High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10103/2015dismissed

Rajinder Kumar v. Financial Commissioner & Secretary To Govt. Of Punjab & ANR

2017-09-29Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan4 pages

!""#$%$&'(()

*$&+",-./ , "!$!$&", 1",%.%

$& &#$ 2//$%%$&",3"#,"! ,4 !5! .&* 6 &!7", "%8&+"&!%

,"%"&!'0

,3 9, :+5# !",!7"8"!$!$&",

, 37 ;2 :: .&* 6 <<< 7 22"&9" $& !7" $&%! &! 8"!$!$& $% ! !7" ,+", + !"+ = &&">.," 0:8 %%"+64!7" $& &#$ 2//$%%$&",! 5! .&* 6:"8 ,!/"&! ,"%! &+$2+2$" ,"%",5 !$& &+$& !",/%;7$#7!7"#2 $/!7"8"!$!$&",%""?$&98,/!$&!!7"8%! "8.!4$,"#!, %! 62$%7/"&!0#./0##.&!%:7 %6""&+"#2$&"+ ,$" #!%!7 !/ 46"&!$#"+ ,"!7 !!7"8"!$!$&",*$&"+!7" ,"%8&+"&! ,"%!"8 ,!/"&!:3! !" .&* 6 %2",?$&!7"4" ,())

"!$!$&",:!7"," !",:" ,&"+8,/!$&%!!7"8%!3"&$,%%$%! &!$& !7"4" ,(@): %3.8",$&!"&+"&!, +"0$&!7"4" , &+!7"," !", % +/$&$%!, !$5" $#",& !%!, &%8$,"%!7 ! 8%!"8.!4$,"#!, #./0##.&!%$&!7"8 4%# 2" %: 0 :A0; %#," !"+$&!7"

,"%!"8 ,!/"&!.&+",!7"%%$%!"+ .&* 6,"%! !$& ,*"#!$& !7"4" , 8&!7"#," !$&%.#78%!.&+",!7"8,*"#! ,"0 &!$#"+:&"37-B 27!, :;7; % 2," +4;,?$&9$&!7""8 ,!/"&! %%! 62$%7/"&!0#./0##.&!% $#",:; %+"824"+ 9 $&%!%.#78%!

00 37 -B 27!, ,"!$,"+ & .8& !! $&$&9 !7" 9" %.8", &&. !$& !$%.8&,"!$,"/"&!37-B 27!, !7 !!7"8"!$!$&", %! ?"+ 7$% #2 $/ ! 6" 8,/!"+ ! !7" 8%! "8.!4 $,"#!,

%! 62$%7/"&!0#./0##.&!% "!$!$&"," ,2$", 88, #7"+!7$%.,!$& !",/%$2$&9 @== &+;7$#7; %+$%8%"+64 ,+$& !""&#7!7$%.,!$&!7"2$97!!7",+",+ !"+(=: ;7","$&+$,"#!$&%;","$%%."+!#&%$+",7$%#2 $/ &+!! ?" $& 2 +"#$%$&& 2"9 2&!$#"!7 !7 +6""&%",5"+ !$%$&8.,8,!"+#/82$ &#"!7"+$,"#!$&%$%%."+64!7$% .,!!7 !!7"$/8.9&"+,+",+ !"+= &&">.," 07 %6""& 8 %%"+ .&%"2,!7"8 ,!$"%7 5"6""&7" ,+ !2"&9!7 ! 7 % 9&" .&#&!,5",!"+ !7 ! " ,2$", !7" .&* 6 ,"%!

,.8 $&$%!",$ 23",5$#" .2"%:=;","$&8", !$&7",.8 8%!% ;7$#7 ;"," #5","+ .&+", %.#7 %! !.!,4 ,.2"% ;"," +"$&"+ $& 88"&+$>CC 7"8%!$&D."%!$&$""8.!4$,"#!, #./0##.&!%; %&!#5","+.&+",!7"= .2"% !",!7"%%$%!"+ .&* 6,"%! !$& ,*"#!#2%"+ &@!7"">",#$%","%!,.#!.,$&9!7" ,"%!"8 ,!/"&!; % .&+",! ?"& 8& 88,5 264!7".&#$2 $&$%!",% &!$$# !$&; % $%%."+& &+$!$%,!7"$,%!!$/"!7 !!;8%!%"8.!4 $,"#!,:+/$&$%!, !$&A 2 &&$&9 &+.+9"!A##.&!%;","#," !"+7"

.&* 6 ,"%! ,.8 $&$%!",$ 23",5$#" .2"%:E7 5" 2%6""& 8,/.29 !"+ &+ $& ;7$#7 !7" 8%! "8.!4 $,"#!,: +/$&$%!, !$&A 2 &&$&9 &+.+9"!A##.&!%$%,"2"#!"+$&88"&+$>CC

00 2 $/ !7" 8"!$!$&", $% .&+"+ & !7" 8,"/$%" !7 ! & 9"&+ ,72+$&9 !#&%$+",!7"& /"!7"8"!$!$&",, 8,/!$&!!7"8%!"8.!4$,"#!, %! 62$%7/"&!0#./0##.&!% 7 + 6""& #$,#.2 !"+ & ) $!%"2 .8& ,"!$,"/"&! 37 -B

27!, :4"!:&8,/!$&,.#!$$"+$&8.,%. &#"!%.#7 9"&+ 7 5$&9 6""&#$,#.2 !"+ !;.2+,"D.$,"&!$#"!7 ! !!7","2"5 &!8$&!!$/"$"$& !7"4" ,;7"&!7"8"!$!$&",$%%! ?$&97$%#2 $/!!7"8%!"8.!4 $,"#!, %! 62$%7/"&!0#./0##.&!%!7","; %&%.#7# +,"8%!$& ">$%!"&#"7"8%!$& #!# /"$&!#," !$&&245$+"&!$$# !$&+ !"+ 5"& !7",;$%": 9 $&%! !7" 8%! "8.!4 $,"#!,

%! 62$%7/"&!0#./0##.&!%.&+",!7" ,"0&!$#"+8,*"#!:37-B

27!, ;7$2";,?$&9 %%! 62$%7/"&!0#./0##.&!% $#",7 +&! 6""&8,/!"+$&8.,%. &#"! &4,"9.2 , 8,#""+$&9%6.!$& #!

7 +&246""&+"824"+7$%$%8,"#$%"24,!7"," %&!7 !!7","; %& # +,"8%!"8.!4$,"#!, %! 62$%7/"&!0#./0##.&!%$&">$%!"&#"

$&!7"+"8 ,!/"&!5"&!7"+"824/"&!37-B 27!, %"8.!4 $,"#!, %! 62$%7/"&!0#./0##.&!%; %&!7"#&+$!$&!7 !7";$22 #&!$&."&!7"8%!!$22!7"8,*"#!%.,5$5"% &+!7 !7";.2+,"! $&7$% 2$"& & !7"8%! !7 ! 7"; % ;,?$&9 $" %! 62$%7/"&!0#./0##.&!% $#", &+.8&!7"8,*"#!6"$&9!",/$& !"+,!7"8%!$!%"2#" %$&9! ">$%!:7";.2+ .!/ !$# 224##.84!7",$9$& 28%!%! 62$%7/"&!0 #./0##.&!% $#",

0=0

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

"!$!$&: ##,+$&924:$%+$%/$%%"+

2.#?4 7"!7",%8" ?$&9A," %&"+'

"%A 7"!7", "8,! 62"'

"%A