High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19315/2011dismissed

Anita Puri v. Industrial Tribuanl & Labour Court & ORS.

2015-01-06Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan6 pages

#! $%&' ()%

*&%&%+$*) *),(, $-(,&)%'.)%/($'.0'/+()+()&!$%+$*))%&+)1 2'$-%3')2'$-+&2*),

*,4+$-*$&, 5

6 5

6 )*,*$&

)*,*$&

) '33'!-7+8'&*9+)&2*4*&%&%+$*) )

'$&+,2 2'):'!-7+8'&*9+))*,4+$-*$&,'$- ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ! ! ! ! 2*%$,&'$&4*&%&%+$%,-%)*8&*-'3'%$,&&2*'=')--'&*- "

!$$*>()* !4',,*-/1&2*$-(,&)%'.)%/($'.58(:5 '/+()+()&! !2'$-%3')2=2*)*/1&2*)*9*)*$8*2',/**$ '$,=*)*- %$ &*):, +9 '=')-%$3 ' .(:4 ,(: 8+:4*$,'&%+$ +9 ?!@5&+&2*4*&%&%+$*) *')$*- 8+($,*. '44*')%$3 9+) &2* 4*&%&%+$*) =+(.- ,(/:%&&2'&&2*=+)A5.'-1@4)*,*$&4*&%&%+$*)2'-/**$*$3'3*- /1 &2* '$'3*:*$& +9 &2* )*,4+$-*$& B 2)% ()( ')A%,2'$ +-*. 82++. ', .*)A = * '$- 2'- 8+$&%$(*- &+ ,*)7* &%.. =2*$ 2*) ,*)7%8*, =*)* &*):%$'&*- %$ -*)+3'&%+$ +9 &2* 4)+7%,%+$, +9 *8&%+$ 5 +9 &2* $-(,&)%'.

%,4(&*,8&!" C9+),2+)&6&2*8&6D &2',/**$')3(*-&2'& '.. &2)+(32 2*) ,*)7%8* &*$()*! &2* 4*&%&%+$*) 2'- =+)A*-

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

*')$*-8+($,*.2','.,+',,*)&*- &2'&&2*'44+%$&:*$&.*&&*)-'&*- ! >2%/%&!','.,+ 8+41+9)*,+.(&%+$+9:**&%$3+9&2* >*8(&%7*+::%&&**+9&2* '$'3*:*$& '..*3*-.1 2*.- +$ # "! >2%/%& ! %$ 4(),('$8*&+=2%82&2*,*)7%8*,+9&2*4*&%&%+$*)=*)*&*):%$'&*- ')* 9'/)%8'&*- -+8(:*$&, '$- =*)* F(,& '$ '9&*)5&2+(32& *')$*- 8+($,*. 2', '.,+ ')3(*- &2'& ' 9%$-%$3 2'7%$3 /**$ )*&()$*- /1 &2* '/+() +()& ', )*3')-, $+$58+:4.%'$8* +9

*8&%+$+9&2*8&!)*.%*9+9)*%$,&'&*:*$&=','$*8*,,')1 8+$,*G(*$8*!4')&%8(.').1!A**4%$3%$7%*=&2*.*$3&2+9,*)7%8* &2'&&2*4*&%&%+$*)2'-)*$-*)*- *) 8+$&)'! .*')$*- 8+($,*. '44*')%$3 9+) &2* )*,4+$-*$&5'$'3*:*$& 2', ,(/:%&&*- &2'& ' :**&%$3 +9 &2*

>*8(&%7*+::%&&**+9&2*'$'3*:*$&=',2*.-+$# "

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

*')$*-8+($,*.9+)&2*4')&%*,2'7*/**$2*')-'& .*$3&2'$-&2*4.*'-%$3,+$)*8+)-2'7*/**$4*)(,*- &%,$+&%$-%,4(&*&2'&&2*4*&%&%+$*)2'-=+)A*-',' $+$5&*'82%$3,&'99+9&2* 82++.% * +$&2*4+,&+9.*)A9)+:

&%.. .'%:+9&2*4*&%&%+$*)%,&2'&,2*2'- /**$4)*,,()%E*-&+)*,%3$,+',&+'88+::+-'&*,+:*+&2*) *:4.+1** '$- %& %, &+=')-, ,(82 (.&*)%+) -*,%3$ &2'& &2* '$'3*:*$&2'-&*):%$'&*-2*),*)7%8*, +&2*8+$&)')1!&2* '$'3*:*$&&++A,&'$-',)*3')-,'/+.%&%+$+94+,&%$G(*,&%+$ *9+)*&2*'/+()+()&!*7%-*$8*2'-/**$'--(8*-%$&2*,2'4* +9 >2%/%&, ! ! ! " '$- =2%82 )*9.*8&*- &2'& &2* 4*&%&%+$*)2'-:'-*8*)&'%$*$&)%*,%$&2*,&'&%+$*)1'$-($%9+): )*3%,&*),)*.'&%$3&+&2*1*'),&+ (82*7%-*$8*!

($-+(/&*-.1!.*$-,8*)&'%$':+($&+98)*-*$8*&+&2*8+$&*$&%+$ )'%,*-/1&2*.*')$*-8+($,*.&2'&'4')&9)+:-+%$3&2*:'%$ =+)A+98+..*8&%+$+9,82++.82')3*,=2%.*2+.-%$3&2* 4+,&+9

.*)A! &2* 4*&%&%+$*) =', '.,+ -%,82')3%$3 '--%&%+$'. -(&%*, )*.'&%$3 &+ &2* =+)A +9 ,&'&%+$*)1! /++A, '$- ($%9+):, +9 &2* ,82++.82%.-)*$ *&2'&',%&:'1!&2*&*,&%:+$1+9'$'3*:*$& =%&$*,,'):%& %$32!*'82*)!!=+(.-/*8)(8%'.=2+2'- -*4+,*-&2'&&2*=+)A+9,82++.82')3%$38+..*8&%+$2'-/**$+(&5 ,+()8*-&+ 1$-%8'&*'$A%$')82"!,&'&%+$*)1=+)A=', +(&5,+()8*- &+ @, (A*,2 '4*) +$7*)&+),! '))'$3*:*$& +9 /++A, &+ ,&(-*$&, =', +(&5,+()8*- &+ @, '-'$ ++A 2+4!

2'$-%3')2 '$- *7*$ &2* =+)A ', )*3')-, ($%9+):, &+ &2* ,&(-*$&,2'-/**$',,%3$*-&+@,'82%&'):*$&,! *8&+) !

2'$-%3')2 >2%/%&%,&2*8+41+9)*,+.(&%+$+9':**&%$3+9 &2* >*8(&%7*+::%&&**+9&2*'$'3*:*$&+9&2*)*,4+$-*$&5

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

'$-':+($&%$9%3()*',?"#@5 '$'3*:*$&=%&$*,,%$ 2%,-*4+,%&%+$'-:%&&*-&2'&%&=','8.*)%8'.*))+)'$-'$':+($& +9 ?"#@5 %$8.(-%$3 %$&*)*,& 9+) &2* -*.'1*- 4*)%+- =', -*4+,%&*-%$&2*'88+($&+9&2*4*&%&%+$*)+$# 2* 9%$-%$3',)*3')-,$+$58+:4.%'$8*+9 *8&%+$5+9&2*8&2', *7*$+&2*)=%,*$+&/**$',,'%.*-/1&2*'$'3*:*$& 2%,+()& =+(.-4)+8**-/1&'A%$3,(829%$-%$3&+/*=*..59+($-*- I 2*+$.1%,,(*&2'&)*:'%$,9+)8+$,%-*)'&%+$%,',&+ =2*&2*)&2*4*&%&%+$*)=',*$&%&.*-&+&2*)*.%*9+9)*%$,&'&*:*$& &%,/1$+==*..,*&&.*-&2'&&*):%$'&%+$+9'=+)A:'$ 2'7%$3/**$9+($-%$8+$&)'7*$&%+$+9 *8&%+$5+9&2*8& =+(.-$+&*$&'%.'(&+:'&%8)*%$,&'&*:*$& 2%.*8+$,%-*)%$3&2* 4.*' +9 )*%$,&'&*:*$&! 7')%+(, ',4*8&, ,(82 ', $'&()* +9 '44+%$&:*$&! '7'%.'/%.

%&1 +9 4+,&! '7'%.'/%.%&1 +9 =+)A! %$%&%'. '44+%$&:*$&/*%$3 ',4*)(.*,@,&'&(&+)14)+7%,%+$,!.*$3&2+9 ,*)7%8*'$--*.'1!%9'$1!%$)'%,%$3&2*%$-(,&)%'.-%,4(&*=+(.- 2'7*&+/*A*4&%$:%$- *9*)*$8*%$&2%,)*3')-:'1/*:'-* &+')*8*$&(..*$82-*8%,%+$+9&2%,+()&%$ + "+9 !&%&.*-',J($%8%4'.+($8%.!%$' '3')!*2,%.0%,&& !

($%8%4'.+($8%.!%$' '3')!*2,%.0%,&& !

()-',4() 7 )*,%-%$3 99%8*)!'/+()+()&!()-',4()'$- ()-',4() 7 )*,%-%$3 99%8*)!'/+()+()&!()-',4()'$- ()-',4() 7 )*,%-%$3 99%8*)!'/+()+()&!()-',4()'$- ()-',4() 7 )*,%-%$3 99%8*)!'/+()+()&!()-',4()'$- '$+&2*)K '$+&2*)K '$+&2*)K '$+&2*)K!-*8%-*-+$ "

7*$&2+(32&2*4*&%&%+$*)2'-,*)7*-9+)'4*)%+-+9 '.:+,&&*$1*'),','$+$5&*'82%$3,&'99!/(&,(82'44+%$&:*$& '$-,*)7%8*&*$()*=',%$&2*8'4'8%&1+9'&*:4+)')1*:4.+1** +41+9&2*'44+%$&:*$&.*&&*)-'&*- ! >2%/%&!'.,+ %$-%8'&*, &2'& &2* '44+%$&:*$& +9 &2* 4*&%&%+$*) =', 4()*.1 &*:4+)')1'$-,2*=',&+8+$&%$(*&+)*:'%$'$-,*)7*','

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

@5G('$&%9%*-/1&2* '/+()+()&%,+$&2*.+=*),%-* +$8*-*-.1!&2*4*&%&%+$*)2'- ,*)7*-9)+: &%.. $:17%*=!&2**$-,+9 F(,&%8*=+(.-/*,(/5,*)7*-(4+$8+:4*$,'&%+$+9?.'8,/*%$3 '=')-*-%$9'7+()+9&2*4*&%&%+$*) )-*)*-'88+)-%$3.1 (82 *$2'$8*-':+($&+98+:4*$,'&%+$+9?.'8,/*)*.*',*-&+&2* 4*&%&%+$*)=%&2%$'4*)%+-+9*%32&=**A,9)+:&+-'1!9'%.%$3=2%82 &2*,':*=%..

(&9+),(82:+-%9%8'&%+$%$&2*%:4(3$*-'=')--'&*- "

! $$*>()* ! &+ &2* *>&*$& +9 *$2'$8*:*$& +9 8+:4*$,'&%+$9)+:?!@5&+?.'8,!&2*'=')-%,'99%):*-'$- &2*=)%&4*&%&%+$%,-%,:%,,*- C D C D C D C D #! #! #! #!

+&*

2*&2*)&+/*)*9*))*-&+*4+)&*)N *,@ + 2*&2*)&+/*)*9*))*-&+*4+)&*)N *,@ + 2*&2*)&+/*)*9*))*-&+*4+)&*)N *,@ + 2*&2*)&+/*)*9*))*-&+*4+)&*)N *,@ +