High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16298/2012allowed

Satinder Singh Bajwa v. Punjab And Haryana High Court, Chandigharh

2017-10-06Mr Justice Jaswant Singh23 pages

!" !

#$ #%&&% '" !

( )*+,-./ 01-++(.(0)1

# $%& !

# ' ( # # "

(

) * + ," -

.//01//23 4

56*7 *

3# * /6/21//8 3 4

5'1*7 * $" !" ## '9/.1/''

3 4

5'0* 1 ( (

'9/9'8;1 19'''8;;( (

: # $ 3 * '8;8)8/

#" #

" "

(

" # "

" "

# #

(

< #

" (

( ! "

( #

"= ! ""

( "

= !"

" ?$(-

( ( + " (""

(

+ "

( "

# ( " "# #

" 9' "

" /;'/'88/

(" 19'/'88'=+ ,"

.//01//2

+ (" "( # : 4# 5"

+ ," -

("# '2'/1//2="#

"# # - 4# 5 "

(

@ )

> ( &

# !

# "

!"+

# & ) $! =

# !

( ''/21//6/0/'1//8

# @4"

! !% # 8*3 A

, ?

2* # 8 $

# @4"

! !% $

1 ("

> -

3* 3!* !

34* "

" ) B

! " ! ! "

! " # C ! "

+ ## !

(

@ ) =

@ )#

(# -4# +

# # )

# $"

" "# )

@ 3 ##

!"* $

'86.

'86.*

( "

+ .//91//8

# # "

+ 3#

* = "#

# # "

# /6/21//8E !

# #

## >

1//8( "##

'9/.1/''"# # "

+ ," -

"# ##

. F "

# + ( !"=+ ," 4"

" #

!" # (" ( # # " " =# ( #

! ": "

# " + (

"! - ! # "

# !"=+ "# ##

! ## " "

# <# :" "

# - #

) ## "

+ "

+ ," -

9 F "

# # # )

# # "

( ! #

# "

# , # -

+ # !

( 5"

> (

';/01//8 " # # $# G"#

# - 4# #"

# )

# # "

= !

" 4( "#

# # "

@! "#

" "

# (" "!

# .

/6/21//8(" B$ ! %&%'(''& )* +'',(''& # =!"#

" "

# $

.2 $

'86. ($

! !"3 ## *$

'86/3

'86/* (

( #

" # # "

(

# -!

# (" " 2 (

"# #

" ( $

'86. ($

'86/$

( + #

: + ," -

( # -4# + ," -

( + ##

: #

# #

'86. ($

'86/ #

+ "

# # " $

'86.

( $

'86/ =

( + ," -

(# -4# >

(

( $

.2 $

'86.

H "> -

( (

( + ," -

# -4# > -

" 4

# # "

# :"

# ""

'86. ($

'86/ # ( > -

( ## > -

"# ##

0 "

# #

( # (

"# ##

# # ( # ( ! "

# ( ! " "

1183'*

# " F

991 1/'6 B

! !

/1/91/';="

!#"

"( 4"

> "

> " !

! 1./.1/'6F %"(# !) - $ .!. .! . ! " ! ((/0%1 2 ! ! 3 !31* I F "

# +

# # (

F 6 F "

# !

9'" ! ! # " DD :#

" "

:# "E

" "

( "

("! !

( " "

(

+ "

! "

= # #

( ! ""

!" # # "

= > -

!:! !( 4 "

# "

; "# # ( "

118 ( "

1.'= ( 4 " # ( $

'86.

, ?

2 # 8

# @4"

!% #

( $

1 ("

# > - = "( !

: $

134*G ("

> > !

( "

''/21//6(

/0/'1//8 3 4

$)'0* !(

@ )

G B+

# & ) $!

# !

! I "

@ )G+

# & )

+ ," -

# -4# +

# = "

! $

'86. ($

'86/

( + ," -

# - 4# > -

: #

# "

"# -"

" 8 "

# '/ F "

# +

" # "

991 1/'6" ("

> "

! F

4 " # (

.; #" # ( 4

! ( # " "#

" !D( "#

5 > "#

( ## + ! # -4# > -

134* # 8

, ?

2 ($

.2 $

'86.$

'86/=

# -"

! " # F " " F "+

( ""!

.;G 4 #" #

! $

'86.#

( 4# " "# #

" $

.2 $

'86.$

134* # 8 A

, ?

2 ($

'86/ ""

# - +

( '' =# ( " "# #

# ( #

"5 " "

* !

#" #

)## "

( # !

!"("!: "

! " ! #

" "#$%&&'()*+,,++& $-&% &+

( + %.. &/*+0)# 1#%&

(#'&,&#+&+# 1/4"

# "

110

#" "# #

" 1/ ) ! * !! !

. ! .

! !

! ! $

! 4 ! . ! ((,

! ! !!

! . $

! ! . 5! .

! 4

! ((, ) ! ! . !

. . ! !! 3 3 .!

! ! ! 6.

! 6 ! )* 8%& ('''# =

# -"

+ ,"

## " !" " " # !

!": "

'1 ="#

.2 $

'86.

'86/$

134* # 8 A

, 3?

> "# # (

# ( 4 "

, 3?

2* (

134* # 8!

" E

# "

''/21//6 ( " /0/'1//83(*)

@ )B12 )&2'3 - $ 4&' 5111&

# !

# "

!"+

# & ) $!

# !

! > " > " > "( ##

(" + (

! +

# & )$!

# !

+ !

> -

" + (

> -

( +

+ !+

> -

# -4# + ," -

4 "# ( # # =

> -

(

" + " #

< +

# & ) # ( +

.2 $

'86. ($

'86/ $

.2 ) &$&+3 $ !! ! . .

!93 01 :

01 ;

! ! :

! ! ! 3 !:

01 . ! ! 7. !

01 :

01 ! :

.! .! . 7. *! ! :

6 ! .! . 7. *! ! :

!! .! !

&4 3! 0(1 ! +, 3!! !!

. 0(1

. !

! )) 4:

. " ! !!

. !

0+1 $ ! ! * !! 7. . . 7. !! !

5+%) 6) -&% & -6&#7*$(&*-&+#+,&% 8''&$.#$&+ !5&&&9:#6

-&+& &;+-'$6#6,+&$

&-'6 & :#6 &' +$$ 7& #+&% & %&$:#&

-& &7$&,&'&+&&;+-'$6 8#6 5 & ,& +'&- &% + 56 & &:#6&'+#$%7&--&'&%%-&%#' 76&;+-'$68#6 0&1 ! %% .! . 0

!1 ! %/<' !

!! !!93 -=

! !! ! * !

! !

. !# 0,1 8

.! . 0

!1 ! %/<' 6 ! * >4!

* .! . 0

!1 ! %/<' ?

!"#

+ :"

# = #

( + ," -

!# -4# + ," -

> -

: !

.239* $

'86. (

.2 $

'86.

134* # 8

, ?

2 #"( # ( "

@ )

#" + $

# # "#

"# # -4# + ," -

( > -

: # # # "

# "

+ ##

( " ( #"# "

# "

" 5

" ! )

* 7(/;#7&6*+(&

(#'&,&#+&+ %% 4 -%% $

*! !

! ! !! * ! ! . ! * &'

! ! $ !

! !! ! 8@

. A 0 ) %/+, (&+1 ! 5 .

0%/,C 0C1 CD&1 ;

* .

0 1 !

!. ! !.

01 ! .

.! * . !! # 6 <=, $ *+ 1$ +#- ,'6 *&<,&%%&+

(#'&,& #+&+

(& 93 -(& E! % ! ?

!! .

$ !! . ! !!

! . *

!! !! !

! !

. ! !!

! . . ! ! ;

* ! !! ! ! $ ! * # '. F "

# "

! ! #

# # "

(

# #

" #

> -

"# ##

" ##

# .9 (# =

( #

# > -

'/''1//;.//91//8

" > ?%%&+*+. ()

!( +

! C

! #

4# + ," -

# # C

- # : "

! !#

# " # "#

# ( "

> -

+ # )

" # #

> -

" # 33467 34 !6$8& '347 34 ! E

(

( "#

> -

+ > -

! # "

(

# =

# ##

> -

# (""

( # # "

# '9 F "

# " # # ( "

118 (

1.'

( + ## # -4# + ," -

# "

# = ##

)'.8/1) <)1/'6

!( 4

$)'1 $)'6 4 " # '/ ! ) -%' $ !

! " ! " !

! " 4 *

!* !2 ?

$ 4

! ! " *

!* ! F

! "

! ! " !# F "

# -"

> " # # ( # $#

# ""

> 4 +

+ " " :##

" # # "

" !

" "#

( # # ( 4 " ( " $

'86.

, #" "#

" # "

# & ) ! $

.2 $

'86. ($

'86/=

> " " !

# "

, :$

% ! "

118

'86. #" "#

# $

'86.3 "

118

* ($

'86/3 "

./8

# ( )

#" 4 " $

.2 $

'86.<$

.2 #""

"# #

" H

> -

: # (

# =# ( "

134*

# 8

, 3?

( " ''/21//6/0/'1//8 #" (

> -

#" + "

" E

#"" # ( " #" + !

4# " "

( + ##

"# # -4# +

# # " # " #""# ( "

> #" + "

" " "# # ( (

: > -

( # ( " +

!( " $

.2("

" ! 4"

!5 !" :"

" > " > -

# ( "

" > ?%*+"#$%&&'

()

(#'&,&#+&+ # 1/1'

19 )

;

! E

! 0 $ ! G 6 1 ) - # 4

!!:

: 4 !!: ! !

! !

! !!

: . . ! ! 0 $ ! G 6 1 (% 6 !

) ?!

: !

!! !

!! . ;

. :

) . ! ! ! ! 4 !

! 0 G ! G . ;?! %D/% %<+9 0%DD,3/'1 !! B ,&% 0G1 0 ! 7 "

. 5 ) ) %/,< %C(<1 (C

!! .

. .

! ! 4 . !

;

. ! !

? ! !

. 0 ;!! " G .

$ " ! 0%DD<%1 G , &<,9 (C G$ D(< E . E 0%D,/1 G % FE ,CC# =

4 " "

# ( "

( ## > -

(

!# "# (

.2 $

'86. '2 F "

# # # "

( #

"# ##

" ( # "

" # "

( " + ( !

! ! " " (# ) 87 5 *+ 0&, %#/ ,7$/ % & ! (

' @ * ! 3 (&&)5(&&$.$$)$$+*+,,++& &$9=-+&%& (

3 * ! .

! ! .&% (/ (#/$ % &+ *+ (& +)%&+ ( (

# - "

# "

" : "#

" '0 = # ) * =!

+ ##

# # "

# (

(7 * #

! "

'/''1//;.//91//8

# )

# # "

# "#

"7 * % "# ##

! "

" "

"# ##

/6/21//8'9/.1/'' '6

/6/21//8##

'9/.1/'' = # G"#

"# # -4# 5 "

+ ," -

"( ( '; < #

( % '" !

9++$:$ '&;

!: .32 < #: 5 K <