Ram Pal & ORS. v. State Of Haryana & ORS.
!
#!$%&'( ")
"*
#+ #,-%
% .%'% -/#!#(##,-%
%01%
!"#$% ! # % &
!"#$% %$ '''
%& !-0%
2
2#-#3#)1$##)#(##4- 2 /#+#-/#5#)11 1$##)#(##
66666 %$ (! -%-01-0%40%4-- -+%$+07$%-04%$!1'1%'89 %$:
;!/$ !-#(##2'$0#0#$)"<< :!%-)"<< $;1$#5#5#1-2'$0#'$)#+'# #5# 2'$0# '$ #% #+'# #5#9#5#1- 2'$0# 0#8(#115'### -5#$!-0%)%-)%-##%0- 0%%!/$ 9!-#(##2'$0#$)"<= #1%'89 %$:
;!/$ !"<< $)8!0+'5#!$5- 2'$0#'$8(#115!4#5%#%2'$0#0#)
00'(!-#54#%5#(83$%4%'5- %'00 !-#!+1%'8+%%)#$-#%8#1-0%% !$% 9#1 !-%'!1#%'8+-# 20###+#%###-#5#00'#!#$%+ $+0%1 + 1%$% #1 $%%5 ! 4 + 2'$0#% #$-#(#%-$5''%##%%0$!18(- 8(0'8$!$#8#20### 2
2#-#3#)#11$##)#(###%%%1 8( 2 /#+#- /#5#) #1 11# 1$# #) #(## %'8+1-#-$%(-%5#1-#%##1(8%#%8( -%$-!-%'# ) *+*,-* . ,/ ,0,#*
*1* ** . ,(
234 3(1$11
">) 4- $%15 - 3'15+ 11 8( ?8 - /'0+' *.
# 5-* . ,/ ,0,#* )*6-* *.
,-* . ,(%427#4(4--#%8-1#$! -+!(5$%'!-2'$0#(715 %+%#5%#!'$)4-$-1%@'#(00'(! -#5
-#-#1-#11$##)#(###1 #00#%1-0#08A
/'89%$:
;!/$ !"<< $#1%#%'1&9 B-++#()!+++)8(!$#- !!$# #C) 1$# #( +'$0#( $'15 ## $+0%5 '# ## # 0# -!) ! #() 8 # 0#A4#%B-2'$0#0#!:#+! 0#;D
+ - 0# #1 %+0 #15 ! - #!+1
0%) % $# -# - + % %1 4- 04 0+'5#-+'$0#(#1-%0%!#!!15#( 00'(
/+#00%$#+818#1'0-3'15+ $1%'0#)4-)4-$5-#1$11$'1'- 3'15+11-) ) 8*) * 6-*1*(*
*9** .
,/ ,0,#* 0 9*:* . ,(
73
2( 1$11
)-#%8-1-#00'(!
-#5!-0'0%!715%+$%'!2'$0#( %@'185-$###%85#5%#!'$ 5%##$%-$##10+'5#!#5#'!$1'$ 4-'!$0#$'#$#%%)4-#%##1+%##$%- +#A5#1%%'!#%0$!$1$-#00$#!#5#' # 0#$'# $#% #$$1#$ 4- - @'+% ! 0$(
%' ! 2'$0#( #1 $% ! 2'$0# '$ 8( #115!4#5%2'$0#0#%-1+#!- 5%#'#1)-'%)$#8@'%1 -%#A!8()# 0!-3'15+#1%-'%&9 B!#$)#%$-!-%' "=
>!
*1#+ #$-#(#)2#2#3##1-% /# ! '3#8#1-%)1$11
)-#%#%-1-# %#8%-+ ! # 2'$0# ++ % # 5%# !'$ -#7#$!+-%#13'15+#1%#% '1&9 B/+#%-4!---3'15+%1 '08(#1$'%!-0% 2#1#E# /#! '3#8):
<; :;> F#11# /'$% E+1 /$#() 0#+ ! E$# 1%):
F; :;>F -3'15+%!1
8(-#1$'%!-00$1 - #%%'+0 -# # !$# $%'5 # 2'$0#( 715 % +'$0# +% % #1+%##' /'$-#%%'+04#%08#8( !-#%-#-0%%!-$$+0# # 00'( ! -#5 ! - 3'15+% !18(-#1$'%!-0)- 1%$ 84 - #1+%# #1 5%# !'$%4#%8'5--$!-')4-$- -#%8%'83$+#!$%1#8!-#5 $-%!-G8/'0+' %0$!- 2'$0#%#%#%-##5'%0%%) - '$-3'15+%!-%'-##A- %+#4 -!)#$!-#1$'% !-0-%$-3'15+%! -% ' - 3'15+ !- /'0+ ' #1/5-#1%% /#!+#$-# #1%-#1 %) "<*=/"
<)%!-00 - 3'15+ #1 /5-G% $#% :%'0#; -#% 8 $%11-$#%%#1-#%81%5'%-1
-!)4!1-##$!-/#+ !(5$%'!-2'$0#(715 %+%#5%#!'$#1-%#+)1% @'#00'(!-#5 '%$-%#' $+0#%#00'(!-#5)-5'! 5#!00'(!-#5%-%#+#%% @'1!##1+%#@'#%3'1$#!'$ %'$-00'($#1+$'100'(! 0%#-#5 -'%)4!1-##!$#$%'52'$0#(# !$##8%-52'$0#(%##$!5%##1 -'%$# 8+0'51-5'1%4-$-####8 ! #1+%# @'#%93'1$# 1% $5 - 1!!$84-5%##1#1+%#!'$) % $- #+ #$-#(#) 2# 2#3#G% $#%
3 :%'0#;)8%1#%'1&9 B4!-#8)$#8-1-##5%##$ %-$##10+'5#!#5#'! $1'$4-'!$0#$'#$#%%)4-#%# #1+%##$%-+#A5#1%%'!#%0$!$ 1$ - #00$# ! # 5# ' # 0#$'#$#%#$$1#$4--@'+%! 0$( E5%#%-0$%%'%'#(0#5 !'') #1+%# % - 0$%% ! 0!+5 0#$'##$%)!%%'50#$'#1%!+#A5 1$%%4-$-#00(5#'%0#$'#$#%%
#13'1$#)---#1)#00%%0$!$ 11'#%%'#% ')-%#(#8#1 1%$% - 83$ ! - ') - #$- ! % #00$#)-5-%#185#%#%5'!)% 11!!$0#%)0%#1!''%)% !+)-+#!%0+'5##%+!#$% 4-$-+#(-01#45-845%# #1 95%# #$% - %#1 !#$% -# 8 #001!-15-#-!7#!0$'1- 0%%!-%%#++1%$#!! '1-$$($)
)#5%##'
/'$-0$0%-#8#001%0$!- $%'!-2'$0#(7%!%+%) -!$%'$-3'15+%%+#1-#! 0#!+-#!%#13'15+)#%$- #+ #$-#(##%%/A-# /#! '3#8#1-%) :
<;" :;
)-#%#%#A-%#+4-##$ !$%'!#2'$0#(%5%##$
#%!1-##0#!+-!#$-#3'15+- $#%!.
H#0:%'0#;-#%8!'181'1#8( - /'0+ ' 8' - 1%$ 84 # #1+%# !'$ - 5%# !'$ 4#% 8'5--$!-'-3'15+%!E#5 $-%!-G8/'0+'#%$%11#+
;
#$-#(#)2#2#3#G%$#%:%'0#;4!1!- 0'%#!-' -!)-%#13'15+1%#( 14#8150$1!-%'
%@'()41!1#(+-0% 40
%+%%1 $#+#'+1!'!-!#$-#-40% 015#13'1$#%$
4-'#(+%#()-!)$#'% !#$#51(#$$'15%'%
%#'0%-!'#%5)-40%1%+%%1
<! # % & = <%$ = !"&8 !"&8 !01(2 *) ,- - ,> *+ 5? *,
.
@ ,?
- > *: @ ,?