Serco Bpo Pvt. Ltd v. Authority For Advance Rulings & ORS
!"# $% &' (")* +#,-./.*0# 1
! " #$% " &+ 23&
44 56 0 4 23&
4 43 &' "
"
" (
$ ) * +' ( " * ,' ) (" % * - .
!
$
/%
$
.
)
! )
"
0) /
" 1111 56 0 4 0"
2+23+2&4 (" #&5
+435
6 0 7 &89& :
;
<= >
" #+5
6 0 7
"
!
( (" #& +435
:4= 0"
>
7
"
( "
(
( "
$ > $
7 "
"
" #&
""
0 ""
$ $ " $ $
$ (
"
+ ,&23+2&& "
""
" 5
0
" (
"
2+23+2&4
""
( "
") (
(
> $
76 $
$
+435 :+=:
=
5"
(
" ( , '
"
> ( .
!
"" (
"
5
(
0
""
+43 :9= ( $
7 6 $ ""
$ 2,23+2&& 0
(
( " #& 6
( ( " < ""
6 (
" #& 0
$ ( " #&
"
""
" "
" ( " #& / "" (
%"
"
" '
"
(
$ ) ( ( / ( / 6 $
(
(
" ? 0 4 0"
$ "
+22&+22+
:@=
:
;
<=$ "
2+2A+224
! B "
:
=B5 :
;
!
<=$ "
&223+229
2&29+22C.
$
"
6
3 +C29+22C ""
$ (
!
? 6 :?6= ( ( "
A2D >
"
.
0 ""
"
!
$ "
0
"$
$ "" "" >
$
""
$ 7
(
6"
"(
$ ""
$> -5 F9
! "
# # # $%&'( )*( +(, -. / -
0
*2$3 )%%&'(((((("4) !
# -.# 5 # -. # 5 3+62+&'3 *((, 7 # -
0
1
*2$3 8 8)9) *32# # %((('( #
9:- ) !
# -.# 5 # -. # 5 6''2$(( '(, - /-
0
*2$3
9 5 1- ; )*%(34 "'+ <! #4 %(((3% #
9:- ) ! -.
99#
)=
0 ""
(
> $ ( 9 0 ?6 ""
+C2A+22C ()
!
$
(
,&2A+2&2
:@=
$
$
?6
""
$ ( "
(
( 7 ( $ "
(
$ "
"
$ (
$
$
"
$ (( 6
! 6
5&, ""
$ "
"
E
$
60 $ () 6
$ C ( &C28+22C
!
( ( 34C+2>
.
$
A2D
.
44C+2 +92++22A
!
( ( "
.
( ,&+3
A2D >
.
2C2C+22A
!
( ( .
94+3
(5( ! (. 6
!
$ C824D >
.
0 ""
?6 "
((
A 2&&2+2&2
:@=
" &+C3D .
!
+8+3$
!
99+8D 8 0 ( > "
,&23+2&&$ ( $
!
:@=
% " ?
"
:%? = . 0 B
" 566
:
&
+
,0
"
= "
:
" = " "
! "
" "
"
; < ( "
" 6
"
.
G
"
"
"
"
!
99+8D>
&+C3D>
.
( &422 +9842 "
0 > $ "
$ (
7
"
&2 H
,&23+2&& "
$ ""
" #&!
+43I:&= 60 7 &89&
$ > -5
F& < 7 > 1 >4 0) ? @! 8A! 0 ? @! 1
?- @! -. / -
0 # B
*6 %!
C # 9B
:
5 ? C9
@! 5- 2( '! 9B *23* ?
@!D ') < # # - # B
*6 %! C9
5 2( '!
5 B - *2$ 5
- D= 0
(
!
$2A2C+2&& &8&2+2&& && $ (
"
"
J6J5
-5 E
)F 1 B 5 F !E = F ! G)) GG GGG) GGG !
#
4
H 5 #
# #
5 4
5
I G)) GG GGG) GGG
)F *!
# 1
#
# 5 ) G)) GG GGG) GGG
)F *! /
# 5 1
5 # #
## 1
) '! 9 B
# 5 J
5
5
F ! # B
9 # KB
#4 ! ! - '%$4;H
I !
I ! 5
BKB
#4 ! ! - '%$4;
#4 ! ! - '%$4;
# J #4
#
#
5
J
J # ) 6!
#4 '! #
1
) %! <
5 #4 '! B
# # #
##
) $! /
#
#
)
F
#4 E
= #4 '! - '++
5 )
3!9
5 B
GG= &+ "
(
!
"
$
"
7
"
$
(
(
7
&830"
$
( "
7
(
( $
6
>
$ >
( >
7
&, 0 ( F
(
"
$
K :
;%0 <=( $6
0 ( $ 6
(
"
$
"
7 "
6 7 "$ 82 +4:= "
:
=
7 &894
"
$ (
6
B
" $ ( $ $ 0
"
%0 -5 E18
9:*-1/ :/98:1/;>:;9/;
910: * L L 9 1
5 # 1 -)
'L9B L*)9BB 5 1
! 4
! 4B
4B *23* %6 *23*!I ! B
1
!- B *23% & *23%!
EB=! GGG) GGGG GGG GGG
910: %4 L *)
1
E 1 -=
5 5 - # B #
) 9
E =# ) GGG) GGGG GGG GGG
*6L1 L*)7
#
'! 3 #B1 -5
) ') 7
#
#
# 5
1 - 1 -
#
B# # 1 - 1 -
# 5 5
! B # # B -) 6) ; 5
'!
#
#B# 1 - 5
) %) 7 # 1 -
*! '! 6! #B# -) $)
E = B
B
5 1 -)=
&4 0%0
' $
7
E
"
$
$
(
% 0 7 &&8 " %0 $
"
! "
$ ) "
'$
&3=
#9A+
,25,5&884 F
(
$
K "5,
-5 ! 1
#B 5 *)A') GGGG GGGG GGG)) 6)
% 5 B
B - 5
)
% # #
#B# B 5) 9
5## B B55 B# )= 0
7 $ ( "
$ $ $
:=
#CA8
&,24+222 "
-5
F1 ; )&+2*64%4'((( &6%) 1 B
4 C #9B
1 C9 1!) *) 9
4 C9 1 *2+6
?
@ # )
% C9 1 -
E 5 5 - # B #
)= ) 5
#
) 9 ?# B@ 9B 05 # 5C9 1) ')
*434*22& # #
5 B# B5# 4B *23*) M C9 1 B 5 # $, *$, B ) M 4B *23* B 5 # **$ )C # # B
) # 5 1 # 1 5 5 # 5
C9 1 ) 6) 9 # 5
) ) 5 5 #B#
% *6)= 0
$
"
65
%( 0 7 :%0 = &9 0 "
( (
"
$) 0(
5
"
"#9&3&9 &C'$
" !
-5
E3) < #
# ) #
5
# "
# B - )1
# C 5 # ) / # # B # 5
5
"
# B# # )
5#
B # 5
B ) # # ) < B
):
5
! '%$ '! 5# 5
) GGG)) *$)
5 5 # # 5 #
5 ) ; J
# 5 5 #
5 ) *3) 555 )< B 5 5 5 5 5
! - '%$ '!) B
B
5 5
5) 5
! #4 '! - '%$
#
#) *&)
5
J # # 5
B)<
5
J)= &C 0(
"
"59
"
$
(
L"
> (
( 0
( $ ! / $ $
>
"
( >
( $ &A 6
$
(
"
$
"(
" &8 0 ""
$ ,&23+2&& .
!
(
( :9= +43
"
$
$
7 "
""
' !
" (
" (
7 !
$ " (
0 " $ "
0 "
()
( " #+
60 7 "
" $/+2&+
+2&+$
( $
$ 0
$
( "
$ "
L
+C2A+2&+ "
"
""
(
$
0
$
"
(
("
+43 :4=
0 $
(
0$ "
+C2A+2&+
" 7 6 $
( 0"
(
+92,+2&,
(
""
( (
,&23+2&& ,&2&+2&+ +,2C+2&+ &42A+2&+6
>
((
$
( 0
" 60<
$
( "
(
" $ ""
0 "
"
"
" .
"
!
@
!
0 7
"
% #
(
"
@ ?6 ""
"
.
"
.
( !
>
.
"
$ "
$ "
( !
.
? $
(
"
+2&+ %( +2&, $ ( $
$ 0
$
28&++2&,0 "$ "
2+23+2&4 +2 "
!"
!
( (
" $
" $
"
""
%"
(
(
(
$
( ' ""
" 7 ( %"
%"
E
$
(
" $
$
! ""
+& 0
"
L $
7 6
0
( "
"59 "
"5&C 0
"
0 $ $
" "
0 5
( $
6
"
"
"59
"
L $
5
7 (
"
"
6
7
"
"$
$
(
7 (
!
$
""
"
7" 0 5
"
#
$
"
" "
$
""
"
7" $
0
" $ $ "5&9
" (
$
"
:
= (5 :+= +43
5"
(
" ( 0 $
$
(
' "
! /
$
$ !$ $ "
E
$
""
"
7"
> ' ! / $ $
> ""
.
!
"
$ $
> $ >
(
" "
++ 0
" $
$
"
L (
7 6
(
( +, ' $
" (
( $
(
"
('
: =
2424+2&+ $ "
"9&3&9 &C "0
" 0 " ( "
$
"
+4 0
!
( ( ( A2D >
"
" &+C3D
!
2&&2+2&2
"
/+22C
"
,&23+2&&.
( (
!
L
0
.
( 7 "
( " 0 > $
"
$
.
$ "
2&29+22C
""
?6(
!
"
$ +C29+22C0 $
/+22C$ $
$ "
6 $
,&23+2&&$
!
.
"
$
!
( ( / +22C
"
$ "
+2&&0
6
+3 '
" ( %"
"
'$
?
""
( $
7 0 ""
$ ,&23+2&&
7 <" 7"
,&&&+2&&0
( ( $ +2&& +2&4 0
$ "
(
"
(
$
5
>
#""$ ( (
+9 0 (
/ <(
( /
(
(
$ (
!
%0 ( $6
0 $
""
(
!
( (
( (
0 (
0
0
( (
(
(
"
0
!
>$
"
( "
"
7
+C 0
"
( "
60 7
&&8 "
( ) "
+A 0
> $
!
6 "
0 7
$
:@=
!
(
&2&++2&&00 7
$
( ( "
-5 F0J G6%G# G G 06?6 0G .0 #GB 60 0#G H 606HB50% :6 ( $
"(
6
%( 0
?
G
$
" 0 7 "
G
0 6 = 606G GM G 06?6G%00 .0 #GB 60 0#G H 606H B5 0%
"
&2 +229 "
7 "" 60 7 0
" +&/ +2&& +2 / +2&+ 0 ?( $ L5 B
: = ?% 5
K 0
( +8 " & ""
" $ (
!
(
0
(
(
+ %0
# CA8 7"
(
"
$
(
$ " ""
%0 0
(
!
$ "
(
6
$
>
(
" (
0
(
(
!
$
5& ,2 6
$
( "
6
"
(
#CA8
&&8 6 (
( " " ( 6
"
( (
( > ( 6
0 L
( $ $
"
(
$ (
"(
6 6
$
( "
(
(
(
"
(
$ (
( ! $
"( 6
(
&&8 ,& >
""
!
( "$ (
56
,+ .
!
<
" ""
82 $
6
(
:= 82:4=
" +2&25&& -5 "# $% # 5
#4 *!
# K # H
# # #
7
)= := 0?
+2&, ! ( +A2++2&, $
""
+2&,5&4
+& (
""
$ -5 F &
#
& ' () * ! GGGGG) #! GGGGG) ! #4 %!# :B * 5#4 # 4 E $! 9 #
#
#4 %! #
#
)= 0""( :3=$ "
$ (
#CA8 +222
(
$
"
$
(
$ "
""
%0 0
?
$ ""$ $
$ "
: = 0
"
2&2,+2&, ( ?
"
0 7
6
"
6
(
( ( $
# CA8 $
(
0
-5 "+
,
- .
() -.
$(.% ''(*6 1 # B
2( 4B 5 C # 9B
) -#4 %! 2( 5 # '(*') 9 #4
9B 1 91! # C9
) C9
N )9C9
5# # C9
) B
'(*'5
) 9 5
# 4B #4 $! 2()8 5 # 5 #
55 ) 8 5 #
#4 $! 2( 9B 1
# # # 9B )9
5
#4 $! 2() 9 9B 1
# 5# 9B 5 # 91 ) )&+2 *6)%)'((( # #5 ) 8 5 # B
# #4 $! 2( 5 # # 5 )=
! ,, ( :4= >
( 0 $ ( :3= > "
"
( " ( # ( " (
,4 0 > ?
+2&,
( ?
0 7
2&2,+2&, ?
+2&,
(
( (
(
( "
"
(
( (
"""
$
"
" (
!
$ (
,3 0
) "
! "!# $ % & '"
' $
(
)
$ >
$" "
$
$
(
% 0 7'
# 9A+
,22,&884 " (
(
:
F?66K=$ $
"
6
"
$
7"
!
"
(
$
( ()
7 6
6 +222 60 7
?66
" $ $ (
7 "
6
0( $ $ $
?66 $
F
"
K
"
"
$
"" $ 6
6 $
( "
$ (
"
$
6
$ ; <
(
%0 0
"
> $
$
(?66 6
0 ?
"
2424+222
$
!( 60 7
"
"
"
"
6
$
7 (
?66
(
"
#CA80
$
% $$
"
0 " 5 $ % >
$
E:%=:G= :=
$-5
! ! 1 # 9B
C9 1 9B
I 5 #
:
#
#
# 1C9) ! E9
= # 5
#) "
5
5
B 5
5 5 C # 9B
#5 )=
)
$ ( " 6
" ) % 6"
% " -5 "GGGGG)'+)
J #- 2( #
5 1 7
C # 9B
)<
5 5
5 5
9B ) <
5 5 ) 5
# B - %
- $ 5
E#J
=) 9
#J
5 5 # 1 7 - 2( 5
C9 155
9B # B B 5
C9 1) #9 5 5 5 8 1 N)
1 ; )&+2 5
4 ) 5 1 ; ) &+2 5 - 2(
# #4 '! - 2()
5
9B *23* #
C9 1 ) /GGGG)) ////// 9 # B
5
5 5 - 2(#1 7 C9 1 5 7 ) < #
#4 '! - 2(
5 #
C9 1 #
C9 1 5
9B *23* ,9 %
$
&&8 " "
( %0 &&8 (
"
"
7
"
6 $
$
"$ %0$ 0" -5 "981 9B
# # B 4J #
5 #
I # 9B
C9 1 9B
#J4 # 5 ) 0 6(464*22% 1C9 1 ; ) 3+' 5 #
5 ## B B5 5 B # ) 9 5
C9 155
- %$ 9B
*23*# - 2( *! ) 5 1C9 5 J E
= 1 ; )&+2 5 - **2 # #5 #
)91 ; )&+2 5 # # 5 5
)
# #
#
C9 1)
< 5 5
J # ) 5
1 ; ) &+2 *64%4'(((
- **2 ) J
5
1C9# #4 *! '! - **2 5
) GG
!=) 0 (
"
$ / < ( (
" " ,C ' " (
!
!
,A ?
$
/ (
7
(
" ( 0
$
0
"( ( $
"
0 6
(
$ 6 $ ( (
$
,8 4"
""
F
K "$
$
(
( 5
"
0 $ F
(
K
" (
(
7"
7 0$
7 " $
$
"
7 "
( "
7 (
> "
7
?
($
( ( ! 0 ( "
"
7"
"
7( G "
(
0 $F "$
$
K $
" $ F
(
K
( $ 4$
($
$ $ ! %0 $!
( ( 42 $ $
54 ;
< "$
$
(
(
"
0 F 6
K F
K
(
' "
> "
7 " "
$
(
$
%0 ( $!
( 0 !
$
7
7"
"
" $
77"
!6 " <( ( "
"
$ (
" "$ " > "
7
"
6 $
" $ (
( "
7 6
$ 7"
(
"
7
$ (
( "
7 6
$
"
7
6
( $
"
7 $
7 (
( 0 $
"( (
(
"
(
7
( $
7
("
(
7
"
( / (
&,:4="
$ ""
7
(
7 "
6 $ (
$
$
7"
$ " " 4& 0
( ) "
:" = 0 "
$
7" ;
(
< -5 EGGGGGGGG))
5
# I
I # B 9B ) 9 #
B 9B *23* B # #B C9 1) GGGG)) GGGG) # 7 - -
E# B = E B=) 9 # B #
# B
# #
B 5
-) K- #$ "% ) & *2&6! ++9*32H # # B
B # B# # B ) 9
9B
5 # B I = 5 C9 1)= 4+ 0 "
G 5"
% "
: G% = &8CC
""
$
$-5 E # #
# B 5 B -)= 4,
"
( (
7
0
&, 44
54 &, "
(
:
!
=
"" "
" :&= :+= :,= :
.
(
!
$
"
":&=:+= :,= &,
(
(
0
"" $
0 $ ;
"" < $ "
"
"
&839 0
( 60 7 &89& + %0 $ "
7
7 $ ""
6
7 "
60 7 &89& 43 0 $ ;
< (
0 (
"
"
"54 &,
;
< 0 $
E ;
<
0 "
.
(
!
(
"" "" "
" & + , &,
( ;
<
49 .
!
(
$ ;
"" < "
"4 &, >
(
"" 0
"
"#&+ , "#&+ , "
< "" "5&
( "" "
(
7
;
$ ""
<0 "
"
" 4
(
( "" 0$
""
6
"
"
""
"
"5+ &, (
7
0 $ ;
<
$
$ ( 6
""
"
"5+
6
7
"
"5, &,"
"
"
"
( "" "
"
"
(
(
$ "
"
0
7
"" ( "
" 0 "
"
"54$ ""
" 0 %0
"
6
(
7
6
$ > 4C /
""
!
(
"
$
> 0
0 "
%0
( 4A 0 ;
""
< $
$
( "
:" =
0
$ (
"
-5
9
#
5
5
#
5 C9 1 #5 )9 E
=# 1 #
) E9
= B
#
#5 5 -) 0 ;
#
5 #
? -@ # B
# #J # # =)K0 ; 905 9
)663 /B 1
*23*!)H
5 #
0 ; K& )H E
# 5 #
? -@# B
# #J # # I 4
1
5 B
B
B 5 5
# # #
5 5 ? -@=) #
55 - #
# C9 1#
#
) 5 5
'% 4M- 9
C # 9B 5
#J 5 # 9 # ) /
$(, #
$(, #
# 5 #
-)
'% 4M- C9 1 5 4 C9 1) 9
#
'% 4M-9 # 4 9
#
# ) 9
55 #
5
5 )9 ):
)9
# B
5
) 5
) < B # ) 9 1
C '( '")& K *2$6!*<0%+6 *2$6!* :3*$H 5
B
# # 5 #
E =)9
) 9 # 5
5
5
5) 5
C9 1 #
## - 2( 9B *23*
9B #
#
# ) 5
5
C9 1 # # 5
9B ) 5
# GGGG= 48 0"
$
"
$
" ;
""
< (
6
$ (
6 $ (
"
""
"" )
5
7
7
$
$!
"
6 "
""
7
"
0
!
$ !"
"
" 0 " (
)
""
(
"" ' $
"
" "
(
"
! $ ( > ""
( $
" (
32 .
!
$ $
$ $
$
6
6
$ +3&&+2&& " #+
()
(
""
>
2424+2&+
" "
>
(
7
(
(
+43 :4=
" ( "
(
" $
$ ()
$
>
(" "
$ ""
! "
6 $ (
"
$
"
(
""
$ 0
> $ " " $ ( "
7 6
+43 :4= 0 -5 F-#J #
5 '%$ '!
5 # )9
5# '%$ %! 6()(&)'(*'K .
!
< (
$
" $ ( ""
$
(
(
(
+43 :4= $ >
"
(
" "
"
$ $ >
""
$
$ +43 :4=
$ $ F
$> ( K0(
(
""
$
("
+43 :4= $
5
( 3& 6
" >
6
"
7$ "
( (
:@=
! B "
:
= B5
"
.
( "
0"
$
( $
7 " 0>
( "
(
$
:/BN6?% = 06# 6G?/H06 G :#%'6= /H%G #, # 1 ;
< Whether to be referred to the Reporter or not.
√ Yes.