High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14526/2020allowed

Shankar Gupta And Others v. Bar Council Of Punjab And Haryana And Others

2020-09-16Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain,Mr Justice Jaswant Singh28 pages

C W P N o s . 1 4 5 2 6 & 1 4 5 2 4 o f 2 0 2 0 P a g e | 1

! "!#$%$&' (

! "# )' &*+,!)-.% $#! /!%01.2-$& &*+,!)-.% $#!%3& 4$&50 $ %& '

'( %& % '

' ) &*+,-.-/-/& %& "0'

' %& '

' ) &*+,-+-/-/& %&

' &* -& %&

""'

'( %&

""'

' &+) &*+,-.-/-/& %& '

'( %& " 01('

' &,) &*+,-.-/-/& %&20 03'

'( %& '

' &.) &*+,-.-/-/& %& '

' &4) &*+,-.-/-/& 555555

C W P N o s . 1 4 5 2 6 & 1 4 5 2 4 o f 2 0 2 0 P a g e | 2

/!%01.2-$&6

*& 1 ( ( 0 ) &*+,-.-/-/ 6

& 7 8 6 79 ) &*+,-+-/-/ 6 ! "#& 7 8 6 79 ""& (' ' 0 :

& -& 1 %"

;:&<= 0 ( (

( > 0 /4&/4&-/-/8&&!7.-! 89

8 6 79 0""

' ?1 0 0

-/-/<-*

( &,$&!!,!# $&%6 @/&/4&-/-/A/*&*/&-/-/'( ' && ' ' ' 2 1 :

"0 = ;: %"

0 "

= 89& 1 "

0 ' :0 ( 8

B 0 9 ' -/*, 8

C W P N o s . 1 4 5 2 6 & 1 4 5 2 4 o f 2 0 2 0 P a g e | 3 6 -/*,79'"

C 8 6C79& @& 3

-/*,&C

( 0 ) &,4,- -/*+

6)0$&"!- 4$&50 0.0& 9% - .&#$, .&:+ &" -;&6 0&"$5-07 (

' ' 0" + "

(

< ( 0 ""

" " "' '

<('(( 0"

" ( &1 ( 0 (

( '" '% 0 (

(

<(' 0 ( & 1 (

03 &*+-D-/*+ 0 *+&/E&-/*+&C

"#$"%&

1 (

'("

" # #

C W P N o s . 1 4 5 2 6 & 1 4 5 2 4 o f 2 0 2 0 P a g e | 4

> # 0 " ?&1& 0&C ( " ( (

' ' " &C (

" "

(

< ' "

( :

' 0 (

( & C ( /*&/4&-/*+'

' '

( "

' -/*,' ( ( " 0 # # B ?&1& 0& 1 "

C& +& # 0 0'

-/*, ("

/-&/,&-/*,

C*-&*/&-/*,& " -/*,

C*-&*/&-/*,' ( ( 0

(

0 ) &./+D -/*, <-: 4$&50 -$/; 9% - .&#$, .&:+ &" -;& &" & 0!-=& C ( (( 0 ' (0

C W P N o s . 1 4 5 2 6 & 1 4 5 2 4 o f 2 0 2 0 P a g e | 5 -/*, ( & 1 ( (

# /+&/E&-/*,( (0 $< 61 " 00 "

& "

& 1 00

<( A A0 ( &1-/*,

: A 0 "

" & 1 0' ( ( 0 '

0 0 ( (:" " ( 00 ' 0 ( 0 & ( (

0 0

" (00 $ 89 1-/*, & 89 89 **(

( 0

& C 89 @ 0 F 0 0 ""

,// ( " &,'///A<

&*///A<

0 " ,// ""

0 ( "&*/'///A<

& -'///A<& &

' " ' ( '

0 & 89 ) **&/,&-/*,'

C W P N o s . 1 4 5 2 6 & 1 4 5 2 4 o f 2 0 2 0 P a g e | 6 (

-/*, & '( ) (

"( ( **&/,&-/*, ( " (

G " '

--&+&-/*, ' (

(

& 1

( " -/*, &

A""

(

( : (& 1 :

&7 1 /+&/E&-/*, ( "

C*-&*/&-/*, -/*,

" *,8@9

' *4.* 8 6 79& " '

-: 4$&50-$/;*%#%!%.>-(

" !!>/1.2".&" 0!-%9% - .&#$, .&:+ &" -;& &" 0!-%6 8-/*.9 *, " .E4 0 "

( "

(" & ,&

" ' ( 0) &,-@-'-@E.,'-+@4- -,4*--/*,( 0 ( ) &-+@4--/*, < /!%0 .&$ 9%-.&#$, &"$&"& 0!-=6( > ( "

'! ) (

*+", '

*+",

)

"#$"

C W P N o s . 1 4 5 2 6 & 1 4 5 2 4 o f 2 0 2 0 P a g e | 7 .

)

"#'"('(

! .7C '

0 ( " -/*, .8

9'.89 .89 ( *,

*.'*D *E

)F '-//* 8 6 -//*79& C

( " > 0 ' " 0 +- +@

-*&*-&-/*.'( $< 6+-& ' ( "

(

" " ( 0 "

' ( & C "0 "

0 "

( 0H

0 ( "

" "

G "

0 & 0 ( " 0 " ?

0 "0 ( &

C W P N o s . 1 4 5 2 6 & 1 4 5 2 4 o f 2 0 2 0 P a g e | 8 +@& ( ' ' " : ( & H0 " 0 A A " ( ( 0

00 (" &1 &7 " /!%0

.&$*% #%! %.>- ( ( (

0 ) &4D.+ *//.4 -/*E 6- &2, &4$"0.9%-.&#$, .&:+&"-;&&" 0!-%7' ( ( 0 -4&/E&-/*E

0 -/*,& .& F" " 0 '

-/*,("

( /*&/4&-/*+ 3 &*+-D -/*+ ( "

" ) &-+@4--/*,&

"0 -/*,' 0 ' ' ' ?1 0

( %!#-! +,, ' ( .8989 -/*,& 1 -/*, $< )44 )) 4 ? 44 4 ::: ::: ::: :::

C W P N o s . 1 4 5 2 6 & 1 4 5 2 4 o f 2 0 2 0 P a g e | 9 9891

%!#-! +,, 0 * F " #"

' * F ' ( :

(0 :

&7 1 D -/*, ( $< 6D&

4' ; 0H (0 (

& &

< & &

& &

1 & &

2 & &

3 C0& & ;: %"

8 "

0 "

9& 4 ( " ' (

$< 64& )4

'8 1 = %"

;: ""

" & ( :

" "

" (

' & 1

( :

"' 0( " (

' ( ( ( *" &

@* = & 89 1 @* = & 89 C "

" ' > (

0 =

& *$

' ( " 0 "

' -/*, * F #"

' -/*, :

(0 :

& 1 0" " " "

0 0

' '

" ; & " "

' ' &

" 0

(

0 "

(

( & -$ 1= (

@* %' -/*, " ""

" : 9&=

' -/*,& @$ 1 ( ( " ""

" & 0 ( " " "

"&7 D& 1(

*E&/.&-/-/

( -89' .8989 4 -/*, ( " & 1 $< 61 8

0 9 '-/*,< 7$% $&5

->%!"2!&"2!& -!$ .88C9$< 89

" "

< ""

# "

0 (

"" " # */

(

G 2 0 & 4$< !-2% 0!

$#! 1

: ""

& ( :

" " (

' & 1

(

"' 0 (

(

' ( (

( *" & 1 " : 0

(

-/-/&;

(% -/-/& 1 ' ( <

" 1

B 0 9 -/*,'

" .8 989 -E&*/&-/*D

$ C " 0 :

' 0

0 "

;

(

' (0 $< 9 ) 9 ;

"A " 9

&0& ' > & = 9 3 (A 0 0

" 1

(

0& ;:

$ 9 1

( < 0 "

( :

& 9 1 ;: ""

(

;

& C

( & 9

" 0 $ 91

9 " 0 $ 1 (

" : ( 8C ;: " 9&

-/*,J0"&"& 1 *E&/.&-/-/ (

*4&/.&-/-/ (

C*.&/D&-/-/ " ( *,8@9

& E& C "(' (( 0) &*@.*. -/-/ 6%0& 7 ) &*@.@/ -/-/ 6% 0 K & 7"

*EA*4&/.&-/-/ -*&/E&-/-/

( # ' 0" (

& (

" 0**&/4&-/-/'( (0 ( $< 6 " " :

" -8!9 8

0 9 '-/*,& %& 3"

( & C ' " - 8!9 ' " 0 (

( & 0 " 4 8

0 9 '-/*,'

0 ( "' (' ( 0

0& 3 "

" 0

& C ' (

" ( ( "

' ( " " 4

0 9 ' -/*,& (' " :

> -!

0 9 '-/*, ( & C " ' 0 4 8

0 9 '-/*, &

*+&*/&-/-/&

&7 4& " **&/4&-/-/ (

' '

" "

C' "

0 /4&/4&-/-/ 0"" &,$&! !,!# $&% ' && ' ' ' 2 1 &1 /4&/4&-/-/

6 =? C3=F? 2 #

)

) #%0' <@D ' 0'*.//@.' ) (((& && # /4&/4&-/-/ =1CFC 1C= ;:0 ( 61

B0 9' -/*,&8 "

C91 0

0 0

8-/-/<-/-*9 (0 $< @/&/4&-/-/ 8)

' 0

& 4&//

-&//% 4&//

-&//% 1 (0

/*&*/&-/-/ 81 9

& ?

' 0 ( "

A" "

( H

*-&/4&-/-/

> ( :

0 " 0 ( 0 = (0 " '( (

*.&/4&-/-/ 0 " ' ' ' 2 1 " */&// % ,&//%

0 0 " 0( ( 0 8 H9'

" 0

" (

& $ 1 0

( "

B 0 9 '-/*,& -9 1

(

0 = ( ( "

(" " " (

& *D&/4&-/-/ " " */&// *-&//% *D&/4&-/-/ ) ( " " /*&// " -&//% *D&/4&-/-/ # > " "-&// " ,&//% *D&/4&-/-/ F (

(

( 0" " 0 ( 0 ( ""

*E&/4&-/-/& $C

0 ( H :

( ( "

" 0 & 1 I 2 0

0 '%&2 (

& 1 (

' 0 (

-/-/<-/-* " & 1 ( ' ' ' & 2 1 "0 : ""

( "

& 1 " 0 (

-/-*'

' " ( " #"

& 8! 09 "7 */&

00 0

/4&/4&-/-/' & 10 (

0 # ' 2 ""

# '2 & "

" #

' ( " /*&/@&-///'

' 2 ' ' 2 ' D;: %"

& 0

-/-/<-*

0 ' 2 "

( "

=( ( & 1

2 ' ;: %"

( 0

<( # '2 & 3

0 ' ( 0 0 " ' "

*EA*4&/.&-/-/'

( " " " -89'.8989 4 -/*, 0 -/*,("

(

/*&/4&-/*+ 3 &*+-D -/*+' ( 0 = #

""0 &C "

# ( ""0 -/*,' (> >

""0" " -/*, ' '

" ( 0 *+

C & "

*+, ' ( # #

&0" ' ( 0 : 0 "& C ' ' "

( "0 : ' ( (

0 0 0 " ( 0 =C#<*4 ; "" C 0 0 A

< 0=C#<*4

" 0 0

(

'&& ' ' '2 1 "0 = ;: %"

( " ""

( " &C "

(

0 = 0 A

( " & 0 *EA*4&/.&-/-/

(

0 D "

" "

=: = ;: %"

& C ' 0 -/*,

/!%0 .&$*% #%! %.>- -/*,> < *, '"

(0 " 0

CC " < .8

9' .89 .89 & **& 3

0 &+ " 0 " # 0" % 0 @$&$ -!" %! 9% - .&#$, 2$, ". &"

.".#0!--; -!> +; $ % 0$-2& $50 .- 2>.% 0!&&$ 6 A $9$,( 3

0 &, "

" **&/4&-/-/ ) &*@.*. -/-/' " 4 -/*,

( 0

' 0" " 4 ! )"0; -"!%0 9% -2" #0 &",& &" & 0!-6 8-/**9 D " .@4& 3

0 &4 "

89& C

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

( &1 0( ' "

-/*, " "

3 &*+-D -/*+& 1 -/*, ( 0 ) &-+@4- -/*, 0

*EA*4&/.&-/-/

0 " " 4 -/*,' ( 0 '

" **&/4&-/-/

) &*@.*. -/-/' ( 0 & C '

' "

(

# " " " 0

-/*, " " " 4

-/*,' " 0 "

0 ( 00 " " -/*,&

"0 : ""

;: %"

( 0&C "

0 ( " =C#<*4 ( > " 0 & *-& C

' "

-/*, *EA*4&/.&-/-/'

( " " 0 4' 0

:0 ( -/*,'

"0 -/*, " " ' ( 0 -/*,0 0" " '0 ( >

& "

9' .89 .89

/!%0

.&$*%#%!%.>- &

0 # /!%0

.&$*%#%!%.>- .89

CC ( < 89 . :

" & 1 ( ""

0"0 '

0 = & ; '

0" -/%00&"-)!0 *%#%!%.>-((0

(

" (

"" " % &C ( 0 ( " .809'.89 .89 ( " "

% % & 1 (

*@& )

( &

0 0

" -/*, 0"

'" '

! &"# $

%&6 ' ( ) " (

* ( +, ! -*

. * /+0 1 # & "# $ ( ! ( ) " # %&-%%#$ $&?0-6$% 0$&" &4 !- .&#$, ) &" & 0!- %&' 0$- .%%$& .>-;6 "9# ! & - .&#$, .&:+ &" -;&6 0-.50 $ % 4!#-! -;6 ?3 03&6 4!# - CD86 0&"$5-0 &" 0!-% 4.>-6 - >0&"-)!0 &4 !-.&#$, ) &" 0!-%%& @$&$ -!"%! &-.&#$, 2$,". &" .".#0!--; -!> +; $ % 0$-2& $50 .- 2>.% 0!&&$%& 0

/!%0 .&$ %& > . B D *4.*

" -//*

0 -/*,'

'( 00 (

0 " "

4 -/*,

(

( ( (

: ""

(

( "

: ""

& C 0 ' "

# "2 34/545 6 4/5/738787

' 0 4 ( & C " **&4&-/-/ ( 0)<*@.*.B*@.@/<-/-/(

0 "

' ( " " 4

-/*, " '0

: ""

( :"

: ""

( ""

( 0 "

& 0 :" )<*@.*. B *@.@/<-/-/' ( 0 **&4&-/-/' 0 4 -/*,'

' ' **&4&-/-/ )<*@.*.B*@.@/<-/-/ & C 0 ' ( " " -2"#0&",& &"& 0!-4.>-( /

) &

0 !

) )

)

) ) )

)

)&%

: ""

' " ' ' ' '2 1 & F:"

: ""

-. ""

' "

-* ""

;: ,= -*""

;: '*/""

D""

0 0" */

-""

" 0

" & " 2 ( : ""

" & C "

3 <*+-D<-/*+

= # (

" 0 "

( " " " :

( 0 "

: ""

( ( 0

( 00

( "

= (

0 ( 0

" :

" 0 ""

& )' ' ( 0

" " " " " 4 -/*, 0 0

0 0

'( 0 " " "'

(

& '( '((

( "

0 4&4&-/-/& &

& 141 ) 44 (