Pawan Gupta v. State Of Haryana And Others

. IN TH HE HIGH COURT FOR THE E STATES OF PUNJAB AND HANDIGARH HARYANA AT CH
&'( () +/, .0 &    1, & &  &0 &0

           22  
*++ +   



,-+     + , +
 
$ 

 !"#$
 $ #
Mr. ( 
) 
*! 


+, 
( (-
Mr. Neeraj Poswal, AAG, Ha aryana.

)
.
*! 

/


0
+ 
+, 
(-

12
)
)
) 
3&
)!
*! 

.
*!
 
*
)
*! 

/



%

 

 #%! 

,





"



) 



 



 

 



$



 

5
+*6
 -


"



 

  


)





   
 







:

% "


 




  *


 






 
!
"


#
  

 
$"


 
%



)2
7*8
 





%
&
 





% 
% 
4


!

!

 !

 6"
1
0

% 
;
<
%
&


 

  =
4

'


 
%



% %

.&% 
/%
#

 



% %
&




*
3 
) 
)


% %

 

!"


 

%
%

 



%
=


 

"
,
) 

 




% %
%
&


"

 
 <
 




 
%


%

 

"


%
  


%
>
%


! 


&%
 

#

3
)  )
%



,
 
%!
 

 

/
= 
9



 


!


! 

 
86 

 !

)


*!

!
* :9





%

 


 

!! 

>


 
*


) 
9+ -+-

= 8=)*
%


 

 

) 



 









 (


0'


"


  


 
)

%




 




,
 
%




"
%"

  

/%

=


6

 





 



     



'

."
 !



  


"
6
 

 
 


 




 
"

,



 

"






 



 
"

 


 

 

5


 


"

"

%

%
 






 
 
 







 

)




 

  

%



 






% ,

 
 

!


 ! 

 "


0'
"

 




6 

 
 





6 6
,



# 

1!
<  

!



"
 



# #

%

 

)

 



 

 



!
%


&

 
"


 
?

?


  

 




!


%


 
 

 





*
2
"



 



/

 
0 %


"



 



/

<

 
"

*
*!
@ 
>"


 

 
/


0


 

"

 "
 

 




 

 




>%!


 

/

 


 
%



 


#

1! 
<  






*
 




 

3 

 




  

>

#  ,
 

 



/ /
%



&%
 
;
 


%
*
 



! 

= 8=) )*
%

 

,




!




/ 


/


! 
"

> 
 



 
%



2 

%

 


"



<
, 

 

 %



% %

 




 


 "

"
 

 

*
%


"
 


*
5
 

 

<


#
>  

 

 




!

 

'

>


 


 


 


 

<
!



 



 
 

!
 

 


 



=
!

  




 
"

 






!




 
"

 
 


 


 
 
)
 




 

 





 

 

<



 



 
 


5



  


 


$ 
%

 
$
 
 


:

*



%

 !




! 

)
 



%
! 

 

 

 

 

<


 

&'()  0 

 !

"

#$ $

%

&!'( 








  
  
 
 








 


 


 


















 


 






!
 


 

 
 


"






















 



 





 

 #
$
%  
 
 


&(




  


   










 
 


  
 

'








   



  
 




 


 
 


 

   
 


 




'



 
  
 




   



 ( '

 

!

!



!




 
 


 

  




 


   
 


 
  


 
 

#

)
*




 

 
 

 

  



  












!


 





  

(


$!
 
   



 
  "






 




 

!
 
  

 


 
#

+
, 

  





(


















 


 




)-$!
)-+!
).+!
).

./!
)0$!
)1$!
)1)!
)1+!
)12!
)1.!
)1/!
)10!
)11!
+--!
+-$!
+).!

!
++1!
+21

+.-


 
3 



+2

0.-!


 







 









 "


  !




!
 
  
"



!
 



 

  












#

 2
% 

 (


$

)

















(


+

 



   








#4

,



2




> 
 



$
"



  

 
 

 

) )




  


 
A
, 
$
!

 




 *! ?+-    $ " $ *!.
 5= =01 )!

*+&, ,  *  & *$  -   #$  .    /    001

$ $&$ !'*2$'!-   $ "3.  /
 456

*%&7
8 91 :+##:

:+' & *$ -   $ " ,

$. 0 
!4501* >  ! -   $

"7,.68
6
!

! 8 1 !

%'*!'*-    $

"+;% .6<78=68
6 !

! 8001 * >?+-    $

" 7,  &  *$ .  6/8 

 6
!! 8 ==1  ?+ + :+# -  @*$  $ "A). 9
!45 501)!& -   $.  =
!45 0= =12$'! !  $%+-   $ "3 3& *$1 /
!45 9  !

!'*- @*$  $. ==
!45 5

,


%


 %


 !

 
"

 ;


+-



% 


"




$




  



 






%


 

 



+-
,



 





 

%
%
% %


 






 

%



 

6
 

> %!






&
!


 




 
)

+ -




&'()  4 +-
,


 




 




 

&


,

 




 



 
 




 

%


! "



6 

 
 

+!-
,
$





 




 
$



 





 

)






0'

"

 




  




+!-
?




 %


 
 




 






 "
"


 



 
A

 






 
 



+!


 






 
 "



 



%

!  

%


 "
B



 


6


 





 

%


 "




 



%

!  



"

 




6 






 
,

 
+-
+-

) 

+-+-


 
2!


2 !
%



% %


!
 
 





 


 
 
!
?



 

"


 



"
 


"
%
 




%

 
"

*!  "





 
%



 






 


"

 6




 





% %


"
 






%

! 


 



 



  

5  
"

 



"



* 
"
%

$
%




$ 


 


% 

+!-
)


 !





"

"









 






+!-
,






& &



%

 




%
"
 


 
"





) 

+-+-




) )


%
"

 




 !
!


$ 

)

!

 
%



 
%
 


 "

+6-
,

 

)
+-





 


 
 

  

"

*"
  
%


 


C "D

 



  
 $


 "

 =
"

 !
 


%


 


 



 






 





!


 "



< "

@!

< <




 
 


 


!

= 8=)*

'

'5 '4
*

)
0
+

-


*
 
@!


) 
@!

"

 


@ !
"
% 
"



%
 

"
 
+

 -

% %

!%

!

 


"

2

 
!

  

 
6  

%

!%

! 




  

 
 














&
 






 



%
 
"

6   





&



 

 


 








 



 


&








,


)
9
 

*



@ !



!



 


%


 




  


 





 

6

@! 
"
& 



%


 



 


2 
 



% 



"
 

 

!

)





"

 


 


"

<
6


%
 


! 

 




  



 


 
!

+*6
 -
 

2 
 

)
 
'9

,

   !
 



5

+*6 


-


 
)
 



 

 
/%

$

$ 
 
"





% 




  

) 





 
%
"

2 
  

E

=




 



!
 




 

 




 

 



*
 "






 



*6


, 





F

 

%
!
&
"
6
,"
 "


0'
"
 



)


!

!



6

.& & 

) 

!

  /


 



%
 




 !

<

"
00'
 >

% 

 "


 

/%

  
A
0



 

:

G

*


*6
 
!


6
 

*) )<
%
) 


 



 


5




 


0'

':

5A'



! 

!



 



"

 
 





! 


"
%
 


 



,#<
"

 
%




 




=




 


6

 

%

 





 



 


5



 
 A6
"

0'

':

5A'


 "





 


0 0'
"


6
> 


%


! 


! 

)
+ -


 


%


 



 
0'
"

$


!

!





 

 



%

 "



1


 
 



Gurappa Guga al and others Vs. State of Myso ore :

LJ 826 and Shokat Ali Vs. S 1969 CriL State of Haryna : 2020(2) R RCR (Criminal) ) 339.

* "


!%


 


 !

 

!%

 


%


%

 !



 


%


 
 


5
+*6
 -

.. . 
"





 


)





 


 



 

:

:

% "



 





$
%

$
  



,
 
%


 "







 
%
% (MANISHA BATRA) JUDGE & & &0


Whet ther speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whet ther reportable Yes/No