High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17205/2012disposed of

Krishano Devi v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2017-08-01Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan6 pages

!" "#$%$&'( )*$%+ &",$ -- "!$!$&"* ."*%/% 0! !" /&1 2 &3!+"*% -- "%4&3"&!%

*"%"&!'-

* 0 &+ %53,# !" *!+"4"!$!$&"*

*,$&$!, %!+$55 /&1 2

"!$!$&"*57+$%!+"7$37 8 !"0+/*3$ 80$&9+5+ % $8"3 !+" $&%! &! 4"!$!$& %"":$&9 !+" $%%/ &#" *$! &3 ;/% * 3$*"#!$&9!+"*"%4&3"&!"4 *!;"&! **$9 !$&50! !" /&1 2!*"8" %"

!+"* ;$8<4"&%$&!+ ! 8*" 3<%!3% &#!$&"37" ===($"!+"

3 !" 3" !+ +"* +/%2 &3 % 8% ! *"8" %" ! +"* & ;/&!

%5>-57+$#++ %2""&7$!++"83 *;!+" ;/&! 9* !/$!<!+ !7 % 4 < 28"!+"*3"#" %"3+/%2 &3 *$"

#!% !+ ! ; < 2" &!$#"3 *" !+ ! +/%2 &3 !+"

4"!$!$&"*+ 3%"*,"37$!+!+"&3$ &*;< &3*"!$*"3 % $:"7 %5 !+"*"

!"*5 44$&!"3 %"83 *$&!+"

$#" +$"

&9$&""*5 &1$!0 9 * ;50+ +4/*) &3$5$%!*$#! !+ &:!/&3"*!+""4 *!;"&! **$9 !$&5 0! !" /&1 2&=((&7*:#+ *9"2 %$%0"*,$#"% !+"+/%2 &3 !+"4"!$!$&"*&!+"4%! "83 *7"*"*"9/8 *$?"37" ==@ /%2 &3 !+"4"!$!$&"*3$"37+$8"$&%"*,$#"&(==( !$%!+"48" 3"3# %" !+"4"!$!$&"*!+ !%+"&!+"%!*"&9!+

8"9 8+"$*#"*!$ $# !"* $%"3 #8 $; ;$8<4"&%$& % 8% *

-- *"8" %" !+"* 3;$%%$28" $& &#$ 82"&"

$!%

8 #"3&*"#*3 &3 44"&3"3 !&&"A/*" -B$% 3#/;"&!

7+$#+4*$; #$"$&3$# !"% *"#;;"&3 !$& ;$8<4"&%$& !!+"4*"%"&!4"!$!$&"*2"$&9 8"9 8+"$* 8 !"0+/*3$ 80$&9+ +"9*$", &#"* $%"3$&!+"$&%! &!4"!$!$&$%!+ !$&%4$!"

%/#+*"#;;"&3 !$&5!+"*"C/$%$!"2"&"

$! ;$8<4"&%$&+ %&!2""& *"8" %"3$& ,/* !+"4"!$!$&"* &3&"$!+"*+ % &<%4"#$ $#*3"*2""& 4 %%"33"#8$&$&9%/#+#8 $; %*"9 *3%7$!++83$&9 %/; %5>-/&3"*!+"+" 3 9* !/$!<5!+"% ;"7/832""A48 $&"3$&!+"8$9+!

$#"*3"*3 !"3 =D !&&"A/*" -( 4&4"*/% 8 !+$%*3"*5$! 44" *%!+ ! #8 *$ $# !$&7 %*"#"$,"3 *;!+",! /1 25"4 *!;"&! $& &#"5

$& &#" "&%$& 8$#< &3*3$& !$&* &#+!!+""

"#!!+ !%4"#$ 8 $&#*";"&!% *"!2"*"3/#"3>$9&*"37+$8"# 8#/8 !$&94"&%$& *<2"&" $!% ##*3$&98<5 ,$"77 %! :"&!+ !%$&#"3"#" %"3+/%2 &3 !+"4"!$!$&"* + 32""& ##*3"3%4"#$ 8$&#*";"&!%7+$8"%"*,$&9/&3"*!+""4 *!;"&! **$9 !$&5!+"4 < !+"3"#" %"3";48<""7 %!2"*"- $A"3 & 4/*%/ &#"!!+"*3"*3 !"3=D -(!+"#&%"C/"&!$ 8*"-

$A !$& ! 87"*%! 9"+ %2""&"

"#!"3,$3"3#/;"&!48 #"3&*"#*3 !&&"A/*" -= & !+" 7*$!!"& %! !";"&! $8"3 & 2"+ 8 !+" 0! !"5 !+"

#&!"&!% !+"3#/;"&! !&&"A/*"% -( &3 -= *"&!3$%4/!"3 %! &3+ %2""&! :"&!+ !*"- $A !$& !+"4 < !+"3"#" %"3";48<""

7 %& , 8$3 &3#9"&!2 %$% %!+"2"&"

$! %4"#$ 8$&#*";"&!%!+ !+ 3 2""&9$,"&!8 !"0+/*3$ 80$&9++ 3&!2""&*"3/#"3 !$% /*!+"* %! !"3!+ !4*$*!7$!++83$&9 !+" ;/&!$&C/"%!$&$" %5>-5

-D3/"44*!/&$!<7 %9* &!"3$& %;/#+ % %+7# /%"&!$#"7 %$%%/"3! !+"4"!$!$&"* &3","& 4"*%& 8+" *$&97 %

*3"3 &3$&7+$#+%+"

+ 33/8< 44" *"3 &3+ 3","& /*&$%+"3 &/&3"*! :$&9$&!+" *; &21"#!$& *%/#+ ;/&!!2"3"3/#!"3 *;!+" 3;$%%$28"9* !/$!< +" 3 &% * %9* &! ;$8<4"&%$&$%#&#"*&"35!+"%! &3 ! :"&$&!+"7*$!!"&%! !";"&!$%!+ !!+"4"!$!$&"*+ %2""&3* 7$&9 ;$8< 4"&%$& *;*;<$&8$"/ %"*,$#"*"&3"*"32<+"*+/%2 &3$&!+"&3$ & *;< !$%#&!"&3"3&2"+ 8 !+"0! !"!+ !!+"4"!$!$&"*$%&!

"&!$!8"3!3* 7!7 ;$8<4"&%$&%$"&" *;!+"*;<%$3" &3!+"

!+"* *;!+"#$,$8%$3"$&!"*;% /8"@ ( !+" /&1 2$,$8 0"*,$#"% /8"%5.8 E" *&"3#/&%"8 44" *$&9 *!+"4"!$!$&"*7/83%/2;$!!+ !

!+"4"!$!$&"*$%&! 99*$","3 !+""A"*#$%" *"- $A !$&$&!"*;% *3"* 3 !"3=D -(2/!7/83#& $&"+"*9*$", &#"&8< % *"9 *3%!+"*"#,"*< !+" ;/&!$&C/"%!$&$" %5>-$!+*"9 *3 !!+"#8 $; ;$8<4"&%$&#/&%"8%/2;$!%!+ ! *"8", &!3","84;"&! + %! :"&48 #" !"* $8$&9 !+"$&%! &!7*$!4"!$!$& &33/*$&9!+"#/*%" +" *$&9$!%"8 *"

"*%! &!$ $# !$&3 !"3D@@5$%%/"32<!+"

/&1 2 ,! "

"&#" 0"*,$#"% "8 *" "4 *!;"&! "

"&#" 0"*,$#"% "8 *"* &#+ &3#&!"&3%!+ ! %4"*%/#+&!$ $# !$& 44*, 8 8*" 3< %! &3%9* &!"3!3/ 8 ;$8<4"&%$&!!+"7$37% A-%"*,$#" "&5 7+7"*"*"-";48<"3$&!+"9,!%"*,$#" !"**"!$*";"&! *;!+"*;< +"#&!"&!% $# !$& *" % 887%'-

#$%&'() '(%'*+,-.

/ 0

! - 1 '2$()$'(%3

- #$(%*().5'(%(* . %&$(%$'(%2 6

1 $ '$

$7$ $ #$25/5%22

!538)3(%5% '/ '(%3 *

! 9 .$ 2$ 0 *0

! - 9 . $$7$#$%52&5'(%3% ! 5'%:) ')$()$'(%3 ! - $ /$

#4< $# !$&+ % 8%2""& /*&$%+"3!8" *&"3 0! !"#/&%"83/*$&9!+"#/*%" !+"3 < E" *&"30! !"#/&%"87/831$&$%%/" &37/83%/2;$!!+ ! !+"&!$ $# !$&3 !"3D@@$!%"8 *"#$!"%!+ !$!7/832"4"* !$," *;

!+"3 !" &!$ $# !$& &!"&!$&* $%"32<0! !"#/&%"8$%!+ !%/#+ &!$ $# !$&3 !"3D@@7/83&!+ ,"*"!*%4"#!$,"4"* !$& &3 % %/#+5&!+"%!*"&9!+ %/#+&!$ $# !$&!+"*"# &&!2" & /!; !$#9* &!

;$8<4"&%$&!!+"4*"%"&!4"!$!$&"* %+"*+/%2 &3+ 3"A4$*"37 < 2 #:$&!+"<" *==( 0! !"#/&%"87/83!+"*7$%"#&#"3"!+ !& %4"#$ $#*3"*!$883 !"+ %2""&4 %%"33"#8$&$&9!+"#8 $; !+"4"!$!$&"*

;$8<4"&%$& /&%"8 *!+"4 *!$"%+ ,"2""& +" *3 ! 8"&9!+ &3 !+" 48" 3$&9%&*"#*3+ ,"2""&4"*/%"3

-- &!+"#&%$3"*"3,$"7 !+$%/*!!+"#&!"&!$&* $%"32< #/&%"8 *4"!$!$&"* %*"9 *3%*"#,"*< %5>-2"$&94*4%"3

*;!+"4"!$!$&"*$%;$%48 #"3 &#"3"38<5,$3"*3"*3 !"3=D

-( &"A"*#$%" *"- $A !$& !+"4 < 3"#" %"3+/%2 &3

!+"4"!$!$&"*7 %# **$"3/!+"*"$%&#+ 88"&9"!%/#+"A"*#$%" *"-

$A !$& ! 87"*%! 9" +"#&%"C/"&!$ 8"

"#! !+"*3"*3 !"3 =D -($%!+ ! #"*! $& ;/&!# 8#/8 !"3 &3#;4/!"3 & !+" 2 %$% *"- $A !$& ! 87"* %! 9" $" %5>- + % 2""& 7$!++"83 "*%"!+$%7/83&! ;/&!!*"#,"*<!$%&! # %"7+"*" #"*! $& $& &#$ 82"&"

$!+ % 8*" 3<2""&*"8" %"3 &34 $3!!+"";48<"" *!+"7$37 !+"3"#" %"3";48<""+ ! 4 *!5!+"*"$% 8%&3"&$ 8 !!+" #!/ 84*";$%"!+ !!+"4"!$!$&"*+"*"$&+ 32""&# 88"3/4&! %+7# /%" &3 !!+"%! 9" 9* &! 4"*%& 8+" *$&9+ 3 /*&$%+"3 & /&3"*! :$&9 &3+ 3%4"#$ $# 88<3"4%"3!+ !%+"7/83+ ,"&21"#!$& !!+"7$!++83$&9 !+"%/;$&C/"%!$&7+$8" ##"4!$&9!+"2 8 &#" #;4/!"3 ;/&! 9* !/$!< & % * % !+" #8 $; * ;$8< 4"&%$& $% #&#"*&"35 #&#"3"38<5&%4"#$ $#*3"*+ %2""&4 %%"33"#8$&$&9!+"#8 $; &!$ $# !$&3 !"3D@@+ %2""&$%%/"32<!+"" "&#"

0"*,$#"%"8 *""4 *!;"&!50! !" /&1 2$&!+"$&!"**"9&/; &33/*$&9 !+"4"&3"&#< !+"4"!$!$&%!7+"!+"*%/#+&!$ $# !$&7/83+83!+"

$"83","&7$!+*"9 *3! #8 $; * ;$8<4"&%$&$&*"%4"#! !+"

3"#" %"3+/%2 &3 !+"4"!$!$&"*7/832" &$%%/"!2"3" 8!7$!+2<!+" 44*4*$ !" /!+*$!<

&3"*%/#+#$*#/;%! &#"%5!+"4*"%"&!7*$!4"!$!$&$%3$%4%"3 7$!+ 3$*"#!$&!!+"0! !">#;4"!"&! /!+*$!<!"A ;$&"!+"#8 $;

-@- !+"4"!$!$&"* ;$8<4"&%$&$& ##*3 &#"7$!+8 7 % 8% 9 $&%!!+"2 #:3*4 !+"$%%/ &#" $# !$&3 !"3D@@ $%%/"3 2<!+"0"#*"! *< !,! /&1 25 "

"&#"0"*,$#"% "8 *"

"4 *!;"&! &3!4 %% $& 8*3"* &3#&,"<!+"% ;"!!+"4"!$!$&"*5 7$!+$& 4"*$3 "$9+!7"":% *;!3 < !$%#8 *$ $"3!+ !!+"2%"*, !$&%; 3"2<!+$%/*!$&!+$% *3"*7/83&!2"#&%!*/"3 % &"A4*"%%$& 4$&$&&;"*$!% % *"9 *3%!+"#8 $; !+"4"!$!$&"* ;$8<4"&%$& % 8%7$!+ *"9 *3!!+" 448$# 2$8$!< $# !$&3 !"3D@@

;$8<4"&%$&

"!$!$&$%3$%4%"3 $&!+" *"% $3!"*;%

8/#:< +"!+"*%4" :$&9>*" %&"3'

"%> +"!+"* "4*! 28"'

"%>