← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCUSAP/2/2015dismissed

M/S Tdt Copper Ltd v. Union Of India And ANR

2015-08-18Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary5 pages



       

 !"!#$%$&'((

)%**!+,$-$ !"

..**!//& 

&$&&"$&"& 0!+ . !%*&"!& %  ' 1,

 2

  ,  1,

      

 

       

   

   

  

       !" #

$  !"#!$%# 



   3425-+ $ /6  %#&

#'  '

#$

( "& #(*"  +, &# -#"./&#  

0  1(   )     '

 # (*  21"&   !&"%1

%&'(&# -#%&'(.&(*



&"&  ,)

0 #!(&(*

  00+3

0 "&*&/ 4&/('&5(& 4$ -&6##& ""&"(*"  " # %&'(47(& &&     '

 **&&      21"& 

 8#&999!#(/##

& 4*&&'& &  *:

&&6###%&'(47(& && &/#

  4##  

&"# & 4#

!&& 44#&&/#!(  /#&/#&&/"4&# &"& 

#"#;(*#(#2#  "":.

   4  "  !    #  "&&    #  "!

&!!&#

* '&" %#& *( "( "

4& &/(# <0  21"&  %&

 "  +3    &  #  #&  /  "

  ("&/ "* &#"( #!&/(!&#/ 

1&*



" =&5(&* 4*&&##  "

 "# #

#'/( &* &/# &*&

*  4&>    &  ?&/*  %#  &*   *  '

 #

(

 

% *#"(*(

1&*  

"& & *# 9#*"(

'(&  #  

  #    &  !&(  ""  4&#  # (

&      #* '&/  @  %*&  %&/    ! 4&>!&1( 3 0

) * &A(

 ) % *# *(/(8"*'

0 "

 "#  # &""( #"" # &"&  4&#&5(& & ( *&(* 8) % ""&/ # &"/&#'!""48 <

 (8) *&(*&  5(8< <, 4&#&# 5(& &  &"&/"& &"&('

# &/(

& B    #  '!  "&  #  

  #  &*    "&/*

3%"

"# &'& 

)"&/"& !(  < <, 8@%  

&!&", +

) 1( <  ""&/# # &* "&/*&4'"  #"(*(

'

"(*(#&&& &!#1"!( (//'

#&**&& %#"(*( &' ' &#'& "&!(&  &!&" &" ( &/ 4( #!  '  

) 33 +, '( & 4  '

&**&&  

 + 0)0@$#(#

4

" &&"(*( 

0))3 + &*& * #'& & #

 # & * 3 ,



)4('7"&*&*'

#(#&& #

4 " #"(*( &1"""( !(###*"&!(&* "& 0

#" =&///&! #

 &!&(

' # **&&

 21"& 8#&999 (/ D&  0 )

0 1(

4 #*'!&/##"!(4" &/# &!&"""* &/#"&/*4#&"#4&(4&## ""'4#&* #(

&'(#*# '"" '

#&/

&" %#**&# '& 4&#4(#& 4&" #'& &/#"!( //&!'

# #!( &

' #%&'(  

&"&4

&/4&##

 %#%&'( "&&/#*



0 1( )&# 

&"& 4#'

#&

#**&& 

 0 )

04&#/#&"& *

#'& "!(#'  E"#&

'

# )  6#!#"( # & 0  %#  

  &  //&!  '

 #  &&*    

0 1( ) #%&'( & (/&

  0 )

0 1(

4#'

&"&#'&(# &/

&" * #'& &/# "!(    94(/'

#"( #

## 4 !& &/& &# #**&& 

  4#&  *&/  #  *    #  &/  

&" ""&/#&* #%&'(#(  #

# , ### "( #!(('*& ##**&&

4*&&&"&/*

#'& &'

"" &/#"!( ""&/#&* # &"&"&&/#4-"" &/#"!(."( '/&! "&#'/&!'

#**&& 

 &/  <   6 & "&#('*&& "( # !( 3  %#**&&

4#&"" &/#



    *&/  #  "  #  &"  &  &    

0 )

0 1(

($ -9#!1*& #"" 9  #" # "!( " &/#&"*""* &/

 #  "&/* 4#&"#  4  &  (  4&#  #  ""   '4  #  &*     (

&  #    ' "" '

#&/

&" 9(#!(#' #"#'

"(&/#

 *(

=*#'& && #"*&/#     7"&/  #  "  !(  '

 #  &/ 

&" #*&* #&/& #"*&/ *# '& #'&4#&"###"!( #'  %#&* 4 ( &" ' #"* #"!( 9!&4 '!  "(  &&  #  #"*    #  !(  & '& ((&' %#**&#'&

 &&# 4(#&&&" #'& &/#"!( %#

&  &'!* .

+  %#

4#/&! 7(& &"& "" &/#"!('

/&!&/#

  #  *  9  #  '"      "/    &"&   "" &/  #  "  !(  '

 #  **&&  

  4 (7(& & ""&/ #%&'(4&/#& & (/&

4&#/&"& * #'& #"!( 5( #

 &*&  ##

#' # %&'(#'"&1 &&( #&/'!#&# 'F1 & &&#*& #"  3425-+ $ /

5"7! 575% (6  -!&"+$&

87%8 5"7!