D.R. Chandla & ORS v. Union Of India & ORS


 

       


   

          

 

         

  
     !" !#" !$%&'!(!)"* +%,&-!#!.+#"!&/)" !&/'!*"0 !*



  1   



        !2#/".!"/"/+)!#* 34!*+%' "5+#6%3* /)'+5" !/(.%')!& +#&!#  &3"!&  7  .3**!&  -8  !)"#3,  &(/)/*"#3"/4!  #/-%)3,

3)&/'3# !)9 #!$!9"/)'" !/#.,!35+# /' !#'#3&!.38+5
7:;
5#+(
7;
 "+  **/*"3)"  !)"#3,  )"!,,/'!)9!  55/9!#
  <
=  +5 )"!,,/'!)9!%#!3%<=3)&*%/"3-,! /' !#.38-3)&3)& /' !#'#3&! .38"+**/*"3)" !)"#3,)"!,,/'!)9! 55/9!#
<
=2!5:   !.!"/"/+)!#*#!"/#!&5#+(3*
< =/)" !.38*93,!

+5
:
&%#/)':"+ !.+*"+5!9%#/"8**/*"3)"%)/+# )"!,,/'!)9! 55/9!# #3&!
%)/+#)"!,,/'!)9! 55/9!# #3&!

 3)&  
  -!,+)'!&  "+  >!9%"/4!  93&#!  2 !#!3*  " !  .+*"  +5 **/*"3)"*;!#*+)3,**/*"3)"*-!,+)'!&"+1/)/*"!#/3,93&#! ? " 3*-!!)*%-(/""!&-8" !2#/".!"/"/+)!#*" 3"" !#! 3& 3,238*-!!)3.3#/"8/)" !.38*93,!*+5 *
3)&**/*"3)"*;!#*+)3, **/*"3)"*+5
 34!-!!)'/4!).38*93,!+5
:
2!5


@@:4!)/)" !#!4/*/+)+5.38*93,!*2 /9 "++A.,39!+): .3#/"8+5.3823*(3/)"3/)!&%"%)5+#"%)3"!,84/&!+#&!#&3"!&7@ " !'#3&!.38+5**/*"3)"*;!#*+)3,**/*"3)"*23*%.'#3&!&"+
7:;
) +" !#  2+#&*  " ! **/*"3)"*;!#*+)3, **/*"3)"*  34!  -!!)  !6%3,/B!&  "+ 
/)" !(3""!#+5.38*93,!*;'#3&!.383)& *
 34!-!!).,39!& /).38-3)&+5
@?
?7C2/" '#3&!.38+5
7:;
 #!!.38*93,!*

C

@3)&
:
 34!-!!)(!#'!&"/*.,!3&!& " 3"3*3#!*%,"+5*%9 3(!#'!#
* +%,& 34!-!!)'/4!)'#3&!.38
7:;
 /)*"!3&  +5 
7;
   !  1/)/*"!#/3,  93&#!  &/*9 3#'!  +),8 9,!#/93,;&!*A$+-2 !#!3*" !
3)&
2+#A#+%)&" !9,+9A -#34/)' !3"3)&9+,& 7  !#!*.+)&!)"* 34!9+)"!)&!&" 3"" !.#+.+*3,5+#!) 3)9!& '#3&!  .38  +5 
7:;
 "+  " !  .+*"  +5 
  23*  "3A!)  %.  2/"  " !

+4!#)(!)"2 +#!$!9"!&" !.#+.+*3,+)" !'#+%)&" 3"/)"!#(*+53#3 D@:+5:"    !.+#"" !%.'#3&!&#!4/*!&*"#%9"%#! 3*-!!)!>"!)&!& "+)+)
3B!""!&>!9%"/4!.+*"*2 /9 /)9,%&!&'#3&!.38+5
7;
"+" ! .+*"+5
/(/,3#,8" !.+*"+5
23*'#3)"!&" !%.'#3&!& *93,!+5
D7
<.#!
#!4/*!&=2 /9 23*#!.,39!&2/" '#3&!.38+5
7:-8:"   " 3*-!!)9+)"!)&!&" 3"*.!9/5/9#!9+((!)&3"/+)5+# " !>!9%"/4! 3&#!+5 3*-!!)399!."!&-8" ! +4!#)(!)"3)& " !#!5+#!/"23*)+".+**/-,!"+%.'#3&!" !.38*93,!+5
3)&" 3"

" ! +%#"2 /9  3*)+!>.!#"/*!/*)+"" !.#+.!#+#%("+&!9/&!" !/**%! /)4+,4!&/)" /*93*!   !#/-%)3, 34/)'+-*!#4!&" 3"/" 3*)+!>.!#"/*!"+!(-3#A %.+)" !!)+#(+%*"3*A+5!6%3"/)'" !&%"/!*3)&#!*.+)*/-/,/"8+5"2+

?
.+*"*3)&" 3"" !2#/".!"/"/+)!#*3,*+ 34!53/,!&"+(3A!+%"393*!" 3" " !#!23* +*"/,!&/*9#/(/)3"/+)9 +*!"+&/*(/**" !3..,/93"/+)5/,!&-8 " !2#/".!"/"/+)!#* :  !.+/)"" 3"3#/*!*5+#9+)*/&!#3"/+)/*2 !" !#" !.38.3#/"8 *+%' "5+#-8" !.!"/"/+)!#*-8*"!../)'
%." !/#'#3&!.38/**%*"3/)3-,! D

!3#)!&  9+%)*!,  3..!3#/)'  5+#  " !  2#/"  .!"/"/+)!#*  2+%,& *%-(/"" 3"" !**/*"3)"*;!#*+)3,**/*"3)"*+52 +2!#!5/>!&3"" ! .38*93,!+5 *
 34!)+2*"3#"!&#!9!/4/)'" !.38*93,!*+5
 2 /9  /*  3'3/)*"  " !  *./#/"  +5  " !  #!9+((!)&3"/+)  (3&!  -8  :"  38

+((/**/+) )3*(%9 3* *
2 +2!#!*%.!#/+#/)#3)A 3&-!!) &+2)'#3&!&-8*"!../)'
%." !.38*93,!+5**/*"3)"*;!#*+)3,**/*"3)"* +52 ++#/'/)3,,8#!9!/4!&" !.38*93,!*+5 *
" !.,!35+# !) 3)9!&'#3&!.38(3&!-8" !.!"/"/+)!#*&!*!#4!*"+-!399!."!& C ) 

          

 /" 3*-!!)+-*!#4!&-8" !+)E-,!%.#!(!

+%#"  " 3"  %),!**  " !  #!6%/#!(!)"  +5  */(/,3#/"8  +5  *A/,,  !55+#"*  3)& #!*.+)*/-/,/"8"+&/*9 3#'!"2+&/55!#!)".+*"*/*!*"3-,/* !&" !.,!35+# %.'#3&3"/+)+5*93,!+5.3893))+"-!!)"!#"3/)!& @ )    

 !"#$!%& '(

 )*)* '+,-./" 3*-!!)93"!'+#/93,,8 !,&-8" !+)E-,! %.#!(! +%#"" 3"93"!'+#/B3"/+)+5.+*"*3)&" !.#!*9#/."/+)+5&%"/!*+5 !39 .+*"3#!" !!>9,%*/4!&+(3/)+5" !!(.,+8!#)3*(%9 3**%9 3 93"!'+#/B3"/+) 3)&.#!*9#/."/+) -8/"* 4!#8)3"%#!3#!4!#89+(.,!>"+ 53" +(/"9+%,&-!3**!**!&+),8-8.389+((/**/+)*+#!(.,+8!#*3*" ! 93*!(38-!2 + 34!" !-!)!5/"+53**!**(!)"(3&!-8!>.!#"-+&/!*

7
 ! +%#"** 3,,)+"4!)"%#!"+*%-*"/"%"!" !/#+./)/+)2/" " !+./)/+)+5 " !!>.!#"*2 + 34!'+"3,+"+5!>.!#"/*!  )" !-39A'#+%)&+5" !3-+4!&!9/*/+)*,3/&&+2)-8" ! +)E-,!%.#!(! +%#"2!3#!+5" !9+)*/&!#!&4/!2" 3"*A/,,!55+#"*3)& #!*.+)*/-/,/"8#!6%/#!&5+#&/*9 3#'/)'" !/#.+*/"/+)3***/*"3)"*;!#*+)3, **/*"3)"*+53#!"+"3,,8&/55!#!)"5#+(" 3"+5 "/*3)3&(/""!& .+*/"/+)  " 3"   *  53,,  %)&!#  " !  >!9%"/4!  3&#!  3)&  " !

**/*"3)"*;!#*+)3,**/*"3)"*-!,+)'"+" !1/)/*"!#/3, 3&#!   !#!*.+)&!)"*/)" !/#2/*&+(" +%' "/"5/""+%.'#3&!" ! .38*93,!+5**/*"3)"*;!#*+)3,**/*"3)"*+59+)*/&!#/)'" !/#&%"/!* #!*.+)*/-/,/"/!*3)&" !5%)9"/+)* !#!/*)+" /)'+)#!9+#&"+* +2" 3" " ! #!*.+)&!)"*  34!  39"!&  /##3"/+)3,,8 +# " !/# 39"/+)  23*  4/"/3"!&  -8
   )3*(%9  3*  " !  6%3,/"3"/4!  &/55!#!)9!  /)  " !  &%"/!*  3)& 5%)9"/+)*+5" !**/*"3)"*;!#*+)3,**/*"3)"* 3*-!!)&%,82!/' !&-8" ! #!*.+)&!)"*  2 /,!  %.'#3&/)'  " !/#  .38  *93,!*  " !  +%#"*  93))+"

%))!9!**3#/,8  !(-3#A  %.+)  3)  !>!#9/*!  "+  "!*"  " !  2/*&+(  +5  " ! #!*.+)&!)"*  +#3,," !*!#!3*+)*2!5/)&" 3"" !#!/*)+(!#/"/)" !2#/" .!"/"/+)3)&" !#!5+#!" !2#/".!"/"/+)*"3)&*&/*(/**!&  ! "

     %'%*" !

 "

%,3"/