← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19192/2011dismissed

Rameshwar v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2016-08-16Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan4 pages

 

   

      



!" #"$%&%'()*

)  +"&,- .

"!%!%'". & /".&0& 1! !"  .2 '  '#!,".& "&3'#"'! &  ( 4 5165 1 ."&"'!( .0'%&,7728 #9$ !"8 .!,"3"!%!%'". . 9""'1,". '8 "30!2  .2 '   ,"!,".!,""3.!".& 7$ 7'"-&3 3".+ 2:" 77-"#!&""!," ;0#<+"'!=

 :"."

".."#!!,""3.!"..'! > ,"!,".!,";0#<+"'!&,07#:"."3.!"#%'!,"#%<"&!=   65 1 ,"  3"!%!%'".  &""?&  !,"  %&&0 '$"     -.%!    + '# +0&8 #%."$!%'<!,"."&3'#"'!&!<. '!,%+3"'&%'-%!,"

"$! .+ 

7'<-%!,%'!"."&! !!,". !"  @3". ''0+'!," .." .&!%77!,"# !"

3 2+"'! ,"3"!%!%'".;%'"#!,"'#% ' .+2 &1"32'A )> #0.%'<!,"3".%#  !%' 7+".<"'$2 

!".."'#".%'<+."!, ' ) 2" .& &".9%$"8,"."!%."# &  %:10:"# . .+!,"'#% ' .+2'

> * "- &<. '!"#3"'&%':2!," .+2 0!,.%!%"&5 !".'8,"

- & 33%'!"# & "7 .".< '%B".%'C%7 1 %'%?  .#8 ,%- '%89%#"

7"!!".# !"# "$"+:".

8 D

''"E0." ";%'"#!,"& %#3&!'

 )"."!%."# .+!,"3&! "7 .".< '%B".'>

!".

  ."'#".%'<!,"&".9%$" )2" .& '#+'!, &3".07")) 0'; :

%9%71".9%$"&07"&8 .!8!,"3"!%!%'".- & ."F0%."#!$+37"!"

2" .& &".9%$"8!:""7%<%:7" .<. '! 3"'&%',"3"!%!%'".$7 %+& !, !,", #&".9"#%'!,"'#% ' .+2 .+A )>!  )* .D 2" .&  '#  )  # 2&  #0.%'<  !,"   !%' 7  +".<"'$2  '#  !,"'  #0.%'<

'<7 #"&,- .%' G  &3".!,"!% %$ !%' >* A1 # !"#G!,$!:".8 8%&&0"#:2!,"9".'+"'!  .2 ' 8,"%&"'!%!7"# !  :"'"

%!    +%7%! .2  &".9%$"  ."'#"."#  :2  ,%+  #0.%'<  !,"   !%' 7 +".<"'$2,"."

."8,%&&".9%$" D2" .& '#)# 2&:"$0'!"# .!,"

30.3&" <. '! 3"'&%' '#,%&&".9%$":"$+"&2" .& '#8!,"." ."8 ,"%&"'!%!7"#!3"'&%',"3"!%!%'". 7&."7%"&03'07"G  !,"

0'; :%9%71".9%$"&07"&8/70+" 8 .!8-,%$, 77-&,%+!<"!

3"'&%'%'!,"$%9%7#"3 .!+"'! 7& ,"."&3'#"'!&8'!,"!,"., '#8, &! ?"'!,"&! '#!, ! & 3".07")) !,"0'; :%9%71".9%$"&07"&8 .!8!,"3"'&%'$ ':" <. '!"#'72-,"'!,"3"!%!%'".$+37"!"&F0 7% 2%'<&".9%$"  2" .& ,"3"!%!%'"., #."'#"."#&".9%$" '72)2" .& '#+'!,%'C%7 1 %'%?  .#8 ,%- '%8 & "7 .".< '%B". ,"."

."8 ,"#"&'!

F0 7% 2 .3"'&%'!%&&! !"#!, !!,":"'"

%! "+".<"'$23".%#%'!,"

.+2 .+A )>!  )*$ ''!:"<. '!"#!!,"3"!%!%'". 3"'&%' .2:"'"

%!& $$.#%'<!07"A %%% % !,"0'; : !%' 7 +".<"'$2 '$"&&%'07"&8 )D8!,"3".%# +%7%! .2&".9%$"%&!:"

$0'!"#8&0:;"$!!$'#%!%'&+"'!%'"#!,"."%'8-,%$, ."'! !!. $!"#%' !,"3."&"'!$ &" &!,"< 3:"!-""'!,"#%&$, .<" .+!,"+%7%! .2&".9%$"

'# 33%'!+"'!%'$%9%7&".9%$"%&+."!, ''"2" . '#!, !,"%& 7." #2 " .'%'<3"'&%' .+!,"+%7%! .2&".9%$"

> , 9"," .#!,"7" .'"#$0'&"7 .!,"3"!%!%'".8!,"7" .'"# 1! !"$0'&"7 '#, 9" 7&$ ."

0772<'"!,.0<,!,"$ &" ,"#%&30!"%'!,"3."&"'!$ &"%& &!-,"!,".!,"&".9%$" ."'#"."#:2!,"3"!%!%'".#0.%'< !%' 7+".<"'$2 .+ A )>!   )*%'!,"'#% ' .+2%&!:"$0'!"# & F0 7% 2%'<&".9%$" <. '! 3"'&%' .2:"'"

%!&= 07"A %%%  !,"0'; : !%' 7+".<"'$2 '$"&&%' 07"&8 )D8%&."3.#0$"# &0'#".( HA %%% "'&%'( ,"  3".%#    +%7%! .2  &".9%$"

+"'!%'"#%'$7 0&" %&, 77$0'!!- .#&3"'&%'I %'$ &"

 %.&!. '2&0:&"F0"'! 33%'!+"'!! '2&".9%$".3&! 0'#".!,"9".'+"'!8&0:;"$!!!," 77-%'<$'#%!%'&(

 ,"3".&'$'$".'"#&,07#'!, 9"" .'"# 3"'&%' 0'#".  +%7%! .2  .07"&  %'  ."&3"$!    !,"  +%7%! .2  &".9%$"  %'

F0"&!%'



'2:'0&.<. !0%!23 %#%'."&3"$! +%7%! .2&".9%$"

:2!,"#"

"'$" 0!,.%!2&, 77, 9"!:"."

0'#"#!!,"1! !"

9".'+"'!

> ,"3".%#8%  '2:"!-""'!,"# !" #%&$, .<" .+ +%7%! .2&".9%$" '#!,"# !"  33%'!+"'!! '2&".9%$".

3&!0'#".!,"9".'+"'!&, 77$0'! .3"'&%'83.9%#"# &0$,3".%##"&'!"E$""#'"2" . '23".%#"E$""#%'< '"2" .:0!'!"E$""#%'<!,.""2" .&+ 2 7&:" 77-"#! $0'! .3"'&%'%'"E$"3!%' 7$ &"&0'#".!,".#".& !,"

9".'+"'! II .9%#"#!, ! 3".&'-,, &:""'."7" &"# .+%7%! .2 &".9%$"'$+3 &&%' !"<.0'#&&, 77'!:""'!%!7"#! '2 $'$"&&%'&0'#".!,%&.07"J ,"3".0& 7 !,"& %#.07"&,-&!, ! .!,"30.3&"

3"'&%'8 &+" $'#%!%'& , 9" :""' 7 %# #-'  %' !," .07" ," %.&!

$'#%!%'%&!, !!,"3".&'&,07#'!, 9"" .'"#!,"3"'&%'0'#".!,"

A +%7%! .2.07"&8-,%$,<"& < %'&!!,"3"!%!%'". &,"%& 7." #2" .'%'< 3"'&%' .+!,"+%7%! .2&".9%$" ,"!,%.#$'#%!%'%&!, !!,"< 3 :"!-""'!,"#%&$, .<" .+!,"+%7%! .2&".9%$" '# 33%'!+"'!! '2 &".9%$".3&!0'#".!,"9".'+"'!&,07#'!"E$""#'"2" . "."8!,"3."&"'!3"!%!%'".- &#%&$, .<"# .+!,"+%7%! .2 &".9%$"'> *  '#;%'"#!,"$%9%7&".9%$" & "7 .".< '%B".'

 )%"7%!!7"7"&&!, 'G2" .& :"%'<#%&$, .<"# .+!,"'#% '

.+2!:"%'<&8 + !,"9%"-!, !!,"3"!%!%'".%&'!"'!%!7"# $0'!%'< ,%&&".9%$"8."'#"."#:2,%+%'!,"'#% ' .+2#0.%'< !%' 7 +".<"'$2 & F0 7% 2%'<&".9%$" .!,"30.3&" 3"'&%''#".07"

G

 !,"%9%71".9%$"&07"&8/70+"8!F0 7% 2 .!,"3"'&%'%'!,"

$%9%7&".9%$"8,"+0&!."'#".!,"+%'%+0+F0 7% 2%'<&".9%$"8-,%$,%'!,"

3."&"'!$ &"%& 2" .& '9%"- !," ."<%'<#%&$0&&%'8!,"3."&"'!-.%!3"!%!%'%& #%&+%&&"#

65 1   )*

) &;?& ,"!,".&3" ?%'<." &'"# ( "& ,"!,"."3.! :7" ( "&