High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/600/2006disposed of

Bhim Singh v. Mahender Singh And ORS.

2016-07-25Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh12 pages

!"# $%&$'( # #)(''"

!!"" #!"$"

%& ' #( )*

! + *****

#)(''"+% $ ( )* , -. ( !!" /* ( (!! -.. 0 ( ( ." 1 2 . *"*

* $. '3,, 4 ' 3 5 ." %! ." 6 !!"" 7( % #!" 8, % 3- $ 8, %#) 8,2 %( 5)* 8, + 90"&- 8,1 -:"%.;! 8, < #.() 8,4 !)* 8,=0 5( 8,>"*.(0 .( " !4 5 9"(60."

0 ? 60."@5 7 0

6 " 60." 5 . . + !*A..( (!!0" "( " ! "( ""0" 3

1= B, ""5, 6( !" 3> B,

* 3 B, 2%0" 3

B, + ""(0 3 B, 9." !!"" .0( (! 5 0 " 60."!.5 7( "* . ! "* 5 *. " * (! -. ; . *. (! 5 . + A. .0" 0 "( !!"" * (! .

" ; .!! -.

*( '@0" ).!(9.)-#.(< /#.( + 393 9 ">41 % )* <$--""C &";.9: + 2393 9 " 2 9."

! .!! 5 ! 0 60." ; ." ! !. !!,0/ !."" 5 ! 0 60." $

* .0(( 0." ! !!! "*" . 0"*.! 60."-. 0"(! "* .(0*;( .

-.(! ; 7( .-.

*( . ".

* " .! 0 ." !!"" ; !!!!." " *. "" 50'@0" !7 9. 3- #.( < - #.(

393

9 " 6 " !*! 7 0"5, D6 . 5 (!5 !"-. ""5* . (* )!" (*

E7! "* ( !" ( ! . *

("".7! .

: * * 5 -. 5."

( 0-.

(!*

: * .* ! (F

0: ..*. !( 0"

..( "7! ,!. (* &" (*

%(* ! .

* .( A. -.

: ( B" !! (*

: 7! " * (""* ; . !" -. (! 5"" 0 5 " . ; " . -. 5 ! ( " 0* "( (!5""0* .

"*" ..*. !( 0" ..( "7! " ( B " !! (* " 7! " 4 ( !. (* . ;( . ;(

! (.

." "

(0.( ." "0" ( 5 . .. ( " 7! ;( ! .! ! ( " * * . ( ( !. (*;(

( ".(! .( (. 5 .( . * . -.B ! B 0" .

0 "(

.. " "( % 9. '* 9. *. " 5 . 8 ..""!

+ (

." ( " .. * . !( 0";( G ;)-#.(@ .! (5(0

/"" 5/ " "*( '@0" ).!(9.! ( 3+1 B,!( ""5 0 ..!! 7 1 H " * ! 4 H . !( 0" "." .. " ( 9(! . 3 B, 5 5 ! .

* .( 3

B, " ( " 6 (5 "

" (! . 3+ 1= B, * (! 3+ >2 +4 B,5 0 60." ; % )* @ .! ( .

H !( 0" .(!. "*6 ).!(9. /* H!( 0"5/ ." .. * 5 " !* (."!" ( * ( ( $EE**5/ I."E* ! (!3

>+ B,!( '55 (. 3

B, ! * .( 32 B, " ( ; J/ '. < )0 1

393 9 " + > 1 (.

!( 0" 1 H * 5(!"". ( ( '55/* 9. "

!( 0" 0 H 5"" 00"5/ * " ;. 9(! ( ."

/ .!

" (!"( 5 "

0 -.

."0"6 9.""5 (! 3 B,

! .

* " ( " ; < /" < " +

393

9 " >> !7 9. ""5 0 (

.. !! " * ( 5 .

4 H!( 0" . . 0 0 "* " ( ( 5 3 B, ! ( ' 5 5 (. 3

B, " -( " (*!! ; ) ) A < % " * K ; ;.9 + 393 9 "41 (5 +"

*0" '.

0" 7 H . (!. "*'@0" ).!(9. " *! . >1H ""5 0 ..!!

!.! "."*" ( ; )- <( < ' 3 5 + 393

9 "=+ (5""5 0 ( .. !! 7 1 H *" (0 !* (."!"( )("" 3/ J <";. 9: 2 +393 9 "2 3-<)")0

1 2393 9 "=

!79.""5 0 ( ..!!" (0 !*(."!" (

'@0" ).!(9.3%'* <B 9" ; : ;3 ==1 )9 411 " 5 ! = ! . 0"5 , D=$ "!/*5 " 7*(. (!!0" ( (* 0 !" !. (* !" (*. (* 5 ( ."" . 5 !0" 0* "." ( (, 5 ,!. (* 5 !0" 0* 0 (""." ; !! 5 ! !. (* ( ".

7!. 0 "( ( " F " * ! .! "F ("") ,!. (*

(".

(* (" ! " / !.

* " .

"/" 0.

..F (*(! " ( " 5 (".

(. -. "((00"5"/ .F (* " 7! " . -. (""* ! F !

( !!( . ("" G 5 *

60." 5 (. 3

B, ! 0"B" ( 0 !!"* (."!" ( 6 60." . " .! ( 5 (!" B < % ). : " 34 B, ! ( ;(

5 0/* 5* ./"" 5/3 + B,!( /* 0" 7 > H 60." " ! 7 1 H !!"*(."!" 1 " ( 0 ("3 7 71L3

B, !" * * 60." 0 *" *! 7

1 H ; 5 " * ! 0 5 ( .

!( 0" 5 ""0/.!*. "B!!"" 53-#.(@

.!'@0" !79.

5 A.0 0 60."

!( 0" * ! -. F * " *! ( !* ( 0 A. ( ( .." * 0 !!"* (."!"( . (" ! ;! -.

*( 0 "

A. ., D (

!( 0" ." * ! "

! 6 60." 5 "( ."

! !( 0" 5 ."

." !(0" "" 5 *(!. " ( " 6 ! ! . 5/0 " * 6 ! . 5 "( ""

0" (*/ " "

5 ! !( 0" "(."

" . 5 5 " * 5 5 ! ( ** ! . . 0.."

( "" . .. " " MMG ; % # ) "

9 " '!"

35 8,2 5 7( ! 0"

E782' ! 0" $ ()* 5 . > H . (!. .* "5 B2 * * 60." ." !* ! 0 9.0"5 / !5 5."

." 0"." > H 0" .(!. * "(0 (. " /5 5 !!"" ! !( 0"6 ! .5 60." 9.A. 7 (. (! "

( *. 5/ ( ! " ( (. (! "/ 5 . 0" . 0. "( 0 5 5 0- 6 0* 9."C ! "* . 0 ! !" !!"" ! 55/*5 B< % ). : "

" 34 B,!( 5

( .(!. * "(06.0 !" !)* )E7. ! ( .* 57( 8,=6 5(/ ", E7 ! * E7$ " E79 ; 7( ! 0.* " " ( (" 2 5 ( ( 5 = 1 2 .( 5 * !!( 0 * (. " * !( " 34 B, ! ( 5! . 6 .(0.* 0 !)* 0 / .

! !" !!"" 5 5/*"

5 B< % ). : 5**" 34 B,!( ;5."

"( (! "(*"" " *.A." (K .( " 60." * " ( 0 5*

= "0"./"" 5/ 2'5 60." ""5 0 ..!! (5 " 2 * " ..!! 7 1 H6 60." ! (."!" 10. (5 *0/ N2 (0"(."!"5."

04 6 (.

(!. * "*0 / 6 0" "(/ -. * 6 ( -. 0 0 5* ./"" 5/8 .( ! 7( "* !!"" 5! 3-#.(@ .! 7 0 ( ! -.5."

0 (! " ( 0 /* " * ! 7 H ; ( (!!0" !!"" " ..(B 0" (3+ + + B, 32 B,7 747 B 8 * " ( .*! (

(( ( !"5 = 1 2 2 2 6 !!"" ! ( 0 ! ( ( 6 ( .

(!. * "* 7 "5B2 * "(06 !!""5 (. 3 B, " ( ! .( 6 60." 5 (. 3> B, ( !" ; 5 . -. .

(. 3

B, 6 (! ! .

* (3 B,3

B,6 !!"" 5 (. 3 B, " ( "

(. 3

B, (. 3 B, 7!!(. 3 B,

""(05 0 60."

( ; 5 0 " (! !0" !!"" ( 34 + B, 6 (! 31 + B, 34 + B, , 3

1= B, 6 !!"" "" 0 " 41H ! .( (! 0 60."5"" (! (

"* !"""C6 (! "" 0 ! 7 %!3!. ( !!"" ""0" 5 53

B, $ !*5 -.

*( ;5."

"/ * "*

*. 60." "* 5 (! '@0" !7 9. 3- #.(@ .! 5 60." 7! *-.(!5 " "*5 !"-. " 7 ( ! -.

*( A. 0"5 ( 60." . !. 0"*, D 6 60." ."

0 " ! 5 ( " * -.

!." 7 !( 0")> = (/ 60." . ." .(! ". 0. 7!" / . 5 A. O "

A. "(P (* O-.(!P6 60." ."

/ " . ! O-. (!P 8 " "* 5 !" -. 60." ."

! 0" A.! "

5 " % ' 0/ ". !( ! " (!(

7(!" ." E ". ( ";(!(

! ).* !! 0( ( ! ).* ; A. " . C 7 . * ( " * ! "

." 0" 6 60." ( " /! 5 ." 8/(P9(! = 25 * ( 0. 7 !( 0"

! -. 5/( ;

% * * . " ( " ( 60." ."

. (

(!",( "( .

-. ;

* 0. !* !(

0" 60." / " 5 . !* 0" ." 0"5 5 " 0 5 " 5 "(0 ;

!* !( 0" 5 "(0 60." 5"" / P ! 5 !0" . ! * ." !( 0" 5 5 "0 !* 6 60." ."

"5 . !! ! 7! 5 -. 0.5 * O .P 0" 5 .!!( "( 6 " ..!.". 5 5 .* -.

" * * "0" 0" "! "( $. 5 0" * 0 ." . "$ (0! .0- * * *. . 6 60." ( 0" (/ ! A. % 5 -. 5 !( 0" ! . 0" % *9 5""0 ! 7 0" ." % 5 "(5 ( ""7( 7 0" "( , 7( 5 ;

60." 5 ( " ! . 0 "( . " $

(!"( 0."5 !. "" '!"B " 9""* "( . " $ ( 0"G

8 " "*5 !!" ( (! -. (( 0 60." * 0"* 5 ."

!" " . ! -. (! ". 60." *, " " ! -.

*( '@0" !7 9. ." " ! * !!""* ./*

" (* ( 60." (/* (; * ( 60."( " 0 !" 5 " * (! !."" 5 "* 5 !"-. 9! -.

*( 0 ." "" % )J.

* ) .-0 ' K69 * (!" ?%&."@ 8 !/*B B 8 !0" B