Ashok Kumar Mittal v. Sat Kamal Pathak & ORS
"#$%&&'
#$#($) "#$&&'
* +,- & . -. -- , ****
!
"
# !
$ %$ %&' %(
)* !
+* !
$ %, ./$"
0 #("1234 & -&. * ! '/& # # 0 $ 01 2 3 + 2 ('/&(/&4 01 #) ) "! ! $ 01 !(&&5((/5,''5,'657//5&(/ 89# 0 -(. *
"
2 0 $"
$
! * "
1$ 5:
*
! 1 $ "$ 0 2 " %&""
20 $
! 0
1$ 5;
< ) 0< 2! $0 $4 7/ ///5 0 01 %& !
2$0 01 2 !3 %(=/4/( &4(//,$
0
"
*
- 2 - !2 ! &,= $ %2 0 9
!
%&0$ ! ! !
* 2 2 (//," !
0 $ $ 3 2 !20$ 2# $
-,. !
0 0 !2 01 %& $ ! "!!
$ >9 %&4, &=6(//7 ?5 ,4@5'(/5'645'6=5'4& &(/8 9# 2 "$ !
22 "$ !3 $ 0 $ 2 2 -'. * $ 2
! 1$ /,/4(//7 &6/4(//7$ $ 3 2>9%&4, &=/6(//7
# ,//=(/&& #
(7/'
(//4 >9 * 2 $$ 1!
1 $ ! !! $
! ! $ 0+! ! ! ,'/ # # $
2 + 1* 2+ 2 ('/&(/&4 ! 2
$! ('/7(//= /,/4(//= !
"
$/7/7(/&( 0
01 ! -7. ;
! $ ! %,
%'A02!$$! $
1 !&4,# ## "2 $ 1" "
!
$ 2$!3 !2
- 3 - " 20$ ! ! 0 ! 0$ !$ ! -6. 9 $
2 !
!((/9# ! ! 4 1
$$!" 0 2 "$! '6=-,."! $ $$! "!
10 2 3 0
" $ ! $$!"! 0" -4.
$ B ! $ ! >9$01 %& 201 >9"
3 01# ,//=(/&& ! "
0! $ $ 2$>9 $ $
$>9 -=. ;
! $ %, 0 $ $$! $ $
0 ! !
!$ $$2$! !7//9#
$ $ !3 $ !! ! 21 ! $01 02 0
-@.
! $
2 2
! -&/. *>9%&4, &=/6(//7"
201 %& !,4@5'(/5'645'6=5'4&5&(/ 8
B
!&(/ 89#$ *! "
$01 !(&&5((/5,''5,'657//5&(/ 8/7/7(/&( ! "
2 ('/&(/&401
- 4 - 2 ! $ $$! ! (&&5,''5,'657// 9# "
0
01 >9 3 "
2 01 %& &=/6(//7 0 $ $ $2 $ >9 01 %& &=/6(//7 $ "
/,/4(//7 -&&. * # $9
C
2 !
!
"!
0
$ ! D
" "
!
"
# $ % &' & &(& )*+ , + &,- " "
0" $$!2
!! $ !
2$$!3
-&(. 9"
E"!
>9"
$ "$ 01 %& ! !2F ! $
2 $$! ! (&& 9# !
1 0 $# !$$! $# F0 $ !&@7-&.-0.-.# # !
!!
0$01#
$!(&&9# -&,. %(
2 ! $
%&!
!
2 "$ %,"
9 2 2$$! $ !
"
21 " 2 %'
! !
2 !
" $!
- 5 - -&'. !! 2 ! '6=-&.-!.$ # $ # ! $ 1
$$$! 0 " $
B!2 1
0 B!2 1
!! 2!'6@-&.$# $
$$ !
!- . $$$!G -0. " !
$$$!"
" 01 $$! 1!$$! $ 1"! !$$!! "2$ ! 1!$$! "!
-&7. 9 !
$$! !,''9# 0 " $ 1
$"$$! !,'6 9# 0" $ "1
$$! ! 7// 9# 0 " $ " 1
$ 0 1 $$!$"
2$ !$
$ ,4(//7&64(//7 $! "
1 $$!/,/4(//7""
0! "
" ! $ ! >9 "
01 # ,//=(/&& $ "
! 0$ $
$>90 $ ">9"
3 *!
$ $2$!
" " >9 "
3 2 01 !
$ !$ $2$ ! !77/ 9#"
">9"
3 "!"
00 $ 2 01# -&6. * 2 $ 1 "!((/9# 0$ 3 2 ! $ 01 "
!
0
- 6 - 0$ " 2 $((/9# 0 "! " 01 "
1 $
!2 ! -&4. !! 21 " ('/&(/&4 01 3
0 ! !! $ !! !" " -&=. !! 21 (@&/(/(' ./$"
0 #("123
("1
1. Whether speaking/reasoned?
Yes/No
2. Whether reportable?
Yes/No