High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/10/2023dismissed

Ludhiana Improvement Trust, Ludhiana v. Kiran Goyal And ANR

2026-04-21Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal11 pages

!" #$%&'$ (& ) !"

%%** +& ,& -.* ! "&

%! /&

,' &&) !') & " %%**

(" !!0 %%* 1 " 2 !1$ ! !& !! 3 %! 4. " 5 & !!* & 6 !1) !") 7"&4. 7"* 1 ! " 2 !1$ ! !& !! %! 4. " 5 & !!* 5'* 6 !1 & ') !") " *!

4. " %* 7 !&!

(" %%* $%! 4. %%* 5 *! !& 3 " $ ) 8 91 ! : !.0 !*. *1 " %%*

# " 4 &! " %%* " " %%* 7 *! " 1&. " 5 & 3 8 ! " $ 7 & &! 7" & 42 :

# " &"& 4 '&&! " & &$'* " ! 42) " %%* 7 &*!

! " %& " !*. : !. &&!

# " &"& 4 $! " !%&$* ; &. 7 "*! 1 " &! * & !*.1 " *1 " %%* <; &.

& 7 %%!) 7" 1' " &%& 8 ) &%&1 7"& " "

+&!& , $&) 5*&9 7 &%4* & 4&11 " &*' &&! " " "& ! %%*.1 %. " &!& ! &"& 91 . % & *1 " %%* 4& " 5 & # " &"& 4 $! " *! 4 9 1 " &! * " "! *&!. &&! &$ " &'

* &%&1 " %%* %%**) 7"* &&1 " '&$ $! " %%* 91 ! !*.) &1 " " !*. *1 " %%*) "& * & 7** * ! &"&) " $ ! " & $ =%*! 4' # &"& &1 ! " *! *7 " $& " *! 4 !!! "* ! &"&) " $ " *! 4 !!! $&

# "' !&! " 4$ $! 4. *&! * & " %%*%%**) 4 ! " $ 4 !'! $&

%& 3 " $ ) "7 & %&&&1 %%* & %%*

"& " %%* !& " %&' &!& ??# 5/5 7" " %&&4! %&!) " $ $. 4 !$! & " %&&4! %&! 7** # 4. 7 7** *! " " 5 & "' !% *4&* %%&" 7"* !*1 7"

%%* & ! !*.

# * 7** *!

" &$**.) %& " *! 4 "&! $& ! " *! 4 ! "* # " ! !""!# !$%&&'&$(!)!*+)*,--+""&&,. !* ()!" /($ !.!$ #!0&-1 !)0 ," &$

5 5'* >:3) " @04* %= 5 & **! " %&%* 7" &1&! ! !*.

# 7 *! !7 4. " @04* %= 5 & !& AB&$ " &! "& " %&%* " 4&!*. 4 **! &

("& " *! 4 *4&*) %&1$) 2 &!) %! %%&" 7"* !*1 7" %%* & ! !*.) & " & & %%! *1* 2 4 & 4*1! &$' 2

(" &$ C C " *! 4 !&! "& %&%& %&) %"*%". ! % &% &1&! 41 "! " " " &$ & 4**. * ! & 4 %%*! %&%& %&%' " 41

4* 2 41 %&$ ! %'* " "* !& " *! 4 1' ! ! **! & $%"

' D %& $% 4 "! !*4& !*. 4 ) 1& 1*1 " %& " * & *1 4 9

' 9 4 ! $% 4* %&. 91 ! !*. 1 ! &*'

' # 4 9% $! " !"& & %& " *! % 4* 2 ! % 4* $" 4 " & & &; &! 4 '1* " " *$ ' "& &* * & 2

' (" % *4&* %%&" " % * " % &4* ! 4 **7! **. &! & %*.

' ("& ! 47 &! !*. ! !*. "& ! & & 7 !.) & " &$& !& %&2 ! &! 7"& " *& $. 4 &!

(" %&) " & 7&& & %%&" 7"& " ! ** & *4&* !*

= (" ! ) 4"' & ! ! %&. &*1 & 1*1 & &*' & 4 9 !& # " !$* %&%* " " & & &; &! 71" " * 4* 2 &% 4" %& ! " ! %&%* 4 1' * 1 4. " $ *4&* %%&"

= # " =%* &! ! & " 1& ! &1! " %%* & *) " & " *! 4 '1* =% " "& ! &*. " *1

= # 4 4& $! " 1 7. 7" & !) $&%& & &%* 4. 91 & & " "* *7 *$

= (" & 1$ & 4 & **. & ! ! " %%&" " *! 4 4! " %&!1$ 2 !* !& 7"" !! 42' &1 ! !'! * %&%

= (" & % 4* 4!. & . &%&1 **' " *! 4 1' $ %4* * ! >

** &"&) " !!2!$!%!)0!)," &$' /&#+!3 !)0 #4(++"+,) ..+#&$ 55 :) " @E4* %&$ 5 & #! 7 !*1 7" 2 !1$ " @1" 5 & ,&9 7"& " %%* *! 4. " %%** "! 4 !$! " 1& ! *$ #

3 " *) " @E4* %= 5 & =$! 7" 7 *! $ !! !& 3 " $ # 7 "*! " " =%& C C " *! 4 1' *4&* &%& & " 4* 2 ! 4 *. *1 1*1) & *9 4 ! 4 $% ! " %&. &!

# 7 "*! " 7""& & "! 4 "7) *! 4 !!! " %& *& ! &29 &$ * 7 %4* # " ) "& 7 !*. 3 F .& *1 " %%* ! " @1" 5 & ,&9 "! !$! " %%* " 1& ! *$ (" @E4* %= 5 &) & =$1 " " ! *7 " 42) !*! && " ! " ,&9 @1" 5 & !) "&&) &2! " %%* # 7 "*! 4. " @E4* %= 5 & !& A8

" & 7"" !! *! 4 4*$! & " 4 (" $1 " 7&! C C C!; C & C 1"C) $ " $. 4 &. 7& " % &% !!

("&&) " 7&! C C $4& $& " " 7"" %&'! %* !) 7"" 7" " ! $%*" " % &% !! " ! & $ =1 ) ! *. =$! &$ " '7 % &4* !&! $ # " =) C C $ " " %&. " *! "' ! 1*1 $& & "& 7 7 4 ! %& '7 " ! & $ & 4 **1! " " %&. " C ! !*1*.C & 1& ! 4* " 5 & &! =& !& & " & " 7"'& " 5 & =& !&) " 4 =&! 2 ! *.

(" %%* $ . " 5 & " " 7 %&'! 4. . C

C &$ %& 1 " ) ! * &. =%* &"!) " 5 & " *! **7 " %%* & ! !*. (" & " =$ 7""& " $9 4 ! & 7 $&*. !' '& *&& % &%

!)+)0$! !)0 !)0 (+30+)* ,$/,$!"+,) "0 ' ,,")!" !)&$%&&5 $ 67896::8;!3! !"!0+)'!$!1!)!) 67<=67>:; !$+-!3 ' &&)! ? !$"+ @=66 @ +'+3 6>> @=66

&#&)" /&A (0*-&)"

866 !)0 !)+B&) &'$!% ! ' ()+#+/!3 ,$/,$!"+,) ,. $+ !) (-B!+ @=6@68@7 # $%()+)* ', +)0$!(-!$ # 8

5 88 " 5 & =%*! " !& 47 C1! C ! C C ! 4&'! " '&. C C 1! ! ' '&

@7'&) . !& = *. 4 " " &; &$ 1! $%*! 7" *& !1& %& " C C

(" =%& C C " *! 4 1' *4&* &%& & " 4* 2 !) 4 *. *1 1*1) & *9 4 ! 4 $% ! " %&. &!) 7""& & " 4 &"!) 4 !!! " %& *& ! &29 &$ * %4*

+! !0!)3!3 ' 1!-3!3 @==@ @ +'+3 :86;!)0 !-!" !, ? !- !" ! ( 5 $ ' ,B!$0 !) !, 5 $ @==@ @ +'+3 ::<

# *! *1* %&% " *7 *$ $. "&"*. %& *& %&. 4 " 4 %%*! 7" ** &1 & 7" " %&&4 (" 5 & " %7& =! " %&!

*$ ; 4* 1& ! C & * *71 &$ &. %&' '& '* 5 & " %7& 1& " %&' &*' 7" !& !& & *1 &$ %& C (" &.

%&' $. "&!"% & ' %& *& %&. 4 " 5 & " " 4 & 1'1 ** " $ (" *1* $=$

> C! & *= ! *=C 7"" $ C" *7 "&! 4 " *7C) ! &! " # " *. 4 "*! ") C' C !' & 4 !&! 7"* &%&1

(" $ !! % 4* %*.) $ 41 & % " $$ .) %%& & ! ! %&2 &.) ; 9 !*1 ! %&' %%& # 9 4 &. ** " % 7"" "' 4 1! =%*4*. ! "' &$ *% $ 4$ * &!1 @*4 &.E 7 <1*!) +* ) % : C /*. $ (" & "' =%&!

* "& !&1 & %%&1 " = *$ $*.) " *1 !&$ *$ "' $& & *. " 2 "$) " !! $1" "' * " '! !%&' * *$) !

" %& 7" 1! " *! % & "$ 7" &4* !*1C *$! *$ 7 *! *! &. ! &.) ! "&&) *$ %&' ! &4 & !%&' 7" $. "' 4 ; &! ; . ! 2

4. *1 2.$ & 7" $. "' 4 * 4. %&.E 7 ) 1*1E & *"

,/!" !)0 ,"&# ! $,/&$"1 ' "!"& !)C ,. )0+! "!.. ) @==> +'+3 ::9

@==> < >6= !%&)0!$ +)* 5 $ ' !)"! +)* 5 $ 67<: @>:< !)0

()03+C !3!- !"+3 ' A&#("+'& )*+)&&$ !3*!,)&0+(- $,%&#"

@==D 6<99D69 # !-!# !)0$! !, ' "!"& ,. !$)!"!C!

@==@ @ $+-+)!3 >>:) " 5 & "*! " 2 !**.

1&1 %&%* *$ $ *1*1 ! 7 *! *. " *7 *! !7 4. " 5 G" )"(3!1 ' !1!C 677@ @ $+-+)!3 8:9

: >

(" *7 " 4 $$&! " " 7"& " 4 %&! " & 4.! *$) " %%* " =%* " & 7" 7 " C C 7"" $ !; ! 1" & 7"" %&'! "$ %%&" " & 7" *$ # %&. ! 4 1*1) & & 7 4 ! " %& " ! & $ " ) & ! "' ! !*1*. & &$! ') "& 4 2 ! 1& ! ! " !*. D & *! 4 2 ! !1 " &! !*. 4. $%1 . ! 7"'& (" %%* 4 !!! *. 7" " %&$& *! !7 4. " & &1&! " ! !*.

# "& 7 %&' *1 %%&" " & $ !1 " !*. 7" . 2 ) % 1 . ! 7"'&) $ %1 &!& '* " &. %&' ! $ "71 & !&1&! " *1* &

(" 5 & ! !3,($!!'&&)! !%!) @=@9 +'+3 @9D) 7"* !&1 " &!

2 !1$ " @04* %= 5 &) " "*! " 5 & 4 2 ! !1 &! !*. 4. $%1 . ! 7"'&

*.) " @04* %= 5 & +) +'!--!

&!0 B1 !$)!"!C!,(+)*,!$0!)0,$ ) 3 55 * 5 8

8) " "*! " $ 4 "7 & " & %&! *$ ! " " ;

8 *$ $&*. "* !& # " 4 "*! !& A38 I & " '7 " " ; *$ $&*. "* !& (" & * *$ & 4! " %&%* ! % 4* %*. ! %&%* ; .

I " *! 9% " E7&! $*E "11 '& " "! " &%! & ! %&! $ 4 !&$! " 7"$ ! " %%**

B&$ " 4' =% *7) 4 !*. *& " " @1" 5 & " && *. !! $' !*. 8

!. & *% " !$&' *'* ! "& 41 **7 % " %&!1) *1 7" !1 & $& " " &%! 1 " $4*. " " %%** ! " " &* $*!! 4. " B& %%** 5 & I "' " 1 " " 1& ! & 7"& & 41 C C %& 3 " 8 (" @1" 5 & * 1" " " " %&! ! "& &*! % 4. "! !*. 7 !1) & ' " 1*!1) $& %& *&*. " !*. " 7 %%&! 4. (" %& ) "7'&) ! '&. !& 1) 71 " &$ !*.

@) 7 & *! % " ! " !*. 4. " @1" 5 &

'&1 " " %& ) " 5'* *! 4. " %*&%! 7 !$! 4. " &* 5 & '! 2 !1$ ! !& !! (" %%* *! 4. " %*&%! 7) "7'&) **7! 4. " & %%** 5 & '! 2 !1$ !

!& !!

(" %%*%%** *! " %%* 3 8

F .& & " ! " & %%** 5 & (" %%* 7 & &! 4. " 1&. :

7" & 42 (" $ 7 &*!

@7'&) 4& " %%* 7 *!) !*. : !. ) &*.

JF .&) "! *&!. &&! *1 " %%*

(" 1& ! " %%* 91 ! " &! !*. : !. *1 " %%*) & **. '1 D !* "' 4 1' &1&! ; &. ! "' 4 ! ! & " !*. *1 " %%* (" %%*%%** 7 %%! =%* " !. !. !*. ! ! !1 " $) *. '1 '&$ "' 4 $! &1&! ; &. "'1 4 ! ! ! $ *) 7" &* & !1 " 4 %!) "'1 4 ! 4 '*'! # . ) " & " %%* ! . " %&' 3 " $ ) 8 ("&&) &"$1) 7"" $. "' %&'! " %%*%%** &$ 1 " %%* 7" " %&! *$

&*. 4 ) " %%*%%** -'&$ 1.) *) 7 *! 4 & ! **7 " %%* 91 ! !*.

(" 1") &$**.) $& & &; &! 4 !!! $& ! 1 %& "*) . $ 4 4& $! " " %%*%%** $ "7 = & !1 " !*. *1 " %%* ! 4') "& " 1 !*. : !. &*.

JF .& *1 " %%* # " !&!

% " 5 &) " %%*%%** " *! %

= . 91 ! " &! !*.

# '7 " 4') " %%* 91 ! !*. !$!

5; *.) " %%* * ! !$!

E F

! I""& %91K&! LKD I""& &%&4* LKD