High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/3366/2017dismissed

Savita v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2019-10-01Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan9 pages

!"#$#%&'&()*

!+&"! #"&"&(#, -#,'.'

"!"#!,/!(!!($"0#,' #'1($#("'

) 23

- 4

!"#$ %&& - 45 67 6* ' " !(()" *" 67 76* * & %& (&$ & & $ ((&+ % " "

, " -* %& )%-* % #&& && ) "&.&" $ & ' " /#&) #..

"&% (&$ & "-*

!"#$ $ ( %&& %

(&$ && (()" "%""

" ,

,&$ (("0% #&&&&&""-"&&+& ( .- " +

"(&- 1 % &+"

*&( 6***6

*&%& (&$ && $" & "( * 2"

& &(&+%#&& 3% "&% (&$ & % .& (()"

"%"( * 2"

*& &(&+%#&&&%-*$""

*&%&#&&& &+ &"%4 "+.

$5 & ( "

" ,

2 " -* % & ( )(( % "+."

"-*%() (( #&")%&$% % ( &("-*%$.( & 6&&) "&.&" 7& $ % $ % & % * ,,

"6" . 8&+% ) % 8 $% % 3 &9 (& "6") %%7:! % ((+ &&%3/ -%% "% "% $%"

$&.& ($& $*$% %+#. "&

$ % .

( &"

, ,, ) +"-*% " "

6) )&%" ) . ( &#8$&*7 1 !(&&%*

.( & & %& + " ) ) "" -* % % 7: &" (&$

( "%3/) +&" :

&+ &#&+ & % " $* % "& ( "%$%5 ) 1&(&$$ "*0% ")

" " %& . " 8$& ) $"" 0% $.(& &#&+ & $% (( + &-%% "

) -.&"- % &"&+ &.

$&$ $% + "8$&;

; ;< ;

7 %/) ."

+ &% " )%&$%%*( ""+ &(* "$( &."

& (

0% %$ & &"#&$ = .&"

! 8&+% &":#(. &$ > ?

) 8&+% 7 + > !8/ 4@ > % &"7 + >; 8 #& :#& >2 /$8 -&8&+% > &"!8/ .) > '8 &%@ >< &"8/ "

( >, %@ 1 4 7: >

0% % . " "8$& ) $"")%&$%%*( ""&$$ (&.(&$ &/ " $ % "= .&"7&% .- %)1&"

:> 0% & ( % $5 &" % " " " %$% + ." + &%.0% &#

%4 "+. " " ;! % &+-%%&"$$" " 1&+ &$&" &%#&"$"

$"$" "

% # &( -($" %$ %& " + )&%% + . ( " %8 "

( "$ ( $.( & % %$ &% #"$& $* $% &+ +* " +"

"$ . + &0%& ("& +)&%%

+ . """% %- "% #%& "

% "#%&&$$-$

% $ "& ( &$&( $&.& ( 4 & "$ () * 1% &%.

$&.& (& (% &

() * $ & - & &$ -*"

% ") -( " - 2 C" -"(* %

" % # " % "& " ( & "

, ,, "% &"( &) "-*%. )&%" ) (

6-*"& $%5 0% "

$* % $%5 & D=> 6! ')# % $& $*&$ &% "& % " "&

; ( ")&%" ) (

6- %+& % $& $*#(# "% %( & &%-+ & +" 0%$ & - & &$ = .&"> ! 8&+% &$ % 7 1 % "" % $%5 D=> 6!

%$*) -.&"%- 1 )&%" ) (

6-*%%8 $% .(* .8&+% "

%$%5 ) $$.

*&+ %( "

-*$ " .(*8%* .@ > ?

)

% + %7 1""% (&$ & D=> 6!) .#"-*/#&+ &+ &$ "%& )&$""%&D=> 67)&%$& &$ D=> 6 > !8/ 4 @ % "(&#" % $& (/(( +& "%$$"

&$>; % "& % + % 1 "% (""% ".

" (&$

"$& %"& "( "$%5 )+&#-*%&.

0% +% %)&% # " )&% + " % -.&& % "& ( (+)&%%$%5 %7 1 "

%$&$& %"$ .) (+&# % /#&+ &+ &$ #&" $#* .. D=>6! - % #& % -# .&"

)&&&%(# .

& (& *.

% $ % +"+ & % "& "( & %)&% ## - $& "& *.

&%$"&+ "% %*% #1)("+ % % &"( &) &%+ &) +"

&% -* " * ( < / .

&&+ )& >2 8.8 #& & % )& $ & -&+ % ) % % $% " $ & #& % % .- &.& ) + +" -* % " # %

2 "& "( &"

, ,, 8%&)&-= " % .&+ . ) #

""-*%!$$ " +"%"& "( &

" %* )&%" )

6 , A " " $ $ (% "& " ""&"% >2) % % $% . /& ("&

""&"% %( &&5 &) $ &&+ % % .- &.& %& )& 0% +% & &

% $ % % &" % .- &.& ) &%+ & +"')# %& & ".&& % " $&"" - & -*&( % $ $ &' %$ &) % #&+

.( &*$ %&+& (( & .

%$$"7 1 "%1%$&.% .- &.& >2 % $.

& % % .- &.& "& " ( & 0% $ & %)# #-%"&%1% &+& ($* ( & 1>2+&#% $&.% .-&.&0%$ &% )&% %("%- #&"$ "% "# & $% -" ))&%+ "% ((+ & $ &% %% .-&.& >2# % "& " ( & ) +"

# "

$& .%$* "& "$ .+#%$ $ &5

((+ & +* "%$5 & ($% &+ 0%'E-('&+% &$

%("% $ +*$ (*-#""

$& &+& ( "& ""$ .0%$ &&$ &% "% &% "

$" % $"&+ -1 %&+& ($* "& "( & % - %) % (&+% % "

* 0% % #& $ & +*% -#&& "&%&

) *

&&+)& $ &>& /$ 8 -& " % #" % $ & &#&+ & ) $.(" -* %&. > 8) &( &+%+& & 3/D=> 67 ><'8 &%@ % - $& ")&%> "

&+%&#&+ &!"&$ " -# %)&&( &+%-"* %% " %#& %)& " %)(&+%& *.

% $ % ((+"

+* %"& "( &

>, "A (& .

()& $ "&.&( #& >

%@ 1 4)%&"& &"%&+ $.( & # $.( & D=> 6! 0% &+& ( $.( & # "- % %) % % " & &" %&.( )&% + " % +& & %3/ %$ &% + &

" 0% " ( & $.( & % &" (&$% ( - "

- % # % ( )% ) " -* % : * ..&& -&+ % #&&+

%&* % "&-"* &5 &*) $"

$"& *.

% .% &%- $( &." "

$" - %& $ %)% &" . ($"&+% ") # "#&.

$&+ &(* $..&& % $ $% &+ " +* )(( $&.& ( $& $* :> %%)1&"

%#&(( + $& &$ ((* " $ +&$ ((*% % &")&%" )

6 ) &" %&. -* % % $% "$&D=:F) =$ "-*%&.&%& + "0%$ &#")&%+ " + & %$&D=:F/ % 1

+ . %$"&+$"

$" "$.("-*

"& $$"&+ ( . "

% . & &+ . . 1&" $"

( & &.&*$ $% &+ ".& & )(( +* $ - & " (* % - & $"

(& &.&*&+ ( &*% -%

"(& $&%&+ "-% ( .

*-( $"

! ""# $"

%&'

!'( ""

$ ;/#&)%"&$ &.

-# %& % &=$$$( "% % $ & % &(" # & $ -*"

% ") (( -( " - &+ - & " -% " %* " $5 &"0%&- &( -" " *-" &%" ""&$% +"3&( -$&+"%$". "

$.(& $G 0% &&6$.( & &(" ($% ((+&+ % &"4 "+. $5 & ( %)# % .) "&.&"-*% () (( #&"4 "+."

A "$ ( %&&% + "% & $

$.( & ) +&# -* % 7: % (&$ % % &# "6 " &$& $*)&% $%% % +" ( & . )%&$%% .-&.& &&6$.( & #& )%) )% %# "" * $%.&+%

%% .-&.&% &"( & A "$ ( %&& % -.&"% % - & %( &"

, ,,

%&9&+% " )&%" )

6 . % - 1 %* % # $

" ( % +#. "% "$% &+)&%%&& A "$ ( %&&% % + "% % &&% #"$"% % &"( & )%&$%) & $

1( & ) $" -* % " " %*% "

)&%" ) % . % +% & - % 1 % .- &.& &&8 #& )%) ( $%"

&+% )% %

") 8 $% A "$ ( %&&% % + "% % & ( % $"" * $& &$ &"&+ )%% % % .- &.& %&&% &"( &) + & +" ! % &+( "$ ( %&& /" &"

*+ ""& )&%%$$ &"&+ -%%$ -() !

(* % && % &% = .&" * % ")&&+=$.

%"& "% .-&.&% &"

( & )&% % "

" % .- &.& # % % ( & %% .-&.& %&&) 1 0%&&# &("#% %) )%% &"( &) " &- %&+ .% $% %.) = .&"#% $% %% .- &.& 1 D#%)& -%%$ -()% #$"" &"&+ % . :> 7&% .-%)1&"

&&#"% &

$ %( & %8 $%% ")&%" ) .

6 )%&$%) &"%&. "&(& % %=$ "% $&D=:F0%$ &% #"& "%# (&"&* % $&D=:F )%&$%& % $" " % %

6 )%&$%) )&%" )-*% .

1&+

*.:> ) "

(* $$ "

, 0% &"&+&((+ (&*& &.&*&%$$ &"&+$""-*-%%$ -() %&&&%-* "&.&" * - 4