High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10809/2014disposed of

Executive Officer Cum Secretary,M.C. Sirsa & ANR. v. Permanent Lok Adalat Sirsa & ANR.

2016-02-01Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain11 pages

#$!%$&##' (# # "#! #% )*+, (# -. !"#$ %&'()!*+,-.) "/)+0-%1"( #

##*(/ 0+" #-(,0+" ###.& 1(0+"0 #&& 1(0+" ##2&30+"0

#(. # #2&&(!0+"0 ##.

450

5 #!

(6(,0+"0 ##.

5 #+%+11#7,0+"0 ##. 8 0880885085 8085 08550 85 085408 80 0 550 5 #9(!1(0+"0 ##.

08 0880885085 8085 0 85 08 80 550 ##. 5 ##. 5 854 5 #2!#"& 1,0+" # #& /"2!.0+"0 ##.

450

"/)+0-%1"(2 :(##7,,.

0 0855085 0

450

08 0 880885085 8085 085408 80 0 550 50 %% ;! ,7 # ","(#

<# " 0( #= 1* #%

8 (,, 1 (7#. (7# 4 8

. =' ( #% )* +, !=, >,' &#"0 &# (# #=# ##?()*+,?0,,7 1(. ,='

#. -. (# 7,,, 80%!# ?

@! 72# #*02,* 2(!#(.0#&#0",,% ##-1 85 4

#,, # 0 0 A$0= ((1(=# ! , 5B (=% ' 05 A$ 7=.( ,, ((%%#+.#(#% ,#0(,,7.'(=, 45B (%!

(#7(

8 ' #%( # (, '#,' 7( # C 5B .#

!% &% ( 7# . ='

#. 0 (7"#0 ,# ( .. :( . # ! "#!% #.'% (=, ,,% % ', 7( # + , % 7 , # !

:(%7(,, 1='#. = #( )*+,D%.!1 7# 4 80(,% #.

7,,7:(7#(= %.!1 (.# . 5 (#

. 0(!1((7#.='( )*+,7#

# =!(.., = #()*+, (,1,!7(%

)# !

, # ( . # !=% ( # #. 7 ! !, ( ! 0 ,,% ,# 4

7! ( "!# #% 7(( #/! 1(= % '.(% ! 0=, 405405 A$7. 7( 8 ' #%( ! ,## (,

'#,' 7( # C 5B .#

!% :( , , # 7 0 0 A$ ,!# .' ( 0 ,. , #CB%.!

(, '#,'7,(#1=, !, .'% 7!" 0(., ( =!, 10 ' #!(# 0!,=#!% .,7=

#7( 8 ' #%( ! ,# #.#" 1= ,:( 7=%., 7( .# 7'# #%(

# .,0

8 7((!,= # !#(#.# (#'# .'%

.##= :(. (.,7

##. " %%!

4 4 =! ( ,, , * . " .1# !#(#..#!

01, ..#!

71# .(! 1! %., # . 1 ( $ "%% 8 =! ( ,, ,.(#% 1,,% .#7( #

$ -. , . = # ( )* +, 4 :(,, ( ( ( ,.'(#% E #.,'(. ,= #()*+,0.#,% #'

=/ 7* #1# 1/!# #% &

$+ )1,&#"+!(#'+0

4 #(#0?(+?E7!=% (()*+, ("(/!# (. #7 "#> #(!

/=+1#!,!#,#!#*+0

0" /!# (",!#=##

+ #(%# (# # 07!=% (=% (",#'= .#" ,' 7# *7 = #! 7,#'.# ,:(,, .'

" (.# .,%!

( 07(,* #(# :('(.!#((.,7(. ':('7#=!

.'( E !..# (.,0#, 7.,!. /!1%

3 ?=, ( &!.#% !#

--",

0 !

" +E- & 8 0 #

$ %

5 --",4

( (# ( 0 ,# !

, # #. !=%(# #"("= .#" &

$+ +37"#0 !#(#%.7#(2"# % '(##" ='! 1( :(2"# % 3#' !

1(?3! ?0 (#""# !

$+ (+0( 0,%((. # "#!

#(.#" (+,,'% "3#,

!. ##.='(!# )+8 & % '

( )## "

% & "

0 4 %#0,# !

, ##. !=%( .#(#% ,#0(. 7=

# ,'

#(=% 7#.#":(;! 7((#= % (= .#"# 3# ##(% 7#7(#

..# "#!,# ( 1=7 (#*%% # (6#07=,(((=% !( 7#07#1 #( = .#" (

,,% ,#,#,'.#"((,=,'.' #7!,# ,' #

# (,,7

% !, ,,% .#$ ,7 ,#0 7

# (' ,73 0(,,7,,

=,=,.' ' # ( 37"#0( .!( ((,,7#,=,.'(=%!

., ( #(# #%(( =%! )# !

, ##. !#(#!=%( (. (.,!, =

#,1,,'(,, (= (",.% 7#* (#0( ## 7( 7'#!, =..,3 0" ( = 1(#17#1(,'='()*+, :(# ### (##.:(%#"=!.(,E

!..# (#1!% 0#, 7.,!. /!1% 3 ?=,( &!.#% !# !

!% ' *

",!#44 & 3 !#(#!=%(" 7(=% # ",=, ,' (. (= #!E (= % 0( ,,("=,*(#(## % ':('!, " ##'

(#=! #. ( #=',# !

, #( ,,0,# !

, #(. #!=%(" ,,(

5 % 7# ",=, 7( ( . 7

# ( ,,0(%7# (.# = 1",. .# # #'" (,,7!,("* %% # 8 3#,# !

, #(.# .#!(..# =* :(, ., . ! 72#

#*2,* 02(!#(.0#&#0 7(( (,,7#! !,=#7 .!:(#," #% ,## #=,7 F :(!% - 5 A$.=''! 5B ,,% .#A= (.,(= /!

'!#.,!

G!##;!#%!%

-4545 A$ !

=, 45B (.#

(.,(#7(! #7( 8 ' #%( ! (,## (, '#,' 7(5B ##!(# #%'= . ='(6# #%%%E #

7,, #! #% (

. % (#!

+ , + # '

# - ./0 + + #

48 485 8

854

5 E ,!#.( % . , #CB+ =%.!

'#,' (,, = (#1 ( #%, # E !, 7 !" 0(., (=!, 10 #!0 (,, = #!% =' ( #* %% # 1" ..#!

' = 1(#'!

4 :(. (.,(,,=

#'!

7( 8 ' #%( ! ,# .#" ( % %!% = , -0#&!..,'0&7#1 ,#

# (= ,# 10( #.#" 1(= ,

8 :( ,, (,, #! ( =!, 1 .# ..#"1 7( .# 7'# #%(

# (.,07((%'= !#(#='(#*%%0&#!. % %!%.# (#'# .'%

- 0 A$0 - 50 A$ -

0 A$ # ( #0 (# '#

0 #.",' E ( " !( #!%. 0(#*%%(,,! B (.# (., 5B # =, "#! #@ 5 :("#!#% 0 #1(# 7!,,( ,! ( #. 1 5B (=% ' ( ,, (%%#0(=, !,(#=.7(! #7(

8 ' (! ,## (, '#,' 7( #C5B.#

!%:( # 7#!

#%(

# :(,,% ,#. ( %!

.# ., ( ##!(# :( ,!% . ,,'% ?E #C5B+

#? ,!#.( %0. , #CB.#

!%%.!

(, '#,'7(#1=,:(. (., 7=

#7( 8 ' (! ,#.#" (% %!%= ,-0#0&7#1 ,#

# ( #= ,# 1( # .#" 1( , ( ( 0 7% ( #(! 0 (. 7

#(,,",#4 7(#% #,#

4 4 :( #!#=',# !

, #(. #7 (()*+, ("(/!# ,7((.

,='(,,(#".#"='(. # "#!

#(.#" &

$+ (+:(#," .#" &

$+ (+# #=,7 -$)E:E2+:EE)E+:E+&::):

+ $ E ( (.# # ( .!#.

80 !

, ( (#7#;!#0$ H#% )*+,H% #% )* +,=,(!

#!=$

6 =H.!=,!,'#"H% '$ # .##" #(##1 . 1# #1='#0##7#0# .,0,1#.(#,.( #"I# !..,' .7#0,1(#7#(.!=, =' '=,(% I# "'% .!=, #" '# I# "#" (.,#. #'I# " !# #"0 ,! '#"7((( #,2"# % #(&2"# % 0(%'=0%'0 .!=, #0=' 0,# =.!=, !,'#" #(.!#. ((.# !=0 (#"% ( #.#" (. #%' ="#0(7"#0 !#(#.#"(( #,2"# % #(&2"# % %'=' ,# ' (# #" = .!=, !,' #" # ( .!#. ( (.#E # (.7#0(& 3#' !

1. ,,'( ,,7 1#"=(.!=, !,'#" F 3! 0 6 * < @

:("' (. #%' ,, (! 10=! 7,,# ,' ,,7( (% 1 ??(.,(= , 3 0 (()*+, ("/!# #

(. ,='(,,0,,'% " #/E !

(.(#= 1 (1"# % 0( . #(,,* ( E1 # (.# (. # =! ( ! =' ( &

= . ..# &%,# 7 ( . & % '

( )## "

2 !.#0 7(# ( 3#' >#= ",.% +!(#' ( * % :( =#" %(# # #=,7 F:( ..,, ,,' 1 #

JKK 5

0!='(3#' 2"# % 0"7((7%##"03! I 6 * < 0("= ,# =.!=,!,'#" #(.!#. (,

#"0 .#" &

+= ( + :( # 7!0&

+= +.#"(?.!=,!,'#"(,, ,! '

#" 7(( ( #, 2"# % # ( & 2"# % 0(%'=0 (.!=, #0='

0,#=!=,>,'&#" #( .!#. (+?<7((! 0,# !

, #(..,, #,' ((#"

;! "," ( ,,!

#?3! ?0(# #0( 7 .#(=/

7(#1#/!# (#% )*+, !=,>,'&#"@

+ #(%# ( #"#'# # 0 "#! ,###1(#0" (# #%((=, , # 0 #. 1 5B = (.,!,(#=.7(! #7( 8 ' #% ( ! ,# # (, '#,' 7( #C5B.#

!%:( # ( #!

#%(

# " ((!, .'% % ,#,#,'(7( #.'=, ,'

# ,!#.'( %0. , #CB.#

!%%.!

(, '#,'(#1=,

( #%, #:(. (.,=

#7( .# 8 ' #%( ! ,#.#"( % %!% = , -0 &7#1 ,# # (= ,# 10( #.#" (= ,-1# 1 (=!, 10.#" ((,,# 7( .# 7'# #%(

# (.,07((%'= !#(#!. % %!%.# (#'# .'% .##= :(. (.,7

#(. #",# 4 4:(#7#!=;! #% #

:(,,.% ( 07(#% 7# .:(,# = 1% (" =

.#" ,,(:( #% (,,( 7# .

:( 1##='()*+, (%.!1 ## #1# 1",=,' =% # #=,7 :(.# .!(# =7 (.# =!(#. (" ,%.,'7(( #% :(#. = 1,,# ., 2"# % .#% 7 %., ( . # . ( #% 1 45B %!

7( #!

#((# #!%. (.,* 7

!,,'7,,(('(" .#"(=%

( ,,' &( D(7 # !1(

#%(

(#. !

#(-:E+

5 8"(,#

0.' 7(( $ 0 ( &##'$!%$ !"

#0 #* %%0&#

#%.., D(7#

6 7#),( 2# #*0(!#(.0= % ,*7#!..,' 7#1(" =

.#":(. #7,,((#,,%" .., 0.' 7(( 0(#.

#%(%(('("7# 1,'!,#

. (" 7# 1,' #;!# (% .' ( # (#% 1, # #%(

,# :(#. * '

(#;! (. # (#:(,#0 (7"#01 (7( ( = % 7# .#"='(. #!. 5 8:(= 1 (#. ("7# 1,',,1 (#.,' ( . (('(".#"(=% :(

#% 0(,,(=% (" =

.#" #@

8 :( # 11!..#" #%%%

5 #%( !" 1 #03&+6#0&#0( &##'$!%$0#*%%0&#0 (!=/ .#" = , + / $ED0+ / ,,* + / (!#(.07(# (= ,#,'% (7#* # .#" 17#!..,'7#1 ,' 2(!#(. .#1#07((,*,'=%.,='88 5 1(#='0 7(,* (%7( (,,..#(()*+, # ##, (#1#" " K !#'0 50(= ,

7# 7#17# ",=,:(=",#7.#! =',# !

, #(. # !#(% (# 1

( # 1 # 7( 4 ,,% ,#0(,,!, =

#. (.,E

#% ,! 0 # ( =, .# #! ( ,' (. (.,

#:(7!,%

!, ,,% ( ,7 ,#

# ..#E ,,= #%,#",=, ,'(

,, # !,(.#.#' #(.!#. ( =! (#7

5 '% # ,!, ( .#" # (,# .#:(,,% ,#

% ( 7((( #=.:(,, 7## ,'=!

.'(,,% .# (! ,!# .'(% (!0('## ,',=, #.'%

# #%( 7#C5B.#

!% !#(#" ,=, .'% . , #.#" # ,!5 ,#

,# .#"( ,, (%., =!, 17( 7'# #%(

# (#7# =% ",=, ( . !, =

#0(#7 ;! ,"' 3 0(,% $ ,,'!

4 <# ( # % ="0( .# . # . 7(,(, 1((,,7#,=,.'(.# ., %!

( (!% ,# ,!#.'(%0('#,=,.' #C5B .#

!% #%(( =%!,,.'% :('

(,,,,=,.'. , #.#" ,!5 ,#37"#0(,,7,, =,=,.' #,!, % .#,!% 7((,?E #C5B+

#? :(,, (,, =,=, .' ' ,,( .#' 7'# #%((.

(.,

# #.#" 1 = , !( #07#0 7#1 ,#

:(7#. #. # 1,'

-/(6 , " K!1 - #-.##