High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2713/2017dismissed

Davinder Singh @ Kaku v. State Of Punjab

2018-07-06Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain6 pages

!" #"$%&%'( ) *

+%'#",-%'./ 0% &1 23 "!%!%'", 4",&3& -! !" 3'5 6 '# '!/", "&7'#"'!&

,"&"'!( ,1-%'./8#+$ !" ,!/"7"!%!%'", , ,7,""!30! '%883'5 6 ,-- ..38#+$ !" ,,"&7'#"'! 99999 :*;

, !/" ," &'& <"'!%'"# %' !/" 770%$ !%'8 !/" & <" %& 00="# "0 > **# >&%' %0%'.!/","+%&%'%&$'#'"# /,3./ !/%& ,"+%&%' 7"!%!%' 3'#", -"$!%' : , $/ 00"'." / & 6""' 0 %# ! !/" ,#", # !"# * 7 &&"# 6> !/" ,%'$%7 0 .%&!, !"8 3+"'%0" 3&!%$" ,#8 / 0% /","%'

!", ,"

",,"# ! &!/" ,#8=/","6>7"!%!%'",/ &6""'#"$0 ,"#< 5,8 !! %'%'. ." <,"!/ ' *>" ,& !!/"!%<" 00"."#

"'$" 3,&3 '!!!/"7,"+%3&,#",# !"# ? *8

%# +%! -/ , <5%! -%'./8 -36 %+%&%' 0 .%&!, !"8 ", &&%8 %&!,%$! -- . ,8 / &6""' %0"#$$,#%'.!!/"& <"86!/!/"/=2%# ,& 7 !",' 0 '#

< !",' 0+%00 ."& !/"7"!%!%'",/ +""@7%,"#'!/,3./$/"$2%'. ,"0"+ '!6%,!/ '##" !/,".%&!",< %'! %'"#6>!/"<8'"'!,> !/"6%,!/ !/"7"!%!%'",= & 3'#!/","%''A3%,>%'!/%&,". ,#= & 0&$'#3$!"# 6>- 8 ", 6 &&% ' '3!&/"008 !/" 7"!%!%'", = & 62"# '# !,%"# %' $ &" * # !"# : ,".%&!","#3'#",-"$!%'&

8 ?8 : 8::8?

)8 :* ," #=%!/-"$!%' :; !0%$"-! !%'B 0,38 %&!,%$!-- . ,8/ 0% 6> !/" -"&&%'& 3,! ! !/" !%<" ##3$%'. #"

"'$" "+%#"'$"8 !/" 7"!%!%'",$0 %<"#/%<&"0 !6" 53+"'%0"/","

,"8#"$0 ,%'./%<53+"'%0"8 /%&$ &"= &,"

",,"#6 $2!!/" ,# ' $'!"&! ,< !/" $<70 %' '!8 !/" 7"!%!%'", = & #"$0 ,"# < 5, '#$ &"= &8!/","

,"8,"

",,"#6 $2!!/"-"&&%'&3,! -36&"A3"'!0>8 7"!%!%'", <+"# '!/", 770%$ !%' 6" ," !/"

,# , #"$0 ,%'. /%< 53+"'%0" =/%$/ = & #%&<%&&"# +%#" ,#", # !"# ? ,# /"7"!%!%'",$/ 00"'."#!/"& %#,#",# !"# ?

,# 6> = > :

) ? /" & <" = & $$"7!"# 6> !/%& 3,! +%#" ,#", # !"# ) "&30! '!0>8 ,#", # !"# ? #"$0 ,%'.!/"7"!%!%'", & < 5,6>!/" ,#= &&"! &%#" '#!/"$ &" = &,"

",,"#6 $2!!/" ,#=%!/!/"#%,"$!%'! &$",! %'!/"6 &%&' =/%$/!/"# !" 6%,!/$",!% %$ !" !/"7"!%!%'",= &%&&3"# '&"A3"'!0>8 6!/ !/" 7"!%!%'", & ="00 & ,"&7'#"'! 77" ,"# 6"

," !/" ,#8 =/ !", ,"$,#%'. !/"%, ,"&7"$!%+" "+%#"'$" '# #3" #"0%6", !%'& ' * ,"%!", !"# %!& &! '# !/ ! !/" 7"!%!%'", = & < 5, ' !/" # !" !/" 00"."# %'$%#"'! ! %& !/%& ,#", !/ ! !/" 7"!%!%'",/ &0 %#$/ 00"'."6>= > !/%&,"+%&%'7"!%!%'

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

,"8/", # !" 6%,!/ & ;;

/ &=,'.0> '#%00". 00>6""'$'&%#","#6>!/"

,# '!/"!/",/ '#80" ,'"#$3'&"0 ,!/"-! !" '#,"&7'#"'! 8 77&%'. !/" 6+" $'!"'!%' 0" ,'"# $3'&"0 , !/" 7"!%!%'",8 $'!"'#&!/ !!/"# !" >3'.",&%&!", !/"7"!%!%'",<"'!%'"#%' !/"< !,%$30 !%'$",!% %$ !"%&%'$,,"$!6"%'. &36&"A3"'!"+"'!%' &<3$/ &!/"& <"= &%&&3"# !",!/"# !" $$3,,"'$"/","

,"8!/" ,# / & ,%./!0> %.',"# !/" & <" '&%#",%'. !/" # !" &%&!", !/" 7"!%!%'",8=/%$/= &.!,"$,#"#6>".%&!, ,

%,!/& '# " !/&8=%!/%' =""2 /",6%,!/%'!/">" , ;;

8%& <," 3!/"'!%$#$3<"'!/" ,# / & ,%./!0> #%&$ ,#"# !/" # !" !/" 7"!%!%'", & ? ;;:8 #"$0 ,"#6>!/" 0$20"<"'! ,>#3$ !%'

%$",8 ", 6 &&%8 &!/"& <" = &'!6 &"#' '> 3!/"'!%$7, 8, !/",= &<"'!%'"#'!/"6 &%&

%# +%! !/", !/"7"!%!%'", +%'. .%+"' !/3./!

30 $'&%#", !%' ! !/" &36<%&&%' < #" 6> $3'&"0 , 6!/ !/" &%#"&8 !/%& $3,! %'#& !/ ! !/" %'&! '! 7"!%!%' %& $<70"!"0>#"+%# '><",%!/" ,#/ &,%./!0>#"$0 ,"#!/"7"!%!%'",

: &< 5,%'!/" 6&"'$" '> 3!/"'!%$#$3<"'! /%&# !" 6%,!//" 7"!%!%'", = '!& ! ! 2" #+ '! ." /%& 6"%'. 53+"'%0" ' !/" 6 &%& "+%#"'$"=/%$/%&0% 60"!6"#%&$ ,#"#6"%'.8$'!, ,>!!/"6%,!/$",!% %$ !" /%& >3'.", &%&!",8 %&&3"# 6> ".%&!, ,

%,!/& '# " !/&8 ", 6 &&%8 =/","%' /", # !" 6%,!/ %& &/=' & ;;

/" 6+" #$3<"'! %& 3!/"'!%$ '" . %'&! =/%$/ ' ,"63!! 0 "+%#"'$" / & 6""' 0"# 6> !/" 7"!%!%'",8 "@$"7! /", < !,%$30 !%' $",!% %$ !" &/=%'. /", # !" 6%,!/ &

;;)/","%& . 7 !/,"">" ,&%'6"!=""'!/"# !" 7"!%!%'", <"'!%'"# %' /", # !" 6%,!/ $",!% %$ !" '# !/" < !,%$30 !%' $",!% %$ !" ' !/"&" 7"$30% , $%,$3<&! '$"&8 %! = & %'$3<6"'! 37' !/" 7"!%!%'", ! "@70 %' , $0 ,% > & ! /= !/" & %# #%

","'$" ." = & $<%'. /" $! $ ''! 6" 0&! &%./! !/ ! &<"!%<"& ! !/" !%<" #<%&&%' $/%0# %' &$/08 /%& # !" 6%,!/ %' !/" ,3, 0 ," %& .! <"'!%'"# 6> 77,@%< !%' ' !/" %'&! '! $ &"8 % !/" 6%,!/ $",!% %$ !" >3'.", &%&!", !/" 7"!%!%'", =30# / +" 6""' 7,#3$"# ! !/" !%<" #<%&&%'%'!/"&$/08%'!/ !"+"'!3 0%!>8!/"&$/0 3!/,%!><3&!/ +" &/=' /", "@ $! # !" 6%,!/ & ;;

%'&!" # ;;) /","

,"8%!$ '& "0>6"& %#!/ !!/"# !" >3'.",&%&!", 7"!%!%'",<"'!%'"#%'!/"< !,%$30 !%'$",!% %$ !"/ &,%./!0>6""'%.',"# 6>!/" ,#,"0>%'.37'!/"# !" 6%,!/"'!","#6>!/"".%&!, ,

%,!/& '# " !/&8 ", 6 &&% / ! 7 ,!8 73,&3 '! ! !/" #%,"$!%'& !/%& 3,!8 !/" - 8

", 6 &&% $/"$2"# !/" "'!%," 6%,!/ '# #" !/ ,"$,# !/" 7 ,"'! 0 '# < !",' 0+%00 ."& !/"7"!%!%'", '# 3'#'"'!,>A3 !/"# !" !/" 7"!%!%'", /","

,"8 !/" $",!% %$ !" ''"@3," %&&3"# 6> 0$2

? 0"<"'! ,> #3$ !%'

%$",8 ", 6 &&%8 &/=%'. !/" # !" !/" 7"!%!%'", & ? ;;: =%!/3! '> $,,6, !%+" "+%#"'$"8 6 &"# ' ' $."'! '# $'+%'$%'. "+%#"'$" / & ! 6" %.',"# '# / & ,%./!0> 6""' #%&$ ,#"#6>!/" ,# /"7"!%!%'",%&8 #<%!!"#0>8"0#",!/%&&%&!", '7,""!1 3,8 =// #6,'%' ;;

/","

,"8/%&# !" 6%,!/ & ? ;;:%&7 !"'!0>

0&"8%00". 00>$0 %<"#6>/%<!! 2"6"'"

%! /%&53+"'%0%!> !!/"!%<"

%' 0 #53#%$ !%' !/"!,% 0 &&% %$ !%'!"&!%&'! 7", "$!7, &$",! %'%'.!/" ." 7",&'/"> 0= >&&/=!/" ." 7",&'6> 77,@%< !%'/","

,"8 !/" 77,@%< !" ."<"'!%'"#%'6!/!/"&&% %$ !%',"7,!&%&0% 60"!6" %.',"#8%'+%"= #"

%'%!"7, ,". ,#%'.!/"6%,!/ !/"7"!%!%'",86"%'. "0#",!/",&%&!", /" 7"!%!%'", / & '! $<" ,= ,# '# / & '! 6,3./! ' ,"$,#/%& $!3 0# !" 6%,!/%'!"'!%' 00>,#"0%6", !"0>/"# !" 6%,!/ ,"0%"#37'6>!/"7"!%!%'",%&6 &"#' 77,@%< !%'=%!/3! '>$."'! '#$'+%'$%'."+%#"'$"/" $!& '#$%,$3<&! '$"&

! "# $%%#&'()*+),!

-./+,"0%"#37'6>!/" 7"!%!%'", ,"'!%#"'!%$ 0!!/"'"%'!/"7,"&"'!$ &"8%' &<3$/ &%'!/" & %# $ &"8 !/" 7"!%!%'", / # 6,3./! ' ,"$,# *!/ &! '# ,# $",!% %$ !"8 =/"," &%'!/" %'&! '!$ &"8!/"7"!%!%'",/ &'!6,3./! ',"$,#&3$/ $",!% %$ !"8, !/",/ #&36<%!!"# $",!% %$ !"%&&3"#6>!/" 0$20"<"'! ,> #3$ !%'

%$",8 ", 6 &&%8'0>$",!% >%'.!/"# !" !/"7"!%!%'", /" & <" $ ''! 6" "A3 !"# =%!/ !/" $",!% %$ !" , #"! %0"# < ,2 &/""! %&&3"# 6> ,# , -$/0 /","

,"8 !/" 6"'"

%! !/" & %# 3!/,%!> $ ''!6""@!"'#"#!!/"7"!%!%'", ,< '> '.0"%'+%"= !/" 3!/"'!%$

) 7, !/" # !" !/" >3'.", &%&!", !/" 7"!%!%'", 6,3./! ' ,"$,# '+%"= 6+"#%&$3&&%'8!/","+%&%'%&#%&<%&&"#/"!,% 0 3,!%&#%,"$!"#!7,$""#=%!/!/"!,% 0%' $$,# '$"=%!/0 =!," !%'.!/" 7"!%!%'", &< 5, 0 -1*2)*+3 &/= , 4#%#!5#6

78!#& #9:;#8 & 4#%#!!#5&!%<-#:;#8 &