Jai Singh And Another v. State Of Haryana

       
    

       
    

  ! "# $%&'

"%(%) $%&*

+,-,%./+%$+%0/ "  0,0,% "! # "!(! -0+0  +"1+%+  !2%$ %0
 & 3 4-
     " ! %0& "-+%5,#(20+6 $#)+0 6 "0/ 2 0,0,% "!     6 4

/ ,%!0+%0" #,!,%2 0,0,%(%$ "! )0,%7

0/ 
$ 

",8,%+9  ") $("  ,!  $," )0 $  +.+,%!0  0/  5($.8 %0  $+0 $  ' :

2+!! $;19 +"% $ $$,0,%+9- !!,%!($. 6<("(=!/ 0"+6$,!8,!!,%.0/ +22 +9    0/  2 0,0,% "!  +.+,%!0  0/  5($.8 %0    )%#,)0,%  $+0 $

'

' +%$"$ " ! %0 %) $+0 $

'  9 +"% $ ($,),+9 +.,!0"+0  !0
9+!!6<("(=!/ 0"+6/9$,%..(,901+%$)%#,)0,%.2 0,0,% " % +,-,%./0(%$ ".",."(!,82",!%8 %0 "+2 ",$ !,>8%0/!

(%$ "- )0,%?? 0/ %$,+% %+9
$  "!/"06@
3+%$2 0,0,% "

%-(" %$ "A,%=(0(%$ ".",."(!,82",!%8 %0 "+2 ",$

!,>8%0/!(%$ "- )0,%??
+%$",."(!,82",!%8 %0 "+2 ",$  0/" 1 +"!+%$02+1+ ,%  
'6

 (%$ "
! )0,%? 
 % $ +(90 2+18 %0  ,% 6 ("0/ "(%$ ".!,829 ,82",!%8 %0 "0/"

8%0/!

", 91!0+0 $6%'

:6(2% " ) ,20 +0 9 2/%,) ,% "8+0,%  "8  2%+  !2,0+96  <("(=!/ 0"+6  " .+"$,%.  +$8,!!,%  

 ,%5(" $+9=/+%-,%./6  - +/ %$ "+9" +)/ $0/ " +%$8# $+% +229,)+0,%00/  $,)+9

,) "! =,%.2,%,%+;(00/  ,0% !!

,%5(" $08+= +!0+0 8 %0B # "60/  $,)+9

,) "0" +0,%.,%5(" $ +9=/+%-,%./$ )9+" $/,8(% ,0 ,%+9916% 

:6!0+0 8 %0

,%5(" $+9=/+%-,%./ B+!" )"$ $00/ 

)00/+0%0/ $+0 

,%),$ %06, 6'

:6/ +))82+%, $/,!8+0 "%+9(%)9  +9$/,"-,%./ 00/ ," , 9$!6B/ " /,!(%)9 /+$!9$!8 !0+%$,%.0" !0+)%0"+)0"

0  +"(%$ 

 6  /,!  9$ " 8+0 "%+9  (%)9  +,  -,%./  +%$ /,!  !% -(" %$ "A,%=(2 0,0,% "!/ " ,%+9%.B,0/0/" 2 "!%!)+8 +00/ !20-(" %$ "A,%=(B+!+"8 $B,0/+%+> +,-,%./B+!+"8 $B,0/ 9+0/,+%$0/ 0/ "0/" 2 "!%!B " +"8 $B,0/ .+%$+!, +%$ ;+"8+  0,0,% "+,-,%./+!= $/,!!%0)(00/ 01"  0 826B/ " (2% 2 0,0,% "-(" %$ "A,%=(;"= 0/ .9+!! 0 82B,0/0/ +> ,%/,!

/+%$%+!=,%. ,%5(" $+9=/+%-,%./%00$62 0,0,% "-(" %$ " A,%=(.+# +%+> ;9B%/,!9 0+"8 88 $,+0 910/ " + 0 "6/,!

8+0 "%+9(%)9  +9$/,"-,%./"+,! $+%,! +%$ 9 $+B+1 "80/ !20 / 2 0,0,% "!+9%.B,0/0/ ,")82+%,%!2(0+"2 ,%0/ % )=

,%5(" $  +9=/+%  -,%./  +%$  $"+.. $  /,8     B+!  " !)( $  ;1  !8 (%=%B%2 "!%! %0/ ;+!,! +;# !0+0 8 %0 ,%5(" $+9=/+% -,%./6     7  $+0 $  

:  B+!  " )"$ $  ,%  9,)  -0+0,%6 <("(=!/ 0"+  %,# "!,016  <("(=!/ 0"+   /  %# !0,.+0,%.  

,) "6  % )829 0,% ,%# !0,.+0,%+%$0/ "% ) !!+"1 "8+9,0, !62" ! %0 $+

,%+9" 2"0(%$ "! )0,%

?
"
,%0/ )("0+.+,%!00/ 2 0,0,% "! ? / 0",+9)("06+ 0 ")829 0,% 0/ 0",+96/ 9$0/ 2 0,0,% "!

.(,901+%$)%#,)0 $0/ 8,%0/ 8+%% "+!%+""+0 $+;# ,%0/ 2 %,%. 2+"+."+2/ 0/,!5($.8 %0

? 7 %0/  ,"!0+22 +960/ 2 0,0,% "!" 8+,% $(%!()) !! (9;

"

0/  ,"!0+22 99+0 )("0+9!+!0/ !+8 B+!$,!8,!! $% ' :

' 4 +"% $  )(%! 9  "  0/  2 0,0,% "!  )%0 %$!  0/+0  0/ ))("" %) 0=29+) %'

:" .+"$,%.+$,!2(0 +;(0)(00,%.

0" !,%; 0B %0/ )*!/+" "!6B/+" " +9;"0/ "!/ 0",+9)("0/+! / 9$0/+0,0B+!+ "  ,./0; 0B %0/ 2+"0, !6, 60/ 2 0,0,% "!+%$0/ )829+,%+%0  2+"01+!  ,0  B+! %0  +!) "0+,%+;9  +! 0 B/   0/ 8B+!

+.." !!"60/ "

" 60/ 2 0,0,% "!B " 9,+;9 0; +)C(,00 $/ " ,!+ $ 9+1,%9$.,%.0/ 6B/,)/B+! +0+900/ 2"! )(0,%6; )+(! +!2 "

0/ " )"$6,%5(" $+9=/+%-,%./B+!$ )9+" $ ,0%

:6;(0/ .+# /,!!0+0 8 %0% 

:/" ,%$ 2 %$ %0B,0% !! !6%+8 916 D +5<,!/+%6D (=+8
/+%$+%$D:+5;,"/+$0("% $/!0,9  %0/ )"!!)+! 60/ 2 "!%! "80/ )829+,%+%02+"016%+8 916 +9$/,"

-,%./+%$/,!!%E,=+!/+# ; %)%#,)0 $/ )829+,%+%02+"01$,$ %02"

"+%1" #,!,%+.+,%!00/ ,")%#,)0,%60/ " " 60/ )%#,)0,%

0/ 2 0,0,% "!,!9,+;9 0; ! 0+!,$  4+!09169 +"% $)(%! 9 "0/ 2 0,0,% "!2"+1! "" 9 +!  0/ 2 0,0,% "!%2";+0,%%!(22"0

/,!)%0 %0,%69 +"% $)(%! 929+) $" 9,+%) (2%0/ 9+B9+,$$B%,%




 

  

  !

"# +#,%..,# %0/(./0 (9)%!,$ "+0,%00/ !(;8,!!,%!8+$ ;19 +"% $)(%! 9 "0/ 2 0,0,% "!60/,!)("0,! 0/ )%!,$ " $2,%,% 0/+00/ " #,!,%6; ,%.B,0/(0+%18 ",06$ ! "# !0; $,!8,!! $ "0/ " +!%!0 99B&*

/ " ,!%$ %1,%. +)00/+0;0/0/ 2+"0, !6, 6)829+,%+%0 +%$+))(! $+" )9! 91" 9+0 $0 +)/0/ " 0,0,% "+,-,%./+%$

7

+9$/,"-,%./+" " +9;"0/ "! +9$/,"-,%./,!0/ 8+0 "%+9(%)9 

+9=/+%-,%./)829+,%+%0/ ;%  )%0 %0,%; 0B %0/ 2+"0, !

B+!B,0/" .+"$0)(00,%. 0" !!0+%$,%.,%0/  , 9$! +,-,%./+%$

+9$/,"-,%.// 9+%$,!+99 . $0; 5,%0+%$/+!%0; %2+"0,0,% $ +8%.!08 8; "! ;0/0/  +8,9, ! 0/0/ 2+"0, !B " )9+,8,%.0/ ,"

",./0!%0/ !+,$0" ! ))"$,%.00/ # "!,% 0/ 2"! )(0,%6;0/ 0/ 2+"0, !2" ! %0+00/ !206; )+8 +.." !!,# B,0/" !2 )009, 0,%.

)(0B$ 0/ 0" !6B/,)/9 $0+!)(

9 ; 0B %0/ 2+"0, ! 0/0/ 2+"0, !2 % $+%+00+)=(2% +)/0/ " +9=/+%-,%./)829+,%+%0 !(!0+,% $,%5(", !+00/ /+%$! 0/ 2 0,0,% "! 0/0/ 2+"0, !B "

)/+99+% $%0/ )"!!*)+! 629,) /+!+9!" .,!0 " $+)+! (%$ "! )0,%! ??F?7F?'" +$B,0/! )0,%?7
+.+,%!0D' +9$/,"-,%./+%$/,!

!%  E,=+!  +",!,%.  (0    0/  !+8     /  ,%),$ %0  0=  29+)  % '

:,%0/  , 9$! #,99+.  8,%/ 0,8  ,%),$ %0+%$29+) 

))("" %) ,!0/ !+8 ,%;0/)+! ! B # "60/ 2 0,0,% "!6,%0/ ,%!0+%0" #,!,%6$,$%00+= +29 +6,%$ %) 60/+00/ 1/+$+9!)+(! $ ,%5(", !0+9=/+%-,%./*)829+,%+%0,%0/  > "),!  ",./0 2",#+0 $ %)  # %,%0/ !0+0 8 %0" )"$ $(%$ "! )0,%? ?
"
60/ 2 0,0,% "!$ %, $+99,%)",8,%+0,%. #,$ %) 2(000/ 86;(0$,$%00+= 0/ 29 + ",./0 2",#+0 $ %) %0/ )"!!*)+! 60/ 2 "!%! "80/ )829+,%+%02+"016%+8 916 +9$/,"-,%./+%$/,!!%E,=+!/+# ; % )%#,)0 $+.+,%!0B/,)/0/ 1$,$%02"

"+%1" #,!,% : "80/  +)0!%+""+0 $+;# 6,0,!)9 +"91 #,$ %00/+0,0,!+)+! 

"  ,./0; 0B %0/ 2+"0, !6, 60/ 2 0,0,% "!+%$0/ )829+,%+%06 0/ "

" 6 +)/+%$ # "1+))(! $6B/2+"0,),2+0 $,%0/ )88,!!,%

0/ )",8 ,!" !2%!,;9  "/,!,%$,#,$(+9+)0/ 9 +"% $0",+9)("0/+!6

' = 2,%.,%#, B0/ "+0, 9+B9+,$$B%,% 


  


 

 6

'

",8,%+9? 6,% 81 )%!,$ " $2,%,%6",./091/ 9$0/+0G +)/+))(! $,%0/ 2" ! %0)+! B+! " !2%!,;9  "/,!,%$,#,$(+9+)0+%$0/(!6- )0,%?7 0/ %$,+% %+9
$ B,99%029+1+%1"9 H  / 29 + 0/ 9 +"% $)(%! 9 "0/ 2 0,0,% "!0/+0!,%) 0/ 9 +"% $0",+9)("0/ 9$0/+0,0B+!+)+!   "  ,./0; 0B %0/ 2+"0, !

+%$,0B+!6%0+!) "0+,%+;9 +!0B/,)/ 0/ 2+"0, !B+!+.." !!"6 0/ "

" 60/ 2 0,0,% "!B " 9,+;9 0; +)C(,00 $6)+%%0; +)) $ $06 = 2,%.,%#, B0/  +)00/+0 +)/+%$ # "18 8; " ;0/0/ ."(2 +)0,# 912+"0,),2+0 $,%0/ )88,!!,% 0/ )",8 +%$0B! 2+"+0 )+! !

 # "!,%+%$)"!!*# "!,%,%0/ !+8 B " " .,!0 " $+.+,%!0;0/ 0/ 2+"0, ! .+,%0/ 29 + 0/ 9 +"% $)(%! 9 "0/ 2 0,0,% "!0/+0 !,%) 0/ )829+,%+%02+"016, 6 +9$/,"-,%./+%$E,=+!+))(! $,%0/ )"!!*)+! $,$%02"

"+%1" #,!,% +.+,%!0 0/ ,")%#,)0,%60/ " " 6 0/ )%#,)0,% 0/ 2 0,0,% "!,!9,+;9 0; ! 0+!,$ 6$ !%0)(0+%1,)

"0/ !,829 " +!%0/+00/ 12"

"" $0+)) 200/ $ ),!,% 0/ 9 +"% $)("0!; 9B+%$)/! %00 ,9 +%1" #,!,%;

" 0/,!)("0 +.+,%!00/ ,")%#,)0,%+%$! %0 %) %!()/),")(8!0+%) !60/,!)("0,!

0/ #, B0/+0$( 0%0 ,9,%." #,!,%+.+,%!00/ 5($.8 %0 )%#,)0,% +%$  ! %0 %)  ;1  0/  )829+,%+%0  2+"016  0/  )%#,)0,%  +%$  ! %0 %) " )"$ $+.+,%!00/ 2 0,0,% "!6)+%%0; / 9$0; ,99 .+9"2 "# "! 



2 "(!+9 0/ " )"$)9 +"91!2 99!(00/+00/ ))("" %) 0=29+) %'

:B/ " ,%)829+,%+%0+9=/+%-,%./!(!0+,% $ ,%5(", !+%$/ B+!.0+$8,00 $,%0/ /!2,0+9%0/ !+8 $+1 / $)0"60" +0,%.0/ ,%5(" $6$ )9+" $/,8(% ,008+= +!0+0 8 %0%

  '

:  +%$   

:6  B/,)/  +)0  ,!  #,$ %0  "8  0/  2,%,% >D

F
.,# %;10/ $)0")%) "% $/ " +!% "%09$.,%.0/ +!!,.% $;10/ 2"! )(0,%B+!0/+0,%5(" $+9=/+%-,%./8+$ /,! !0+0 8 %0>DF ;

" 0/ 29,) 0/+0!8 0+9=! )82"8,! B "

.,%.%; 0B %0/ 2+"0, !6B/,)/6(90,8+0 916)(9$%0; 8+0 ",+9,! $ +%$0/ "

" 6$ 9+1,%9$.,%.0/ ))("" $/  >29+%+0,% ("%,!/ $ ;10/ 2"! )(0,% "%%9$.,%.0/ ,%0/ 8+00 "6,%81)%!,$ " $ #, B6,!!+0,!

+)0",91 >29+,% $%+))(%0 0/  +)00/+0;0/0/ 2+"0, !

B " )9! 91" 9+0 $0 +)/0/ "+%$0/ " B+! # "12!!,;,9,01 0/ 8+00 "  ; ,%.  )82"8,! $  B,0/  0/  ,%0 "# %0,%    0/  " 9+0,# !  +%$ " !2 )0+;9 ! 0/ #,99+. / +".(8 %0 0/ 9 +"% $)(%! 9 "0/ 2 0,0,% "!0/+00/ " B+!+%,%"$,%+0 +%$(% >29+,% $$ 9+1,%9$.,%.0/ 6/+!%9 .!0!0+%$6= 2,%.,%#, B0/ !0+0 8 %0>DF 8+$ ;1 0/ )829+,%+%0*,%5(" $+9=/+%-,%./;

" 0/ 29,) / )%)("" %0

,%$,%.!" )"$ $;1;0/0/ )("0!; 9B6,%81)%!,$ " $#, B6B,0/ " !2 )00 >29+%+0,% ("%,!/ $;10/ 2"! )(0,%,%0/ 8+00 " 9$.,%.

0/ 6)+%%0+0+99; !+,$0; ,%)"" )0+%$+!!()/6$%0)+99 "

,%0 "

" %) 

/ )%0 %0,% 0/ 9 +"% $)(%! 9 "0/ 2 0,0,% "!0/+0 D +5<,!/+%6D (=+8
/+%$+%$D:+5;,"6),0 $+!,%$ 2 %$ %0 B,0% !! !,%0/ )+! 60("% $/!0,9 +%$$,$%0!(22"00/ 2"! )(0,% # "!,%   / !  B,0% !! !  B "  )"!!* >+8,% $  ;1  0/  9 +"% $  (;9,) "! )(0"+%$)% "%0 $B,0/0/ ,"!0+0 8 %0!.,# %;

" 0/ 29,) (%$ "! )0,%

6
"
6;(00/ 1!2 ), ,)+991$ 2! $0/+00/ 1% # "

.+# !()/!0+0 8 %0!00/ 29,) / "

" 6,%0/  +)0!+%$),")(8!0+%) !

 0/ )+! 6;0/0/ 9 +"% $)("0!; 9B/+# ",./091" )"$ $)%)("" %0

 

,%$,%.!%0/ +!2 )00/+00/ 1+" 0! 0/ C(+9,01  #,$ %) +%$%00/ C(+%0,016 !2 ),+991B/ % D? +9=/+% -,%./*)829+,%+%0*,%5(" $ +%$ D' +9$/,"-,%./60/ 8+0 "%+9(%)9 6/+# %+""+0 $0/  %0," ,%),$ %0 )"";"+0,%.B,0/ +)/0/ ";

" 0/ 0",+9)("0,%+# "1%+0("+98+%% " D' +9$/,"-,%./6+% 1 B,0% !!+))(%000/ ))("" %) 6)"";"+0 $ 0/ # "!,% D?+9=/+%-,%./*)829+,%+%00/+02 0,0,% "!-(" %$ " A,%=(+%$+,-,%.//+$,% 9,)0 $,%5(", !0+9=/+%-,%./+%$0/(!6/,! 0 !0,8%1" 8+,% $(%,82 +)/+;9 6B/,)/,%!2," !)% ,$ %) +%$)+%%0 ; $,!)+"$ $%91%+))(%0 0/  +)00/+0D +5<,!/+%6D (=+8
/+%$+%$D:+5;,"$,$%0!(22"00/ )+!  0/ 2"! )(0,%



2 "(!+9 0/ " )"$!/B!0/+0,%0/ ))("" %) 0=29+) ; 0B %0/ 2+"0, !%'

:6)829+,%+%0+9=/+%-,%./!(!0+,% $ ,%5(", !+%$B+!.0+$8,00 $,%0/ /!2,0+9%0/ !+8 $+1%"$ "0 2"# ,%5(", !6 "E,=+! 96"0/2 $,)-(". %!0 22 $,%00/ B,0% !! ;>+!D

+%$2"# $0/  99B,%.0/" ,%5(", !%0/ 2 "!% 0/ )829+,%+%0+9=/+%-,%./&*

;"+!,%8+"=# "% )=),")(9+",% +!/,% 0)8

"+$29+) $+%0 ","918 $,+991%",./0+%$9 0!,$  % )= +,%  !B 99,%.  $ "8,01  9 0  9;B  2" ! %0  -/+"2 8+".,%6;% $ 2 )84%.B(%$# " 9;B# "0,)+991 29+) $2!0 "8 $,+9912" ! %0I*"+1B+!+$#,! $ ? +,%# "",./0 !,$  ;+)=%5("1% ,! +!/+"2 8+".,%6;% $ 2 )89%.!/+"28+".,%6;% $ 2 )8 9%.B(%$# " 9;B# "0,)+991 !2 "I*"+1" 2"060/ "

B+!9 )"+%%;%  "+)0("  9 0 9;B

? / 9 +"% $0",+9)("06%0/ !0" %.0/ )(9+" #,$ %) 

: D?+9=/+%-,%./)829+,%+%0*,%5(" $+%$D' +9$/,"-,%./60/  1 B,0% !!0 0/ ))("" %) 6)"";"+0 $  ;18 $,)+9  #,$ %) 6+! %0 $ +;# 6/+# ",./091;! "# $0/+0,%5("1%B+!,% 9,)0 $;1+))(! $ -(" %$ "+%$!+,$,%5("1,!+.", #(!,%%+0(" 6)+(! $;1+!/+"2 $. $ B +2%6, 6+> 6B/ " +!,%5("1% ,!%91+%+;"+!,%8+"=# "% )= +%$,%5("1%?,!%91+)829+,%0 2+,%# "",./0!,$  ;+)=B/,)/+"

!,829 ,%%+0(" +%$0/ !+8 B " ,% 9,)0 $;1;0/0/ +))(! $$%0)+99

",%0 "

" %) ;10/,!)("0

4+!09169 +"% $)(%! 9 "0/ 2 0,0,% "!2"+1!0/+02 0,0,% "

+,-,%./,!+%9$8+% 

1 +"!+00/ 0,8  )88,!!,% 0/ 

%) 6B/ " +!2 0,0,% "%-(" %$ "6/,!!%6B+!+. $ 1 +"!/ ))("" %) /+$0+= %29+) %+))(%0 )(00,%. 0" !,%; 0B %0/ )* !/+" "!B/+" " +9;"0/ "!/ 2 0,0,% "!$%0/+# +%10"+)=" )"$  ,%$(9.,%.,%+%1)",8,%+9+)0,#,0, !+%$+!!()/60/ 1$ ! "# 0; " 9 +! $%2";+0,% .$)%$()0

'

+#,%." .+"$00/  +)0!+%$),")(8!0+%) ! 0/ )+! +%$ +9!0/  +)06$,!) "%,;9  "80/  +)0!%+""+0 $+;# 60/+00/ 2 0,0,% "!

+" !)"( 90/+00/ 10, $0/ % )= D?+9=/+%-,%./*)829+,%+%0 B,0/+"2 +%$$"+.. $/,88 "),9 !!91,% 9,)0,%. /,8.", #(! ;$,91 ,%5("1B,0/0/ ,"" !2 )0,# $ +$91B +2%!69,= 6+> 6.+%$+!,+%$;+"8+

$,!2(0 6; ,%.+0",#,+98+00 ",%%+0(" 60/+0+"! +;(0)(00,%. 0" !

!0+%$,%.,%0/ +99 . $5,%0/9$,%. 0/ 2+"0, !)(9$; " !9# $;1;0/ 0/ 2+"0, !+8,)+;916;(0(90,8+0 916)(9$%0; )(98,%+0 $0,0!9.,)+9 %$/ "

" 6,% +)0!+%$),")(8!0+%) ! 0/ )+! 60/,!)("0$ !%0

,%$,0+ ,0)+! 0" 9 +! 0/ 2 0,0,% "!%2";+0,%/ 29 + 0/ 9 +"% $)(%! 90/+00/ 2 0,0,% "!8+1; " 9 +! $%2";+0,%6,!%0

 +)) 20+;9 00/,!)("06= 2,%.,%#, B0/  +)00/+00/ 1)+(! $,%5("1 %6.", #(!,%%+0(" 6% 0/ 9 0  9;B ,%5(" $ +9=/+% -,%./6 0/ " ;1)88,00,%.+%

%) 2(%,!/+;9 (%$ "! )0,%? 
" !6 0/  +)0!+%$),")(8!0+%) !%+""+0 $,% +1+ +,3!)+!  !(2"++" %0 +229,)+;9 00/  +)0! 0/ )+! ,%/+%$+%$60/ "

" 6$ !%0" %$ "

+%1+!!,!0+%) 00/ 2 0,0,% "!,%+%18+%% "

%#, B 0/ +;# $,!)(!!,%60/,!)("0$ !%0 ,%$+%1 ,99 .+9,01 "  ,% ,"8,01 ,%  0/  )%)("" %0  ,%$,%.! " )"$ $  ;1 ;0/  0/ 9 +"% $)("0!; 9B0/+08+1B+""+%0,%0 "

" %) ,% > "),!  " #,!,%+9 5(",!$,)0,% 0/,!)("0
%! C( %09160/ 5($.8 %0! )%#,)0,%+%$ "$ " ! %0 %) 2+!! $;1;0/0/ )("0!; 9B+" (2/ 9$

))"$,%.9160/ " #,!,%6; ,%.B,0/(0+%18 ",06 +,9!+%$,!

$,!8,!! $

0/)0; "6

     E<  

D/ 0/ "!2 +=,%.F" +!% $  !F D/ 0/ " 2"0+;9 &  !F