Govind v. State Of Haryana
-1-
!
"
#
$$$$
% &'( ) *+
, -(
,
) *+ ,
.
#( ( -* ,
(
- *+ ,,+ !
"
/0( &(
&1
$$$$
0( #
2
& *
*
45 6 2 7
2+278+ 279+ 28 +
) +
&
* (
) &(+
#
5 + 45
& 3"
:;
;
<
#
**& =( . '
>
"
&(
&
# (# '+ '*"+ >
=(
:
& ('*
&
;
,>!
"
;
,+ 8 /
(
?( , 8@1+ 3
& 056 7,AB .2. B
-2-
**& C
&
& & -
*
#*
'
(
& C "+ 3 (
&
'3*
'3
=( . '
3*
0( ''
8 , 8 - .
= ) =
D'+
#
&
& ) = , 6 7 7
) = '
3*& >
=( :
; ' >
:
( + '
=( . '
&
('*
&
, 8 =
&
'
' , ( 3"
3'&
= '
*E& # ;
('*
& #
;
(
'> ;
3* # 3"
&
& :- "
3**
& -( ( "' ;
**& +
' 7>+
0+ 3"
0( D
*
3'
+
' 45
3'
' 7> -(( 3
0+
"
'
(*
,'
&
'
(*
,'
-((
3' +
"
8
( **
"
-3-
"
3 '
*
*
' &
*=
'*"
(-
#
"
* (&(*&(
"
' 0 # ;
(
"
-(( 0
-(
-
"
' 0
'
"
3'
*"
&( 3 '#* *
' (*
&+ ,'
F( (#
+ *"
"
8+> '
-((
'*"
*=
-(
**&
D
*
* #
F &' + 3"
)( (
7 *
G
F &'
!"
$%
' '#*
* ' ( * ' "
*
0(
* # "
& F &'
# 3*-
G
! " " #"#"
!$%!%#&'%#( )' %
!"%!%#!*%!(%#"%*&%
-4-
*%&!%&
* + '
, -% ) .,
, /
, / 0 / -, / # ,%!.$""/ / !((.,, - 1
-
,
/
%
/
, 2 ,
/
-
#& "$ #"#"
-
,
/
1 ,
3
1
+ #& "$ #"#" , 40 G+ 0!(
/
, ,1
,
,
! #"#"
!$%!%#&0'%#( ) ' % !($
, -%) ., 5 ,
,
,
, /
,
, / 0 /-, / 1
-5-
# ,%!$""/ / !(( ,,- 1
, ,
, / , /
,
/ , , 1 /
-
/
, /
,
, ,
2
-
, ,
,
- 1 / , / 6
1
1
, /
/
!"
#"#"
,
, % 7 , , %)'8 %6
7 -, %
3
1
1
9
1
+ + , % , ,
/
,
9
1
:,
,%3
1
-, ,
,
# :, % , - 3
, ,
:, , ,
-
,
-, , ,
- , - ,
-6-
, - 5
%
-
,
, 0
/ ,
/
, :, /
-, , ,
, 1
;
1
, 3
1
%
,
, / 61
, ,
%
,
,1
1
, / 0 / < 3
,
,
'
(
) + $)
,--
* .
-,
, 1 -,
1
, -
$ ) ' -
,
, /
#$ =1 '
'
/ /
, - ,
#$ =1 '
/
*& )'
/
)'
1 -
%
- 3
-7-
/ #& "$ #"#"%-
, /
,
, /
, +
- 1 % ,
,
3
1
-, 2
1
+ , ,
#
>
< (
+ *
* 3'
+
#
( - +
,
3'
# (# '
=( :
& =
& '
=
+ ( + #& '
'
7>
3'
' (*
&+ ,'
F( (#
-( '#*
D
*
* 3' =(
. '
=-*&
3
*"
3
3' -
45 -((
&
&
= '
& -( ' && # ;
0+
# '
**
D
*
3'+
'
, 5 6# &(+
*( &( + ( **
-8-
3' 3 - ;
'
( + ## *
##*
D
*
3
3' (
* & ' **
-+ ' &
' #
#
' (*
,'
+ ("
- *& -(
#
( )
'
'
(
-+ -( # &
"
*& -(
( + '
' *"
"
&
"
&&+ ( '
(*
,'
&+ ' (
# -( =
3 # ;
# ' '
#
& &*"+
# '
( +
* ' (
=
# ;
3 (*
,'
-(
= # ;
+ ( + -(
3*( *=
*( &( *& **"
'3*
#+ (
* (*
,'
3 '
"
3'
**"
'#*
** '>'*
**&
+ (& *=
-9-
* #
# "
* 3"
)( (
*
& *
* 3"
)(
3'
*
+
"
(
D
*
* #
F &' !@3* ' *
,)$
/'
$
#
01
.2+
*
-((
( *
*
' *"
* (
' + -(
&(
3 '#* (
* '*
-( 3&
"
*= 3*(&
"
;
3"
0(
3'
*
*
, # 45 - * (-
' '
#
'
7> -(( 3
' 0 +
"
# 3"
(*
,'
&+ -(
# -( = 3 # ;
0(
&( 3 '#* ' (*
&+
,'
F( (#
0(
*
# ' (*
'#* &
# 3*-
-10-
?@@@0000@@@0000
/
$ 3
, /
/ 9/ /
,
,
, / / % ,/%8
,/ )
, < :,
1
-
, % -
, /
,
$ 4 ( $ '5
- $
$4
-
$)
" / < ' :3
7 6) < '9
$"#"""##&*$""!9:3 ; 6) <' . '9
$"#""""*!*$*&9 )
1
5 6) <' .'9
$"#""""$*$9 ' ; < <' . '9
""""""&*(#((* , 1 / 6) <' .'9
$"#"""!$("($ @@@0000@@@0000@@@ ' $ 7' - $
$) ) +
) ++ 2+829: -
";,';*'+ - $
$ -$ $% < '1 " -
-$ 4 $ %> , #
3 - * (- (*
=-*&
*& -(
#
( ) - *
6(&
-(
(- =-*&
!-
3C *"
("
"'
-11-
&
&( 0
#
#
( ) '
(
0( +
(
*& -
+ ' - *"
-(
#
( )
-(
##
'
'
' # ;
= 3"
('
"
#
'
' *
' -((
##
'
&
#
3= -((
45
-(( *
6
0 '*
' ,'
&+
* # -((
# 3*-
?@@@0000@@@0000= $
) 3 , /
A
, / ,/% 8
,/ )
,< ' % ( $ $
$
3 "
-
$)
- , / ,
/ '/
7 6) < '
$"#"""##**##$% 8 ;B 6) < '
$"#""""*!*#% , 1
: ;
1 5 B< < '
##!($(!$
, , :8 @@@0000@@@0000@@@ 7 1 /
1 /
:;
/
#%"(%**%&# / #(%%&*90
-12-
%
/ #%(%!!%(90 ,
, 8:
> F( (#
#
( #
-( '
*
0(
* # ' F( (#
# 3*-
?@@@000@@@00' , //
) / #"!% ,
,/
, / ,1 / ,
/
,1 , , & <
/%
-, ,,
/ ? 3 ,, C %
& /
%-, ,1 / / , ,
/
% 8
,/ ,1 1 /2 / - , -,
,
/ > /
- ,/
, ,
8
-, - 1 ,1 / /
%
-
@@@000@@@> '
#
3+
##
'
*&
"
5 + '
+ (
"
8+>+
(
*=
*
0(
& '
*
*
-13-
+
"
& & (+ ,'
(*
-(
# -( = 3 0 #
;
'
-('
"
'
C ( * '
"
+ -&("
& ' '
"
(- ( - &
"
' 0 (
' 0
**&*"
"
#+
( (& 3
'
*
-&(
#
# 0 ,+ 8 - * (-
-(
' ;
' + ( '
&E 3*
3 * 3*
-(
' ;
* +
+ - * 3 * 3*
3'
*( &( 45
&
2+278+ 279+ 28 +
) + &
**& -(
# 0+ -(( - * 3 & 3"
8 ,
* (&(*&(
- * '
3
- & ;#
# &&&
"
& "
3"
"(& (-
(
(
' # ;
( + 3'
- * 3 *
*
0(
& '
"
3 3*
-((
3 *= -(
**& '
A(
# (
+ ('
& ' *
*
-14-
'#*
'>'*
**&
+
- * 3
*
'
& '
##
'
+
# "
*
3"
)( (
* # F &' 2 29
*
5(
$%
#
3*-
?
,
#( "* "!
#"!(
#"%*&%*%&#% !#"0< %
,
<,%
% )
E,
/
,
%
- ,
## "# #"!(40 ?5 ,
/
%
-
, /
=; :;
+ %
<1
, , % %
1
%
)
,<
, /
-, , / 2 / , % 4) $ 4$
) - $ -$ >7
/ '
; 0
0$ 5 , /
, -
,
4 $ ) / )
,<
,
-
, ,
-15-
8
% ,
, /
/
,
3
1
, , 79, <3 =
1
+ > 5 ,
/
, %
, 3
1
2 ,
1
5 %
/
/3
,%,
,
,
/ 2 ,
1
1 - , 1 % ,
-
/
,
1 ## "# #"!( / 3
,
# >
* 3' ' !!"#$"%!
$&$"+ *
'()*+, - .
./ (0
2+
& *
*
3"
( 3"
)( (
0(
# 3*-
?:, /
, , , 1
/ +F )0!(
,
#& "* "!
#"!(
#"% *&% *% &!% #"! !#"0<
,
<,%
-16-
,
8
-
,
/79 = %
:, /
-40 ?C
,
,
, /
, / 8
1 :; ' % #"!&
, % &5 ,4& 6
1 :;' %#"!&
,  ,4& :,
,
C
, , ,
, /
/
1
;
:
1
, /
H /
#-
1
/
C
, :,
, / - ,
!"
, 1 / #"#"
, - * , /
-, , ,
- -, , / - 2
1 / , > 7 C/ < %
7 7
% '1 , , /
,
,
/ /
%
,
,
, //
1 8: / AA /
,
, 1 / ,
-,
-17-
,
, //
5 % , /
/ 0 ,1 - , ,
!( " #"#! #( "* #"#!
, , 7 81 C
% ' '
6 ,
,
, /
1
8: / AA / -
,
,
/
-
/ ,
1 - ,
/ ,
'/
% ,
/
, /
C
, ' $ - %
$ % $ - 44 $
$
- $ 4)) 4
) $ %
%
44 7 1 % , ,1 - , :,
, 7
1 - !( / %
1 - ,
/
,
- , '
% ,
,
, C 7 9) 7 %
-18-
- 1 %
/ ,
1 ,
,
;
, /
) >
* 3'
"
(
+
& *
*
,)$? / #
1+ !@3* ' (*
?' 1 , 6 , %/
, /
% , / ,
3
, - %
, ,
, ,
,
-, , , , ,
, / ,
- / , 3
, >
.#& -
3
'
' +
"
8
"
-+ -((
;
'
*=*"
= '
' 0
"
'
(*
,'
' # ;
*
' 45
*
3 3* >
& '
-(( * 3
3+
*( &( ' - *
3 **"
F # *+ (
**-
#
& *
*
-19-
, &*"+ #
**-
3
* * ( (& *> "
3
> "
&
3F ('
3&
C
"
(
However, nothing stated above shall be construed as a final expression of opinion on the merits of the case and the Trial Court would proceed independently of the observations made in the present case which are only for the purpose of adjudicating the present bail application.
/3./45/ "6$&$" #
A((
# =&>
H>6
A((
# 3* H>6