← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19006/2019dismissed

Dharamvir And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2019-10-01Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary,Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal10 pages

   



 !"!#$  



 

 



 %$&'%(( 

&'%((%'

 

  

!

 "  

  # 

"



"$    (%') %



#&  '

()**(+*,

-  

.

" . 

 

 

/

0  

 

1 ..!23  -





 

" 

 

 - 2-"



.

 %

*+4  - %  "" 

5""'

  % "   $ '

" 6*(

"  

& !

 /".

"

%      

 '        .

'

 !

"

7      

"

 "

 -"  



(),(++8 



8 / & 

*,680  



   1   23 !

  " 

  "

 9-:



 4       

 

 (;((++4  /

&  !

""

 



     ((8     % 

<



 (4,(++4    

  

 ;     

" ' ;,, "   

-"  5

(,(++) 



6 

" 



(;,(++)  '    

 $  

 

 (8,(++)   ' &  9 (+6(++) ..! 

 .

 

"!



7  ' 

 '  & 

  -

" 

(6+*(+*+

$  

 ""

  &

 '    "

 "

 ""

&

 '-

  

  



6*+(++)

$  

&

 ' . 

"

 <





8 





  ' 

  

"   

'1

 2 "'

- "

(),(++8 (6*(+*+

$  

'

"

 





- %

 ""'

"'

  &

 '    

!

"

!=< (>);6 (+** "

-**)"

""

' '

(8,(++) (6*(+*+   -

$  



*

  & %  

 





:

*4*((+*8  ' " '  //    '

/ 

!" "

< ,),, (+*4 +",- . #/ ,."0."1"(

 .2 # #/ ,."%  " " ""



:

*(+>(+*,  

   '

 " "

"?

.  '  

'

 @. 

   '    -"



  :



 ="

""

 ' "

 "

  

A B>(=  A 3  %  

"



C







 -

'

-

-

 "

!

 1

2

    "    7   "

 -"

  



-&  -3%

(8,(++) (6*(+*+

""

  ' "  ' "    

' 

&

  



 

-

 %  



  '

 -  

 

          

  

 

'



C

%

 '-



D @ -   ' 

"



-









8 

 

 

(8,(++)  ""

(6*(+*+





3 % -" -

 

 &

"" ' "

 

"  &

    





 "

"





A B>6 '-







 '

 

  

 03%

(8,(++) (6*(+*+ 

 - 



-  '-

' -

-" 

 

. 





"

 

  ""

 0-3%

(8,(++)  #  

" 



 

(;,(++)   "" 

  '

    

 

" " "

#



(8,(++)-

   



  



 (;,(++)

" 03 

"



; 

 03 

    -   "

 

 '   

(),(++8  "" (6*(+*+  %  "    

  



 '

 (),(++8  "" (6*(+*+  

 '

 - 

 03 

  

  

 "



0-3""

EC.!

-

   

    "" 

-   EC.!

   #  

!

"""

"   '

   

  "  - 

 

(;,(++) ""   

EC.! 3  '    &  (8,(++)  

-

(6*(+*+



(8,(++)



4 :

 "" 

     

(80(3 '

@!

 

%      /  &

  -"





(+*> 3""   

 '   

  (8,(++) ""(6*(+*+

  ' "

"

         '    

C

   ""-

   

     ""  -





 03!





 >> E

$' 0 3

C

 ""



 

"

% "



 

C 

""-

 

 

 ""

 

 

    

 

C

%

 ""- "- 





*,   







@     ' 

  ' '

"

 ' 

6>(++; (8((++)""

-. 

 







-  

 

C

""-  

   



.

""

 '    

 

C



"     ""  - 

 -  

  

& 

   &

.

   "

    





 

C



      





""

  0'3!





!

'>>; >>) E

$' 0 3

C

  ""  -

C -

     

 

"

   

 

 





""-

- E .!  '  -

"  7

 '  E    .!



  - 

 ""

-  



 



 -

"

 ' -

  -

  ""

 '  

 

!"

C

  

 

 ""  -

# 



" '"     

C

 ""

  <

 ""- -"



 03%      



""

-

C

 "" -



 





-"

C

 



 -

 "-"

     

"-  '   ""- ""

"



    '

     "

 

 ' F  """-  

-E .!.   



:

 "



 ' "

" "



""-

 "  



F7  

"   '  

 ""- "

"  " E

.!

  -

 ""- 



    "

"

 . 

"

 ""    

     

 ""

 "



"" "   





  """-    



 

 03

 

 '' - "



B

 D. 

 '

  '

!?.

""

 "

.

5  

   

B

 D



' "" - ' '

 . 



""

  -  '-"

'  &

'

 '

"

   -







 . 

 

' ""- '

=

 ""



"$  



 

  

 '"

 #

$  

 "

  '

     "

 '

 '

"' 

 -B

 D""-

# !?. 0:3.!?."

'



 -

"

 "  0#3 %  

 ""  '

   B -"



/ & 9

D " 

CEC.!

 

""- 

& " 0"3%

   "  '

"

' ' G "  

"  

&  03=  '

   

 

 

  '&  

"  $ '  E- !

"

7



"

""

 

 ' 

  '!

 :-  

       

       =

7  '    

 ""

'!

"  



 " -"

-"  







  



 -"



 -

"  

D /  

"    '    

   -



""

  

03-

6 

  ' ""

H 0-3   7 '

"    

""

 



(6*(+*+H 03     

  C 

"  

    :

  '" 

$  

(6*(+*+H 3  

'

""  -

C



$  

(6*(+*+-

'

"



 '" ' - '!

% 

 -



     ' "  % -  '

 '

"

#5

*,,(+*) 5""'

    " ' 

'

"

 " 

 -"

 %   "      &  

 '  

"'

   "

    

C

  %   " 

  & 



% ..!  '"





  '"

()**(+*, ""

'" "-"

&  @

 

"  /

""



"



"

 ' "

   



9  -

-

' ""

 "

'   

 '

(6*(+*+

 

' ""



(),(++8

(8,(++)% 



 

  "

 

(),(++8 (6*(+*+%

  " 

"

'" :

  =   ""'



':

*(>(+*,  - I-"

     0 3 

7 

" 



    I

  I          

"



"" "  '

&

  %



$  

  ' &

"

 

      

  -   

 $  

 

(8,(++) (6*(+*+

"&  %    



 



  ;,,  "



(4,(++4



 ;     

  

"

 

 &   

"

 

 &

"" ' " '

 

  ' "

" ' "



  

"

&

 - 

'  

"  

& 

  %

   

(),(++8 (6*(+*+ -

"

 ' "

 "    

    

  "

 '   

&

 

%   

"

"

" ""

 



   -   

     

 "

 . 

  '

 

 ""

'"   

()**(+*,%  

   '"  %

 ""

"- 

" "-"

 

  7   7(%'8     9. ) :# + , ,.":

;!#<=.

"#/

, ,..:.

9>