High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18844/2011dismissed

Smat. Saroj v. Presiding Officer And ORS.

2023-11-15Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger11 pages

!"# &#'()($*

+,, -.", -!/$0 ,,,,,, #"("($*#/ 1#/)2) 3# /#)(&(*4

%%('#/5 *&2)"/(!6 /(72*!6'2.8!7$2/ $2/"5 !*(9!"

$"3#/)

,,,,,, #)9$*&#*")

/#)#*"

), -!*4("!

3!*&!5

&:$'!"#

9#"("($*#/,

/, -!2/!:

;32/!*!5

&:$'!"#

/#)9$*&#*") $, , , , , #"("($*#/

-.", -!/$0 %(6#& (*)"!*"

(:(6 /("

#"("($*

/"('6#) < $*)"("2"($* *&(!5 )##=(*4 >/("

*!"2/# '#/"($/!/( ?2!)3(*4 (.924*#&

>!/& , ,

5 >3#/#7A /#%#/#*'# *&2)"/(!6 /(72*!6'2.8!7$2/ $2/"5 !*(9!"

3#/#(*!%"#/ /#%#//#& B"3# 7#6$>B &#'(&#& !4!(*)"

9#"("($*#/>$/=#/,

%2/"3#/ 9/!A#/ .!&# &(/#'"(*4 /#)9$*&#*") $, /#(*)"!"# 7!'= '$*"(*2("A )#/:('#5 %266 7!'= >!4#) !66 $"3#/ '$*)#?2#*"(!6 7#*#%("),

/(#%6A5 /!()#& !* (*&2)"/(!6 &()92"# )#/:(*4 #.!*& $"('# , +, 5 >3('3 /#%#//#& !99/$9/(!"# $:#/*.#*"

-"!"# $:#/*.#*"

#@#/'()# (") 9$>#/ -#'"($*

' *&2)"/(!6 ()92"#)

'"5 C<

3#/#(*!%"#/ /#%#//#& BC<

'"B !&02&('!"($* 7#6$>,

* !%$/#)!(& &#.!*& *$"('#5 '6!(.#& #.96$A#& ()"/('"

#& /$)) -$'(#"A5 !*(9!"

2@(66!/A 2/)# (&>(%#

3#/#(*!%"#/ /#%#//#& B , , >$/=#& )!"()%!'"($* )29#/($/)5 "#/.(*!"#& , C, >!A 2*%!(/ 6!7$2/ 9/!'"('# :($6!"($* 9/$:()($*) -#'"($* +5 -#'"($* + -#'"($* + C<

'", 3# '6!(.#& >$/=#& %/$.

, ,

, C, ()"/('"

#& /$)) -$'(#"A5 !*(9!"

%2/"3#/ '6!(.#& '$.96#"#& .$/# "3!* &!A) '$*"(*2$2) /#)9$*&#*"!*!4#.#*", !6)$ '6!(.#& 02*($/) /#"!(*#& )#/:('#5 "3#/#%$/#5 "#/.(*!"($* (66#4!65 !/7("/!/A5 9#/:#/)# !4!(*)"

9/$:()($*) 6!>,

''$/&(*46A5 '6!(.#& /#(*)"!"#.#*"

'$*"(*2("A )#/:('#5 %266 7!'= >!4#) !66 $"3#/ '$*)#?2#*"(!6 7#*#%("),

, !99#!/) &#.!*& *$"('# )#/:#& "/#!"#& )"!"#.#*"

'6!(.

7#3!6% 9#"("($*#/>$/=#/5 >3('3 '$*"#)"#& /#)9$*&#*") $, ()"/('"

#& /$)) -$'(#"A5 !*(9!"

3#/#(*!%"#/ /#%#//#& B/#)9$*&#*"!*!4#.#*"B 96#!

'$:#/#& 9/$:()($*) -#'"($* +

-#'"($* +5 -#'"($* + -#'"($* + C<

9#"("($*#/B) 92/#6A 7!)() "#/.(*!"($* (*#:("!76# :(#> &(/#'"($*) ())2#& (/#'"$/ #*#/!65 #!6"3 -#/:('#)5 !/A!*!

, , 5 >3#/#7A !.$2*"

4/!*"

/#&2'#& + D ("

)"!*& "#/.(*!"($* 9#/ "#/.) 6#""#/,

!6)$ )"!"#& $%%#/#& 9$)"

5 , <, 5 &(& !:!(6 )!(& $99$/"2*("A,

) 9#/ /#)9$*&#*"!*!4#.#*"5 "3#A 3!& :($6!"#& 9/$:()($* C<

9/!A#& &().())!6 '6!(.

9#"("($*#/>$/=#/,

, /$.

96#!&(*4) 9!/"(#)5 ())2#) %/!.#& #:(&#*'# 6#& /#)9#'"(:# 9!/"(#), +,

%"#/ '$*)(&#/(*4 .!"#/(!6 #:(&#*'# 96!'#& /#'$/&5 7#6$> /#0#'"#& '6!(.

!*)>#/#& /#%#/#*'# !4!(*)"

3#/5 (.924*#&

>!/& , ,

, , * !%$/#.#*"($*#& '(/'2.)"!*'#)5 %(6#& (*)"!*"

>/("

9#"("($* 7#%$/# "3() $2/",

8#!/*#& '$2*)#6 )27.(") (.924*#& !>!/& !/7("/!/A5 (66#4!65 9#/:#/)# !4!(*)"

9/$:()($*) C<

3#*'#5 2*)2)"!(*!76# #A#) 6!>,

8#!/*#& '$2*)#6 %2/"3#/ )27.(") "#/.(*!"#& :(#> , ,

+5 ())2#& (/#'"$/ #*#/!65 #!6"3 -#/:('#)5 !/A!*!5 (*&('!"(*4 #*"/!6 $:#/*.#*"

3!& (.9$)#& + D

'2"

!.$2*"

4/!*"

!*&5 "3#/#%$/#5 !'"($* .!A "!=#* (.9$)(*4 '2"

)"!%% )"/#*4"35 )$ !:$(& #'$*$.('

&(%%('26"(#),

)27.(""#& (..#&(!"#6A "3#/#!%"#/5 (/#'"$/ #*#/!65 #!6"3 -#/:('#)5 !/A!*!

3!& >/(""#* !*$"3#/ , <,

/#)9$*&#*" !*!4#.#*"

/#4!/&(*4 )#*&(*4 "3#.

%266 4/!*"(*!(& "#/.(*!"# !*A7$&A5 :($6!"#& )!(& >("3$2"

/#!)$*,

)27.(""#& 7#6$> #//#& !99/#'(!"(*4 #:(&#*'# /#'$/& !6)$ "#/.(*!"#& &2# (.9$)("($* '2"

)"!%% )"/#*4"35 )(*'# "3#A /#'#(:# %266 4/!*"5 &2"A 7$2*& /#)"$/# )!.# #.96$A##),

'$*"#*&#& 7#6$> $:#/6$$=#& %!'"

$%%#/#& %(@#& 9!A )'!6#5 ,, 5 >3#/#!) '!)# /#(*)"!"#.#*"

>$/=#/5 3# )3$26& "!=#* 7!'= )!.# "#/.) '$*&("($*) >3('3 3#

/#"/#*'3#&5 "3#/#%$/#5 /#)9$*&#*" !*!4#.#*"

'$26& $%%#/ !*$"3#/ %(@#& 9!A 7!)(),

*#@"

'$*"#*&#& 3!& '$.96#"#& .$/# "3!* &!A) #!'3 '!6#*&!/ A#!/5 72"

*$ '$.96(!*'# 9/$:()($*) -#'"($* + C<

.!&# >3(6# "#/.(*!"(*4 9#"("($*#/>$/=#/,

!6)$ )27.(""#& 7#6$> >/$*46A $7)#/:#& !>!/& -3/( ,-, $/#5 "3#* -#'/#"!/A ()"/('"

#& /$)) -$'(#"A5 !*(9!"

32)7!*& 9#"("($*#/>$/=#/5 >3#/#!) (*%!'"

>(%#

!6,

("3 !%$/#)!(& )27.())($*)5 6#!/*#&

'$2*)#6 9/!A#& ?2!)3(*4 (.924*#& !>!/& %2/"3#/ 9/!A#/ &(/#'"(*4 /#(*)"!"# 7!'= '$*"(*2("A )#/:('#5 %266 7!'= >!4#) !66 $"3#/ '$*)#?2#*"(!6 7#*#%("),

, #/ '$*"/!5 6#!/*#& '$2*)#6 !99#!/(*4 /#)9$*&#*" !*!4#.#*"

$99$)#& 9/!A#/ .!&#

7#3!6% )27.(""(*4 7#6$> 9!))#& >#66 /#!)$*#& !>!/& !%"#/ '$*)(&#/(*4 !66 %!'") '(/'2.)"!*'#) *$ (*"#/%#/#*'# /#?2(/#& )!.#,

)27.(""#& 92/#6A 7!)() >3(6# "#/.(*!"(*4 )#/:('#)5 !66 '$*&("($*) 6!(& &$>* , ,

5 '$.96(#& &26A '$.9#*)!"#& >!A $*# .$*"3B) !&:!*'# 9!A 6(#2 *$"('#5 "3#/#%$/#5 "3#/# *$ (66#4!6("A '$..(""#& >3(6# "#/.(*!"(*4 9#"("($*#/>$/=#/,

8#!/*#& '$2*)#6 %2/"3#/ )27.(") :(#> &(/#'"($*) ())2#& (/#'"$/ #*#/!65 #!6"3 -#/:('#)5 !/A!*!

, ,

+5 >3#/#7A !.$2*"

4/!*"

/#&2'#& + D5 !''$/&(*46A5 9#"("($*#/ >$/=#/ &()9#*)#& 9#/ 6#""#/,

)27.(""#& )27)#?2#*"6A5 !4!(* $%%#/#& !99$(*".#*"5 ,, 5 &(& '$.# %$/>!/& !:!(6 )2'3 $99$/"2*("A,

) /#4!/&) 96#!

02*($/) 3!& /#"!(*#& )#/:('#5 ("

)27.(""#& 6#!/*#& '$2*)#6 /#)9$*&#*" !*!4#.#*"

$*# -!*&##9 ;2.!/ >$/=(*4 !* #.96$A## #&

/$)) -$'(#"A5 >3$ "!=#* 9/$0#'"

$/&#/ '$9# )!(& 9/$0#'"5 !%"#/ (.9$)("($* + D '2"

4/!*"5 )!(& -!*&##9 ;2.!/ !6)$ )#*"

7!'= 3() 9!/#*"

&#9!/".#*"

(,#, ()"/('"

#& /$)) -$'(#"A5 !*(9!",

'!)# '$:#/#& -#'"($* + -#'"($* +5 -#'"($* + -#'"($* + C<

'",

) /#4!/&) '$*"#*"($* 6#!/*#& '$2*)#6 9#"("($*#/ >$/=#/ 7#6$> >/$*46A .#*"($*#& 9#"("($*#/ >$/=#/ >(%# -3/( ,-, $/#5 ("

)"!"#& )!.# &!A5 '6!(.

!*$"3#/ >$/=#/ -.",

##/.!"(5 >3$)# "#/.(*!"#&5 &#'(&#& >(%# -3/( ,-, $/#5 "3#* -#'/#"!/A5 ()"/('"

#& /$)) -$'(#"A5 !*(9!",

'$*"#*&#& 6#!/*#& '$2*)#6 /#)9$*&#*" !*!4#.#*"

)!(& $7)#/:!"($* !99#!/) "A9$4/!93('!6 #//$/ )!(& 4/$2*& !6$*#5 (.924*#& !>!/& 6(!76# )#"

!)(&#5 .$/#)$ >3#* #*4!4#.#*"

92/#6A *!"2/#,

''$/&(*46A5 ("

)27.(""#& "3#/# *$ .#/("

>/("

9#"("($* 9/!A#/ .!&# &().())!6 )!.#, C, 3#!/& 6#!/*#& '$2*)#6 /#)9#'"(:# 9!/"(#) !6)$ 92/)#& 9!9#/ 7$$= "3#(/ !76# !))()"!*'#,

, It is well settled position that !* #.96$A## !99$(*"#& 7!)()5 4$:#/*#& 26#) 3# 7$2*& "#/.) '$*&("($*) (*'$/9$/!"#& 6#""#/, !6)$ )#""6#& 6#4!6 9/$9$)("($* 9#/)$*5 >3$ !99$(*"#& !& 3$'

7!)() '$*&("($*) )"(926!"#& 3() 3()

'!* "#/.(*!"#& !"

"(.# >("3$2"

*$"('#5 &$#) /(43"

'6!(.

/#6(#%5 (% 3() !/# "#/.(*!"#& "#/.) "3#/#$%, *

CC - C5

9#@ $2/"

'!"#4$/('!66A 3#6& 2*&#/

$*B76# -29/#.# $2/"

C+ -29/#.# $2/"

5 3#6& $ %

%2/"3#/ 3#6& &

* '

- CC5 $*B76# -29/#.# $2/"

3#6& "#/.(*!"($* #.96$A## &$#) /#?2(/# (*"#/%#/#*'# 7#(*4 /#.$:#& 4/$2*& ("

&$#) '!)"

)"(4.!

$/ !)9#/)($* 3(.

3#/,

* ()* !

$ -29/#.# $2/"

9#@ $2/"

3#6& >3#/# *#("3#/ '$*%#/) /(43"

*$/ #?2("A %!:$2/ #.96$A##5 92/#6A '$26& "#/.(*!"#& >("3$2"

*$"('#5 *$ 4/(#:!*'# '!* #*"#/"!(*#& )2'3 #.96$A##, $/#)$5 3# '!**$"

'6!(.

#?2("!76# /#6(#% %/$.

$2/",

$/ !& 3$'

&$#) '$*%#/ 6#4!6 /(43", -2'3 !* !99$(*"## '!**$"

'6!(.

#?2("A 3() %!:$2/5 *$/ #?2("!76# /#6(#% '!* 4/!*"#& 3(.

$2/"

#:#* (% 3# 3!& >$/=#& !* 2*2)2!6 6$*4 9#/($&5 32.!*("!/(!* '$*)(&#/!"($*),

9#/)$* 3$6&(*4 !& 3$'

9$)"

.#.7#/ !''$/&!*'# )"!"2"$/A 26#) !*&5 "3#/#%$/#5 '!**$"

:#)"#& /(43"

9$)", E1(&# ()* !

)29/!

" $

C< -29/#.# $2/"

-(.(6!/ :(#> /#("#/!"#& $*B76#

9#@ $2/"

'!)#) >3#/# 9#/)$* 3$6&(*4 "#*2/# 9$)"

$7)#/:(*4 #%%62@ "(.# '$.#) !* #*& !2"$.!"('!66A #@9(/A "#*2/# !99$(*".#*"5 )2'3 !99$(*"## '!**$"

'6!(.

/#6(#% #("3#/ 7!)() #?2("A5 $/ 32.!*("!/(!* '$*)(&#/!"($*)5 $/ 6!>,

1(&# " # + " CC -29/#.# $2/"

< "

CC+ -29/#.# $2/"

<, , $.(*4 '!)# 3!*&5 '$*'#&#&6A5 '!.# #*4!4#&

5 , ,

5 >3('3 92/#6A 7!)(),

3# /#6#:!*"

#@"/!'") , ,

/#!& , - $ ( + # .///01//0.2//03 * 01//04///

+ 5 &

6 " 7 ' 8

- 9

;

32)5 :#/A >#66 !>!/# *!"2/# &(& /(43"

'$*"(*2# )#/:('#,

, &()92"#& /#6(#:#& %/$.

)#/:('#5 , C,

5 >3('3 /#!&) , < ( '6= > 8?/@?1A/B @/ 4 /@ " & 5 5

C/D E E

@ F /@" '

"7 '

A F /@6= ( 8$ 6

* $ ( 1/4B. ;

9#/2)!6 !7$:# #@"/!'"#& >$26& '6#!/6A (*&('!"# >3(6# /#6(#:(*4 %/$.

)#/:('#5 9!(& !//#!/) 9!A '$.9#*)!"($*

!*=

''$2*"

$, <,

"32) .!*(%#)"

'$*&("($* #*:()!4#& , ,

5 (,#, 9!A.#*"

$*# .$*"3 6(#2 *$"('#5 &26A

'$.96(#& >3(6# /#6(#:(*4 %/$.

)#/:('#), , !6)$ &()92"#& !4!(* $%%#/#& !99$(*".#*"5 ,, 5 /#%2)#& 0$(*,

* "3() /#4!/&5 /#%#/#*'# '!* .!&# '/$)) #@!.(*!"($* 9#"("($*#/>$/=#/5 >3('3 /#!&)

, # # =

>' #

3 #

:::::::::::

7 .///?0

' '* 7 7

# 9 0 $

(

$ ( + #

@//4 # @//A > # (

# 3: >G# $

3: >G

: #

< #

# %

;

9#/2)!6 !7$:# #@"/!'"#& '/$)) #@!.(*!"($* 9#"("($*#/ >$/=#/ >$26& '6#!/6A (*&('!"# 3!& &26A '$.96(#& "#/.) , ,

>3#/#(* ("

'6#!/6A )"!"#& !99$(*"#& 9$)"

6(!76# "#/.(*!"#& $*# .$*"3B) *$"('# #("3#/ )(&# $/ 9!A 6(#2 "3#/#$%,

'6#!/6A !&.(""#& $*# .$*"3B) !&:!*'# 9!A &26A 9!(& !"

"(.# /#6(#:(*4 %/$.

)#/:('#,

, ;##9(*4 * :(#> 6#4!6 9$)("($* (*&('!"#& !7$:# 9#'26(!/ %!'") '(/'2.)"!*'#) "3() '!)#G &$ %(*& .#/("

(*)"!*"

>/("

9#"("($* )!.# !''$/&(*46A &().())#&,

9#*&(*4 !996('!"($* )5 (% !*A5 )3!66 )"!*& '6$)#&,

+,,

)0=) 3#"3#/ )9#!=(*4 /#!)$*#&

$ 3#"3#/ /#9$/"!76# #)