Sushila Nagpal And ANR v. State Of Punjab And ORS
!" "#$%$&'( )
!" "#$%$&'( )
!" "#$%$&'( )
!" "#$%$&'( ) *+%,$- ./ - &0 &!,"1 *+%,$- ./ - &0 &!,"1 *+%,$- ./ - &0 &!,"1 *+%,$- ./ - &0 &!,"1 "!$!$&"1% "!$!$&"1% "!$!$&"1% "!$!$&"1% 2"1%+% 2"1%+% 2"1%+% 2"1%+% ,"*! !" +&3 4 &0!,"1% ,"*! !" +&3 4 &0!,"1% ,"*! !" +&3 4 &0!,"1% ,"*! !" +&3 4 &0!,"1% "%/&0"&!% "%/&0"&!% "%/&0"&!% "%/&0"&!% '
'
'
'
5 6* * 5 6* * 5 6* * 5 6* *
,"!,"1"/1!"1% !,"-# -/ /"1%7 84" --9"0 !%""!," 3+0.7"&!:
4"1"
"11"0!!,""/1!"1%1&!:
; ,"!,"1!,"3+0.7"&!%,+-04"1"/1!"0$&!," $."%!:
1"%"&!'
1 3 8 $&< 0=# !" 1!,"/"!$!$&"1% 1*+1"%,*$&.- < 00- <+&3 4 1* "0$< 0=# !" 11"%/&0"&! >>> 1 73""!*$&.,<1 - 1 73""!*$&.,<1 - 1 73""!*$&.,<1 - 1 73""!*$&.,<1 - ," $&%! &! 91$! /"!$!$& , % 4""& $-"0 48 *7! *+%,$- ./ -9$ " 6 ./ -!,1+., $&"%, .. 19 - %& ? .. 19 -<1"%$0"&! @)@<, %" < +.1$< //%$!" +1. ! &0$1<6+0,$ & &048/"!$!$&"1< +&""! .. 19 -%& ? .. 19 - ,"&!,"# %"# 7"+/ 1," 1$&.< --9$&.10"1 9 %/ %%"0& A
'B C!$#" 7!$& 1 A
&!,"7" &!$7"< +1!,"1 -$"& !$& !,"/-!
%, --1"7 $&%! 8"0 6"! !," $-" 4" /+! +/ 4"
1" !," ".$%!1 1 +0$#$ - "&#, 1 #7/-"!$& %"1=$#" &0 /-" 0$&.%D ,"1"
!"1 &!,"110"19 %/ %%"0& ( A ;< 9,$#,1" 0% %+&0"1'B C6" 1&"0 #+&%"- 1!,"/"!$!$&"1%%+47$!% !, !/"!$!$&"1 4"# 7"7"74"1 !,"*#$"!8 $&!,"8" 1
A) &09 % --!!"0/-!7" %+1$&.
; *E 10% 48 9 8 1"%-+!$& 0 !"0
)
; &#$0"&! --8< !," --!7"&! 9 % &! 1"
-"#!"0$&1"#10 !,"*#$"!8 ,"1"
!"1<%,"
"&!"1"0$&! & .1""7"&!!%"--!,"% $0/-!9$!, /"!$!$&"1 $& !," 8" 1
&0 "F"#+!"0 1"-"= &!0#+7"&!%17!,"8" 1
)! < *#$"!81"7 $&"0+&0"1!,"#&!1- 07$&$%!1 !1 & !," 8" 1 < !," /"!$!$&"1 //-$"0 1 !,"
!1 &% "1 /-!$&,"1& 7"4+!%,"9 %%+1/1$%"0!
$&0!, !!," --!7"&!$&,"1 =+19 %# &#"--"0 *," 1 $%"0 1"
"1"&#" 1 14$!1 !$& 9,$#, , % 4""&1"3"#!"048!,"+1!%4"-9 . $&%!9,$#,!," /1"%"&!91$!/"!$!$&, %4""& $-"0 +&%"- 1 !," /"!$!$&"1% , %< $&!"1 -$ < 1.+"0!, !!,"1"
"1"&#", %4""&0$%7$%%"0& !," .1+&0 0"- 8 $& 1 $%$&. $! &0 -% !, ! /"!$!$&"1 9 %.$="& &!$#"!#7/-"!"!,"
17 -$!$"%9,$#,%,", 0 $-"0!0"%+47$!% !, !&&!$#"9 %.$="&!/"!$!$&"1 "$!,"1
1 #7/-"!$&. !," 17 -$!$"% 1 4"
1" !,"
# &#"-- !$& --!7"&! ,$% #! $% 0"&$"0 48 -" 1&"0#+&%"- 1!,"*#$"!8<9,%+47$!%!, !
&!$#" 9 % .$="& 9,$#, $% ##"/!"0 $& !," /1#""0$&.%1"#10"048!," 14$!1 !1 "/1 8%
1 !$7" ! /- #" !," % $0 &!$#" & 1"#10 1 /"1+% - !,"+1! &,$%1"E+"%!< 03+1&"0! @ ;D
&43"#!$&9 %1 $%"048!,"-" 1&"0#+&%"- 1 1"%/&0"&! 1". 10$&.!,"= -$0$!8 !," &0$!9 % /$&!"0+!!, !1$.$& - --!!""<*+%,$- ./ -, %&!4""& ," 10 1!,"- %!71"!, & 8" 1% &0&;
; )<
--9$&. 10"1 9 % / %%"0 48 10$& !" "&#, !,$% +1!'B C6" 1&"0#+&%"- 1!,"/"!$!$&"1%/1 8% 1 03+1&7"&! 6" 1&"0 #+&%"- 1 !," 1"%/&0"&! *#$"!8/$&!%+!!, !!,"/1"%"&!/"!$!$&, %4""&
$-"048!,"1$.$& - --!!""*+%,$- ./ -!,1+., ,"1 &0 %/"1!,"1"#10% !,"%#$"!8<!,"
1$.$& - --!!"", %&!4""&," 10 1!,"- %!
71"!, & 8" 1% "<!,+%<%+47$!%!, !!,"1"$% %"1$+%0+4! 1". 10$&.!,"= -$0$!8 !," %&!0 8 &!,"-$.,! !," %%"1!$& !,"%#$"!8<$!$% 0""7"0 //1/1$ !"!0$1"#!!," !%+47$!!,"
/1 = -$0$!8 !," 48/10+#$&.!,"1$.$& - --!!"" 6$%!& ) )D ,"1"
!"1 &!,"1 //1!+&$!8 9 % .$="& & ) ) &0 &
)< !,$% "&#, / %%"0 !,"
--9$&.10"19,$#,1" 0% %+&0"1'B
C& ;
; )< 0$1"#!$& 9 % $%%+"0 ! /1=" !," = -$0$!8 !," 48 /10+#$&. !,"
1$.$& - --!!""</"!$!$&"1 4"
1"!,"+1! 9"="1<!$--!0 8<!,"% $0 --!!""$"/"!$!$&"1 , %&! //" 1"0 6" 1&"0#+&%"- 1!,"/"!$!$&"1%""G%!$7"
!/10+#"/"!$!$&"1 $&+1!&!,"&"F!0 !"
," 1$&.
03+1&"0!( ) &# %"!,"/"!$!$&"1 $%&!/10+#"0 4"
1" !," +1! & !," 03+1&"0 0 !"< /1"%+7/!$& 9$-- 4" 01 9& !, ! !," /"!$!$& , % 4""& $-"0&!,"4 %$% 41$# !"0 D &!,$%10"1<$!$%%/"#$ $# --87"&!$&"0!, !$&# %"
!," /"!$!$&"1 $% &! /10+#"0 4"
1" !," +1! !,"& /1"%+7/!$&9$--4"01 9&!, !!,"/"!$!$&, %4""& $-"0& !,"4 %$% 41$# !"0 !, %4""&/$&!"0+!48!,"-" 1&"0#+&%"- 1 !,"1"%/&0"&! !, !%$7$- 143"#!$&9 %1 $%"04"
1"
!," 00$!$& -".$%!1 1/"1 !$="*#$"!$"%<+&3 4 ,"
00$!$& -".$%!1 1/"1 !$="*#$"!$"%<+&3 4, 0/ %%"0 !,"10"10 !"0
A<!,"1"-"= &!"F!1 #! 9,$#,1" 0% %+&0"1'B C; & !," 4 %$% !," "=$0"&#" /10+#"0 &0 1.+7"&!% !," //%$&. #+&%"-%< $! , % 4""&
+&0!, !!,""&"1 -9"1 !!1&"8&4", - *+%,$- ./ -$%0 !"0
<,9"="1<!,$% 1"
"1"&#"H //-$# !$& , % 4""& $-"0 $& !," 8" 1 ) ," #+&%"- 1 !," /"!$!$&"1 0$0 &!
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
1"!," 00$!$& -".$%!1 1/"1 !$="*#$"!$"%<+&3 4 9$!,1". 10! = $- 4$-$!8 *+%,$- ./ -4+!%,"9 %&!
/10+#"0 -!$7 !"-8< 00$!$& - ".$%!1 1 /"1 !$="
*#$"!$"%<+&3 40"#$0"0!,"# %"&
A&%/$!" !," 10"1 / %%"0 48 10$& !" "&#, !,$% +1! & ;
; )< 9,"1"$& !," 0$1"#!$& 9 % $%%+"0 !, ! 1$.$& - --!!""4"/10+#"0$&+1!!/1="!,"= -$0$!8 <!,"
% 7", %&!4""/-$"09$!,,$%+1! -%/ %%"010"1 0 !"0
)<9,"1"$&<$!, %%/"#$ $# --84""&7"&!$&"0 !, !$&# %"!,"/"!$!$&"1 $%&!/10+#"04"
1"!,"
+1!</1"%+7/!$&9$--4"01 9&!, !!,"/"!$!$&, %4""&
$-"0&!,"4 %$% 41$# !"0 &%/$!" - /%"
%+
$#$"&!!$7"</"!$!$&"1 , %&!4""&/10+#"0,"
&-8 1.+7"&! 0= &#"0 48 !," -" 1&"0 #+&%"- 1 !,"
/"!$!$&"1%$%!, !!,"1"$%&1"E+$1"7"&! /10+#$&. !,"
/"!$!$&"1 4"
1" !," 00$!$& - ".$%!1 1 /"1 !$="
*#$"!$"%1!,$%+1!$&=$"9 1".$%!"1"09"1 !!1&"8 &0 !,$%/"!$!$& # &&! 4" 0$%7$%%"0 1 &&B/10+#!$& /"!$!$&"1 $&!,"+1! , =" #&%$0"1"0 !," #&!"&!$&% 1 $%"0 48 !," -" 1&"0#+&%"- 1!,"/"!$!$&"1% ,$%+1!0"%&!$&!"&0!0"#$0"!,"$%%+"& 7"1$!,"/"!$!$&$%4"$&.0$%7$%%"0&-8 1!,"1" %&!, !
$&%/$!" %/"#$ $#0$1"#!$&%$%%+"048!,$%+1!</"!$!$&"1
<*+%,$- ./ -<9,$%!,"1$.$& - --!!""<, %&!4""& /10+#"0$&+1! !$%!,"%/"#$ $#43"#!$& !,"*#$"!8 !, !%,"$%7$%%$&. 171"!, & 8" 1%!9 %%/"#$ $# --8 7"&!$&"0$&!,"10"10 !"0
)/ %%"048!,$%+1!
!, !$&# %"!,"/"!$!$&"1 $%&!/10+#"04"
1"!,"
+1!</1"%+7/!$&9$--4"01 9&!, !!,"/"!$!$&, %4""&
$-"0&!,"4 %$% 41$# !"0 !$% %"!!-"0 /1$&#$/-" - 9!, ! &-8%+1=$="%!$-- /"1%&$% -$="< !,"19$%" -%<!,$%+1!$%% !$% $"0!, ! 1!,"1" %&%4"%!
G&9&!!,"/"!$!$&"1%<!,"/"!$!$&"1 $%&!#7$&.! !,$%+1! &=$"9 !,$%< & 0="1%"$& "1"&#", %!4"01 9&
!, ! $% 41$# !"00#+7"&! &/1#""0$&.% +&0"1 1!$#-"@ !,"&%!$!+!$& &0$ <9,"&43"#!$&$% 1 $%"0!, !!,"/"!$!$&, %4""& $-"048$7/"1%& !$&1& !,"4 %$% &8 1."0 &0 41$# !"00#+7"&!<!,$%+1!# & $%%+"0$1"#!$&!!,"/"!$!$&"1!% !$% 8!,"#&%#$+% !,"
+1!9$!,1". 10!!,"$7/"1%& !$&< 1.$&. &0 41$# !$& !,"0#+7"&! !$%9, !!,$%+1!, %0&"480$1"#!$&. /10+#!$& /"!$!$&"1 $&+1!9,$#,$%0$1"#!-81"- !"0 !!,"$%%+"*$&#"!,"/"!$!$&"1%, ="&!#7/-$"09$!,!," 10"1</1"%+7/!$&$%%!1&.-8$& =+1 !,"43"#!$&1 $%"0 &=$"9 !," 4="<!,"1"$% 4%-+!"-8&&""0! #&%$0"1 !," 7"1$!% !," # %" % !, ! 9+-0 4" +!$-"
"F"1#$%" &!,"1"%+-!<!,"91$!/"!$!$&$%0$%7$%%"0 #!4"1(< ) #!4"1(< ) #!4"1(< ) #!4"1(< ) * * * * G &#, &