Devinder And ORS v. Union Of India & ORS

   
   

    
   

    
   

    
   

 











 


  

 

  !   

 

  !   

 

  !   

 

  !

"#$%&"'(%)'$ * +)'*))%&,+"'(

",$,$%"'( "'(-( %$%%&$))%&,+"'(

"(.%&"%,(
 /
 /
 /
 / 

0    

 1  

0    

 1  

0    

 1  

0    

 1 !!!!
 
  
 
  
 
  
 
  

 

 

 



0    
 

   



0    
 

   



0    
 

   



0    
 

   

'"("%, '"("%, '"("%, '"("%, '

(+23-*)' +)'*)!&#4),"',+".",$,$%"'( '

*$,3-*)'!&#4),"''"(.%&"%,( ,5 '

)')%6!&#4),"''"(.%&"%, 787878 787878 787878 787878  

   

!  

   

!  

   

!  

   

! +".",$,$%"'((""2)9'$,4"',$')'$,:-)(+,+" '&"'  &),"&   5!  %%";-'"  <!  9+"'"=>  ,+"  4%,')4,   ("??$%6,$42",(), ,),$%+)(=""%)??,,"&$% )#-''"(.%&"%, =>,+")$?9)>-,+'$,$"(  +",+$'&'"(.%&"%,$ "

"%$' $#$($%)?
**"'4$)?

)%)6"'! ',+"'%)$?9)>! "9 "?+$$((-"&)%)&#"',$("*"%, &),"&@  5$%#$,$%6)..?$4),$%('*"?$6$=?"4)%&$&),"(' 6$#$%6  4%,')4,  ' ()?"  ,$42",( ), $?)2+"'$ )?, ,),$% A),

)$&%B  %  $%&/ )%$.),  ?$%"  '  )  ."'$&    $#"  >")'(   +"

 "?$6$=$?$,>4%&$,$%(?)$&&9%9"'",+),,+"4)%&$&),"(+-?&=" *$%$*-* ),'$4-?),$%.)(()%&'"($&"%,,+"?4)?)'") .% 4%,')4,="$%6)??,,"&!4**$(($%9)(.)>)=?"%)(,'-4,-'"& =)($(  %  ,+"  ()?"    ,$42",(  ,  ="  4)?4-?),"&  '  ")4+  &)> (".)'),"?> ,9)(*)&"4?")',+),-.%'"4"$.,*'",+)%%" )..?$4),$%!,+"4%,')4,9-?&=")??,,"&=>&')9?,( +"

.",$,$%"'(="$%6"?$6$=?"(-=*$,,"&,+"$')..?$4),$%(9$,+$%,+" (,$.-?),"&,$*"')*"

,+)(=""%(,),"&,+),)&')9?,(9)( (?),"&' 5)%&,+".",$,$%"'(&-?>'")4+"&,+"#"%-" ),,+"6$#"%,$*"

9"#"'!9$,+-,&$(4?($%6)%>=)($(,+"'"! ,+"&')9?,(9)(.(,.%"&)%&)%)%%-%4"*"%,9)(*)&" ,+),,+"&),")%&#"%-"'4%&-4,,+"&')9?,(9-?&=" &-?>$%'*"& ")'%"&  4-%("?  )..")'$%6  '  ,+"  .",$,$%"'(  +)( &')9%-'),,"%,$%,
**"'4$)?
$'4-?)' <&),"& D $((-"&=>,+"#"'%*"%,%&$)! $%$(,'>)$?9)>( A)$?9)>)'&B)%&9+"'"-%&"'.)')'"6-?),"()..$%,*"%, )?,
%,')4,'('()?",$42",( +"'"?"#)%,.)',.)') )%&  -.%  9+$4+  +")#>  '"?$)%4"  9)(  .?)4"&  $(  ";,')4,"& +"'"-%&"'

E  "?"4,$% 
**$,,""    '

4)?"  $4"'(  '*   "?"4,$% 
**$,,""    '

4)?"  $4"'(  '*   "?"4,$% 
**$,,""    '

4)?"  $4"'(  '*   "?"4,$% 
**$,,""    '

4)?"  $4"'(  '*
**"'4$)?!  $%)%4"  )%&  ."'),$%6  ".,,(  (+)??

**"'4$)?!  $%)%4"  )%&  ."'),$%6  ".,,(  (+)??

**"'4$)?!  $%)%4"  )%&  ."'),$%6  ".,,(  (+)??

**"'4$)?!  $%)%4"  )%&  ."'),$%6  ".,,(  (+)??

(4'-,$%$F")%&(+',?$(,,+""?$6$=?""'( "?"4,$% (4'-,$%$F")%&(+',?$(,,+""?$6$=?""'( "?"4,$% (4'-,$%$F")%&(+',?$(,,+""?$6$=?""'( "?"4,$% (4'-,$%$F")%&(+',?$(,,+""?$6$=?""'( "?"4,$% 9$??=>=>)&')9?,(!&')9%=>)%>4+$?&$,+"'"$( 9$??=>=>)&')9?,(!&')9%=>)%>4+$?&$,+"'"$( 9$??=>=>)&')9?,(!&')9%=>)%>4+$?&$,+"'"$( 9$??=>=>)&')9?,(!&')9%=>)%>4+$?&$,+"'"$( *'",+)%%"(-$,)=?"4)%&$&),"

 *'",+)%%"(-$,)=?"4)%&$&),"

 *'",+)%%"(-$,)=?"4)%&$&),"

 *'",+)%%"(-$,)=?"4)%&$&),"

 ??,+""?$6$=?"4)%&$&),"((+-?&=")&#$("&,+" ??,+""?$6$=?"4)%&$&),"((+-?&=")&#$("&,+" ??,+""?$6$=?"4)%&$&),"((+-?&=")&#$("&,+" ??,+""?$6$=?"4)%&$&),"((+-?&=")&#$("&,+" &),"!  ,$*"  )%&  #"%-"    ,+"  &')9  ,+'-6+ &),"!  ,$*"  )%&  #"%-"    ,+"  &')9  ,+'-6+ &),"!  ,$*"  )%&  #"%-"    ,+"  &')9  ,+'-6+ &),"!  ,$*"  )%&  #"%-"    ,+"  &')9  ,+'-6+

-'$"'G"6& (,+),,+">*)>),,"%&,+"&')9$
-'$"'G"6& (,+),,+">*)>),,"%&,+"&')9$
-'$"'G"6& (,+),,+">*)>),,"%&,+"&')9$
-'$"'G"6& (,+),,+">*)>),,"%&,+"&')9$ ,+">(&"($'"

,+">(&"($'"

,+">(&"($'"

,+">(&"($'"

+".'"4$("4)("(",-.%="+)?,+".",$,$%"'($( ,+),9$,+-,$%'*$%6,+".",$,$%"'()('"6)'&(,+"&),")%& #"%-",+"'"(+&')9?,(!,+"'"(.%&"%,/-,+'$,$"(+)#"! $% -,,"' #$?),$%   ,+"
**"'4$)? 
$'4-?)' &),"& D !

)??,,"&,+"4%,')4,'()?",$42",(), ,),$%'

)."'$&$#">")'($%)#-''"(.%&"%, ,+)(=""% )'6-"&,+),,+")4,$%$()'=$,')'>)(,+".",$,$%"'(+)#"=""% &"%$"&,+"..',-%$,>,.)',$4$.),"$%,+".'4"(()??,*"%, 4%,')4,',+"()?",$42",(),,+")?, ,),$%$%:-"(,$% )%&!  )(  (-4+!  ,+"  $*.-6%"&  '&"'  )9)'&$%6  ,+"  4%,')4,  , '"(.%&"%, 4)%%,(-(,)$% %'"(.%(",,+".",$,$%!)I$%,'".?>+)(=""%$?"& %  ="+)?    '"(.%&"%,(    ,  5   +"  "?$6$=$?$,>    ,+"

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

"(.%&"%, 9++)(=""%)??,,"&,+"4%,')4, 9)(&-?>("'#"&)%&$('".'"("%,"&,+'-6+4-%("?  "+)(!

+9"#"'!4+("%%,,$?")'".?> ",+),)($,*)>!)(,)%& 9)(,)2"%%+$(="+)?,+),)%,$4"+)&&-?>=""%'"4"$#"&9$,+ '"6)'&,$%,$*),$%'"(+&')9?,(4%&-4,"&%5 )%&%,+"=)($(,+"'"!+"+)&.)',$4$.),"&$%,+"&')9?,(  %#$"9,+"(,-,&"%$)?%,+".)',,+".",$,$%"'( )('"6)'&()%>$%,$*),$%+)#$%6=""%'"4"$#"&9$,+'"6)'&,,+" &')9?,(4%&-4,"&%5 5)%&,,"(,,+"#"')4$,> ,+"(,)%&,)2"%%="+)?,+"'"(.%&"%,(!??9$%6'&"'9)( .)(("&=>,+$(
-',%   E".?>%="+)?'"(.%&"%,( ,5+)( =""%$?"&$%
-',,&)>)%&,+"()*"$(,)2"%% '"4'& +"$4$)?'"(.%&"%,(+)#"%,.'&-4"&)%> "#$&"%4"  ,  "(,)=?$(+  ,+),  ,+"  "?$6$=?"  4)%&$&),"( "(."4$)??>,+".",$,$%"'(9"'")&#$("&,+"&),"!,$*" )%&#"%-",+"&')9,+'-6+
-'$"''"6$(,"'"&

  "(.%&"%,  !  9+  +)(  =""%  )9)'&"&  ,+"

4%,')4,  4?)$*(  ,  +)#"  '"4"$#"&  ,+"  %,$4"   +"

'"(.%&"%,(  )'"  6$#"%  %"  *'"  ..',-%$,>   .'&-4$%6,+"()*"=>,+"%";,&),"

"%4"!)&I-'%"&,  @ %(.$,"..',-%$,$"(+)#$%6=""%)#)$?"&,9$4" #"'$ "

% )%&< !,+"$4$)?'"(.%&"%,( +)#")$?"&,.'&-4"="'"-()%> *),"'$)?,(-=(,)%,$)," ,+"$'(,)%&,+),,+".",$,$%"'(+)&=""%$%'*"&)('"6)'&(,+"

&),"!,$*")%& #"%-",+"'"(+&')9?,(4%&-4,"& % 5 -'"?>!,+"$4$)?'"(.%&"%,(9-?&*)$%,)$%)% -,9)'&'"6$(,"' ,+"?",,"'(&"(.),4+"&,+'-6+"6$(,"'"& G(.""&  .(,   ")'%"&  4-%("?  )..")'$%6  '  ,+"  $4$)? '"(.%&"%,(4%4"&"(,,+"()*"

 9"#"'!+"";.'"(("(+$( $%)=$?$,>,.'&-4"(-4+'"6$(,"'

,$(%,"#"%+$(4)(",+),,+"

-,9)'&  '"6$(,"'  +)(  ($%4"  =""%  ?(, #"%  ?")'%"&  4-%("?

)..")'$%6  '  '"(.%&"%,    (,),"(  ,+),  "#"%  ,+-6+  ) 4**-%$4),$%G$%,$*),$%+)&=""%&-?>'"4"$#"&)('"6)'&(,+" &')9?,(,+),9)(4%&-4,"&%5 5!>",+"$(-%)=?", .'&-4",+"()*"

%,+"6$#"%)4,($,-),$%!9"4)%%,!=-,=("'#",+), ,+"4%,')4,+)(=""%)??,,"&$%)#-''"(.%&"%, $%) (-''".,$,$-(  *)%%"'

  +"  4%4".,    ":-)?$,>  )%&  )$'%"(( )..?$"("#"%$%*),,"'()9)'&$%6.-=?$44%,')4,( +" ,),"

+)(,+"'$6+,,"%,"'$%,4%,')4,(=-,$()?(-%&"',+"=-%&"% &-,>,=("'#"":-)?$,>  #"%,+-6+)%$%&$#$&-)?*)>4+("

%,  ,  &")?  9$,+  )%>  ."'(%  =-,  ,+"  ,),"  4)%%,  4+("  , ";4?-&"."'(%()'=$,')'$?> +"'"?"#)%,4?)-("4%,)$%"&$%.)') ,+"
**"'4$)?
$'4-?)' &),"&D $((-"&=>,+"

$%$(,'>    )$?9)>(  )(  '"6)'&(  ,+"  "?$6$=?"  4)%&$&),"(  ,  =" $%'*"&  ,+"  &),"!  ,$*"  )%&  #"%-"    ,+"  &')9  ,+'-6+
-'$"'G"6$(,"'"& $(,"%(-'",')%(.)'"%4>)%&)$'.?)>$% ,+"  *),,"'    )..$%,*"%,    )?, 
%,')4,'(  '  ("??$%6   ,$42",(  +"."4-?$)')4,(%,$4"&+"'"$%)=#"4?")'?>$%&$4)," ,+),  ,+"  .'4"&-'"  .'"(4'$="&  -%&"'  ,+" 
**"'4$)? 
$'4-?)' &),"&  D   +)(  =""%  &"#$),"&  '*   +"  4%,')4,  $%

:-"(,$%+)(=""%)??,,"&$%)#-''"(.%&"%, 9$,+-, "#"%$%'*$%6,+".",$,$%"'('"6)'&$%6,+"&')9?,($%(.$," ,+"$'="$%6"?$6$=?"

 %  #$"9    ,+"  )=#"!  ,+"  9'$,  .",$,$%  $(  )??9"& *.-6%"&  '&"'  &),"&   5  ),  %%";-'"  <  )??,,$%6  ,+"

4%,')4,'()?",$42",(), ,),$%')."'$& $#"  >")'(  $%  )#-'    '"(.%&"%,    $(  :-)(+"& $4$)?

'"(.%&"%,()'"&$'"4,"&,4%&-4,,+".'4"(()??,*"%, ,+"4%,')4,),,+")?, ,),$%$%:-"(,$%)'"(+$%)44'&)%4"

9$,+  ?)9  )%&  =>  (,'$4,?>  )&+"'$%6  ,  ,+" 
**"'4$)? 
$'4-?)' =")'$%6  <      &),"&  D  -4+  .'4"((  ="

$%$,$),"&  )%&  4%4?-&"&  ";."&$,$-(?>   $??  ,+$(  '&"'  $( $*.?"*"%,"&!'"(.%&"%,  (+)??="."'*$,,"&,4%,$%-"

+".'4"(((+)??!+9"#"'!="4*.?","&9$,+-,)$?!?),"(,=>    ",$,$%)??9"& A

 1 B A

 1 B A

 1 B A

 1 B A 

   

B A 

   

B A 

   

B A 

   

B    
 
  


 
  


 
  


 
  

 

 

 

 

  !

  !

  !

  !

 

 

 

 

,"

,"

,"

,"

+",+"''""''"&,".',"'JA "(G B +",+"''""''"&,".',"'JA "(G B +",+"''""''"&,".',"'JA "(G B +",+"''""''"&,".',"'JA "(G B