High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10209/2015dismissed

Amandeep Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2017-09-21Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan6 pages

!"#$#%&'#(#')#!%*+, -&##./(/%*, $-%!##01/%"2 #&/&/%#'

4#'( ( 1&-&# %5-6-%!&2#'( #(0%!#%&(

'#(#%&*3

'1-781'!).-&#9/&2

(-'$-%0'##&:- '8!).-&#'&2#0#&/&/%#'

')/%/&)-(&2/88 %5-6

''0-%!##0-' 7-8!).-&#''#(0%!#%&%;

'1-$ #7/778!).-&#'

' -9-8!).-&#''#(0%!#%&%

<<<

#&/&/%#' (##=( -00/%&$#%& % &2# 0(& ((/(&-%& 1 6 %(0#.&'>1 6%(0#.&' 7/.# %!#' %5-6 7/.#%.$0-((/%-&# 6-(/( 0'-?#' /% &2# -7&#'%-&/)# 2-( 6##% $-!# & (#& -(/!# &2# -00/%&$#%&( 0'/)-&# '#(0%!#%&( %; -%! )/!# '!#'( !-&#!

@-%! 3;-%! '#(0#.&/)#7?$-!#/% &2#/'-) '6?"'-%&/%"'#7-A-&/%&2##((#%&/-7#7/"/6/7/&?.%!/&/%( B#-'%#!(#%/'. %(#78-&&2#)#'? &(#&82-($-!#-(&-&#$#%& &2-&2#9 7!%&6#0'#((/%"'&2#-7&#'%-&#0'-?#'-%!'-&2#'9 7! -&&#$0&&!'-9( 00'&'$&2#/$0 "%#!'!#'(!-&#!@-%!

3;-%! &6 &&'#((&2#.7-/$&2#0#&/&/%#'

'.$0-((/%-&#-00/%&$#%&%&2#"' %!(0-'/&? '/#-.&(&2#.-(#$-?6#%&/.#! #&/&/%#'6#7%"(&&2# 1.2#! 7#!-(&#.-&#"'?-%!2/(!-&#6/'&2/(+ -&2#'&2#

33 0#&/&/%#' -5/%!#'1/%"29-((#')/%"-(1 0#'/%&#%!#%& 7/.#-%!!/#!

/%2-'%#((%, &2#'&2#0#&/&/%#'1$& -%!##0:- '

( 6$/&&#!-%-007/.-&/%&&2#11 8-&-7-(##=/%"-00/%&$#%&/%-) '

2#' (% /# &2# 0'#(#%& 0#&/&/%#' -( ((/(&-%& 1 6 %(0#.&'>1 6 %(0#.&'%.$0-((/%-&#6-(/(4/!#$#$!-&#!C@ %%#A '#

38 /(( #! 6? &2# 8 %5-6 .7-/$ &2# 0#&/&/%#' (##=/%" -00/%&$#%&%.$0-((/%-&#6-(/(9-('#5#.&#!%&2#"' %!&2-&2#/( )#'-"#-%!!#(%& 7/77&2#.%!/&/%('"'-%&'#7-A-&/%&2#'#

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

#%& % /( '##''#!&-%!92-7(9-(-00/%&#!-(1 6%(0#.&'%.$0-((/%-&# "' %!()/!#'!#'!-&#! 6?-..'!/%"-"# '#7-A-&/% &/(.%&#%!#!&2-&&2#1&-&#)&.-%%&-!0&!/#'#%& ?-'!(&/.=(92/7#.%(/!#'/%"&2#.7-/$'.$0-((/%-&#-00/%&$#%&-%! &2#0#&/&/%#'8-(( .289-(-7()#(&#!9/&2-'/"2&&6#&'#-&#!-&0-'-%!

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

7-.#!%'#.'!-%!-00#%!#!-&%%#A '# 3/(&2#(.2#$# '$ 7-&#!6?&2#1&-&#)&'.$0-((/%-&#-00/%&$#%&(/(( #!% 7- (#C")#'%(#7/"/6/7/&?-!#0#%!#%&-!#.#-(#! #$07?##(##=/%".$0-((/%-&#-00/%&$#%&-%!'#-!(/%&2#779/%" &#'$(*3

3;3 2#.7- (#")#'%/%"#7/"/6/7/&?/(. .2#!/% %-$6/" ( &#'$(!#0#%!#%&9 7!6##7/"/67#'.$0-((/%-&#-00/%&$#%&%7? /&2#-$/7?&2#!#.#-(#!/((##%-(/%!/"#%&-%!!#(#')#(/$$#!/-&# /%-%./-7 -((/(&-%.# 2-& -0-'&8 &2# -007/.-%& ' .$0-((/%-&# -00/%&$#%&2-(&6##7/"/67#-%!( /&-67#'&2#0(&/%-77'#(0#.&( %!#' &2#0')/(/%(&2#'#7#)-%&'#.' /&$#%&' 7#( %&2#-.&(&2#0'#(#%&.-(#8&2#'#/(%!/(0 &#&2-&-&&2# '#7#)-%&0/%&&/$#/#/%&2#$%&2 7?8&2#-"#&2#0#&/&/%#' 9-(@?#-'(-%!$%&2((0#' %5-6)& #'(%%#7#0-'&$#%& /%(&' .&/%(&2#-"#7/$/&'"#%#'-7.-&#"'?.-%!/!-&#(''#.' /&$#%&/( +& ?#-'(-%!'1>.-&#"'?'#7-A-&/% 0& ?#-'(/(0')/!#!

#&/&/%#'8-(( .28!#(%& 7/77&2#'#E /'#$#%&.7- (#C 6&2# 07/.?")#'%/%".$0-((/%-&#-00/%&$#%&2-&-0-'&8&2#'#/(%&#)#% -92/(0#'/%&2##%&/'#0#&/&/%-('#"-'!(&2#-$/7?&2#0#&/&/%#'6#/%" /%-(&-&#/%-%./-7!#(&/& &/%%-.. %&&2# %'& %-&#!#$/(# -&2#'&2#0#&/&/%#'7-/$&2#0#&/&/%#' %!#'( .2./'. $(&-%.#( 9 7!%&6#.)#'#!#)#%-(0#'.7- (#C - 00-'#%&7?8 -( 0#' '!#'( !-&#! @ -%!

3;-%! '#(0#.&/)#7?80'/)-&#'#(0%!#%&(%;-%! 2-)# 6##% -00/%&#!%.$0-((/%-&#6-(/(6?-'!/%"'#7-A-&/%/%-"# 7!&2/(&'-%(7-&#/%&-)#(&#!'/"2&9/&2&2#0#&/&/%#'%&2#"' %! 0-'/&?F 7-/$&2#0#&/&/%#'2-(&6#.%(/!#'#!-%!!#-7&9/&2-( 0#'&2#07/.?/%(&' .&/%(&-=#%6?&2#1&-&#)&%&2#( 65#.&(2-( 6##%%&/.#!2#'#/%-6)#.7-/$&2#0#&/&/%#'/(%&.)#'#! %!#'&2# 07/.?")#'%/%".$0-((/%-&#-00/%&$#%&!-&#!

3)#%&2 "28&2#1&-&#)&2-(( "2&&!/(&/%" /(2&2# .-(#(0'/)-&#'#(0%!#%&(%;-%! 6? '"/%"&2-&&2#?9#'#9-'!( 07/.#0#'(%%#7=/77#!! '/%"!-?(&#'''/($8?#&8-(( $/%"-6#%#/&2-( 6##% -..'!#! & '#(0%!#%& %; -%! -%! .%&'-'? & &2# /%(&' .&/%(>07/./#('$ 7-&#!6?&2#1&-&#8/&9 7!%&6#0#%'&2# 0#&/&/%#'&(##=/(( -%.#-'/& -%!-$ (&!/'#.&&2#'#(0%!#%& - &2'/&/#(&0#'0#& -&#-%/77#"-7/&?

#&/&/%#'D(.7-/$'.$0-((/%-&#-00/%&$#%&9-('#5#.&#! )/!#$#$!-&#!C@ 36?&2# 8 %5-62#'# /(%0'-?#'$-!#/%&2#0#&/&/%(##=/%"E -(2/%"( .2'!#'2#.7-/$ '.$0-((/%-&#-00/%&$#%&/(6#/%"0'#((#!%&2#6-(/(&2-&#)#%-&#' '#5#.&/%)/!#$#$!-&#!C@ 3&2#.7-/$2-(6##% %!#'-.&/)#.%(/!#'-&/% B#-'%#!(#%/'. %(#79 7!-'" #&2-&&2# 0#&/&/%#'2-!-00#-'#!6#'#&2# %,;,'2/( 2?(/.-7 1.'##%/%"#(&

1-( 0#'!/'#.&/%(/(( #!6?&2/( '&! '/%"- 0'#)/ (!-&#2#-'/%"/#%@@, %-!!/&/%-7-/!-)/&2-(6##%/7#!/%&2/( '&%6#2-7 &2#1&-&#&-=/%"-(&-%!&2-&&2#1#7#.&/%$$/&&##2-!-!5 !"#!&2# ( /&-6/7/&?&2#0#&/&/%#'/%&2# 2?(/.-71.'##%/%"#(&-%! %!&2-&2# . 7!%&E -7/?&2#/'(&#)#%&/#C$#&#''-.#/%C$/% &#(-%!@ (#.%!(-%!-(( .289-( %!/%#7/"/67#'#%7/(&$#%&-(-1 6%(0#.&'

-.#!9/&2( .2-(/& -&/%7#-'%#!(#%/'. %(#72-(/$0'#((#! 0%&2# '&&2-&#)#%&2 "280#&/&/%#'!#(%&6#7%"&&2#A31#')/.# -% .-&#"'?8(&/7786#/%")#'-"#8&2#'# "2&&2-)#6##%-.%.#((/%/%2/( -) '-%!6?-007?/%"'#7-A#!(&-%!-'!(/%&2# 2?(/.-71.'##%/%"#(&

1-%!-(/(-!$/((/67#&$-7#.-%!/!-&#(/%&2#A31#')/.# -%

3C3 .-&#"'? 2/( '&/%!(( .2( 6$/((/%&6#9277?$/(.%.#/)#! &0'.##!(%&2#-77-./ (0'#$/(#&2-&.$0-((/%-&#-00/%&$#%&/(- '/"2&&2#.%&'-'?.$0-((/%-&#-00/%&$#%&/(-.%.#((/% %&2#&&-7/&?./'. $(&-%.#(-%!/%)/#9&2#!/(. ((/% 2#'#/%-6)#8&2/( '&!#(%&/%!$#'/&/%&2#0'-?#'&2#0#&/&/%#' (##=/%".$0-((/%-&#-00/%&$#%&

#&/&/%/(8-..'!/%"7?8!/($/((#! &/(.7-'//#!&2-&92/7#!/($/((/%"&2#/%(&-%&0#&/&/%&2/( '&2-(%&#A-$/%#!&2#7#"-7/&?&2#'!#'(!-&#@-%!

%%#A '# 3; -%! '#(0#.&/)#7?8 92#'#6? 0'/)-&# '#(0%!#%&(%;-%! 2-)#6##%-00/%&#!%.$0-((/%-&#6-(/(

7 .=?

2#&2#'(0#-=/%">'#-(%#!* #(> 2#&2#' #0'&-67#* #(>