← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-LP/34/2025dismissed

Suman And Others v. Haryana Public Service Commission And Others

2025-07-10Mr. Justice Sanjeev Prakash Sharma,Ms. Justice Kirti Singh8 pages

        +

!  '3 - +   

  

'( )     4(( !   4(  ,   !" !# 

   

  

 

'( ) $  %    4(( !   4(  ,   !" !# 

 

  &

  

'( )     4(( !   4(  ,   !" !# 

  

  '

     !"      "   $#$ - "

$+* - "

$%*.

-"

!- $/.(-"

!-

!

!- 

(( !         0(( ! " 

/ 1" *

 (

 #  ) *

*' 2  

             

      

 

 

      

  

      

         



       !     "

 #  $     

    !""

 #  $           %  

       &              

     

 

     

       

      

          

  %   '            



         (        

       



) !       

         1      '

 

        '  

       

       

     '      

 

        

                     

        &   *   '      



    !  +       

 233.#4$&!!

! ,-.

      /1 0.        



                    



                

  



       



     

      )          

     1          

     

   

  

               5 555 55 6

       

7 



      

        



       58 2        



   

   ##"$"'%  

  &  

           

      

          ' &% *   '              

            8  0(( ! " * (( ! !  * "(  ! ( !

" / *: 6!% *1 05-* ! *!

! 1( !

* 6!  ! 

((* * (  =  

   !  - " *(( !

"!;  -  * !*! <&  0" *(( !* !   !

  ((      " 6     7   ! *

/ 1.08$ !9  " 1 " !

 

 

*"- !!



61 (

 # - ( (( *  !!   

  !" !#

8     : #   59   " ! 

 

  (  

;  ( ! 

 #  

   !

   (( !      " * * (( !*   ((   - -  !   ((    7         " * * (( !  "    *    " * (( ! *  ( (  *(     !/7    * (  *( "   (  ( ! (   6!/ / *1-* !

 !

! /

( ! (   " *- - ! 

>  !

1 " !  ! 

7         61   * 1

((  

(! "     !  (

! * ! "   !

(  61  ( -  1 1 ! ( (  (   *(( !  0 !* 1   !

!

 

  1

!   !

      (( 

  " * * (( ! ( !-" "

"   !  

*  *

 # -    ! *

*  !

  1  ( ! ( 1   6! / *1 !   ( (  1 "  ((  

   ( ! (   ; ;   & ? " !

       !   

/ 1 1  *   

<

    -     !      ( ! (

  " *(( !

!  6!/ *1  

 >  !

! -   *  "    ( "    *  6!  ! 

((7    (

 # *   * 1* (   (  ! (  1!   "  ! /*  

" *(( !

  " - *   1 1   ( ! (    6! / *1 - * !  !

" @ 0 (

  1A!*  

  ( 

 ;     (    ;   7   * * * # * !  1 !;  !



  ** (   

0-1

-

! " ( ! (   ;     ** 1 1 !



  (   ;    0  

(

#  * * 1#  !

! !

"    6!/ *1   * "  1 (  

-  -     !   > 

  1  "



  *  (   ) ?     !   

  !

  #

<& - *(!

!      6!  ! 

  )

 0



 * - -" (( !

0( ! (





  ;

;(    

5   ( #   % 

""$&

  '   (  *$"

"     ""& "

" )-

7 #@&- ' 0-3'  



   

    

               



                    '

  



    

  & .4 

 0  8     42343     0  8 0 

 8'      9

    

 0          8 0: 8

         0  

 8    0

8 '            

     



         

 

          '   

 0 8  

   

' 

     0  8 8     

 

! '

& .4'   :

:     

   1                          

 !       

   

%     

 8  0 ! 

  " * ( (( !  ( ! 1   ((  - -   * 

  7    !-  ( 

  " 1    

     1  ( 1    # -*  *! 1* 6!  61   )

 -



 ( ! (





  ! 0  (  (  (  ((0 * !  -* **! 11 * 6

1 ! -* !*

   - *"  #   !

  !

!( * ( (

"  1 17 !-*

 *- ((

     61     ( !-  (( !  "  "/ 1" *

 7         / "  *   1     *      !   6! / *1 * * 

# - !   1 "

  >  ! "    1  $

( - *

 "  ( "  !!



  ( ! (      (    ;   !!

  61 (  !"

+ ")*8 9## - *  **  1   ! 

((  ?  -(  (  (((-     * (   * ! "

  

 * 11 *   ((    !/     1 31 

!    

*  *

5 (#  $ !   !  * ( !  - "    

 131  

/  !  -(( ! "$ 

"-   (  -" 1((

  !

*   ( *

1#  ! &<

#  

 7 - * ! " 1 ((   0 !

(

 " *

( !

 !

5  (#  

    "  "$  7 #&





7 " *

  

"-  * ;

;   " * (( ! -

   1    *

5   ( #    1 " *(( !   !!

 1 -" * * (( !     ( 1(( !   ( 



!

 '  !"   )  +,-./0* " #  '" )  ?( / 1B  CB

?(

 CB