← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/27662/2024dismissed

Bhupender v. State Of Haryana

2024-05-28Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil15 pages

       

      

  

       

     !" 

     "

 

   

       !" #$  % &&&&&   "#

'    ()*+ +% ,-.)/ 0 %/"1    "/2345 )-.)6 ,, 060)

 ,(.,(*,(-)0))07(0.7683 +,*869:3+:;9  )6.3+;   $4#!"

' 234< 9 /" ;#1 

 

     





  





    

!" # $%& 

 "   "   '(

  ')

%   

  *

 

 $ *   "  

   "

 

     

"

 +  

  



 

  " 



,

 " "

   

   

"  



 "



 

"









   -.''-/-0 1

 





,$

 



1 



!

#20.+324/4'

 

"

 + 

 ,   $   

!

 "

"

 



 





  

 "

"

 

 

 "



"

  * 3    5 $   $  +*  6*  $ $*    # 



+   

7   

2

 



 



"



% ! %   % * *!   *

$

$!  9  $   9

 $   

 $  *  $  

*

% #   "    













% 



  

"

 

 !

"





 #







 

 





  $ 

  *

 ,   $      

7

   $

  

  *

+ 

7

    $   "

  *

       !





  $

#   " 

   

 



 

 ,$:

!

 

$  



   







 



!

2

 



 



" 

       

 



" 

"

" 



 



      !

 < 





" 

   !



"

  

 



"

"

 

"        







   

 











"



   2 

 +



       6

! $%& 

 " %! =)'.))'4-- >



 ?

@ -.2''2-/-0   

   $

 

 

+ 

 $  

 ,  $  





 *





 

@



     8

  A+



$

  !

 

%5   B2+C

 



  *

 %5  .( -0 

-.

''

-/-0



3 !

 * +  %5  ..

-0 

-.

''

-/-0  

 <  *  

+  8

 

B2+C



+  



  





  

 *

 

931;

1@ ;+;A%A3;  

-4 ''

-/-0

 

 ///'0-0./-=-0/)'4 

-4 ''

-/-0



     

!" # $%& 

 "

 

0/ ''

-/-0  #   A+ %

 .-.

>@ +* -<.





     



')( ')4 ')= 0-0 )-( </. 0-< > 

   

  







 "   



   "



 A+ %





.-.









1 3 0=( 

0/ ''

-/-0

')( ')4 ')= 0-0 )-( </. 0-< >



 

  







 





 







 





    



A+





3

?

@



 # +



.4'

8 +  1



+   =0=

8D )

'                1 ="//+ ##%## 0( 060( 4> 1 

* 



 

)04  >



!

1 30=( 

0/''-/-0 E+ 7

>2'F

  ')( ')4 ')= 0-0 0-< )-( </.

> E 0/( >

 

 F



>

 



 "  #  

% #

 

 +



  



 

    

 

+

 





 

 

 "

  >

 



   " D '     "=1  /    /    /"       0.

060(

(

       !"%"

%"  %/"

/% "/%/

   /%#% ##0( 060(

  ""# %/"# #/    ' 

/ %    ?%   ::/#  $% /

  ##/ '   

   < 

!

'%  #/ "/  % '     #" /        ()*    +     %/  '                            "/%/% ()*+  #=%

.

()*++% ,-.)

1 

 



 

     2 HE'F 8







   

 2!!





# 













 !I



  

 

 



"      ?2 EF





  I EF



  





"





  

  



 J!

 I EF

!





  *  I EF "





!*

 * 



   



*

 "







!?

> 

"

# 







 





!2

*





!







 





"



!

 

    E'2+F 8





!2 E'F

 " 





  



 

>! >  



>  "



>! >  

 !

  

"

 

 

 E'2$F





! 

!



 

    

   

>! >  



 





*  K E-F 8

# 







!2 E'F

 

      

 





 

 



    EF  

 

  !

 



 "



I EF  

  

 

 

 



 





 



      







I EF  

 



  





 I EF 

  



!2 E0F )0(  

! "

?> 

"

 



  







  !   



!







  

 *

7   E0F  

 





"







    







"

   



!



 !I  %

 J 

 



"

 



   

  

 

 

!!

"

  





!2 E'F HE)F 3  

 



  

    



!2 E0F 0(.

0(.+$

0(.2+

0(.2$

  >  

E)< '4./FKG *

?< " 1/"+   #"  %#   # "/  '   %+ + +4 1 1,)),71060(          66( 060(#+  "/# /%/# #%##

-

%"/  % + #  %"//"           #   "  /  

    ()*     +    +%     ,-.)  %/@ ,6

2% %/"  / 5 +4 1 108.881 060( #  "// %#% ## 0( 060(9 > 10;

  %%+ #"

,,

 

 

*  / "  /## '   ##  

# %/#1 %% #  %

%+   ! " 

   #$%&'

%(())) )A(#   0

 

 

# 

)04

 > $





/(/0-/'(

"

*

 

 

 







 "

 

 

 

"

2

 )

 

# 

 







"



!











 "



    

 



 



 @  

     "

 



)04  > "  

# 

 

 





 

* 







!D ,0

'>% #< 3%        /   #          "  /    ++% ,-.)% #  +,*-* B / # / /   #%#%

# ##  #% //"?/ %"#         !   +           #     "//"  78,1 +#

% +%%(,  #  +  "/## (*+%%+ ((.+ +% ,-.6%# 1 0'

$

 



! ;  !    

  

  E)'

 F



"

    

 "







7   

 "



 



 "



 



!

   

  



 





  



!  

  

  

 1











  

 

  



  

 





*  D ,)

'+ # ()*>

++% ,-.) '!C/D 

%+     ()* +   ## *!!+   ,!

"--%.$/#(()0)/  %#%"/ %%  EF



7

 :



 :

)04E'F "

 







 

 !

  %

: :



:!

    



 

 !

    

 

 

 !



!





 : 



  

   

!

7



!*    











"







  

 





!



*

 !

   E>  0< )/ )'F !



 !



     "   

 

 

   "  

   !

 



   !

2 ! 







   

 E>  )/ )'F EF  



!  

# 







 "

 

 

"









  

 







%

 

)0(

  "

   E> 0.F EF

  1 

 



"

)04 E> 0(F EF 

! 



1       



 E> 04F EF

  )04  

 



  E> 0=F EF

! 



)04E'F 



>! >  

&



"

 ! 

7



 



 

 





 

 



 !

    







E> )-F EF    

 2   



!



  

 

   





   

  1







 



!



!

)0(

)0=





 ! 

 

 

1  

 $

"

   !

















 E> )-FG

,(

3               %      ()*+  ,-.)"+  % //% >   '+ %  //#   %    '/%""       "  E       F         # 

/

90;

 % #   "/ ,7

'#EF /1 , ()* + #   B""

#+ #% 0,+  3 "// /"  /"

%#%

 ()* ()-+  <  ()- #% 0,+ 3 ,8

'  >+ 

  ()*9,;    +     *!!+   1  9 ;  # 1 G )04E'F



  "

 



 



! 



 

"





 2!!





7





 "

 





 

 !

  %

: :



 









"













  

  

   



 

 



 !

 2!!

 

!

7



!*    











"







 )04E'F

 

 

! 

      





 

!

@

"

!





! "  





 

!  

 

 : !

D





 

   



     

 

 D ,.

  %      <   E    %   /    #  "/  @F# # / #" #  %   "//  / %## 

"%/%%     #/  /"%"  <   +  #/"   %     3

$ !C/+      #  ()* *  % *!!+   ,!

" E F

  G3

 



    



 

  



 



 

   

  



   $ 





 



"  

 

    



 



       

 



  2 2 ! 



  

 



 



 

 



!*  

 

  

$

 

 

      

  

 

 8

"





 !





 

 

   

   

"

     "



  







       "











 



   

   ;



  

 !

    

"



* 



 

"







7





! 

"

"

   



 ! 



    





  

"



! "





'=(0G ,*

!     "+   "//#> #  

()*  +     +    " /      /  /#    %   "//# /     ,-

 " /< / 

()*+  / 1  ##< #/ ##  /%/  #/ /% /< "%

3 #/# /%/ 1 %  #  

"% %" % 

  0( 060(9 > 10;#  #%#

   #+ # %  / %

 %+ ## 3%%" #" %

/   /"

  %    /%        %%% =%   % 11#   /% # ## '> /"  ## + 

2% 0( 060(9 > 1(;  + # 

/"

  ## % ' /"

     %   /     /%     %# /%%   0,

'+ #

>% /%%/"  %/ ()*+  

 /   "#:1 :  #/" )6.3+ /  %   "

0)

!        "  /       %%/% 0(

!#%" / / >% 9    "&



  8





3 8

  !

3