← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19507/2011allowed

Shakuntla Rani & ANR v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2017-09-20Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari10 pages



      

 !"#

$%& '

# !

(%%&#

# !

       

         )&  *+)

, , ,+   



 

    

 , ,-%.-/-- 0

  !

"  

  



##$ %  

&

 ' ( 

#)*$#*++, -.+#/"0  

1 # -.(   

2    0          

2  ( 



0  " 2 2

"

     %

          3     3

242   #**) !  

  0    3

  5   6

  ,356/.

 1 ) (  !27  

 #

#)*8#**9

"



  0 % 

 % %   5 

 

#:*;#**<, -.#/ 

   % "

  

  2  *+*#+<<$    #)*8#**9        

    

0(  =  



!" 



(   (   +<*:#**<! 2   ( 

" +<*8#*+*, -.;/"0  0 -   )+*8#*+*  0

 2 

    (  +**$#*+* , -.:/" "   



 #   % "

 0 %   1  2"     "



"   

 

2

" *+*:#**$  

  1 #  "            

2

  " 

2 0  !   

 !27 "

  .

2.% "

 5 32  +<:; "(0   %>1 ;8+; +<<#"

  "

 "





 0  +*+#+<<#



          ( 

   

"       (2  *,-"-1--2$ --,3.*4

#56,

' 3  .





 %>1 +;8;: +<<$"

" 

  +$+#+<<;0  ( 



6)**++<<:

2 0      %  %> 9<:+ +<<:6+;*##**$

" 

"

 

    2  2   0   

            ( 

   

22

    0  

      

2 

!  "

(  0

"

 2  3 (   " 

!27 

#)*8#**9   0   (     %  0

(%6%1 #)< #**:"  0  2 

 

  

 (  =            #:*;#**< , -.#/

1 + 22

  



1 #

(  +9*<#**<, -.9/

     0 ( 

 2  ( 

#*+*#**<"(  !%>1 +$:<

  #*+*  2    0     "

  " 

      *#*##*+* , -.$/"





 

 ( 

"

 )2 ! 2   ( 

"

+<*8#*+*, -.;/ (2   02



 0

2  ("





  %  !

 5 6

,356/ 2 



#***

 "

0 "!27 

  220  2 " 0(



2

" ( 

 2   

2"  " %   5  +**$#*+*, -.:/!2" " 0% %   5   .& 

 % %   *+*;#*+*, -.</"    2 *$+*#*+*, -.+*/"







220   2 " 2 " ( 0  0

      

22

*8*+#*++ , -.++/ "(  "  

 (

2    

  1 #  0   (        4    

2(  2 0 

0

 ! " 2  

   2  0

 



 2*+*#+<<$ #)*8#**9 "

 

 0 (  =   % "

"

 





+<*8#*+*, -.;/ 2  #*+#*;?.

 

 2*+*#+<<$ #)*8#**9 0

 3.

2.( 2  $*))$?. #8***?. 0

 -.( 2&   - 

 0 (   2  356      "  0         0    

2 "



"*+*:#**$

  #**)

   0

  (

          +**$#*+*  , -  .:/    0

       2 

 0   ! 0   

  1 +  

      #**9    



2"  #**<"

" 0   20   2 

" 

 -    (

(  -.(   

2         "      



2 %   



( (      2  2  0  #)*8#**9       (2 5 @

*7$.-789-2$ ,-"-1---%.$*# #4:5 +

:':

  

0  2 " 0

"  0'

"

 2  

 0   2 

 & 

( 

 

   #**)    2 2  " 0    0 (    &  

( (  

 ( 

  0 +<*8#*+*"   2  8   #**8  "

 0 0#**$

  

     



02  "  0  ( 

2 



 

   (





 !( 

"(

"

 

   (

0  2  0 (

( 2

 

0  0 +9*<#**< 2 0

 0'  2   ( 

" +<*8#*+* 

$( 0  

1 #"             0  

2     -.( 2 & 02  





 0

 2 A 

 0 

22

02    (  (   

 2  0' 2 !

0 0  (  2 2 

 #**8 #**$   & 

 #**)   2  #:*##**)"

"   

)*< %  

&

 !  2  

  -.(

 

    #8 " 0  0

 (     

2 2  "  "

 ( 0 "   

2  )   #B), /

 .

   

  



   

  

  !"              #

      $      % #

!"                        &    '

( &     

 )  !"  *$     #       $   + !"       &

          &         , !"  $   ), !"    (( #   

(2 0    0 % ),/"

  .

)  !"  -    #  .         *

 $             *          /000* 

 

#

  9

 0(

"

 )

  2  

22  2  220" "

2      2 

-2 

 

     "  

-.( 

 

   #8  0 

2    ( -.( 2 2 ! 32"

2 (

      $"      "

" 0



) - 

 

    0    2          

2  2  

 -

        "

  (  



   -   2 -.( 

2 !    (

 2  0

( 

(

22

  "  

   :,/C   <

2  " 02 ( 0  (  2  " 0  

2

02  2- 22 8D 

  

  

    2   "       (  2    

 0

  #**)

   00'  "

  *+*#+<<$ #)*8#**9 

2   0  % !

0   

    



 ( 

0   & 2   



"(  !

0 "           #)*8#**9!

 "

0  2

22

#:*;#**<, -.

#/

 0% %  6

 356!

  .

   1 12

  3*(*04           5  2  $  -75   1  2 5% $   89 



  

    

/048( 004*:00)  (  7  /

 

  & 5

5& ;  5 <    -=  6

      1& 

344/ ) (

00>   5 5&  ;    

 5 <   1     # ! -%  2 (  



 (     2      (

( 22

  2 " 2 (0  

  2  02  *

      

 "

0

" * !"#$ $"

% &'% "    '( 

)*) +    )  *",'"  ' -" .  !/)*+  012 !  

      

           +9*<#**<, -.9/"

(   ""  2

(

2   2 0

 1 # 

1 +    "

   2

 2   "   

  1 #         2  "    

21   

2  02

   (

"

2

  #**) 2  & 

(  0

 2 " ( 2



2    

22 ! (     

  

  0      (          

     "   ( 

 

 !27 @ 28      22



2 "

 "



2 "

  " 2  ( 

! (#**)  "

   =  

A  0 "

 ) 

 "   ( 

"

0(

   

 0  #8 &    2  #**)   0    #**8   2  +<++#**80"

2  

   "  8  2    0  #**$ *+*:#**$! (

 

 

    #**$  "

"         2    

(    

  2       

 

?52 

 2+<$9  # )   .

  *

$   $1 9

     

   

                     

   

)  +                                            *  34/> #

 $



(   0

    #**) #**8 20  $  .

 

 

  



     

      

     

   

     !               " !#$$%#$$&!





!  

 



   



  

       '      '

  ( )  " !#$$* &         

    2(    

A    

    0   

 (  

    

2 

( " 

  "  -

   

    #**)

 "

0



 0

2 "

 

)  2  

    4 , ,+5 , ) # 0# !

  ? 

.&

*  @*? .;  @*?