High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14417/2020disposed of

Bhupinder Kumar v. Haryana Vidyut Prasaran Nigam (Hvpn) And Others

2024-02-13Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri3 pages

!"# !$%&%"' (( )*+%',!-.*/- (((((! % %"'!- 0!-&*& -1'0%,1* -&-'%2/3 ,(4035'," )!-& (((((!&+"',!' & 6736(888 -!&!' 6-(-%)' "19:,;"$ !:

#"- )!+! % %"'!-( 6-(( (<:,;"$ !', 6-( %+'&)*.+*-:,;"$ !:

#"- )!-!&+"',!' &( 88 :( 435 ( )!+-!&!' <-% +! % %"')&=!!'#%9!,*',!-- %$9!>?

"# )!"'& % * %"'"#',%#"-%&&*'$!"#<-% %' )!' *-!"#/',/*& =1,%-!$ %'2 )!-!&+"',!' & "2-' )!=!'!#% "# " )!+! % %"'!-& 2-' !, " )! &%/%9-91 &% * !, +!-&"'& !&+!$%991 %' ;%!< "# )! @*,2/!' ?"-,!-, !,A((>+&&!,=1 )%&"*- %' > ;%,!''!B*-! <)%$))&=!!'*+)!9,%'3 >"'( (

4''!B*-! >5',#*- )!- "+1 )!--!-&"# )!#"-!&%,=!'!#% 9"'2 <% )%' !-!& ( ( 3!-'!,$"*'&!9#"- )!+! % %"'!-&*=/% !, ) )!+! % %"'!- <&2-' !,++"%' /!' %' )!1!-A<(!(#(AA &$"'&!C*!'$!"# @*,2/!' +&&!,=1 )%&"*- ;%,!''!B*-! %'<)%$)% <&,%-!$ !, ) 99 )!$"'&!C*!' %9=!'!#% &<!-! "=!2%;!'!B$!+ #"- )! =$D

<2!&()!-!# !-: )!-!&+"',!'

!+- /!' 2-' !, )! "&"/!"# )!!/+9"1!!&=1 -! %'2 )!%-++"%' /!' #-"/ )!1!-AA =* 9 !-"'

)!<&<% ),-<'("<!;!-: )!1#%9!,+! % %"'=!#"-! )%&"*- =!-%'2 > <)%$)<&99"<!,=1 )%&"*- ;%,!"-,!-, !, A((>4''!B*-! 5',"

"-,%' !!'$)"# )%&"*- ), C*&)!, )!"-,!-"#<% ),-<9"# )!=1& %'2 ) % <&=,%' 9<()!#"-!&%,+! % %"'<&&&%9!,=1 )!-!&+"',!' &

!+- /!' =1 #%9%'23<)%$)<&9&",%&/%&&!,;%,!''!B*-! >', )!-!# !-:!;!'

&"/!"# )!" )!-&%/%9-91&% * !,!/+9"1!!&);!=!!'2-' !, )! =1 $"*' %'2 )!%- &!-;%$! #-"/ AA ;%,! ''!B*-!

( ! #*- )!- &*=/% !, ) &"#-& )!+-!&!' +! % %"'!-%&$"'$!-'!,:)!%&!B$ 91 +-% 1<% ) )!#"-!&%,+! % %"'!-&<)"&!<-% +! % %"'<&,!$%,!,;%,! ''!B*-! ',<)");!=!!'2-' !, )!;%,!''!B*-!

:=* )!-!%&'"@*& %#%$ %"'& "<)1 )!+! % %"'!-)&=!!',!$9%'!, )! %99, !,!&+% ! )!#$ ) 9!29'" %$!<&&!-;!,*+"' )!-!&+"',!' & ;%,!''!B*-! =* '"$ %"')&=!!' D!'%' )%&-!2-,', )!$&! "# )! +! % %"'!- %& &C*-!91 $";!-!, =1 )! #"-!&%, @*,2/!' , !, A((>4''!B*-! 5(

( ' )!" )!-)',:6-(( (<:9!-'!,$"*'&!9#"- )!

-!&+"',!' && !, ) &%'$! )!+! % %"'!-)&#%9!,9!29'" %$!: )!&/! <%99=!$"'&%,!-!,',$"'&$%"*&,!$%&%"'<%99=! D!'=1 )!$"/+! !' * )"-% 1<% )%'+!-%","# <"/"' )&#-"/ ",1',9&"%' )!9%2) "# )!#"-!&%,@*,2/!' 4''!B*-! 5&&"& !,=1 )!9!-'!,$"*'&!9 #"- )!+! % %"'!-( ( ';%!<"# )!#"-!&%,#$ &',$%-$*/& '$!&: )!+-!&!'

+! % %"'%&,%&+"&!,"#<% )"* !B+-!&&%'2'1%'2"' )!/!-% &"# )!$&!: <% ),%-!$ %"' "-!&+"',!' "(?$"/+! !' * )"-% 1 "$"'&%,!-', ,!$%,! )!9!29'" %$!%&&*!,=1 )!+! % %"'!-;%,!''!B*-! =1 +&&%'2<!99 -!&"'!,&+!D%'2"-,!-<% )%'+!-%","# <"/"' )&#-"/ ",1',9&"%' )!9%2) "# )!#"-!&%,@*,2/!' &4''!B*-!& >5 ', )!"-,!-, !,>(E( 4''!B*-!

5( ( !!,9!&& "&1 ) %'$&! )!+! % %"'!-%&#"*', "=! +-% 1<% ) )!#"-!&%,+!-&"'&:<)");!=!!'2-' !, )!=!'!#% "# )! : )!' )!+! % %"'!-&)999&"=!2-' !, )!#"-!&%,=!'!#% <% )%' +!-%","# <"/"' )&<% )99 )!&%/%9-=!'!#% &( >( +- #-"/ )! =";!: =!#"-! ,!$%,%'2 )! #"-!&%, -!+-!&!' %"': )!+! % %"'!-&)999&"=!##"-,!,'"++"- *'% 1"#)!-%'2 ', )!-!# !-:&+!D%'2"-,!-&)99=!+&&!,%'$$"-,'$!<% )9<', )!&/!&)99=!$"';!1!, " )!+! % %"'!-( (( 4885 )*/%D ( )! )!-&+!D%'2?-!&"'!,

!&?"

( )! )!--!+"- =9!

!&?"