Punjab State Electricity Board, Patiala v. Employees Provident Fund Appellate Tri. Del. & ANR
" #$%&"' !(
!)
*+",-"##'".( """
/$*$ 01'$ *.11",*"(234"3
$1.$
!"#$ $# % !&'
33 1$ #"1"1$0"',"2.$3+*.506
, .3 1$6 333+*.50$3*.,1.35$6
$% & /8"$3""3(.#"( 31
& -"+"'"5(.#"( $1.
99999 $# % ()* 3#3"531$21$3.$.".
);<* =>?(1"$$.*.-#@= 301'$A
*.".&$#"*$ $$#(!>) ; $3B!>)
#C?(!
;<* =!D?1"$$.""11#" .*. -#@= 3#".!!
;<* =!)?1"$$.,'3 11",*"
3 1 $ $ ,* *+", -" "$0$$
1"E0."82"$F *+",-"##'".A & /8"$3""3(".#*$"11"5 31 $*,0$3"3"."11. "0 . *531.#' 3$"."11#"(31#*.1"'3#,*". .1$.3#,*(." 23#33"$,51"") 3 21(,*(32(3 *.00$$0".3 "$$$$0 (>:() !G=( 23,' 3 1 2"$ #". *1 .1$3$"0 31$$".3" ."2"11#" 7
@"5"$3" 0..(,*3$"0"$023 3$"0 "...".!
;<* =!D?
3$".. 2"$"$$".,' 5""11", 311",*"(23#32"$ "$ .$0$$. !!
;<* =!)?
$*,0$ 3" 3
*.00$$(23#"*$53"$$$$0(3"$5 11*' 3"5(0*#3$$(3".8."3."$( #,*".1"'0$.1$. 000
& -"+"'"5(".#*$"11"5 $1.
$*,0$ 3" 11*$ 2 5( ,* 3 1 "11". ' # 3 1 3"$ 5 3 ."$ "$ $32 1""5"13) 321 3 $03$* $*#31"
2"$"83"11#"(23,'32 3. "$$$$0 2"$$*53"."$2"$35*.$ "11"
3"3".3".#*$ 31"$"."11"$. 31"1,8
$.53"$*,0$$$ 3".#*$ 3 1"$("11"'"11"$3"31$$".3".1$.
+ 31" #,*(3." 23#33"$,51""5"13) 321(,*3 "#0"$3"31..,5 3# 3 *.00$$3" 0.."$( 23#3$*.1"$$5 3"$$$$0. -#31$"
#01"'5$.*.301"$#( #" "* #01'52331$$ !>) # 3""$0"'($#3 ."$ 3#,*3",..32$"0( .0 "111" 0". 3 #"$ ,"#8 3 . *.
00$$.#.3#$'235".3#,* 3"5,.1$.G 31. 0&"'(!>> 0,(
2 3" 0.,$"$(3.$.".
) ;<* =>?( !
;<* =!D? ". !!
;<* =!)?"3,'$="$. 30"$0.,"#83
. *. 00$$( 3".5"3 1"$$ " $3 . " #$.53#$G$*,0$$$ 31"$233"' #,*235".3" 0.1.3"$,.1$.
$<1#.3"3 *.00$$$3"( 23#$.53#"$ 31(".331#1$ "*"+*$#(0*#3$$(1"$$3."##."#23"2 3 *.00$$$.#.1"$$3. 23"1. 303$ 03." "11""#".#"$3 1=1"$ *.."', (3$"0$3", "$.23" *31. 203$
, 31"$".#."11", 3 *.
00$$(3".5"3
!)
E,'$"$5".31$*,032 $*,0$$$.*'$*11.,'.#*0"'1
321$"##.5'.$1$.
)-%.
($# * )/ !&'