← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10602/2015dismissed

D.C. Goyal v. Union Of India & ORS

2015-08-10Bench- 4,Registrar-Judicial5 pages

  

       

   

   

 

 

                   !" !#" !$%&'!(!)"* +%,&-!#!.+#"!&/)" !&/'!*"0 !*    1 

1 

 

       )2+3/)'#"/4,!*56)&7+8" ! +)*"/"%"/+)+8)&/6" !

9#/".!"/"/+)!# 6*4 6,,!)'!&&/*(/**6,+8" !..,/46"/+)8/,!&-:" ! .!"/"/+)!#"+*!"6*/&!" !+#&!#+8.%)/* (!)".6**!&-:" !#!*.+)&!)"*" /*"+-!)+"!&" 6" /*6..,/46"/+)/)1+;+8.#6:/)'8+# 4+)&+)6"/+)  +8  <75  &6:*  /)  8/,/)'  " !  #/'/)6, ..,/46"/+)  -!8+#!  " !

!)"#6,&(/)/*"#6"/2!#/-%)6, 6)&/'6# !)4 96*6,*+&/*(/**!&   !  9#/"  .!"/"/+)!#  8/,!&  1  +;  +8    *!!3/)' 4+)&+)6"/+)+8&!,6:+8<75&6:*/)8/,/)'" ! #/'/)6,..,/46"/+)-!8+#!

" ! !)"#6,&(/)/*"#6"/2!#/-%)6, 6)&/'6# !)4 !.,!6&!&" 6" !

*%-(/""!&6#!.#!*!)"6"/+)+)==5"+" !6..+/)"/)'%" +#/":#6/*/)' 4!#"6/)  ,!'6,  /**%!*  >%6  " !  /(.%')!&  +#&!# ))%6,  /)4#!(!)"*  9!#! '#6)"!&  +)  7  6)&  ;  #!*.!4"/2!,:  &!*./"!  " !  +#&!#  +8 .%)/* (!)"6,#!6&:/(.+*!&+)  /(%#" !# !96*6,*+(63/)'6)

 6""!(.""+#6/*!6)/)&%*"#/6,&/*.%"!9/" #!*.!4""+*"+..6'!+8" #!! /)4#!(!)"*  9/"  4%(%,6"/2!  !88!4"  " #+%'  

 ?!(/  +)&%4"+#

6-+#6"+#:@  (.,+:!!*  )/+)   !#!8+#!  " !  &!,6:  +8  <75  &6:*  6* +446*/+)!&/" 6*-!!)4+)"!)&!&-:" !9#/".!"/"/+)!# A  !  9#/"  .!"/"/+)!#  6,*+  4+)"!)&!&  +)  (!#/"*  " 6"  !  96* *%88!#/)'8#+((!&/46,.#+-,!(8+#9 /4  !96*'!""/)'"#!6"(!)"8#+(    !  6&  6**%#!&  " !  #!*.+)&!)"*  " 6"  !  9+%,&  /(.#+2!  /* .#+&%4"/2/": !#!8+#!" !4 6#'!" 6" !'62!,!**9+#3+%".%"9 /4 96* ,!**" 6)B6*4+(.6#!&"+" !+" !#"!4 )/4/6)*/*"+"6,,:%)*%*"6/)6-,! <  !#!*.+)&!)"*4+)"!)&!&" 6"* +946%*!)+"/4!96*/**%!& "+" !9#/".!"/"/+)!#+)56* !'62!,!**9+#3+%".%"9 /4 96* ,!**" 6)B6*4+(.6#!&"+" !+" !#"!4 )/4/6)* !#!.+#"*%-(/""!& -:1!&/46,+6#&9+%,&'+"+* +9" 6"" !9#/".!"/"/+)!#4+%,&&/*4 6#'! /*&%":6*6)+#(6,.!#*+) !9#/".!"

/"/+)!##!(6/)!&!C.6#"!&%#/)' " !!)>%/#:.#+4!!&/)'*!#!*.+)&!&+),:"+" !)&* +946%*!)+"/4! 46,,/)'%.+) /("+6)*9!#8+#.#+.+*!&.%)/* (!)"+8*"+..6'!+8" #!! /)4#!(!)"*9/" 4%(%,6"/2!!88!4" !.%)/* (!)"96*.#+.!#,:644+#&!&  !&!,6:/)/(.,!(!)"6"/+)+8" !+#&!#46))+"-!6'#+%)&"+4+)&+)!" ! &!,6:+8<75&6:*/)8/,/)'" ! #/'/)6,..,/46"/+)/"96*4+)"!)&!&   ! !)"#6,&(/)/*"#6"/2!#/-%)6, 6)&/'6# !)4 4 +*!

"+&/*(/**" !6..,/46"/+).#6:/)'8+#4+)&+)6"/+)+8&!,6:+8<75&6:*+) " !'#+%)&" 6"*%88/4/!)"#!6*+)96*)+"6**/')!&8+#)+".#!8!##/)'" ! 6..,/46"/+)+)"/(! !#/-%)6,6,*+ !,&" 6"" !!)>%/#:.#+4!!&/)'* 6&  -!!)  4+)&%4"!&  -:  " !  #!*.+)&!)"*  +),:  /)  644+#&6)4!  9/"  " !

A .#+4!&%#!3)+9)"+,69 !9#/".!"/"/+)!#6,*+ 6&6(.,!+..+#"%)/":"+ &!8!)& /(*!,8 !.%)/* (!)"96*696#&!&+),:68"!#6& !#/)'"+6,," ! .#+4!&%#!* ,"/(6"!,:" !.,!68+#*!""/)'6*/&!" !+#&!#.6**!&-:" ! #!*.+)&!)"*&/&)+"8/)&862+%#9/" " !#/-%)6, 5 "96*4+)"!)&!&-:,!6#)!&4+%)*!,6..!6#/)'8+#" !9#/" .!"/"/+)!#  " 6"  " !#!  96*  6  &!,6:  /)  /(.,!(!)"6"/+)  +8  " !  +#&!#  +8 .%)/* (!)"  -:  " !  #!*.+)&!)"*   !  9#/"  .!"/"/+)!#  6,*+  *%-(/""!&  6 4+((%)/46"/+)  "+  " !  6..+/)"/)'  %" +#/":  -%"  )+  #!.,:  "+  " ! #!.#!*!)"6"/+)96*!2!##!4!/2!&-:" !9#/".!"/"/+)!#!96*6,*+(63/)' 6)6""!(.""+#6/*!6)/)&%*"#/6,&/*.%"!-!8+#!" ! 6-+%# +%#"" #+%' " !

%)/+)  +#  6,,  " !*!  #!6*+)*  " !#!  6&  -!!)  6  &!,6:  +8  <75  &6:*

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

< %" +#/":  /(.+*!&  .%)/* (!)"  +8  *"+..6'!  +8  " #!!  /)4#!(!)"*  9/" 4%(%,6"/2!!88!4"  !&/*4/.,/)6#:%" +#/":6,*+/(.+*!&.%)/* (!)" +),:68"!#'/2/)'&%!+..+#"%)/":"+" !9#/".!"/"/+)!# !1!&/46,+6#& 6*6,*+'/2!)6)6&2!#*!#!.+#"6*#!'6#&*" !.,!6+8(!&/46,/)6-/,/":"+ 4+.!9/" " !9+#36**/')!&"+ /(*!"%.-:" !9#/".!"/"/+)!# !#!8+#! /)+%#4+)*/&!#!&2/!9" !#!*.+)&!)"* 62!64"!&+),:/)644+#&6)4!9/" " !.#/)4/.,!*+8,696)&.#+4!&%#! )(!#/"" !#!8+#!" !.,!6+8" !9#/"

.!"/"/+)!#&+!*)+"*%#2/2! = *.!#" !)&%*"#/6,(.,+:(!)"?"6)&/)' #&!#@4"" !

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

+(/)'"+" !9 +../)'&!,6:+8<75&6:*/).#!*!)"/)'" !

#/'/)6,..,/46"/+)9!6#!+8" !2/!9" 6"" !9#/".!"/"/+)!# 6*4+(! +%"9/" ,6(!!C4%*!*8+#)+".#!8!##/)'" !6..,/46"/+)/)"/(!-!8+#!" ! #/-%)6, !8/)6,+#&!#96**!#2!&%.+) /(%">%/"!%)8+#"%)6"!,: ! 6&)+"4+(!8+#96#&9/" " !..,/46"/+)/)"/(!-!8+#!" !#/-%)6,

  6"  !  96*  %)&!#  " !  /(.#!**/+)  " 6"  " !  +#&!#  +8  .%)/* (!)"  96* 9/" &#69)6**%-*!>%!)"/)4#!(!)"* 6&-!!)*6)4"/+)!&"+ /(6)&" 6" ! 6&-!!)46)26**/)'" ! )/+)"+#6/*!6)/)&%*"#/6,&/*.%"!-!8+#!" !

6-+%# +%#"6#!8+%)&"+-!/)2!)"!&#!6*+)*"+*%/" /*8!#2!)".,!68+# 4+)&+)6"/+)+8&!,6:  +#6,," !*!#!6*+)*9!6#!+8" !4+)*/&!#!&2/!9" 6")+46*! 8+#$%&/4/6,#!2/!9/*(6&!+%"-:" !9#/".!"/"/+)!#"+/)"!#8!#!9/" " ! /(.%')!&+#&!#.6**!&-:" !#/-%)6, !9#/".!"/"/+)86/,*6)&/"*"6)&* &/*(/**!&  ! "     %'%*" !

 "

%,6"/