Mohinder Kaur v. Union Of India & ORS.

 


  


     

 !"# $#%&'&()*

 +&($#,-!., #"&"&(#,' /#,'.'

(&( ($&!!($"+#,' #'0($#("'
 ) 1 2 3
-23 ,#'#(") ,3!+#45 $6%!"#5 ,"+#0#"&"&(#, '#+! !&(5 $6%!"#5 ,5 ,!(&'+!$7!45 $6%!"#5 ,,#'0($#(" '##"!3+!,8!5 $6%!"#5 ,,#'0($#("' !($9  +#"+#,"+##0,"#,' 4%!4(#7'0!0#,8!:;#!447#$"'##"+# <.$=8#(">

;#,# #,,#$""+##0,"#,,(" 9 +#"+#,"+#<.$=8#("'+.4$;#,#0,"#$&("+#$&=#'">   -23 !,;!('  3&(=+  $#%#!'#$ +.';!($   "+# 0#"&"&(#,,#"&,#$

,8"+#($&!( ,8:(9 **?

"#,+&',#"&,#8#("5+#7!'=#""&(= 0#('&(  ,8 "+#  ,8: !."+,&"&#'   +#,#!

"#,5  !,;!('  3&(=+  <&(#$ .(<!;  3"!"#  7#, 
,0,!"&(  2&8&"#$  !'  !(  ''&'"!("  2&(#8!( (4.%@&4:5!,;!('3&(=+$&#$&(+!,(#''( 9

 +#,#!

"#,5"+# 0#"&"&(#,%4!&8#$"+# !8&4:0#('&((!%%.(" '#,6&%#,#($#,#$;:+#, +.';!($7&"+.(<!;3"!"#
,0,!"&(2&8&"#$57+&%+7!',#<#%"#$56&$# 4#""#,$!"#$

("+#=,.($"+!"'+#&'!4,#!$:

=#""&(=0#('&( ,8:!."+,&"&#' +#,#'0($#("'+!6#%("#'"#$"+#0#"&"&(("+#=,.($"+!"

  "70#('&('!,#("0#,8&''&;4#.($#,"+#.(<!;
&6&43#,6&%#'.4#'5 !," +#0#"&"&(#,&'!4,#!$:,#%#&6&(="+# !8&4:0#('&( ,8"+#

,8:!."+,&"&#'+#,# ,#5$.!40#('&(&'("0#,8&''&;4# +!6#+#!,$"+#4#!,(#$%.('#4' ,"+#0!,"&#'!($+!6#!4' %!,# .44:=(#"+,.=+"+# &4# +#'+,"D.#'"&(!,&'&(= ,%('&$#,!"&(&'!'"7+#"+#,"+# $.!40#('&(&'0#,8&''&;4#""+#7&$7 "+#$#%#!'#$#C'#,6&%#8!(5 7+&'!4,#!$:=#""&(=0#('&( ,8"+# ,8:!."+,&"&#'> ("+#&80.=(#$4#""#,$!"#$

5"+# '&804#=,.($8#("&(#$&'"+!""+#0#"&"&(#,&'!4,#!$:=#""&(=0#('&(

,8"+# ,8:!."+,&"&#'+#,# ,#5"+#$.!40#('&(&'("0#,8&''&;4# ("+#7,&""#('"!"#8#("5"+#,# #,#(%#+!';##(8!$#""+#
&6&43#,6&%#'

.4#'7#6#,5"+##C!%",.4#+!'(";##(8#("&(#$   !8   "+#  6&#7  "+!"  .4#  A   
&6&4  3#,6&%#'  .4#'5 !,:!(!
&6&43#,6&%#'.4#'57+&%+&''.=+"";#,#4&#$.0(;:"+# ,#'0($#("'$.,&(="+#%.,'# !,=.8#("'"!4@'!;.""+#0#('&("$#'

("'!:"+!""+#$.!4 !8&4:0#('&(""+##C'#,6&%#8!(,+&' !8&4:&'("

0#,8&''&;4#!,;!('3&(=++!$'#,6#$&("+#($&!( ,8:(!%%.("

'#,6&%#,#($#,#$;:+&8&("+#($&!( ,8:5+#7!'=#""&(="+#0#('&(

,8:!."+,&"&#' +#(5+#<&(#$.(<!;3"!"#7#,
,0,!"&( 2&8&"#$!($"+#,#+#,#($#,#$'#,6&%#+#,&=+""=#""+#0#('&( ,8"+# %&6&4'#,6&%#'&'!(&($#0#($#(",&=+"!($%!((";#$#%4&(#$("+#=,.($ "+!"  +#'+#  &'  =#""&(=  0#('&(  ,8  "+#  ,8: +#  8!""#,  +!'  ;##( %('&$#,#$;:"+#
#(",!46#,(8#("57+&%+&''.#$
&,%.4!,B ?$!"#$ A

957+#,#&("+#6#,(8#(" ($&!5&(&'",: # #(%#5"@"+# 6&#7"+!"(#%!($,!7"70#('&('E(# ,8"+#8&4&"!,:'&$#!($%!(

9 !4'$,!7"+#"+#,,$&(!,: !8&4:0#('&(!

"#,,##804:8#("&(%&6&4 '#,6&%#5'.;<#%"" .4 &448#(" "+#,0,#'%,&;#$%($&"&('+.=+5"+#,# &'("+&(=( &4#"'+7"+!""+#.(<!;3"!"#7#,
,0,!"&(2&8&"#$ +!'!$0"#$"+#'!&$%&,%.4!,5+7#6#,5"+# !%",#8!&('"+!""+#
&6&4 3#,6&%#'.4# A,#4&#$.0(;:"+#,#'0($#("'$#'("'0#%& &%!44:

$#;!,$.!4 !8&4:0#('&(""+# !8&4: "+#$#%#!'#$=6#,(8#("'#,6!("5 7++!$#!,4&#,'#,6#$&("+# ,8:!($&'=#""&(="+#0#('&( ,8"+#

,8:!."+,&"&#' +#8!""#,7!'%('&$#,#$;:!3&(=4# #(%+ "+&'
.,"&(
 

 

5

B?2B**57+#,# &(!%!'#0#,"!&(&(=""+#3"!"# !,:!(!5&"7!'+#4$"+!""+#$.!4 !8&4:

0#('&(&'0#,8&''&;4#+#,#4#6!("#C",!%"&',#0,$.%#$!'.($#,) FB +#&''.#7+#"+#,$.!40#('&('%.4$;#=,!("#$""+# #804:##'57+0."&("+#,#D.&'&"#(.8;#, :#!,' '#,6&%# !'8#8;#,' ,8#$,%#'!($"+#(!

"#,4#!6&(="+# ,8#$ ,%#'57+&4#+4$&(=!%&6&40'"7!'%('&$#,#$;:;"+"+# 6#,(8#("    ($&!  !'  !4'  "+#  6#,(8#("    !,:!(! +,.=+  %&,%.4!,  $!"#$  ?9

9   ((#C.,# 5  "+# 6#,(8#(" ($&!8!$#!'0#%& &%0,6&'&("+!"8#8;#,'

 "+# ,8#$,%#'7+="$&'%+!,=#$ ,88&4&"!,:'#,6&%# !($"+#('#,6#$(%&6&40'"'7.4$;##("&"4#$""+#;#(# &"

 $.!40#('&('&(%!'#"+#:+!$,#($#,#$0#('&(!;4#'#,6&%# &(;"+&("+#!,8#$ ,%#'!'!4'7+&4#'#,6&(=!=!&('"!%&6&4 0'" 7#6#,5 &(!(%&!4;#(# &"'7#,#";#=,!("#$(4:

7#  ?*

+#,#4#6!("0,"&( "+#%&,%.4!,&''.#$&( "+&',#=!,$&',#0,$.%#$;#47) F
('#D.#(".0(&''.# 5  B

0#(4$!"#$A

9%0:#(%4'#$ !' ((#C.,# !8&4:  ,8#$ ,%#'

&%#,'7+ =",##804:#$&(
&6&4#0"3' ."(8.'

;$&#'2%!4  .($'    %#(",!4'"!"#  =6"  !

"#,

? =#""&(=,#"&,#$ ,88&4&"!,:'#,6&%#!($7#,#&( ,#%#&0"    8&4&"!,:  0#('&(  "&44  $#!"+5  '+!44  ;# !447#$  "  $,!7  !8&4:  0#('&(  ,8  8&4&"!,:

'#,6&%#&(!$$&"&(!4""+# !8&4:0#('&(5& !(:5 !."+,&'#$ ,8"+#,##804:#$%&6&4#0"'.;<#%"

"  .4 &448#("    "+#,  0,#'%,&;#$  %($&"&('  !'

+&"+#," ,# +#0,6&'&( !;6#4#""#,!,#!004&%!;4#""+#

,8#$ ,%#'

#,'((#4 7+ ="

$&'%+!,=#$,#"&,#$&(6!4&$#$ ." '#,6&%#7#

?*

,"+#,#!

"#, #(# &" "+&'0,6&'&( +!'!4';##(!447#$&(0!'"%!'#'7#6#,5"+#

&(!(%&!4;#(# &"''+!44;#=,!("#$ ?*

(4:G (!("+#,%!'#"&"4#$!'  

     

5!,&'&(=." 
 BB9

?5 $#%&$#$(BA

 5"+#$.!4 !8&4:0#('&(57+&%+7!'#!,4&#,=,!("#$ !($7!',#$.%#$57!'+#4$";#&44#=!4+&'
.,";'#,6#$!'.($#,) !8 "+#6&#7"+!"!'"+#0,#6&.''#,6&%# "+# 0#"&"&(#,7!'&("+# ,8:7&"+"+#(&( ($&!5"+#,#!,#( ,.4#'"+!"&(%!'# '#,6&%#.($#,"+#(&( ($&!5"+# 0#('&(("+#'#%($!00&("8#("&'("";#0!&$;:"+# 6#,(8#(" "+#,#'0($#("'7#,#"&804#8#(""+#04&%:  ("=,!("&(="+#$.!40#('&("+#("+#0#"&"&(#,7.4$+!6# ;##(("#("&"4#$ ,!(:0#('&(!"!44+#,#$.%"&( "+# 0#('&(  8#!('  "+!"  "+#  3"!"#  !$8&"  "+!"  $.!4  0#('&(  &' !$8&''&;4#&(%!'# "+#0#"&"&(#,,#6#,5"+#6#,(8#("5 !

"#,  "!@&(=  &("  %('&$#,!"&(  "+#  0#('&(  $,!7(  ;:  "+# 0#"&"&(#,  ,8  ,8:5  !00!,#("4:  ,#$.%#$  "+#  0#('&(  

0#"&"&(#, !8 "+#6&#7"+!"'!8#&'!00!,#("4:&44#=!4 (%#5  "+#  0#('&(  &'  !447#$5  &"  %!(("  ;#  4#''  "+!(  "+# 8&(&8.8!'$#%&$#$7+&4#&804#8#("&(="+#?"+ !($B"+ !:
88&''&(,#0,"'G

B
('#D.#("4:5!8 "+#6&#7"+!"&('0&"#"+# !%""+!"!,8:

8!(+!$'#,6#$&("+#!,8:!($+#&'=#""&(=0#('&( ,8"+# ,8:

!."+,&"&#'!($"+#,#!

"#,+#<&(#$"+#%&6&4'#,6&%#'!($0."'&(,#D.&'&"# :#!,'    '#,6&%#  ,  ,  !(:  "+#,  ,#!'(5  +#  ;#%8#'  #("&"4#$  "  "+# 0#('&( !8&4:0#('&( ,%&6&4'#,6&%#'5"+#%&6&4!."+,&"&#'%!(("$#%4&(# +&8+&' !8&4:0#('&(("+#=,.($"+!"+#&'!4,#!$:=#""&(="+#0#('&(

,8"+# ,8:!."+,&"&#'+##C'#,6&%#8!(&'=#""&(="+#'#%($0#('&( (!%%.(" '#,6&%#',#($#,#$;:+&8&("+#%&6&4'#,6&%#!($("8#,#4: ;#%!.'# +&''#,6&%#&("+# ,8: %%,$&(=4:5"+#&80.=(#$4#""#,$!"#$

&'+#,#;:D.!'+#$+#,#'0($#("'!,#$&,#%"#$ "=,!(" !8&4:0#('&(""+#0#"&"&(#,+#!,,#!,';#0!&$7&"+&("+,## 8("+'7&"+&("#,#'"!""+#,!"# *H0#,!((.8 -23   *

'<@' +#"+#,'0#!@&(=,#!'(#$ ) #'

+#"+#,#0,"!;4# ) #'