← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5304/2006allowed

Duni Chand v. Ramesh Kumar And ORS.

2024-10-16Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma14 pages



     

      

 !

"#

!$%&%"'( $ ")!*  

+'% ,'-

......//!00'

1&.

2!&, 3+2* '- " ,!*&

......!&/"'-!' & ( 4 5 6.

6 6  6  

   

   



  !

   

 " 

#!

      

 $%& ' %%%% 6  6

.

5 " (   

     )    *

      $"+,   -   !

. ",,    /   "0++)1     

'

- ()!

. 2    3   ()!

34     -

   -  *

      -

5

 6  

6  ()    -

  -   

 "" )!

0"-     *     

!-   6   -  * *   ! ' - 

* 7!  - 1 ) **   #''%$08,-   * - 1         

 9

1    -    ) ** 

:#%%;%0<"2 

=  * 64--   ) *  1  * *

1  >*>*-

 )1  

"(  *  - 1  !  

   !

     %  *

 - - 1   !

 

! (

 !

 -!

  ! *! 

!      )--

 ) : - *

1?- )1   @ !  *:-) . :- -

  -"" $":  !       !  ! *:- !

  -

  *  !   ! *     -: 

!*-!

 

 -

 $ A    -    

  

 !-

5-   ;-      *            7  ()!

 -   

 * ! %     

 

         

   

 

    

!" 

  



 #

     $%&&  '     (         

) #) ## $%&

*

                 

 ( #(

) #)( 

#(($%&& *  ( (

$%&



+     # #   $%&

" 

  

  

 



  (# 

$%&

,

 # <    *

    *    

   ()!

-   !

# "5%  * 

 B8CD

!-:   -

5

    

   -

- )1 ()!

 6 666   656 , (     !

      -

%

 

    - )1   ()!

    :!  

 % 4

   )  1  E?; -

 )  1  

!     ?

<+D 4

 - *

- ?    

*    ! *



*          4

 -!

 *

!

!   (    1      

   )  

    -  !

)     8 

  !

   

%& ! '- 1 -

1*!    *

1)    -!

-    )1   ()!

 *

1) *

 + &  !

    !      

0 !          )  1  E?;-

 )  1 

!     ?

<+D ;!  - *

- ?     *     ! *



*         

-!

 *

!

!   !

   *

  

   -  )   # <5%-



   - -!-*  )!



 .

:1   F!  !

*   '!  65

57  6 " : 6)   .!-  '!    

      * *  *

  -      )  1(?'!    8 3+2* 1&.

89 3+2* '- '" ,!*

  6+/*!2!

"+* &!&     !

 %            "- #./

'

)!0012'

2#3 ( 4               (    )  

  (    

 )5  )#

   (   

- #  

 (  ( 4 ##   #    #  ( 

)

 # )  

  (

-      

(  

5  #(

     # )(   #  #

  

  )

  '      #



) #

 ##    #  

 - (      

  #

   # #)

    (  (



    #

 )



    (      

   16786 (

9-8  4  )'9

!:6(7*:,) ;  

&7 19

< )!!"13677""

= 4 )!:'7+,:3 , - 



   



  #

>       3  ?5    

     ( )     @  )  (

)    )  

# )

(  5



3<# 

1



3



    (   

 ) (

> 1 3<# 

 

 # ( A 13<## 



 #(

  

3    (

  5   

 

  (   1B   ; ( 3 3; ( #

)##



 (     #

  13<# (

1

C# #(  3 1 3<#5   # #1

# (   3 

 

 )       

 1 3)1

31 3

1 39  

  #

)  

#

(



  



#  ( )     

 #  1

313)1

3)13

1 3 

## 



   # (

  )  # (

  5 )    # (

  1

C    #     #  (  3 

   # 5   # #     

   

 ! 3'

 1(

   

#(

 3)   

# 

 



3-  #(

   #   #  )

 (   ##  

  

  -     

## )        #    #  

 

  (   #(

  15 

 # )-     # 

)     ## 

 

   (   #(

  3

3-  



( 5 (

 (   5 # (

  

  

 

  5 #(

  -#  

 

 (

      -   # 



  3- ((

  ( 

##    ## 

 



##  ) 

 

## )

  ) ) 

 #  "#$ 

 %

%%  

 & 

%  

%  

:

'

 ()( >-

 ) 4( )   * 

 

 *C (   (#

'; 2 

)(

  # (    #

 ,D

  (

         #    *D  -    #   

  

    -   "D   #

)   (



(( )

   7    #   #>  3'

 

(#

> *,)C  3<## 



( 1"D# 

 

(3>  "+C 

3.   

 #  >:

3<## 

>1"+5:3>

!)0C '

 (*(>-

       * ) 

  *C (  

 ( 

 (

  

   ,D (

 #(         #

 ((   4

 # )    4   - -  #   ## 

 

 :"D 7    #   #> 3'

 

( 

> *,)C  3<## 



( 1:"D# 

 

(3 >  :C 

3.   

 #  >:

3<## 

>1 :5:3> +)"!)C '

   (+( >  - 

     "    

  #

    ?





 ' #

) 

( #

;

( )  

  ( 

   ##  -(

 (     :D'

  



    

      #    #)## 





     :D-   #   #> 3.

((

 

(   #  (   ?



 > ,)C 3<## 



( 1:D#5 

 

(3 > +

3.   

1 " 3  >0

3<## 

>1+ 503 > :)",)C E  >  -  #   

    1'3 

 1=3   

-# 

9  173   

  4 #(

'

8( .

 1 3F "" : 6) .!-'!   , '  + - .



/0 < : 

6

;=    !

 . ",,",$% ",+   /   "0++ 

 *  

% 24 !           *  ?      - -!

  G 2H4 .  -!

   * * G 2'4 *  )   1 *-!

 G 24 #  )   *!     

    - 1         !- !

 ?    

>

2E4 ;!

!  

 *    

*  -

)G  %- 1?  1 ( 

   !*-

 ! !

 % I -#)

4 (# 5  (9 (   #    )

()# )#  (

#  5      "))  +) 

")    -

#





  

=  #



 (





4   

   (     #        

 

  (    # D

  #   

            

 

  

    #    G " : 6) .!-'!    1  .

 1&

$+- "#"#)+2"34   !

 % H:-   

   5 (

> 

 %  %(5( 

%(6(A - #

 #(      # #    * 

  (

   7( < (  & 6

%) :'7I

:16739   +,#

 ( )7   =  ##  ## ( (  (   (

 

   # 6   /(  16(3

 %  ;

- 7 

'

) !'7I !016739  



#"

" )(   202   # 



5 #

   - #

  

     #  

  6   7 

)  )   (   

       (        

     #     202

2:2   -

 %     

  % 

   

 

   %78     #    #

)          (

      



I 

   .  J  %)  0'7I   1673 

 6

 8  ';

J'

) :'7I!:!16735 



I 

1 3

  0> K09  

    



  

(

'

(## (  ( 

  



     # -   # (  ( )#

  > &

)##



 ( 

#(

A

<#

(



#

(A

-

 #

(   (  #    (

A 3 .

5 



 

((    

 4

#A

13 <#5   # #K E(   F



- #



   (  @

    ( ) 6

8   1 3

  (  (  



      ##

(  #  (

   ##

 #   # ) #5 (



     #

)        (  C   @     0

#   (# L #('  I   *- #

    

> K, % >

(

#  ##(

#  ## (

(

#   # ( 3 # * )+J"(   

13   

#  #( 1 #  ##( 1

#  #      

5   

  

 #  )       #

6  7    (    

   =   ( )    # (

 #

  # 5  )    

  *#6

8   1 3     

    (    ( )  #     



 (  

  # 

           4



    ))   #   (

  # 

 #



    # (  

  #   4

(

   *D-  #

# (   # (

  9  7<  1 3)(

#

   ,1

3)



 #  )  "D#    

   $ 





 

 

  

   

"8  # #

)    

 

  

 # 

!D

 #

  ( 





I 

M

1 3%    )  

)   

     #

  (  #

!D



 

    7 +0,+-9'0, 0-# #

 

 



)   #   )  

  "#  )      #> :

)  <  #   

   !)0)!:0C



+),+05 5*C      1"  

+)!)!0!C

.

5 



  

 )

 ( )

0)+,)0,+C

<  #  (  (

 

"))C

<  #  (#)    # (



(    

)")C

&

##



 ))C

- 

+),!)0*C

-   ))   #

+),!)0*C   (     (

  #!D 

(#( # 

  # (  5 "$ &  )  

  

 * 1   

       )1: 6) .!-'!  -

 )  

% -

     



   -

-!

  !

) 

6*.

".

!-& "2/!'& %"'

?*-!- "

& - # <5%  7 !

!  2<D4 # ,<5%2<D<4 $ 

! & - # $8<5%2$"<J"4 7 !

!  *

!-2<+D4 # "8<5% <

!

 2"$4 # +8<5%2"8<J"$4 ,   .! *  # "5% . 

# <5% +

 ? # $88+<5%



(  * # 5% " 



'* # 5% ""

7 -     # "5% " " 0 "2/!'& %"'

&.@;@A 2"+'

?*-!- )9 ,!

*%)+'0 &.

@@A ','$!- 2"+'

&.@:@A " .  

       )1: 6) .!- '!   

; *.

  

. >  :

<. 0

 .$ , $  + 

6+/*!2!

"+* &!& :@

-!

  !

 

1 

 B0D 

!--    *  -   

  >  "< (& ! '- 1       -!

 * 

   ()!

   -

 -    1   !*-

(()!

    )!   - 



% -

  ) !

(

% -

    !   ) !

   ()!

 ",    * 1 "8  *   1    

6  6 

 

$ ")!*  @

   9   *5  %  * . *   9  )   K 5