High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2870/2017dismissed

Ganpati Motors v. Krishan Kumar

2022-05-11Mr. Justice Jasjit Singh Bedi18 pages

-1-

!"# !$%&%"'()*)

( + , )---

-- .) /0 !

" "#"$$ %& '%$(

)!

*" + )! ,

) - )! " #"

$( %.

'%$/0$.

%.

'%$/

)!

* " +

'

) $/1 2" ) 3 )!

0 "

"

4 #

-24 5 4 3 "

"" 6 " ""!

))!

-) "2 17'$'7/$ %1 '%%.

$.%%%%0, 3 3489+

) , -

) )8

:

-

)8 #) 2 48 5) 8 4 + )

) 8 ;

< )8 %'

%.

'%%.

" " $7 %.

'%%.

"

8 ! ) - !

" " +

! "

+

!

) $/1 2" )3 )! '( $% '%%.

:

)

/

) 6 # 4 =,$ )!

&

3 !

" ,

-3- 12%3% & 4!"#5"$64!' & >6 $

! "

>6 '

:

" - >6 / %'

%.

'%%.

>6 &

! " >6

>6 ?

" >6 ( 8 " >6

! ) 0

+

>6 .

! ) 0

+

>6 $%

! ) 80

+

>6 $$

! >6 $'

! "

0

+

/$/

" "

?

3

6 4 " 43" 5=,$# 5=,'

5=,/ 3

"

, 12%3% & 4!"#5"$64!' & >6 5$

!

%( %/ '%%?

>6 5'

")8

) 8 "@

>6 5/

! $'

"

0

A

>6 5&

! " @

0 5

-4- 12%3% & 4!"#5"$64!' & >6 57 !

)!5 5

B +

>6 5?

! B ,'

>6 5(

! %7 %$ '%%1 >6 51

!

4# 4 >6 5.

!

)! 6 3

>6 5$% 9 " " $?

%$ '%%?

>6 5$$ !"

)!+

(

"

) $/1 2" )3 "

! !

'%%%0,

" #"

)!

,

)!

)!

#"$$ %& '%$( ,

.

3 " #" -

, )

$%

>6

,?

$% %'

'%%?

6 )! 0

" "

3

"8

$% %'

'%%? ! "

)!

-5-

- -

" )!

,

) - + )

-!) " 0

"

-

" "!

)) 3 0

)) )

" ) 2" )3 > )) "

) ) )8

)! 0

+ - " )

0 ) $$

:

0

)

)! -

)!

- )

)!

" ! ' -

" "!

)) !

!"

)!

3

>6

=$0$7 $'

'%$$)!

)! -

)!

" "

-6-

>

)

"

3

+ "

! 5=$, " 43" " )

)8

" ) #" + C) )-)/7' !'"'8

'%9!/&6&- !"#:!/0.; )) /%4%'0 *< + C) "

"!

))) )) 3 )

) 8

" ) " ) !

) $'

3

"

$/

3 ! - ")!

" ) )!

"

" )! )

0 ! "

"! "

8)!

" )!

->6

'

)!

)!

-7-

"

"

)

"

$% %'

'%%? -- /$ %1 '%%.

! )

- " )!

"

")! 0

B

-) !

"

)

!

)!

" !

")8 -

0

) ))

$&

3 "

" -

0

#" + C)

=326&2'9)- !"#:/' >. *- . ,

!

"

#

$% & ' ()$)*+

$+

! $+

% $ $+ & ,-

-8-

! "

!

#

$

%&'!( # )* %+,-./# + #

0 # ' %++1. 2 # , # * # )*%11/.# ,34 # # 0*%112.1# 3++'

# # )*%113.+# ,/ # )* (& #%11,./# 1#(&# (( %115.-# -/-6

# %11+.1# 13* # ! ( # 6*%11+.3# +5(# # *%11.# 22-. / 7# #

89

67(+/2 * , *

:%76 212.

;<

%.

=

>%.

-9-

!

>%/.

> %2.

= ? $./

"

" ( / ' &

0%1 $+. $ & ! 20%1$+ $3450 & 4 0%1$+3 ))'4 &

($+ )* .) & &

' ($++* .$ & 4!())*. 5 &

2"/6 ()) * * $% & '

6()) *.

.$ ( !.

.*, ($* 0

&

&

(*/ !

$+

7

&

"

( *8 7

9

:9 : 9& "

: 9

:9 6 : 7

&

-10-

9 :

&&

(.*0 &

&

;

"

&

2

& "

& ""

"

&

" (*%

&

" < $3% 5 "=& >!())*$)

.) & &

&

:

/ &

&

&

"

$ % 12 &? ())+*+

3 7

-112 ,(

. )*)@

" &

& &

< $% >!&

())+*. $ & &

2 2 "# /

, ( 3 *A(* / # B

"

& "

C (*/# B

" &

C (* / #

&

" &

2 C (&*/# B 2 " 2

C (&*/ "

&

# C (&*/ 7 "

# &

A0 & " D & ())+*$) .)$ +

@

-12-

A

7

B ( * E

"

&

) ,A)/

" &

&

&"

7 & " 6

& F

/ " &

A

&

A

" &

" (8 12 ' ' & D0 ($+.*. 3 G7 /7

H - -0

0 " & 5 ? I

$++ (* $/ & 1 I !

& G$++. ( * 335"D

&# !

())$*$ )$0 &&

())+* $) )3 5 ' 1 & 0!())+*$) 3 3*A ( * % & ' &

! ($+++* $)

& &

"

&

&

&

-13-

&

% 82"4 & '

6()$+* .

3

! $+

"#

/

$+ % $ & , $0

>J&($+ *$

% #

"

- &

# & # &

& "

2 # & $) ,(

*A$)

"

# - &

"

H " # &

J

& &

/

J "

& "

A

$$% & & ' ($++*

.$# &

-14-

"

" - &

& #

&

"

&" "

"#

&

&

"

"

&

&

" # E

&

" # & ,( .$3*A E& 2

#

E # "

" 1 & 52 ($++3*+ &K

&

"

&" " 2 "

# -

2 "

-

2 " 2 LE 6 % &

&" 2

-15- &

"

"

&

"

& "

"

2 C

2

% & "

" B 2

2 " "

" 2 C 2

& #& &

7 2 A

$ % ' 16 >

& ' ($+++* )+ &

&

# &

& " J

&

"# &

J

&"

J &

/ &

J 2

-16- & F &

# "

- &

/

&

"

"

" "

/ & & &

" "

" #

"

J

$ % 0"& >!0%1$+ )

& , (0%1)+-$)* A% "

2 # & &

2 J &

%

"

.$ !

2

&

% "

#

& &

6 & -

6

"2

" &

-17- &

&

&

%

&

&

2

&

% & &

6

"

2

& &(

& "

" 2 & 0%1$+ CE"' & >!0%1 $+ $*%

# 2 & &

$.% '5 1"& 0!($+ +*$

&

2

"&

6 & &

"

& " # 2 2

A D E

-18- $7

:

4 A F G " -) !

$?

3 ) "

)!) ) "#"

! ) 3 8)!

5 *"+ ))

, #" 9

!

)

$(

3 )

#" 9

)!

-- )*) =79# = 8"0 H = ) H