Kalu Ram v. Gopi Ram & ORS

   

     



 !"# #$
%&&#'
()  * #' +"# ,- +.(/
(
($

$$$$$ **# ! "1"

3#*. " $$$$$ "2# *"






 !"# #$
%&%#'
()

$$$$$ **# ! "1"

4* * #'1 6

#*.  $$$$$ "2# *"




     "

*,-$0

".7  6 /3!#+ * /'#*. 2 **# 8"9 -"$4 :". :"./ /1 6$ ;$;



   $8  ."#3 ".

3"2#" #'*.  6#! ;

3*7# !"#

2 **# "*. "

 2 '  3 "**. +#

513<

*$ 
 #  6 !*=/  *.  '

+*"    6  <  >* +* 3  '# 

 !"# #$
%&&#'
()$ ? .  '# "

3 !"# ".

2 '  36=*.

"**. 513<

*3 * 3
@$(?$
()2 "" 36=*.  33*#

4 ""# "13< / !3 7.+.*. ' <"#'  +#3 36=*.  . '13+ - <"* * / 7*. < 3*#  "2# *#"$?/$ $

133 !7  12. 3

3*.

!+*# #' "2# *#$


37 "#12. 361*. 7 " 3# 2#6 #'<##3+# 31+*1 3 4 +*# 89#'*. #6

#' ''

3 "+*/@%$

   '=/  *.  '

+*"  #'  *.  + "    :  *.

*/  0 1  

;

*.

3' 3 +# "**.  "2# *";

++1" 3  < *.

*# (@$?$
( 6#1*
$?(2$ $/. .

3+# *#.".#1" *#+# "1

"$ *. 

7. /

37*.3

</

7*.0

133 ! 37*.3

< ! 3 **. "2#*$. = " 3 :

*.

**. +#

*".#13+# #1*#'*. .#1" 

3. 7 6 * 1<.*  ""# '# ** <*. 3 * #'.

 < *.  #1*$C.

*.

*+

#1*#'*. .#1" /

3< ! '"*6#77*.0

'#  ! " "3 # *.  '*.

3#'*. +#

#*. 6#7#

*.  '*7"*#'*. +#

*$ 

 '+* 33

<6#7# *.

'# .

3#'*. +#

*$ 133 ! '+* 33

<6#7# *. <.* .2#'*. +#

*$ :

7 " " 37.+. ** +* 3

D

 :

". **. "2#*7.# "+1 3*. +#

*'# *. +1*+. "

#'*.  ++1" 3$

"  <*. 2 #2  ""

6 < **. "2#*/*.  ++1" 3 2 "# ""22 3 =7*.*.  "2 +*! 7 2# "$. +#

*7

** 3 !#"2* * $.  #*! 7 "*.

**. +#

' 3 +!"1*** 3 "0

! "1"

 *+$ *.  #1*#'

!13< / /# ++#1 *#' 3"21* 7*. < 3*#*. < #'.".#1" $  . +#

* 3*. 2 

= !3 + 

3*.  ++1" 3 7  "1

31 3 4 +*# "?
? 37*.4 +*# ?#' $$ $$.

*  .

3  . " '  "* 22 3   *#  7* ""  6#>  "  C; 

3  >

3'#1#*. 7* "" "/

=/ C;


D / C;?

 :

"./ C; ".32

C;$

" 5$4*

*"#'*.  ++1" 3 3 4 +*# ?? $$ $7   +#3 3

3*. =.

! 2#31+ 3 +#2=#'

*. 513<

*3 * 3($(@$
(? >.6*;/** 3 "0

! "1" #2

 

 *+$/2 "" 36=*.  #1*#' !13< /1 #!"# /  / & 333*#

. '13+ - <"* * /.

3+# !+* 3 *.  ++1" 3

31 3 4 +*# ?
?

3"

+ 3. *# 3 <#" 2  2"#

*'# 2 #3#'# *./7.  "/*.

++1" 3

133 !.

+B1** 3!3 513<

* 3?($$
(&$ ) << ! 36=*.  '# "

3513<

*/0

;+#

"7  ++1" 3

3.

3' 3" 2 *  "6 '# *.  33*#

4 ""# "13< / $

3"#1<.* 7.  "/

"#1<.* +# !+*# #' #2 

133 !$#*. *.

"7  3"2#" 3#'!3 513<

*3 * 3
@$(?$
(&$.  #'

133

7 "12. 3

3

37 "#3  3*#6 " 3# 2#6 # <##3+# 31+*

3. 7 "#3 +* 3*#3 2#"*

#1 *#'"$(((E; "+# *#6 2 3*#*. +#

*0 

$ % << ! 36=*.  '# "

3513<

*#'*.  *  #1*/ 1  

;+#

*  .

"  2 '  3  *.  2 "

*   !"#  2 **# "$  



 !"# #$
%&&#'
()/. "" : <+# !+*# #'*.  ++1" 3 3  4 +*#  ?
?E?
E(&   3 7*.  4 +*# ? 

3  

 !"# #$
%&%/*. +#

*0

"" : <'#" ** <;

"3 #'

*. 513<

*7*. < 3*# " #'

3# 2#6 # <##3 31+*$ @ "6#*.*.  !"# ".

!  "

#1*#'*. +#

513<

*#'*.  #1*"6 #7/*. "

 6  <3"2#" 3#'6=*."

513<

*$

 ( **. ! =#1*" */*

=6 

3.  *.

133   !  7    +B1** 3  6=  *.  3  33*#

. '  13+

- <"* * /

3*.  .

" !

6 12. 36=*.  33*#

  4 ""# "  13< /   $  . =    *.  '

= 

6 "  #'

++1" 3

3$ " B1 *=/*. 2#""6*=+

#*6 1 3#1**.

*. =.

"#1<.**#6  2+ * 3# ++#1 *#'

*=6 *7 *.

* "$ !41*6 *7 *. 2 * "" "#2 < *.  #1*$ -# "#/*.  " + * <#+#6" !

#'*.  #1*"6 #7*.

**.  7 3"+ 2

+=7*. < 3*#*.  51= **61* 3*#

133  !$ *. 2 

= !3 + /0

+#

*.

#*"2 +' 3 *. 

#'

$#7 ! / '* "1

<#'*.  ++1" 3/. .

**61* 3*.  51=# ."'# .

3*#

$*.

"#6 #6" ! 3 6=*.  #1*"6 #7*.

*0

;+#

*.

"* "*' 3*#*.  '' +* *.

133 !.

3 '+* 3 51=# ."<.*.

37*.3

<61**.  #"1+. 51= "2 *. -D$ " B1 *=/*7 "+# +13 3*.

51 " **61* 3*#



133 ! *#6 3#16*'1

" B1 *=/*. =7   >* 3 3*. 6 '*#'

6 3#16*$  . ' <#'  +#3 36=*.  #1*"6 #76#"* "

*. 2 "1 2*# #'

#+ +  *. '

!#1$*

=6 

3.  *.

"* /'*7#! 7"  2#""6 

3*.  #1*6 #7 +B1** 3*.  ++1" 3/*. 22 *  #1*7#13 #*6 51"*' 3

" ** <;

"3 *.   =6 + 1" #*. ! 7" "#2#""6 $.

22 *  #1*+

#*"16"**1* *" "#2#""6 ! 7/'*. ! 7#'

*.  3* #1*7.  +B1** <*.  ++1" 37 2#""6 ! 7$ 1*.  # /  *.    #'  *.  ++1" 3  6#"* "  *.  2 "1 2*#  #'

#+ +  '

!#1#'*.  ++1" 3$-# #! / # < *=/ <1 *=#

 2 ! "*="

3 #1* *. 513<

*"2 "" 36=*.  #1*"6 #7"#'

 *. ' <#' .

"6  +#3 37*. < 3*#

133 !$ 
 C*. < 3*#*. B1

*1 #'"

+ B1 

3/*

=6  + 2*1 * 3*.

*. 7 ""

+ 3*#1 3 <#" 2  2"#

'# 2 #3#'# *.6=*.  3* #1*$#7 ! / /*.

+ 7 #3' 36=*.  333*#

4 ""# "13< /

3. 7 "#3  3*#6  " 3# 2#6 # <##3+# 31+*

3 +* 3*#2 = ' #'"$(((E; "+# *#*. +#

*0 

$.  322 *  #1*.

""< 3"1''+

3!

3

'# >* <*. 6 '*#' " #'

3# <##3+# 31+*$.

#++1 + *##:2 +  "6 +: "# (@$(?$
(

3*.  51= **61* 3*# 

3"# *. .

3#'*. +#

*6=61 *"3 #'*. 0 $* "  6  #6" ! 3  6=  *.  #1*  6 #7  *.

*  .  ".#13  6  <!

#22#*1 *=*# '# . " '*#5# *. 

"*

#'*. 

 *.  *.

"

<. *#5 *# >127*.*. .

3 3+

"$

"  < 3  6#1* 
  = "  *  *.  *  #'  #++1 + 

3  #  +

* + 3 *".

21*'#*. "*. $ " B1 *=/: 2 < ! 7 *.  * ++1 "*

+ " +13 <*. < !*=#'*. #''

+ /*.  22 *  #1*.

" +#3 3!

3 "'# >* <*. 6 '*#'

" # 2#6 # <##3+# 31+**#

++1" 3$1*.  # / *.  *  "*#'*. +#

*.

"#6 * :

+  #'

3

"  3 +* 3  *#  2 =   "1  #'  "$/(((E;  "  +#  *#  *.

*;0

3*. "

3

#1 *7 "#3 2#"* 36=. $

"1+.  ++1 "*

+ "/  *.  3"+ *#   > +" 3  6=  *.  #1*"  6 #7  

" <

3# 2#6 # <##3+# 31+*"# *. 6 ""#'7

 

""< 3

33# #*+ '#

= * '  + 6=*." #1*$ ? #*.  '# "

3 "/6#*.*.  !"# "6  3 !#3#'

= *  3"

"" 3$  !"# $"$"

  % &













































'( 


    
   




-;
&?(#'
()

#$
%&%#'
() ;;;

! "1" 4* * #'1 6

#*.   ;;;;

 "

*, -$0

".7  6 /3!#+ * / '#*.  22+

*;2 **# $ -"$4 :". :"./ /1 6$ FFFF #  *.   " 

3    *.  22+ /  *.  "

 "

#7 3"165 +**# 51"* >+ 2*#

3*. 3 =#'3 =" ' <*.

 !"# "+# 3# 3$

-"*

3"3"2#" 3#'$  !"# $"$"

 % &





     '(