High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRWP/951/2016dismissed

White Water Foods Pvt. Ltd. & ORS. v. Directorate Of Enforcement, Mumbai Zonal Office, Mumbai

2018-03-27Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu,Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri15 pages

!"#"$%& '!()*+ ("

' #, -."/"

0'#

"$'# 1'#2# "'!

$'!/$ *&2/3 " #4$ $

6' '!##'#, -."/"

0'#

"$'# 1'#2# "'!

$'!/$ *&2/3 " #4$ $

&% 7.& 8 7.& 8 8

#$"%

&'()

*+#$"%

(),)) - )./

)01& ,

)) /

(2 ))/

3&4 56 # 2

3&4 &)2

'( 2 ( '",

!"#$"% *+

#$"%

& )9 :&

+ #$"!) ='

> ):4 <

= /

& ?. #"% #$"7 7$ $ #$"7

& "7 $"

#$"% 9 :&

7)) )(; 4 '

(<& 4#$$#

) )) 4

7++!

( <& 4#$$#9 = =;

!"#$"% 4 (

23 +"% $@ #$"% / /

2) &32 ( 4 /

4 / '

(<& 4 &2 .

23 +/ /

2( (4

& ) 2

0&)> 4

)0) /

( &32

& ) 2

4"* $@ #$"% !"#$"%

) &

)

= ( ) )( / 3& &32 ( 4 2&

2 4 (

) / 3& &

)

/ 3&

: 3

#$$$97;

###

) :

) +1)1'

2( $+ $* #$"%

4 1)1'

/ . *+#$"% 2( #!

$@ #$"%4 2)

< &

)

&2 4)( 2) 2

2( )

) 2

)

< &

)

) &2)&

# 44

& 4

&2 0 ) &2

) :4 < / ) 4 &

& &

) &

2 )4&

!%$$

A 03 )4 ) / ) 4 &2 7$ $ #$"7

(> &44

):4 < &2 4)(

4 / & 0 2(

4 ?. ) &2

/ '

/ &

/ &4 & ( )& 4

4B2) &

( <& 4#$$#

4/ & 0 2( '

&2 '

4 04

4 '

) ) ) 2(

( ) )

,&4 -

82(

(<& 4 ) /

%*&

)(

) / /

+#$"!

& 04B )

"7 $"

#$"%

& "7 $"

#$"%&

& "7 $"

#$"%9 :&

7;/

)&4

## $"

#$"%> : "% $!

#$"%

& / /&)4 ( "7 $"

#$"% 2

) 2)

A"!

$7 #$"*/

) 2

(),)) - ).

) (23

)3&

&2 3&

( & )

)(/ 82( 4

4 4 &

)

#@ $7 #$"* 4 4&

)3&

'62/$ # . &

) &

)

)( 4& )03 / ) 2 :4 /)4 )/ 4)

&2 - .)

"# $@ #$"7

4 ):4 < 4 &

) &2

) 3& &

))/4

; )

4 > 0&)><&C ;

(

) <&/ 3& C ; ) :4 ) <& /

0 ) / ) ) )/ & )

) <&& (> (

)) )( / / &2 (

0 4& / <&

(&/

)3& C ; +#

4 4 ))

/ < 4 )&

)3& C ; +7 /&))(

;

)) 44

( 4 .)&4 /&) 3& : )(

3& ; '

& )

C )( 4 > 0&)><&

) 3&

)

3 9 & ;)

)

)/ 2

) &

)

)(

&2 )4

&32 ( 4

))

& &2

) / )2 23 4 ) &2 )&4 82( 4 &

)

4 (

4 ) (4 &

4 4&

/ )( )) 2

)

( ) )

,&4 -

82(

) &2

& 2

&2 &

)

&2 3&4

4 43&

39 & ;

& "7* 42) . & (

:) 2( &

D& 3&4 / 2

/ ) 2(

&2 ))

2 &&) )(

?))(&

)

(

)

/ :

) (

0 20 /

) &

) )(

/ '

)

) &2C )( ( ) 9'

(<& 4 ; &2 82( 4

? &

&2)

) "7 $"

#$"%2(/

< ) +#$"!

)

/ ))( //

/& 2

) ( /

)

/ ) /(

) 2

& &2)) 4 3& ) 2

& &

)

) /(

82( 4

& 3& C )( +*#

) &

)

##%##@ &.

)

( :) : (4 D&

)2 (

4 24

) )(

)( )(

) /(

)) &4

)4&

!%$$

) )( )( &2 &4 2()4

/ &32 ( 4 /

) )(2) / /

):4 < )() &2 ?.)4 / 4) /

4 2( ) / 3& ) 4 &2 '

442

2& &4 ()& 4

) )// 0 4B /%* &

. ) ))/4 (

// D&

& :9 '

;'%

9 "# /# '#4!

2<<; 4'

; (

("# $73< 2'

34< #

=!6$"> $!$!&$;

2$ '"$6 "$ 2$ ' 8!

"$ 9 $ 42$"#( 3< 2$ '8!

"$5 ( '?$ "$&$;.

2$ '"$6 !

** "$# ( !!2# 4'#$#@$ "

"# #

"< 3<A $ 4'!## / ; 3 "##2 "$# !!2# "$

!!'

$!A"

A% ,"-8('"$B $"8"$( *,""-8('"/"

&2=('B*,"""-8('"

" (2=( $ "*,"?-8/ $("&2=('B*,?-&@# 6'4'!##'# ?

*,?"-&@#2$ ' #.

*,?""- &@# '"/C$?<4'# ?

*,?"""-8('"82'$ '

* ,"D- 8('"

$B? 66 'A < ,D- 8('" #(A"$ 8"$ (A $"*,D"-8('"1"B ;E2/ '8( '/ *,D""-8('"$"< E2/ '*,D"""-&@# # ( &"$/ $ "

*,D"?-&@# 266'$ 'B!

*,D?-&@# # ( <<;!'4 ?

*,D?"-&@# # ( <<A 8 < ?

*,D?""-8('"

&("

66 'A <*,D?"""-8/ 8(;

/ EB'"A <*,D"D-&@# &( $$ "

*,DD-&@# ?"#("$ '4'"## ?

* ,DD"- &@# '"$ // "

; ?

* ,DD""- &@# (">=" '/ '# ?

*,DD"""-8('" 6/( $ '6* ,DD"?- 8('" " 8( $= ' 8'"?

* ,DD?- 8('"

/ A (8( '/ *,DD?"-8('"&2=2<24

*,DD?""-*&@# 84"$! D "<# ?

*,DD?"""-8('"( $

E /#A '

*,DD"D-&@#("

' # ?

*,DDD-&@# ( '

06' ' 2!

#*,DDD"-&@#1 #.

* ,DDD""- 8('" E / < E $ A $* ,DDD"""- 8('" /"

A $*,DDD"?-&@#E ' "$#.

*,DDD?-&@#E $ 2# '"# .

* ,DDD?"- &@# E '4'

"$* ,DDD?""- 8('""<#(

<*,DDD?"""-8('""/"#(

<*,DDD"D-8('"

'#( $

<* ,D<- &@#

(2'" ##!"

#* ,D<"- &@# '

"$6 '(826 '&"<<#.

*,D<""-&@#

(2<8 <#.

* ,D<"""-8('" $82'"*,D<"?-8('"

(2<$ $ *,D<?-8('"

$B?( #"$*,D<?"-&@# / ( '" $ '$

"$ <

*,D<?""-8('"F3 <8"$6( <*,D<?"""-8('"$ '

8"$6( <* ,""- 8('" 82'B"

8"$6( <* ,- &@# . 2#

"$'"# ?

*,"-&@#. 2#<<" & "

"!# ?

*,<""-&@#. 2#2"< '#*,<"""-8('"'2$8( '/ *,<"?- &@# / ( '" "! 0 $'

< &"<<#* ,<?- 8('" <B"

8"$6( <*,<?<-8('" #4 <8"$6( <*,<?""-8('" "8"$6( <*,<?"""-&@#8A # "= ?'# #'4'

"$*,<"D-&@# $ $6 ?

*,<D-&@### $ ?'# #.

*,<D"- 8('"

B#( &(

* ,<D""- 8('"

B"? "* ,<D""- 8('"

"6$#(8( (*,<D"?-8('"8('"= $ ?

<6= '*,<D?-8('"

8( $= '< <2'2*,<D?"-8('"( 6A

'*,<D?""-8('"

#4(& ##;*,<D?"""-&@#

"$ <84 D!( $6.

,8.- 9 (!/4< "$ $ !'

?# (

"$?# "6

"$#

"$# (' 4'#$#@$ "

"# $ /<;* 8. "!"

<#* &* (' 2< "$6 //3'# 0 ('# ' "$ 4'6'## ( 4'! # !'"/ " (' !<<!

# "$ $! !( '6#* '

$# !

"$ !( '6#* A '(2#"$6 @ <"?'; !( '6#* "$ '# * 1* (' !( '6#* ! 3;

8. ' 2 #

$ "$6 $ ( 2< "$6 //3'#

44'D #5''#"# <#2$ '"$?# "6

"$( /4< "$ $ ('3; (2/3<; #23/"

# (

( "$?# "6

"$"$ ("#!

#"#$6"$6 !/ '/#A"

(

(A" ''

/""!

"$#0 '

!2 ($ "'4'! # !'"/#"4($ "$ (/

' (/4< "$ $

?#< ? ("#84!"

<2'

"<#244</$

!/4< "$ #2$ '8!

"$5 ( &.*24$ !/4< "$"$?# "6

"$ 99 ( $73< 2'

/ ; <# ' ' 2$ ' #23G #!

"$ 8!

"$ + ( '?$ "$ &$;

2$ '"$6 !

* * !$"#!

"$ ( 4'4'

"# "$?<? "$ (/$;< 2$ '"$6'A("!(( #3$2# '!//"##"$$!/$;< 2$ '"$6 (

$ '

<?'$/$ 5 ( <A 2$ # ( '

# ' $$D

$$D2'G(<"# A"

$### 3D /"$

(

"/ '"

< "# $$D # $$D2'G ( <"# !2/$ #'<" 24$"$ (!/4< "$ "# <#$!<# # <$ '?" $!# $ $$D #$$D2'GH )

&2 0 4B )&

)

"7 $"

#$"%2&

)2 )( ) )() &

& (

& ) )(&)4 &

&44

) & )( & ( 2&

) &&) )(2

. ))0/ +! 2 4 2) &

&4 / 20 : /

(

)( ( ) B 4&))2)

. & & )

)/ ) &2

& &2

2( & &2

&2 2

4 ) 0 ) ):4 < &2 &

& ) )(

)3& &2&

& ) 3& ) &

) )( &2 &

) 3& &32 ( 4

2( &

)

4 >0&)><&

<&/

& 4 > 0&)> <& /))( ) & 2

& 4

4 &

(>/

) <&

4 (&

)

)4 )) 2&)

)

) :4 ) <&) :4 <

3& 4 )

)& &

))

)3& &32

( 4

/ D&

)4(

+#$"! 4 &

( ) )

,&4 -

82( )) 4 &

2( &

4 ))() )()&32 ( 4

(

)3&

)3& 82( 4

/ D&

2()4 4)( ))/4)&4 :

3 4

9#$$";# &

# +/&)2 :+ $ !

# "#42 '"#"$6 A( (' $ "$ "?" 2 < !

# ' !

## #(2< 3 "< $ ( '

(42' ' "42'* (# / ( # 3 2$ 2 3;

44<;"$6 ( # I'/A("!( "# '"!

# '"##* (

"#*"$A("!( "# '"!

2# !

"$!

$3# " ( ?

'"#$ $ ($D'!"#"$6 (B2'"# "!

"$2$ ''

"!< ($# "

"$H . ) 2 &

)2 )(/) )4

&4 ) /(

2 & )

) &)2

) / '

)/( & ( 0 &

4 & )

4 )) &4 )0

&)2

) / 2&

2 .&

&))(4&)( 4

)/ 4 3&

)2) ( :

) ( E. &4 '

4 & &4

/ )04 &4 &

5 2(

4 :

) (

!$) /&) &2

/ )

( &

&))(2

) 2)

(

4 4

4 ) =& & 4 2=

) ) 4 >& 42)&

& 2( 2

D& )

/))2

( &

4 )2 (

& &2 2

+#$"! D&

& (

& )

42( '

2( ) &

)

() .

&)/ 0 ))/4 A' "

!"#$"% *+#$"%

) 3& ))

"* $@ #$"%$+ $* #$"% !"#$"% #!

$@ #$"% *+#$"%

4 4 :

) )) 4 2)

C # 2 ))( :

) (

!$) C E. &4

/ &

()4/ ))2

)

) &2 <

+#$"!/ &

(C + )'

&2 42

+#$"! )2 ( D&

& (

& )

42( 4 (/ &

(

C !

)

9 <; &2 <

+#$"!