← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16487/2012dismissed

Distt. Education Officer, Jhajjar And ANR. v. Raj Pal And Anrs.

2015-09-04Mr. Justice Darshan Singh4 pages

1  

    ! 

 !"#$ %$&'('

)* +, !'(#-'&#%.&"#'

)'&$-/ 0"11"-")% )-  $#'#'

)$-( 2$-(.( "1"3")% )-   $(4 )%$)#(  *56 7

2    -$($)#*(2'80"!0'9")/

/"-:")" -#0$4$#'#'

)$- -7")%$$47');"3/ %< &"#$ -#0$-$(4 )%$)# =====  8$-$$--$%# #0$$4 -#$-( -) #> 0$#0$-#0$1.%;9$)#(0 .3%8$-$4 -#$%')#0$!';$(#> 

2    / -"3  0'( 4$#'#'

) '( %'-$&#$% ";"')(# #0$ "?"-% %"#$% )% !$&$98$-/  4"(($% 8: #0$ )%.(#-'"3 -'8.)"3@&.9@6"8 .-  .-#/  0#"A ?0$-$8:#0$?

-A9")0"(8$$)-$')(#"#$%# ($-<'&$?'#0& )#').'#:")% ,B8"&A?";$( 0"<$0$"-%3$"-)$%& .)($3 -#0$4"-#'$(")%4$-.($%#0$4"4$-@

A

2 0$4$-'

% ($-<'&$-$)%$-$%8:#0$?

-A9")"("#$-"--'$- ?'#0#0$")";$9$)#'(- 9 #07$4#$98$-/C#  #0 $8-."-:/,

;;-'$<$% 8: #0$ #$-9')"#'

)D-$#-$)&09$)#/ #0$ ?

-A9") -"'($% ") ')%.(#-'"3%'(4.#$8:($-<');"%$9")%) #'&$ )#0$")";$9$)# ))% ":/,?'#0& 4'$(# #0$6"8 .-)(4$&# -$#&0$-$?"() %$3":') -"'(');#0$%'(4.#$ )&'3'"#'

)"'3$%")%""'3.-$-$4 -#?"((.89'##$% # #0$ <$-)9$)#& )#"')');-$"( )(?0'&03$%# #0$"'3.-$# "--'<$"# "($##3$9$)#0$"444-'"#$;

<$-)9$)#"&& -%');3:9"%$"-$$-$)&$# #0$-$('%');'&$-/6"8 .-#/ 0#"A<'%$$    "%1.%'&"#'

#0$%'(4.#$ 0$?

-A9")& 943"')$%#0"##0$4- <'('

)( 7$&#'

), )%.(#-'"3 !'(4.#$( &#/ +

  - (0 -# E#0$ &#F ?$-$ ) # & 943'$% ?'#0")%0$?"()$'#0$-($-<$%) #'&$8$ -$-$#-$)&09$)#) -?"(4"'% C%":(?";$(')3'$. ) #'&$) -"):-$#-$)&09$)#& 94$)("#'

)?"( 4"'%"##0$#'9$ #$-9')"#'

($-<'&$0$$943 :$-?"() #"4-'<"#$

-;")'G"#'

) # ?"( " %$4"-#9$)#  #0$ 7#"#$  "-:")" ")% '# ?"( $H4$&#$%# & 943:?'#0#0$(#"#.# -:9")%"#$ &# 0$6"8 .-#0"(& 9$# #0$& )&3.('

)#0"##0$?

-A9")0"( & 943$#$% %":( ($-<'&$')#0$&"3$)%"-9 )#0(4-$&$%');#0$ %"#$  #$-9')"#'

) 0$-$ & .3% 8$ )  8$##$- "%9'(('

) #0") #0$ %$4 ('#'

 @ -$9 7');0 ?0  ?"( ) )$ #0$- #0") ") '&'"3 ?'#)$((  #0$ ")";$9$)# (.99 )$% 8: #0$ ?

-A9") #  %$4 ($ # "&#(@-$97');0"%9'##$%#0"##0$?

-A9")0"%4.#') %":(

 ($-<'&$ $"%9'##$% #0"# #0$#$-9')"#' ) ?"(8- .;0# "8 .# ?'#0 .# & 943'")&$  #0$ 9")%"# -: 4- &$%.-$ ")% (#"#.# -: 4- #$&#'

)( 4- <'%$%.)%$-7$&#'

), &#0$4 (# "#$-"--'$-- 9 ?0'&0 #0$ ?

-A9") ?"( -$#-$)&0$%/ 0"( ) # 8$$) "8 3'(0$% -"#0$- )$

3 79#"3"!$<''(?

-A');"("#$-"--'$- ).33#'9$8"('()#0$"&$

 #0'( "%9'(('

)/ #0$ 1.-'(%'&#'

)"3 "&#(  ,  ")% , 0"<$ 8$$) $(#"83'(0$% )-$& -%")%#0$-$"44$"-(# 8$) <"3'%-$"( )# "&&$%$# #0$ (.89'(('

 (2'80" !0'9")/ 3$"-)$%

/ "-:")" #0"# #0$ '94.;)$%"?"-%'( )$- .(")%'() #&"33$% -(')&$#0$($-<'&$( ?

-A9")?$-$ -"'H$%#$).-$?0'&0?"(3$((#0")I:$"-(#0$ "-;.9$)# #0$3$"-)$%& .)($3 -#0$7#"#$'("&&$4#$%/#0$)'#?

.3%8$ 4.##');"4-$9'.9 )%$-$3'&#'

%.#:')#0$%$4"-#9$)## 0"<$) # & 943'$% ?'#0 #0$ 4- &$%.-$ 3"'% % ?) ') #0$ &# ) "): &"($/ ')#$-$-$)&$?'#0#0$'94.;)$%"?"-% #0$6"8 .-#'(-$(#-'&#$%# #0$ ;.'%$3')$( 3"'% % ?) ') #0$  )(#'#.#'

) $)&0 %$&'('

 #0$ 7.4-$9$ .-#')

 / + 7

?0$-$')#$-$-$)&$?

.3% )3:8$'#0$-$'(".)%"9$)#"33"? $-- - ') "443:'); #0$ 3"? - 9'("443:'); #0$ $<'%$)&$ ")% "&#( ?0'&0 (0 .3% "33 4.# # ;$#0$- "9 .)# #  ") $-- - "44"-$)# ) #0$ "&$  #0$ -$& -%')%) #0');')#0$'94.;)$%"?"-%#0"#?

.3%<'#'"#$'# -"):

#0$-$"( )("% 4#$%8:#0$6"8 .-#')& 9');# #0$& )&3.('

#0"#'#?"("'#&"($ -$')(#"#$9$)#0$6"8 .-#0"($H$-&'($%'#( %'(&-$#'

)8:-$%.&');8"&A?";$(# ,B?0'&0'((.8(#")#'"3-$3'$# #0$ 4$#'#'

)$-@")";$9$)# ")% #"A$( &"-$  #0$ "-;.9$)# -"'($% 8: (!0'9")/3$"-)$%& .)($3 -#0$4$#'#'

)$-#0"##0$?

-A9")?"( 4"-##'9$8"('(')"(&0

3?0'&00"%# &3 ($% ?)%.-');(.99$-")% ?')#$- 8-$"A( H&3.('

 4":9$)#  ("3"-: %.-'); <"&"#'

)( 4$-'

% ?"('-(#3:&"(#';"#$%8:#0$7.4-$9$ .-#') 

   + , 7 C)#0"#&"($/'#?"( 0$3% #0"# #0$ 3$&#.-$-( "44 ')#$% ) "% 0 & 8"('( ?$-$ $)#'#3$% #  #0$ 8$)$'# #0$("3"-:%.-');#0$4$-'

% <"&"#'

)(?0'&0#0$:& .3%) #

4 8$ %$4-'<$%   $('%$(/ #0$ 4-')&'43$  &"3&.3"#'

   %":(  ($-<'&$ '( ')%'&"#$% ') " 1.%;9$)#  #0$ 7.4-$9$  .-# -$)%$-$% ')        !  "# $   

  %#      !  "# $    + 7 , ")%')& 94.#'); %":(/7"#.-%":(/ 7.)%":(/4"'%0 3'%":($#&"-$# 8$')&3.%$%')#0$ %":(0$-$ -$/

) 8 #0 #0$ 4-')&'43$(  6"8 .- ")% 7$-<'&$ 6"?/ #0$ ?

-A9$) 0"<$ $9')$)#3:4.#') %":( J."3':');($-<'&$"(-$$-"83$.)%$-7$&#' ,@ &#  ?

.3%/ #0$-$ -$/ ')% )$'#0$- "): 1.-'(%'&#'

)"3 $-- - ') #0$ %$&'('

#0$6"8 .-#")%) -'('# .)%<'#'"#$%8:")$--  3"?"44"-$)# )#0$"&$ -$& -%0$')%');( #0$6"8 .-#"-$ )$'#0$-4$-<$-($) -'--"#'

)"3 ')%');( "&#-$& -%$%8:#0$6"8 .-  .-# "-$ ) # 4$) #  8$ %'(#.-8$% ') ?-'# 1.-'(%'&#'

) .)%$- -#'&3$(  D #0$ )(#'#.#'

)%'"

-#0$  -$;

'); -$"( )(/  ')%) ;- .)% 9$-'#'); ')#$-$-$)&$ ?'#0 #0$ "?"-%  #0$ 6"8 .-  .-# 0'( ?-'# 4$#'#'

) '( "&& -%');3: %'(9'(($% & '!()  !) !) * '+,-

+,  K