* !! 7*1 ' #

*!#

!) %

* -,/ 2!

,

3 #4 # # ##

%&5 4 $ ''

' % * (!

% !%!! 7*1 '% 0##% 0% !#

#%

% '

% !&0 1#% 0 # ! 7*1

! .)17681)516)(5.)(-+(6.5(0-16/95- # / ' 0

*# !!

"%& 0 &

"

"#

&

(#

- "# & 0&( 1" (

6)( "

) (,4 1" (

# &. (

# (

#

' & :

' , . (

'

&& "#

#

" #

"

( & & ,

&

& (

" &

& "

# "#

'

"

&

< : )

*%( ' ! & ' ! !

0%

(

*%(< ! 3'& (

( '%0# !!

!' # !!

( &

" % %(! -)

8/

% < !)!

!%%

##% % =!) (

'! !! -)

/!

5 2!# '

#

(

*%(%%'

!

$%(:.

*(6

$$()*+(,(-.( 35.)7+.1 /95.31 9(.-19+