← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16250/2012dismissed

Sunder Singh v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-03-26Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh8 pages

  

 

    



 !

 "    # 

$%  

  &  

  !! " '

() *%+,)- &    ($  ,)*,$%  &  ' .....

" /&   + ) +



1 

     

 2     3  4&  5  )

6"'!,20%, 3 &    && % -&    +  + 

   

 &    - &  &    ' 6 &% 2++ 

&

  4 -  /  &     2  ++%  &&      

0+ 

$% "+  7 1 &

82+  , 2 &4& $

0+   77/, &

 4 +   2 &4 )

5   /  $%   *- ,  -     

5 714+  /$%  - +-   - "%!

+ ,   71,  20%,    &%  +      $%   *- 94&+% 2-  %2 : - & 

2  & 4  ;&0+    + 2 +    &  6 , 4 ++0 + /,  7 , 4 4 2 4,20%, 2

  &   6 &% +     + ++04

0+ +%  & 6 +&   712 + 4     , %4 4 4

 + ,&  4%0'6 /&   - & 

 6  &% - &% +2 7+ 2 

 & +  '/ /&%&  

 6 - &% + +% 2 &    &  , 4+%,/ ,  4&%  4  +%, 4&  * +  0   : & /,4  2+   8

 04    +% < &     4 +% 



&   0+  0      ) " 2    2     0    8

++  04   - 2  

0% 

#$#%&#'('#'#)*

+ 4&   0  

 )     2

    :         0 +0%&   2  & 24  /+ 4&   <- = 5  8

++  04  &%< &  

0  625 70&%&    6 2 7 &&  6 0%48

++

04       &    4    2        

+  7   , %4 4  + ,& 

4%0'6 0&    - %&& % '6     &    

         7 8

+ 04  &     4 ++%     2              &   0%   &4 9- &  + 0%2%

 7 ,&  0'6 02 -  +  2   44   ,   &    +   '6  

&  8

+ + &  <4  - >     ,-&-.-%$/,( !01(&#)'()2#)3)3#)((&"1(&-'#)#&4%(5"6-&)-%

!:

,2 ,  +  , +++  &  0   4&+%, 

0

 &   -  + 0 +  2 % *-  :&  4*- 4&+%    ++

  - &  <    ) ,+

 04   &    +   + ) " 2  

   8 

+ 04  &%&   

2++        < ,  4+%, /     2   6    &    & 

6 0%4/ 6  &% &- +  712 ++ 0%&     2&   + 

0++%2  - 6&+ $4 %  6  &%&2    & %  ++ , 4  + /& &   + 0+0

 +%  +%8 

:



++  04  &    ) " & =  71        +   0     

3  + 0          &     2  &4    0  

&  

5  ++0   -0   4,&

 04   4 + 0+0

8  

++  04  &   &+   &

2    4 +  ? 15

7      

 7   5  "

   "+        ,     " &0 0 3 +%,2 

 2 3 0%  + $2 2&

4 

- =

1  :

    +  $4 +

+&   -+ &  4&  2++ 4    + @  &+%,    &      6     &   2  7 4-  &% +  +%, &% 2  6) &&   - 0% ,/ , &%2  6 25 7) &&-

 + - "% + , 71, 4&+% 2 :6  &  2    2

  &   6 , ++0 + +-  "% + , 71 6

&  &   '



  

  

  

   





   !  "    #

  #   



   

    

$ "

    %   "

    



        

 !



 

$ $ """

        "

    

"" &   '

  

 (  ""

$  

 

    



 



"

$      ""   )

   

 

    !  

 

   



 

 



   !



  

 

 

$   "

     

 * !  ! 



 )

  

      (  "  "

$ 

 

 

   $ +  $,- 

 "

$

   "

     

   

$   



     

 

    % 

 

  "

$(  "

   .  

/

 0   )     "



  !

!    

 

      ""

     (  "  "

$  

   "       !

 $ 



  $ 

 "  $ +  $,- 1 

  

 

 

2 /&   6  &   

 &% +2 7)& 40% &      % , &   % / +% <     40%+

  2 

44   &    0 3

'6

 &   

0

&-

2  :

2+0 3 +%,&   + &4

0

& %  ++0   -0   4 )  + 4&   2 ) "   , 2  64&  4&

"A=' ,2 ,  /  &

   2,&  

0  0   ) "2 4 &

 "A='   + 0 &4 0 

&"   

+ 4& %2  / / <4   + & 0%+

+ &    &&+ 0+ - 2  4   &  

+ 4 &    2: -   !'-'(    &#//-  $/  ;-&#.,-)  !-.-)'-&-;  *778+9 !+* ,$ ;0+&4  +4:

&

  %6&+   +%/ &  &+2

+   !'-'( &#//-$/&0)60.-&-')-#<*7 8+9!

7*  4 ++%, 

,-&-'  !-)4,-&  #3-.  #.#'(2  $/ ,-)/,;-.-//8 9-)2',(&/

8:9!+7:,'B>  $ ;0+)&6  &  &+  -32#/,-%$/ !'-'( -&;-)-*778 9! += &0 -   &   & +&-   &&  0 + 

1,%2+ 0  &

  %

$ ;0+    )&6    !'-'(    -.#%  -20  $/ !(/,-4,-%-.

78 9!+72 + 3+ %+   0:+% + &

  - 0  , +   '

C   

           

             

         

     

                      



     !  "

     "

  



 #   

          $ $ ;0+&4  (>(%,# 0)#4#1-%0)4#% $/-)!#)3,-)2',(&/

78*9! 7= +

& + 4   &-  + 2 &    ) +





     ,%  +%2 &   +0 +2   0+ 4   , &   +2 &    +%1% 6&+   0<4 &

0% $  2 ' 2 +6

   %<    2 + !'-'(  $-)2%-%*=7!

   6      +   +%

%  + 3    +    +% &&     +%    +% 6&+ , 4%+  -   +  6  2 <    2  + &4   40  /  +   +%&4 0+  6 %4%0   + :+%   &0+ 

 -  0 ,    2 <   ,  2 <   

6   0++%, 4%- +  +%  &   - 0+  <   &  2

&       2  2   <    -:,   6&+   +% &+  2             &%       4  4   

4& 2 + 2  2     2

6  <     & 0%$ ;0+)&6   40  &

2+ 0 36&+   : +%/    65-?--</,.#-,$!'-'( ;/&(* 7!**+/ '  /($)#) )2#-*7 !:7 0%   + 4  42 

0  

   0+    4:

  &

       *-  2  & 4:

   4 ++ 2 ++ 6&+ +% !'-'( &#//- $!-.-)'-&-?*7 ! 74:

&&

= 2   %6&+   +%   &   0 

+%+   - 2 4   0-, 4 

     0%+

 &   , 0 -  %4 , 0%

    )D) $)@$) D!

    B@*9 !