High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/33212/2021allowed

Naresh @ Guji And Another v. Advocate General Punjab

2021-11-12Mr. Justice Anoop Chitkara5 pages

!"" #$ % &'' !"" # () *+'# # $( """$'$' , * -$#$%* +#. /0 $

! 12 " -

3 $! 4(55# 6#78

&#$% $(0$'$' "# 0-' 5(3(#'

#8 8* +#." 9999

38" " #$ 7'&-$#$' -&$' : ";" '

'' 4 '$# <<<=> % '# #7

8:> ?-&$' ; #

*.@* $7AB (0$'$' 8#00 ( ' 5#

$' $(&#0$' #.

8&#4*0 .% $(' $* -&$' :

"8C' 5# $'&'0#$ A.#'7" " # #%$(.#'7#007'&#$' 8$(0$'$' &7# (# ' 5 & '4' #7 ('$ A" 2 * 7 % $( .#'7 0$'$' $#$ ' $ *&$' $(#$ $( (# & '4' #70#$ 7#$' 5$$(%% &0 & '.' 5 $ &% A# # 4 6( & '&$' 8$( $ &'40 6#4 $(# $( A# "($#$* 0 $#7 $4 $' # A& '4' #70#$%$( " '%7A8 $( #775#$' #5#' $ $( 0$'$' # $(#$ $( &407#' # $ #775 $(#$ $( '5($%";"#$"048(6 $$#&(6C%(' 7&#7'$A"(0$'$' #7 56'$($( 6 07#A' 5&#

# (#7 $# $ 07#A' 5&#

6'$($(4" $(4# $'48# 5*4 $$C07#&.$6 ('4# *+'# $( " $('8$(#&&* $# $ #.*' 5#$('4"%$ $(#$ (7%$$('

&40# A# $# $ $* ' 5(4"D( (6# # ('(4 $( 4%$(#&&* #' # $# $ 5*' 56'$(('4"

(A5# ('47#0# #' (*# & A" $(4# $'48,'

C#7'# 7' $C*$C '%# 5# #.768.*$C '%('$ '5($('0%('%#$( 6((# &4$# ('4"%$ $(#$8$(#&&* # #6#A$( #$ ' 5('4%

& @* &" " * 7 % $( 0$'$' & $ $(#$ $( &*$ '#7 '

$'5#$' 6*7

0* 06(#$ ' &# #$' .% $(0 %%5*'7$ 6*7 &#*5 ' +*$'&$$(0$'$' # %#4'7A"2# &* 7%* 5* $(#$$(' +* A6# $#$$ '.*$ $$(0$'$' =" D('700' 5$(.#'78$(#7$ #$'

& $ $' .(#7%%$(-$#$' $(#$'%$(' $'' &7' $5 # $.#'78*&(#.

4*$.*.+&$$ A $ ' 5 $& '$' " ! >" .#C(-' 5(-'..'# -$#$%* +#.8E:?B-

=>=8?# #B8#

$'$*$' #7 &(%-*0 4 $(7 $(#$$(.#'7 &'' 4*$ $ $( &*4*7#$'

%%&$%$( '$A%&'

&*4$# &+*$'%A' 5$(5 # $ %*#7% .#'7" 3#7A# (#

#-# C# #+(# +# )#00*# 8=?B-

8 ?# # :B # $( 44. &( % -*0 4 $ (7 $(#$ $( 0 % .#'7#.7 %% & # $'$7 $ .#'7 '% $( $ & & & &7* $(#$$(0 &*$' (#%#'7 $$#.7'(#0 '4#%#&'&##5#' $ ('48 0'$$(F'$ &%#0 '4#%#&'&#8$( $ &

# % '$ #$'%#&$' % $( $ 7# *&( 0 .#'78 ' $( 5'

%#&$ '$*#$' "( +&$' %.#'7 $0 &7* %'7' 5#*.@* $#007'&#$' " ( &* $ &# 7# .#'78 0

$( &'

&*4$# & $( 0 #'7' 5

8# #&(# 5' $(%#&$'$*#$' " -$#$%#+#$(# #7&(# 8 E;;- ;8?# #GB8-*0 4 $ $'&#.7A'77*$ #$ $(#$$(.#'&

*7 4'5($ 0 (#0 . $ 7A 0*$ # .#'78 $ +#'78 F&0$ 6( $( # &'

&*4$# &*55$'

%%7' 5% 4+*$'& $(6# $' 5$(&* %+*$'&

& #$' 5 $( $ *.7 ' $( (#0 % 0#$' 5 %% & ' $'4'

#$' 5 6'$ # $(7'C.A$(0$'$' 6(C 7# 54 $ .#'7% 4$(

$"$'$ *$(#$$(5 '$A%$(%% &'

'7'C7A $'

*&$( $ # $( &* % +*$'& # 4*$ 6'5( 6( & '

' 5 $( @*$' %+#'7"-#78$((' * %$(& '4" 'C# $'# #'4(*7* *.7'& &*$ 8 ?E;:B -

8 ?# # >B8 -*0 4 $ (7 $(#$ $(

7'&#$7'5($%$(7#6%#

7#* 7&* $ .A$( 5#$'

& '$ '# &'$#$' 5 $(#$ &* " #(7# -' 5( (#$' 8 7('8 ?B -

:8-*0 4 $('5(7'5($ %$(%#&$ % .#'7$.$(0*.7'& $( -$#$1 '44 ' $ $ # '4'7# & '

#$' " #$# #4 -' 5( -$#$% $$# (8?:B-

8?# #>B8-*0 4 $(7 $(#$$(

# $ %*#7%.#'7' $'

7A6'$(' $( '& $' %$(+* 5(# ' 5$( 4#$$ $(*5($(#$ '& $' '* %$$ 8'$4*$.F &' +* '&'*7A8 &40#' #$7A8# ' #(*4# 4# "78& '$' % $(5 # $%.#'7 *5($ $$.$ '&$#$.' &#0#.7%&407'# &8$( .A4#C' 5$( # $%.#'7'77* A" ;" (0'.'7'$A%$(#&&* ' %7* &' 5$('

$'5#$' 8$#40 ' 56'$( &8 ' $'4'

#$' 5 6'$ 8 # $( 7'C7'( % %7' 5 +*$'&8 &# . $#C &# % .A '40' 5 7#.

#$'

# $ ' 5 $ & '$' " -*('7# 55# 6#78?B=-

8# #E8$( $'$*$' #7 &((7 $(#$* **#77A8 *.+&$$$( &0

*& 8$( $&# '40 $ '&$'

& '$' " -*4'$($# "-$#$%"

""%7('8?B=-

=;8# #8-*0 4

$(7 $(#$6('7F &'' 506

-&$' :%$(

8$( $ ' *$A.* $ $ 'C # .#7# & .$6 $( '

*#71 '5($ $ 0 #7 % 4 # '5($ % '

$'5#$' % $( 07'&" D('7 F &'' 5 *$4$

$ #' $8$( $&# '40& '$' &* $ # &' 5'$.+&$#0 4''.7 $(7#6$ * # * ' $

*0$ * (#40 $'5#$' " :" 7$(*5( $( & *&$ % $( #&&* ' ('5(7A 07 #.7 # ' * #&&0$#.7.A# A&'

'7'H &'$A8(6 8 ' +* A6##$$ '.*$ $$( E" (' $%7$(#$ 00 $* '$A.#%%

$$(0$'$' $&* &

&$# .(# ' #&'

'7'H 4# " $( #$* % #775#$' 8 0 $ '#7 ' &# #$' ' D'$(*$&44 $' 5 $(&#14 '$# $(&'

&*4$# &0&*7'# $$(' &#8$(0$'$' 4#C#&#% 7# .#'78*.+&$$$(%776' 5$ 4 & '$' 86('&((#77. #.

0&$'

%$(& $ $% $(% 4%.#'7.

' &(#0$ III%

"8E;" " ( 0$'$' (#77 . 7# .#'7 ' $( 4 $' #.

*.+&$$%* '(' 5#0 %" $(*# ?8<B8# 6'$( * $A%"6 $A%'

$(*# ?=8<B8$$(#$'%#&$' % $( $'5#$ " % #&&0$' 5 $( * $A8 $($$$' 5 4*$ #$'%A $(#$' &#$(#&&* %#'7$#00# ' $8$( *&(* $'# &#0#.7$

*&$(#&&* .% $( $8C0' 5' 4'

$(* '0 &.('

$(* $'86('&('$&* $(0 &%$(#&&* " " ( %* '(' 5 % $( 0 #7 .

(#77 . 4 #&&0$# & % $( %776' 5# #77$( $'0*7#$' 8$ 48# & '$' %$('.#'7

" (0$'$' $F&*$#.

% #$$ # &' $(& & $?B"

&$($ '#7.5' 8 $(0$'$' (#77 $8' # A 4# 8$ A$ 7#A$( & ' 58# * $#C$#00# .% $(& & $# $#$$

$($ '#7 #&( #$8* 7F40$ " &#%# #00#78 $(' A.

8 $(0$'$' #70 4'$#00# .% $(('5( $' $ 4%-&$' ;

" (#$$$' 5%%'& (#778 $( 0#5%0 84 $' $( 0 4# $ #

% $( 0$'$' #7 5 6'$( $( 0( *4. ?B8 D(#$00 *4. ?'% # AB8 4#'7 ?'% # AB8 # $#'7 % 0 #7 .# C #&&* $?B ?'% # #'7#.7B8 # ' &# % # A &(# 58 $( 0$'$' (#77 '44 '#$7A# $7#$ $(# #A% 4*&(4 '%'&#$' 8' $'4#$#.*$$( &(# 5 % '

$'#7 #

8 0( *4. 8 D(#$00 *4. 8 4#'7 #&&* $8$$(7'&-$#$' %$('$$(& & $" =" ( 0$'$' (#77 +' $( '

$'5#$' # # 6( &#77 .A $( $'5#$' 5 # A -*0 J # (#77 &0 #$ 6'$( $( $'5#$' #$#77%* $#5#4#A. " $( $%%#'7* $ 8'$6'77.0 % $(0 &*$' $C&# &77#$' %$(.#'7"D( $('

$'5#$' &&* 6'$(' $(07'&0 4'8$( 0$'$' (#77 $. &#77 .% :# (#77.7$%%.% =8# (#77 $.*.+&$ $ $('

5 8'

& $7# 5*#58' (*4# $ #$4 $8$&" >" ( 0$'$' (#77 $ ' %7* &8 .

6.#$8 0 * 'H8 4#C # A *&4 $8$( #$8 0 4'8 &$7A &$7A8$$(6'$ 8$(7'& %%'&'#78 # A$( #&@*#' $ 6'$($(%#&$# $(&'

&*4$# &% $(&#8$ '*# $(4% 4 '&7' 5*&(%#&$$$(7'&8 $( $8

$$#40 6'$($( &" ;" $(5 '$A%#&&*#$' # $((' * #$* %$(%% &8$( (#77*

#776#0 8%'

# 48#44* '$' 8'%# A8#7 56'$( $(# 47'& $$(& & #*$( '$A6'$(' #A% 4$ #A# ' % 4 $( $'5#$ #.*$$(&407'# &"6 8*.+&$$$( '# 4&$8 E=E8$(0$'$' (#77. $'$7 $ 6# $#C'$.#&C' &#%#&@*'$$#7 ' $('&#" :" (0$'$' (#778* &'

&*4$# &8& $#&$8&#778$F$8 4# C8 $#7C8 $# 8 4#C # A 5$* 8 (6 F0 # A * **#7 ' #00 '#$8

.#7 6' .+&$' #.7 .(# 8 $ ' % $ % $( '&$'48 '$( 0(A'&#77A $( *5( # A $( 4 #4 # '&$'41 (48 # (#77#7$#A#6#A% 4$( '&$'4# ( (*" E" * ' 5$($ '#710 &A8'%$(0$'$' 0#$ &44'$# A%% & 6( $( $ &0 & '. '4 $(# A# '7#$# A& '$' #$'0*7#$ ' $('

8'$(#77#76#A.0 4''.7$$( 0 $$#007A % &# &77#$' %$('.#'7"$(#77%* .0 % # A'

$'5#$' 5#5 &A $.

' 5'$$$( $'&%$( $'H %$(*.@* $#007'&#$' $(#$$(

6## 7' &#*$' $$'

*75' & '4' #7#&$'

'$'" 6'8$( .#'7.

(#77& $' *$ 4#' ' % &$( *5(*$$($ '#7# #%$ $(#$' $ 4%-&$' ;%$(

" A

&#$ % $( 0$'$' # ' 6( 0 & $( 0*$'5 #$* 0 (#77F07#' #77& '$' %$(' .#'7

8' #&*7# '% $%#'.78' '

'" " &#$(0$'$' %'

$(.#'7& '$' ?B# '7#$' 5%* #4 $#78 (*4# 8 '5($8 &#*' 5 '%%'&*7$A * $ # A '$*#$' 8 $( % '%'&#$' % *&( $ 4?B8 $( 0$'$' 4#A %'7 # # #007'&#$' .% $(' $8 # #%$ $#C' 5 &5 'H# &8 $ $( $ $#C' 5 &5 'H# & $($ '#7 $8#$(&#4#A.8# *&( $(#77#7. &40$ $$4 '%A 7$# A& '$' " " ('

$8' # A4# 87'4'$ $ '&$$( '5($%$(7'&

$('

$'5#$' 5#5 &A% 4%* $'5#$' 0 7#6" " A.

#$' 4# ( ' #.

' '$( # F0 ' %0' ' $(4 '$%$(&#8 (#77$($ '#7 $#

$$$(&44 $" " $* % $(0 $&$' % 4' &# #$' 8$( $.7' $(#$$( (#77#7 &'0 &#$$( *5( '

#.7.(# ="

$'$' #776

"" # +* # ' D($( 0#C' 5< # < D($( 0 $#.7 <