High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRWP/830/2016allowed

Gurdeep Singh And ANR v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2016-06-16Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan6 pages

! " #$%&'(!!) $ *+, (, &+!' - !&$&$ !'. /!'..

&,&!,'0, ,, (&+!'. - !.) (! &. 1 2 341

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

22 '!%'(, (,%:)7!&!%)0&+!'!)70+,.8!! ' $.+!( &&+!% .!7'&+!)!&$&$ !'.

!'.,7&+!'!)70$7!($ &+!'&67('!#!,7 &+,& &+! " 7$%! &,&$ " ,(,' ,&!+,8,( +,. (70 #!'$$!(&+!,%&,7).$&$ ,.'!*,'(.&+!(!:$.!=+,5,

$ *+$!,&+!'&+!)'!.! &)!&$&$ !'." ? , ( &+! 7,.& )',0!'<8+* %!'!: 0" +,#$ * 8!! $>!( '

7,%!( '!%'(, (,))! (!(,. !>'! $. , '(!'(,&!( ),..!(80&+! )!'$ &! (! & ,$7"! &',7,$72"$.,'$ &!':.6+$%+&+!)',0!'&+! )!&$&$ !'..!!9$ *&+!!:!'*! %0),'7!+,.8!! (!%7$ !( &+! *' ( &+,& &+! )!&$&$ !'. ,'! % #$%&. , ( ,'! (!'*$ * 7$! $:)'$. :! & $ %,.! ;; (,&!( ; (!' !%&$ ."";" 7$%! &,&$ " ,(,'

,&!+,8,(+,#$ *8!! % #$%&!(80&+!7!,' !((($&$ ,7

!..$ . (*!" ,&!+,8,( ? +! )',0!' ' !:!'*! %0 ),'7! +,. 8!! (!%7$ !( &+! *' ( &+,& (!' 7! ;@$A &+! ,'0, , ( (%& @!:)','0

!7!,.!A 7!." B" , )'$. !' $. ! &$&7!( & ,))70 ' ),'7! 70 ,&!' +! +,. %:)7!&!( ! 0!,' $:)'$. :! & ,&!' % #$%&$ , ( +,. !,' !( +$. $'.& , ,7*(% (%&'!:$..$ (!'&+!%&

22 &+!% .$(!'!(#$!6&+$.'&"&+!8,.$.&+,& ':.&+!'!5!%&$ '(!'(,&!( ,& !>'! %, &..&,$

!%&$ &+!,'0, ,( (%& '$. !'. @!:)','0 !7!,.!A%&"C'!,(.$ &+!776$ *&!':.

! "

$ #%

# #

# &

# '

( #

# ' # #

(

2;2

(

# &

# #

) * #

# +( # * #

# +( #

# ) +,

2?2 -

)) +

)

/ +! '!.&'$%&$ ! 0!,' $:)'$. :! & ,&!' % #$%&$ 8!$ * !7$*$87! ' &!:)','0 '!7!,.! +,. 8!! $:).!(806,0 7!;@$A&+!,'0, ,( (%& @!:)','0 !7!,.!A 7!."B6!#!'"&+!'!$. .%+ '!.&'$%&$ $ &+!%&7!,'70&+! 7!.%, &.)!'.!(! &+!)'#$.$ &+!%& %+:,&&!'+,.8!! !>,:$ !( !#! 80,$#$.$ ! %+&+$.'&$ ,'!%! &5(*:! & (,&!(?C;'! (!'!($

776$ *&+!($%&:7,$((6 80&+$.'&$ &+! %,.!

!"# $" &+!$:)* !('(!'(,&!( %, &.'#$#!, (&+! .,:!$..!&,.$(!

2 +! ,%&,7 ).$&$ 6$&+ '!*,'( & &+! (!,&+ &+! ,&+!' &+! )!&$&$ !'. ? ,. ,7. &+! 8+* %!'!: 0 8!$ * .7,&!( ' " +,#$ * ,7'!,(0 8!! #!'$$!(, (&+!)7$%!#!'$$%,&$ '!)'& !>'! ,7 * 6$&+ &+! '!)70" +,#$ * 8!! )7,%!( '!%'(" &+! )',0!' :,(!$ &+!)'!.! &)!&$&$ $.,776!(

!&$&$ !'. ,'! ($'!%&!( & 8! '!7!,.!( !:!'*! %0 ),'7! ' , )!'$( .!#! (,0. %::! %$ * 6$&+!!%&':B +!)!&$&$ !'.67(.''! (!' ; +!)!&$&$ $.($.).!($ &+!,'!.,$(&!':. ! " @!5$ (!' $ *++$ (.,A = (*!