Jaswant Singh v. State Of Haryana
#
#
#
#%#%='9> ='9> ='9> ='9>%9= 9= 9= 9= 0 /$ 0 /$ 0 /$ 0 /$* *'?+ * *'?+ * *'?+ * *'?+9= 9= 9= 9= = =
@( !* " !"
@(
.0
#$
#$
#$
#$ !
$ !
$ !
$ !
$% 1&# ( # 1&# ( # 1&# ( # 1&# ( # # & # & # & # & #!((5(6 !4+03/ !
!( #!( *!4
+ !" ( 77777 77777 77777 77777
&
&
&
&+(8
&2 +(8
&2 +(8
&2 +(8
&2 #
#
#
#
'( !
.
-
,
0 *0 ! / A?:
!" !)*!) +9: 8 ! !;12 ! !
*,!-,
!/ ! (99'>0 0:'(9'(9A+
!
.* -, *0
! / '- B %
!// !* 0 "/ !./ *-/
/+ '>?= 8 ! ! ; /12+, !
+!/0( (
!34
<*
! //* 0 - 3,3 0 ! /3,3
!4
! ,,
0," *0
. /%//* 0+4 ,"
*
+ 0
-
4 0+ / +
0/,*!
0/%//* 0(
:( & ! 0/* , !
! 0
/*0" / 9(9(9=(& ! 0/* , !
*!
*-4 0
40!" .!3
/ 3 -
/4., 0 +0 *+
.! /*/ * ! !4
0
/( & ! 0/* *!
! ! 0 ,
-!!"
! //* 0
0/,*!
/ /%//* 0+ 4 ," *
( & ! 0 /* * , !
0
/%//* 0
!+ 4 ,"+*
,!
0"-
!
0
// !
*,!-, -"
, ! 0 !, *!+ 9(9A(9A A( & ! 0 /* *!
! 0
* /!/ ! ! 4!
9= = 4 ( * +!
*,!-,.!"
0 !( A( & ! 0 /* .
.. 0
.!
.
-"
!
*
,,
! 0
!!
!**!
0+ *+
0 0 !3
//
*,!-,(& ! /*
,
).,/ !
/!0/* 0"/ ! / 0 0'(9?(9= =
*!+ ) !
/!0( =( 3
!0/* , !
!3 ,.! 0 3 !*
3,-, /!0
/ C(
! !!
9(9(9=
3 /!! 0 * 0 / ,, <* 4 .!
0 '(9(9=( ,'.! /* 3
/ 0+-*
D4
0,,0 (
-
4.,/ 0//* 0
<* , ,"
- 0/,*!
/% %
//* 0%*
+ !4 4 ! 4 ! ,,
0,"
/3 0( 0.* 0/%/ //* 0+4 ,"+*
,!
0" -
! 0 // !
*,!
! -, -"
// 0 , ! !, *!( .
!
.! /* 3 ! +
! 4 !, 3,-, / /
!
/!-0 D/ . !
0 0/,*!
(.
!
*/ 0/,*!
+
- /!!-!3 30 ,0 0 ,4 30 !" 3,* 0 / - - ! 4.,/
!(
!
,/ **- 0 ! !* 0 0*- -*
! 0 -E /3"
3 (0 .*
! .!
.(
3 !/"0
<*!
/
0
0/,*!
40 -"
/%//* 0,,- *,," 0
4
!,(
!3, / ! 0 ! 3 ! 0 --, * + ,,- !/ 0*.0*!
/*! !,( *!0 0
4 ..!.! 0 ,3 0
.
!3, / +
+ , 4" .!
E*0/
!,(
-, -
-!*
!!0 0/
,) , 0
! -/0 !4
.!/ E* / ! !
.! /* 30 C('( E*/*!
+ *,0 - .. !
! E*0 . 0-"
*! *,!03
*,!03
*,!03
*,!03
!* *E-
!* *E-
!* *E-
!* *E-+. 0
#
#
#
#%#%C=9 C=9 C=9 C=9 9>A 9>A 9>A 9>A%9A 9A 9A 9A 89=$ $99A'>?
?2+
+ ! !
," *.
!0 / 0
E*0
1-, *.!
*!
3 !* 4, 0*+ 9 99 *.!
*! ==>F 4(
E4* + -0*, 40
04" H H &0 .* 3 !* *E!+ !/ // !, *!
*+ 9A >9F -" 8 2 2 ,*!* 3 3( ,,*,-0 40 !4* B !(1+ 9 8'2
!4,2C CF06E"
3(
!"+- ! .
/, & 3 .
..
,8 !,(2(82'CCG9:+0 0'(9=(9:+
,0 *$ IC(: ,, -,
0 .!/., , / 40 -"/%//* 0*0 ! / C
/
," !" ). / 30 (*/
82+-"
4 ,3 +/ !4
, - !
/3/ / 030*, 0 4* -
/!*J 0 *4 /* /E*/
! *-3
30 (#!
!+!
/3 !" -
/ 0 !4
.
!+ -
*- <* ,"4.,/ 0//* 0, ,"
- 0/,*!
/%//* 0( !+
*,!-,.
!, 0,- ! !" 030*,+ *!!
-, !) -,/
*!0 0 !,,- !"0 *!
/3 04! E*/
, 3 (
,
30 !"3,* 004-,"
0/,*!
40 -" /%//* 0 ,,
04
!, *! 0 !
-
0E*0/ 00*!
/*!
!,//!0/ -,
.!/., ,( !+ 0E 0E*0/ ., !!
*,!-,+
*! / !
4 -,3*
/!/*4/ *0 !
-
!! 0 ! 4.
4.,/ 0+ /,*0
*!
,,
+
30 ,)
!
,,
.
/ /!, !-* 0
!
/44
,,
(.!4 / D4
/! , *!
0+-* 0!40!
/ 0(K
.!/ ,4* C(( *!
!+ *!
/ 0 !
, 5, 0 !
, 5, 0 !
, 5, 0 !
, 5, !* !* !* !* *E- *E- *E- *E- .
#
#
#
#%#%::> ::> ::> ::>%9= 9= 9= 9= = 89=$
$9?>'C'2
,0 *$
I'A( <**! - .*,
$ 82 82 -,., 4 !F '>?= 3,3 82 / %
0 <*"F ,," !
<* /: /( 82
! *!82 / -,., 824 0/, !*
D
/"/,*0
/( 82
! *!82 /
-,*
!// !/, '
*
* 0 , *0 !%!, 0 ,,"
!-* (
/0 /
!
00
/
!(( (G!"
!.
(
/0 /
!
/*4*,3 *!
0 !
<*!
0 !
6( ! /0 ! -" -,
/:8'28-282 !- , 3
* 82
-, *!
4 !,+ /,*0 / .*!. 0E*0/
82 */ /0 !
*, ! / +
/!*"!
<*!
0 ! 0E*0/B/*,4 82 , 82 0
/,*0 4 !,G0/ ,) 0-"
- ., ( 6( !/0 !
/0 ( (;
,) ,"/44 -3 %0 !*4+
,,
!
.
/ *0 !/ 2 *0 ! / '> ! / A !
82 3,3 /44 !/, *!
0 4
! *!82 : /0..,"
082+ !4-,//* "
0 4 /, 4,"!
,3
: /., -,3 /* , /!/ !3 0( (
-,%..,/
, /*0"+
!, .!/!
*-, */ -,%..,/(
0 / :8'28-2 / /0G.!4 ! / ..,/-, D,(
0 / :8'28-2 / , !3 ( (-
/0 !-,%., - *// *,(
*!
/0 .*, /( (I
!
-, !*0 ," */ K$ ! *
!*
,, !
3 %0!"+ D/,*3 ," !
,4 */ -,., ( !+ // !
4
*,0 4!!!
4 0
/<*,
//* 0
, !,(
-" ..,/%//* 0+ "+
, /*4 *..!
+ 4" -
,% *! 0E*0/ */ -, 0.*, 0 /:8'28-282 2 " -,1$ 82
!0 ;, <*! 0 4!
0 -"
-
/, +
-,%..,/( ) ,"1 *
- !.!
0 -, 0*-,.!--," !
% -,%..,/+ !
! 4
*!/.!
0/ **!
/0*/ %
82
!
/
/
0
*!
!+
3,3 G
//,* .!.
**!
82
-,% *! 4. *.
..
*,0*-4+*/
.*, 0 -"
// .
/, 8*!0/,2 *0 +
/ /44 "
/ 3 / /0 *
*4 ! 0 / 6(
"
. ! -" *!F
/0 .*, 0 / *.
E*0/, 0/!
0/!/*4/ 3 .-,"- ,00 / !
<*!
*
*<* /G/!/* -**. 0 3 E*0/, 04 0 0/!
4 !(K *,4!D 3 / /,*0
-,%..,/+!, /!- 0 4+
!
!
<*!
0 - 0 ,3 0 ( -,%..,/
/ . / !
*,
" !/44
! 4"+
4 ! -,+ ,+ .,/%//* 0 /0
*,!4 !0G !3,4"
*! ! -,+ 03 -
*0
*!G,,< /, # ! G// ,/
-
3,3
!- 0-,( +4. */ /04"
* / ! / /0 :8'28-282(
*!
+40 0 D !/
" , !
!0
: /F ,, 0 0
!/ 0 -" */ *!
/ / ( *3 *0 , / *,0/* .!4 ! !
*0 ! /:8-02 !"/
*4/ (#) */ 4.
*!(!
+ * - ,
*! 0 , */
C(:( 3
4 !+
! !4. 0*0 ! /:
/00,* 0( ( .
!/*0"/ ! / 0 0'(9?(9= , 0-"
, ! /*
,+
,!
0"*
0/!/ ! !.
!0 9=4
090"(*!
!+.
0/*0"/ ! /
! 0 - 3,3 0 4*, ., / G ( !+ /*4/ - !*0* / -"
, +0 /,
//
*,!-,
!
<*
/ 40 * !
*,!-,<*
<*
-"!/ *.
/G/!/*4 /
0
,/ / !
!0/- .,/ *.
E*0
1-, *.!
*!#*,# 0(4!
#*,# 0(4!
#*,# 0(4!
#*,# 0(4!
!!!!
0 3(
0 3(
0 3(
0 3( (( 0
!+ 9'
(( 0
!+ 9'
(( 0
!+ 9'
(( 0
!+ 9'
9' 8'2
8 !4,2 =?C 9' 8'2
8 !4,2 =?C 9' 8'2
8 !4,2 =?C 9' 8'2
8 !4,2 =?CF 3 E*0
1-,
,/*
*! / !0
!0
!0
!0 ! ! ! ! 3( + '>>? 82
8 !4 3( + '>>? 82
8 !4 3( + '>>? 82
8 !4 3( + '>>? 82
8 !4 4,2 A 4,2 A 4,2 A 4,2 A B E*0
*!
#%# (:??%9 , 0 )
3( )
3( )
3( )
3( !" !" !" !"+0 / 0>(''(9'+0,!E ,!E ,!E ,!E E3( !"+'>>?8:2 E3( !"+'>>?8:2 E3( !"+'>>?8:2 E3( !"+'>>?8:2 2222
8 !4
8 !4
8 !4
8 !4 ,2'>'( ,2'>'( ,2'>'( ,2'>'( * / "+ *!
! 0
! *0 !!, !! 0
/0/!
!/*4/
/ ?( 3 -3 +
.!
.
,, 0( ! !0
0!
*,!-, *! -,G*!
"-0
/
&0(// 0!,
*!G*"# ! ( !+ 00 /0 4" - 4 4. 0 -"
// 0 !,
*!G*"# # ! +
! ,, 4-*0-"
,,
/0$ 82
! ,,4 82
! ,, 0/*4 !"+0*!
82
! ,,- 4%*
,- !" ! 0( 4.
! " 30 +!,!
!,( - 4 , "0
!,( 832
! ,, /44 " -,( 832
! ,,0 !, *!( 832
! ,, 3
3 !G
0 ,,/
/ !4
!,
..!+ "+
/ ,,.
*4- !
// 0 ,/ / ,,%.
*4- ! *.!!
*!G,,<# !
832
! ,, " 4 ! !" 0 ,"
!,( 832
! ,,*-4 4+
!!) 0"
!" 4 + 03
*!+
/ /44 " /
!
-
+
- 40 043 + ! ., + -* /*!
!
3+ -
// 0 !,
-
3,3 !- 0-,( *0 - 3,3 0 "
,!
0 -,
.!
03!
! +
+ !// ,, -, ! + ,, - !/ 0 *. >( / -!
/ "
!
0/00
4"- 4. 0-"// 0!,
*!G*"# ! 0!
/
-3 *. "
* / /*
G/4., ,, - ,- !" 4 // ,, -,
!( '9(
!0 0//!0 ,"( ''( 0
-3 ,,- /!* 0 D.!
.
4 !
/ '( /
4/ -
0 0+.
0 4/ ,, * ..,/+ "+ ,,,00. 0 ( * *'?+ * *'?+ * *'?+ * *'?+ 4 3! L
!.
) L
!!
.! 9= 9= 9= 9= G!
0$ G 8 # & # & # & # &2 -, $ G