Ram Nath & ORS v. Bhakra Beas Management Board & ORS


  
  
  
  
 
 
 




 !"!#$  % & 

 !"!#$  % & 

 !"!#$  % & 

 !"!#$  % & '( )

( #* (+"

'( )

( #* (+"

'( )

( #* (+"

'( )

( #* (+"

    ,+"-"

,+"-"

,+"-"

,+"-"

(( .+  "/ 0)# #* (+"

(( .+  "/ 0)# #* (+"

(( .+  "/ 0)# #* (+"

(( .+  "/ 0)# #* (+"

"1#*# "1#*# "1#*# "1#*#
/$
/$
/$
/$ 23/'
 23/'
 23/'
 23/'
 4 ( (+1+ +" (5 51 1+") 67

558* " (9-*0)# :

4 7+ ++* (1+ +"+# :

4 ( (+ (9-*0)# "(-5*7+1+ *!# ( !0"

:

+"# $ /+3'( +) ;*<

!#+" /+,!.

"'-+!;*<

(+"1#*# ===  (+!;>+  (+!;>+  (+!;>+  (+!;>+ (!#"

8+!

1 !#( "7# !5*-#*++ ! 5"

& #*

(
#"

- #*!

+?- "(!#0 (+*+ *

* @ >##A-+B 41 ""*76+"1#*# 

<!*8(! (  5 !) !#+"

(!+ "+<! " < +!-"1"

"( *7#* 5!#* !#+""-7)!

!#+"( *8+.* !#"

(1"

")# !#*!#

!#(*

!5" ("+<! +#*+*76

+ 558"$B
   





     

     

    

            



 

 

!"
#$

%&'

(( )   
#*+ 

 

 
,-

 . / 

       01  , 

 

%
%
#$+
%&'

(( )   
#**  -

    '

    

     ,  

 2


%% +(



'

 

  

%$
#3# &'  (( 

/   

##3 

 

  +      , 

1,

4,

 0,-     5



( 







6 







%"


#$+
%&'

##3 

 

  %'%!
#3+
% 

##3 

 

  



      

 4, /              









6 







#   % ;  +"1#*# B +*  !# +*- * 

" ();  # )56;  +0-5

!#    * !56  +

*D8+.  ( +0* 8+.+"#+55!#/ "#     !#"

<

1"

+ (1-+1" +0-5

* !56+

*D8+. ( +0* 8+.+"; 8 #*!

!#"8+!)1"*;8(! (+ "-#*+$B >!4 8+.+ ( *  7# # !#-!#0  ( 8+.  +  +"+)+ "#   &;

>!!4'

!558+.!#0;8!

(- #67 +##-)7+ * 6"

8+.* !#+""-7)!

!#+"*# "

!"

6 ( #*!

!#"!)1"* !# " ()  *

*   %  >##A-+  B 4   (  1 8+8+.!#0-#!# ++-1 *56 #*; (+ +; (6 +# 5*

"+<! "-#*+ (" ()>##A-+B 4 # ; ))-#!

!#*

*  @ >##A-+B 4!"

# + +6 (

(+"1#*# B +*"-7)!

*

5#08!

( (8+!

#"

)# !###A-+B ;"+<!

+ ! -5 +" !#+"( "7#1+1 +*# (8+!

)# ;!

!"<!*#

!# (6 +"

#* ; "+<! " !#+"8+# #0 0* +8 8+. (+ +; !#+"*# -5 !55 ( #*!

!#""

!1-5

* !###A-+B

(68+# 8+.!#0!# (6 + ;

(*

#8(! ( (" ()8 "!""-*! %  #  <!8   ( 

- 5  "1  +5

!#0    "+<!

+ ! -5 +"   (  1 !#+";  5 !)   (  1 !#+  + +0-5

!#( "7#+!0( 56+9 (6*!*# -5 !55
5 -"B  !  2"

!55  8+.!#02  7 -"  (6  ( <  #  8+.* *-+!#0 (6 +

; +8 8+.!# ('-7!<!"!# (+ +; (+!"#!# !+)!

6!# (+*+*

* @

>##A-+B 4 #  <!8   (" 

"  #*  !+ -)"

# ";  # !# + +#   !"  55*  !#  +"1    ##A-+  B  *

* @  8<+; (!"+*+8!55#  )!# (8 6

 +"1#*# +B #"!*+ !#+"2 5 !)76+5 A!#0

(1+<!"!#2"

!558+.!#0;8!

(- #67 +##-)7+ * 6"

8+.*2  <!#0  +0 +*    (  "+<!   +#*+*  76  !#+" +)E@ ;E@@  #* EE !55*

8!

( +

!# 7+ .!# (6 +

 ##B8+.!#0!# (6 +

8 76#*  (!+  # +5;  "!#   (+  8+  #  8+.  !#  (  '-7 !<!"!#8 #*!

!#

!#!" )!#0!# (8 6 (  1 !#+"  +  58  1 !*  )156"    +*  ) 6 

.

"6)1

! <!8!#+B #"!*+!#0 ()

+ +0-5

!#  !#+"2"+<!   !#"

#*"*!"1"* !# 7< +)"  +*!"*!+

. * !"!#8!

(!# 1+!*  "!A)# (" +) * 6 / 6 ; & / 6 ; & / 6 ; & / 6 ; & >4 >4 >4 >4 .

# (